Skip to main content
OrthoVellum
Knowledge Hub

Study

  • Topics
  • MCQs
  • ISAWE
  • Operative Surgery
  • Flashcards

Company

  • About Us
  • Editorial Policy
  • Contact
  • FAQ
  • Blog

Legal

  • Terms of Service
  • Privacy Policy
  • Cookie Policy
  • Medical Disclaimer
  • Copyright & DMCA
  • Refund Policy

Support

  • Help Center
  • Accessibility
  • Report an Issue
OrthoVellum

© 2026 OrthoVellum. For educational purposes only.

Not affiliated with the Royal Australasian College of Surgeons.

Patella Fractures

Back to Topics
Contents
0%

Patella Fractures

Comprehensive guide to patella fractures - AO classification, tension band wiring vs screw fixation, extensor mechanism integrity, and partial patellectomy indications for orthopaedic exam

complete
Updated: 2024-12-15
High Yield Overview

PATELLA FRACTURES - EXTENSOR MECHANISM

Largest Sesamoid | Tension Band Principle | Extension is Key

1%Of all fractures
3mmStep-off threshold
2mmGap threshold
50%Transverse pattern

FRACTURE PATTERNS

Transverse
Pattern50% - most common, central
TreatmentORIF if displaced over 2mm
Comminuted
Pattern30% - multiple fragments
TreatmentAttempt reconstruction or partial patellectomy
Polar
PatternSuperior or inferior pole
TreatmentORIF or excision + repair
Vertical
PatternSagittal, less common
TreatmentOften stable, may be conservative

Critical Must-Knows

  • Extensor mechanism function is key - can patient actively extend knee against gravity?
  • Operative indications: displacement over 2-3mm, articular step over 2-3mm, loss of active extension
  • Tension band principle: converts tensile force to compression at articular surface
  • Tension band wiring (TBW) is classic, but screw fixation increasingly preferred for transverse
  • Hardware removal common (50%) due to prominence - counsel patients preoperatively

Examiner's Pearls

  • "
    50% of patients need hardware removal - wire prominence is main reason
  • "
    Check active extension BEFORE giving analgesia - critical exam finding
  • "
    Vertical fractures often stable (patella wide in sagittal plane)
  • "
    Inferior pole excision + tendon repair = satisfactory if under 30% pole

Clinical Imaging

Imaging Gallery

A-B: Open reduction and internal fixation of the patella fracture and tibial tubercle pseudarthrosis and 36 months follow-up radiographs, showing healing of the tibial tubercle and incomplete patella
Click to expand
A-B: Open reduction and internal fixation of the patella fracture and tibial tubercle pseudarthrosis and 36 months follow-up radiographs, showing healCredit: Manzotti A et al. via BMC Musculoskelet Disord via Open-i (NIH) (Open Access (CC BY))
Spontaneous patella fracture 9 months following the revision procedure.
Click to expand
Spontaneous patella fracture 9 months following the revision procedure.Credit: Manzotti A et al. via BMC Musculoskelet Disord via Open-i (NIH) (Open Access (CC BY))
Anteroposterior and lateral radiographs of left knee 3 months after patellar fracture and cerclage wiring (K-wires and wiring perpendicular to fracture line).
Click to expand
Anteroposterior and lateral radiographs of left knee 3 months after patellar fracture and cerclage wiring (K-wires and wiring perpendicular to fracturCredit: Hirschmann MT et al. via Cases J via Open-i (NIH) (Open Access (CC BY))
Lateral radiograph of a patient with a left patellar fracture three months after total knee arthroplasty
Click to expand
Lateral radiograph of a patient with a left patellar fracture three months after total knee arthroplastyCredit: Vaishya R et al. via Cureus via Open-i (NIH) (Open Access (CC BY))
Patella fracture with tension band wiring AP and lateral views
Click to expand
AP and lateral knee radiographs demonstrating patella fracture treated with tension band wiring technique. The figure-of-eight wire configuration provides dynamic compression during knee flexion, converting tensile forces to compressive forces at the articular surface.Credit: PMC - CC BY 4.0

Critical Patella Fracture Exam Points

Test Active Extension!

Active straight leg raise is the key exam finding. Failed SLR = disrupted extensor mechanism = needs surgery. Test BEFORE giving analgesia - cannot assess after.

Operative Indications

Surgery indicated for: Displacement over 2-3mm, articular step over 2mm, loss of active extension. Any doubt about extension = operative management.

Tension Band Principle

Converts tensile forces to compressive forces at articular surface during knee flexion. This allows early motion and compression with loading.

Hardware Problems

50% require hardware removal - mainly K-wires/TBW prominence. Counsel patients preoperatively. Screw fixation may have lower removal rates.

Quick Decision Guide

Fracture PatternKey AssessmentTreatmentPearl
Non-displaced (under 2mm), intact extensionCan actively extendCylinder cast/brace 4-6 weeksWeekly X-rays first 2 weeks
Displaced transverse (over 2mm)Gap or step-off visibleORIF - TBW or cannulated screwsTension band principle applies
Comminuted reconstructableMajor fragments identifiableORIF with multiple techniquesCerclage + TBW or basket plate
Comminuted non-reconstructableMultiple small fragmentsPartial patellectomy + repairPreserve as much as possible
Inferior pole fractureSmall pole, intact mechanismExcision + tendon repairUnder 30% pole excised OK
Mnemonic

GAPSOperative Indications

G
Gap over 2-3mm
Fracture displacement
A
Active extension lost
Failed straight leg raise
P
Patellofemoral step over 2mm
Articular incongruity
S
Surgery needed
All are operative indications

Memory Hook:If there are GAPS, you need surgery!

Mnemonic

COMPRESSTension Band Principle

C
Converts
Changes force direction
O
Opposite
Tensile becomes compressive
M
Motion
Allows early knee motion
P
Principle
AO/Pauwels principle
R
Reduces
Fracture gap
E
Eccentric
Wire on tension side
S
Surface
Articular surface benefits
S
Stabilizes
Dynamic compression

Memory Hook:The wire on the front COMPRESSES the joint as you bend the knee!

Mnemonic

LEVERPatella Function

L
Lever arm
Increases extensor moment arm
E
Extension power
Increases by 30-50%
V
Variable contact
Area changes with flexion
E
Eccentric loading
Descending stairs/slopes
R
Retinacular tension
Medial and lateral support

Memory Hook:The patella is a LEVER that increases extension power!

Mnemonic

WIREDTBW Construct

W
Wire figure-8
Anterior to K-wires
I
Intraosseous K-wires
Two parallel pins
R
Reduce gap
With knee extended
E
Eight configuration
Classic figure-8 pattern
D
Dynamic compression
With flexion

Memory Hook:WIRED correctly means the patella will heal!

Overview and Epidemiology

Why This Topic Matters

Patella fractures test your understanding of the extensor mechanism, the tension band principle, and decision-making around fixation vs partial patellectomy. The examiner wants to hear you discuss biomechanics and early motion.

Demographics

  • Bimodal: Young (high-energy) and elderly (falls)
  • Male:Female 2:1
  • Peak age: 20-50 years
  • Often isolated injury in direct blow

Mechanism

  • Direct blow: Dashboard injury, fall on knee
  • Indirect: Forceful eccentric contraction (landing)
  • Combined: Most common - direct + muscle contraction

Anatomy and Biomechanics

Key Anatomical Concept

The patella is the largest sesamoid bone in the body. It increases the lever arm of the extensor mechanism by up to 50%, improving quadriceps efficiency. Patellofemoral contact forces reach 3-7x body weight during stair descent.

Patella Anatomy

Bony Structure

  • Largest sesamoid in body
  • Triangular with apex inferior
  • Articular surface has lateral facet (larger) and medial facet
  • Odd facet on far medial edge
  • 3-7cm long, 2-3cm thick

Soft Tissue

  • Quadriceps tendon inserts on superior pole
  • Patellar tendon originates from inferior pole
  • Medial retinaculum: VMO, MPFL
  • Lateral retinaculum: VL, ITB fibers
  • Expansions allow some extension even with fracture

Blood Supply

Blood supply from superior and inferior genicular arteries forming an extraosseous anastomotic ring. Vessels enter mainly on the anterior surface and inferior pole. This is why anterior surgical approach is safe.

Biomechanical Function

FunctionMechanismClinical Relevance
Increase lever armMoves extensor axis anterior30-50% increase in extensor moment
Distribute forcesIncreases contact areaReduces patellofemoral stress
Protect femoral condylesCovers trochleaPrevents direct trauma
Provide smooth glidingArticular cartilage (thickest in body)5-7mm cartilage at center

Patellectomy Consequences

Total patellectomy reduces extensor strength by 30% and increases patellofemoral contact stress by eliminating the lever arm. Avoid if possible - partial patellectomy preferred if reconstruction not feasible.

The Tension Band Principle

Core Concept

The anterior surface of the patella is the tension side (pulled apart by quadriceps), while the articular surface is the compression side. Placing a wire anteriorly converts tensile forces into compressive forces at the articular surface during knee flexion.

Principle ElementMechanismClinical Application
Wire placementAnterior to fracture axisFigure-8 wire in front of K-wires
Force conversionTensile becomes compressiveArticular surface compressed with flexion
Dynamic compressionMotion increases compressionEarly ROM encouraged
PrerequisitesIntact cortex on compression sideOnly works if articular cortex intact

Classification Systems

Fracture Pattern Classification

PatternFrequencyCharacteristicsTreatment
Transverse50%Central fracture, usually 2 fragmentsTBW or screws if displaced
Comminuted30%Multiple fragments, high-energyReconstruct if possible, partial patellectomy if not
Inferior pole10%Avulsion by patellar tendonExcision + repair if small, ORIF if large
Superior poleRareAvulsion by quads tendonORIF or excision + repair
Vertical/Sagittal5%Sagittal plane, often undisplacedUsually stable, conservative
OsteochondralRareWith patellar dislocationFragment removal or fixation

AO/OTA Classification

TypeDescriptionSubtype Examples
34-AExtra-articularA1: Avulsion, A2: Transverse extra-articular
34-BPartial articularB1: Vertical, B2: Transverse marginal
34-CComplete articularC1: Transverse, C2: Transverse + 2nd fragment, C3: Comminuted

Clinical Assessment

History

  • Mechanism: Direct blow, fall, dashboard
  • Ability to walk after injury
  • Knee swelling - hemarthrosis if intra-articular
  • Previous knee surgery or patella problems
  • Occupation/sport - return to activity considerations

Key Examination

  • Palpable gap at patella (indicates displacement)
  • Hemarthrosis - tense effusion
  • ACTIVE EXTENSION - straight leg raise (critical!)
  • Retinacular integrity (can extend despite fracture?)
  • Skin condition - may be open fracture

Test Active Extension FIRST!

Active straight leg raise is the KEY clinical test. Perform BEFORE giving analgesia - pain inhibits accurate assessment. Failed SLR = disrupted extensor mechanism = operative indication regardless of displacement.

False Negative SLR

Some patients with patella fractures can still extend the knee via intact retinaculae (medial and lateral expansions). This doesn't mean the fracture is stable - X-ray and examination of gap still determine treatment.

Investigations

Imaging Protocol

First LineAP and Lateral X-rays

Lateral view is most important - shows displacement, gap, step-off. AP shows transverse vs vertical pattern. Get knee fully extended for accurate assessment.

AdditionalSkyline/Merchant View

Shows patellofemoral joint articular surface. Helps assess vertical fractures and chondral injury. May be difficult acutely due to pain.

If UncertainCT Scan

For comminuted fractures to plan reconstruction. Assess posterior cortex integrity. 3D reconstructions helpful for operative planning.

Key X-ray Findings

Lateral View

  • Measure displacement (gap between fragments)
  • Articular step-off at patellofemoral joint
  • Over 2-3mm separation = surgical indication
  • May see hemarthrosis (joint effusion)

AP View

  • Fracture pattern (transverse, vertical, comminuted)
  • Width of patella
  • Bipartite patella (DDx - typically superolateral)
  • Osteochondral fragments if dislocated

Bipartite Patella

Bipartite patella is present in 1-2% of population, usually superolateral fragment. Differentiate from fracture by: rounded margins, no hemarthrosis, bilateral comparison (often bilateral). Occasionally symptomatic without trauma.

When to Order CT

IndicationReason
Comminuted fracturePlan reconstruction vs partial patellectomy
Articular depressionAssess step-off better than X-ray
Pre-op planningFragment size, number, position
Associated tibial plateau injuryHigh-energy mechanism

Radiographic Examples

📊 Management Algorithm
Patella Fracture Management Algorithm
Click to expand
Comprehensive management algorithm for patella fractures based on displacement, mechanism integrity, and fracture pattern.Credit: OrthoVellum

Management Algorithm

Operative vs Non-Operative Decision

Operative indications: (1) Displacement over 2-3mm, (2) Articular step over 2mm, (3) Lost active extension. Non-operative only if: non-displaced (under 2mm), intact active extension, and patient compliant.

Conservative Management

Non-Operative Protocol

ImmobilizationWeek 0-2

Cylinder cast or hinged knee brace locked in extension. Weight bearing as tolerated with brace.

X-ray CheckWeek 2

Repeat X-ray to confirm no displacement. If displaced now, conversion to surgery.

Progressive MotionWeek 2-6

If stable at 2 weeks, begin ROM exercises. Unlock brace gradually. Continue cylinder for walking.

StrengtheningWeek 6+

Discard brace if X-ray shows healing. Quadriceps strengthening. Return to activity by 3 months.

Non-Operative Criteria

Non-operative management requires: Displacement under 2mm, articular step under 2mm, intact active extension, and reliable patient for weekly X-rays initially (secondary displacement occurs).

Tension Band Wiring (TBW)

TBW Technique

PositioningStep 1

Supine, tourniquet. Anterior midline incision. Evacuate hematoma. Reduce fracture with pointed reduction clamps.

K-wire PlacementStep 2

Two parallel K-wires (1.6-2.0mm) from inferior to superior pole. Stay in bone centrally. Wires should be parallel and intraosseous.

Figure-8 WireStep 3

1.2-1.25mm cerclage wire in figure-8 configuration anterior to K-wires. Wire passes through quadriceps and patellar tendon or bone tunnels.

TensioningStep 4

Twist wire knots on BOTH sides equally. Check articular surface is reduced. Knee should flex to 90° without gap opening.

FinalizationStep 5

Bend K-wire ends and bury beneath quads tendon. Cut excess wire. Close retinaculum if torn. Assess ROM intraop.

TBW Technical Pearls

  • K-wires MUST be parallel and intraosseous
  • Wire must be anterior to K-wire axis
  • Equal tensioning both knots
  • Bend K-wire ends to prevent migration

TBW Pitfalls

  • Hardware prominence - 50% need removal
  • Wire breakage with non-union
  • K-wire migration if not bent properly
  • Loss of reduction if wire not tensioned

Cannulated Screw Fixation

Screw vs TBW

Cannulated screw fixation (with or without tension band wire through screws) is increasingly preferred for simple transverse fractures. Advantages: lower profile, less prominence, lower removal rate. Disadvantage: needs good bone quality.

FactorTBWCannulated Screws
Hardware prominenceHigh (50% removal)Low (lower removal rate)
Construct strengthStrong in tensionStrong if good bone
ComminutionBetter for multiple fragmentsLess suitable for comminuted
Bone qualityLess dependentNeeds adequate bone for screw purchase
Technical easeFamiliar techniqueRequires cannulated system

Screw Technique

ReductionStep 1

Reduce fracture anatomically. Use pointed reduction clamps temporarily.

GuidewiresStep 2

Two parallel guidewires from inferior pole to superior pole. Confirm position on fluoro.

Screw InsertionStep 3

Over-drill near cortex for lag effect. Insert 4.0mm or 4.5mm cannulated screws. Apply compression.

Optional TBWStep 4

May add figure-8 wire through screw heads (cannulated system allows this). Provides additional tension band effect.

Partial Patellectomy

Indications for Partial Patellectomy

Indicated when a pole cannot be reconstructed (comminuted small fragments) but the rest of the patella is salvageable. More common for inferior pole fractures. Preserve as much patella as possible.

Partial Patellectomy Technique

AssessmentStep 1

Identify non-reconstructable pole fragment(s). Usually inferior pole comminuted.

ExcisionStep 2

Excise fragments down to viable patella. Create flat bony bed.

Tendon RepairStep 3

Drill transosseous tunnels in remaining patella. Pass heavy non-absorbable sutures through patellar tendon and tunnels.

TensioningStep 4

Repair with knee at 30° flexion. Tension to match patellar height of contralateral side (use fluoro).

Inferior Pole Excision

Excision of up to 30% of the inferior pole with tendon repair gives satisfactory results. More than 50% excision significantly weakens extension. Total patellectomy is rarely if ever indicated now.

Surgical Technique

Modified Tension Band Wiring

Lateral knee radiograph showing patella fracture tension band wiring
Click to expand
Lateral radiograph demonstrating patella fracture fixation with modified tension band wiring technique. Note the two parallel K-wires with cerclage wire in figure-of-eight configuration anterior to the fracture, providing dynamic compression during knee flexion.Credit: PMC - CC BY 4.0
AP knee radiograph showing patella fracture tension band wiring
Click to expand
AP radiograph demonstrating patella fracture fixation with tension band wiring. The parallel K-wires traverse from inferior to superior pole, with the cerclage wire passed through bone tunnels creating the figure-of-eight tension band construct.Credit: PMC - CC BY 4.0

Patient Positioning:

  • Supine on radiolucent table
  • Knee flexed over bolster or triangle
  • Ensure full fluoroscopy access

Approach:

  • Longitudinal midline incision
  • Preserve prepatellar bursa if possible
  • Evacuate hematoma and debris
  • Inspect articular surface

Reduction:

  • Reduce fracture with pointed reduction clamps
  • Assess articular congruity with palpation and fluoro
  • Accept no more than 2mm step-off

K-Wire Placement:

  • Two parallel 1.6-2.0mm K-wires
  • Enter through superior pole, exit inferior pole
  • Avoid articular penetration
  • Wires parallel and medial-lateral to avoid impingement

Figure-of-Eight Wire:

  • 18-gauge cerclage wire
  • Pass through anterior cortex (not intramedullary)
  • Figure-of-eight configuration around K-wire ends
  • Twist anteriorly to compress fracture
  • Bend K-wires and bury into bone

Proper technique ensures compression during knee flexion.

Cannulated Screw Technique

Cannulated screw fixation of patella fracture case series
Click to expand
Cannulated screw fixation for transverse patella fracture: (A) AP view showing parallel cannulated screws, (B) lateral view with lag screw compression, (C,D) healed fracture with hardware in situ. Screw fixation provides lower profile than TBW with reduced hardware irritation.Credit: PMC - CC BY 4.0

Advantages Over TBW:

  • Lower hardware irritation and removal rates
  • Less soft tissue prominence
  • Good for simple transverse fractures

Technique:

  • Parallel guide wires across fracture
  • Usually two 4.0mm or 4.5mm cannulated screws
  • Lag screw technique for compression
  • Screws oriented perpendicular to fracture

Add Anterior Tension Band:

  • Consider adding figure-of-eight wire
  • Converts construct to true tension band
  • Especially if concerned about fixation strength

Fragment-Specific Fixation:

  • Headless screws for small fragments
  • Mini-fragment plates for comminuted patterns
  • Suture anchors for inferior pole avulsions

Screw fixation provides reliable results with lower removal rates.

Managing Comminuted Fractures

Comminuted patella fracture with complex fixation
Click to expand
Lateral radiograph demonstrating comminuted patella fracture treated with combined fixation technique using multiple K-wires and cerclage wires. Complex comminuted patterns may require multiple techniques including partial patellectomy if fragments are non-reconstructable.Credit: PMC - CC BY 4.0

Principles:

  • Reconstruct articular surface first
  • Use multiple techniques as needed
  • Consider partial patellectomy if severe

Plate Fixation:

  • Low-profile mesh or locking plates
  • Particularly for inferior pole comminution
  • Acts as buttress to support fragments

Suture/Cable Techniques:

  • FiberWire or cable instead of wire
  • Basket weave technique through quadriceps
  • Good for osteoporotic bone

Partial Patellectomy:

  • Excise comminuted pole (usually inferior)
  • Up to 30% can be excised
  • Advance and repair tendon to remaining patella
  • More than 50% excision compromises function

Total Patellectomy:

  • Last resort, rarely indicated
  • Significant quadriceps weakness
  • Consider only for severe infection or failed salvage

Individualize approach based on fracture pattern and bone quality.

Complications

ComplicationIncidenceRisk FactorsManagement
Hardware irritation/removalUp to 50%TBW, thin soft tissuePlanned second surgery counseling
Stiffness10-20%Prolonged immobilization, poor rehabEarly ROM, aggressive physio
Patellofemoral OA40-50% long-termArticular damage, malreductionActivity modification, ?later arthroplasty
Non-union2-5%Poor fixation, comminution, infectionRevision fixation or partial patellectomy
Loss of reduction5-10%Poor fixation technique, early loadingRevision ORIF
Extensor lag5-10%Lengthening of mechanismQuadriceps strengthening, rarely requires revision
Infection1-2%Open fracture, multiple surgeriesWashout, antibiotics, hardware removal if needed

Hardware Removal Rate

50% of patients undergoing TBW require hardware removal (mainly K-wire prominence). Counsel patients preoperatively about likely second surgery. Screw fixation may have lower removal rate.

Postoperative Care and Rehabilitation

Post-ORIF Rehabilitation

Early MotionWeek 0-2

Hinged knee brace. Immediate ROM exercises (tension band allows motion). Brace locked for walking. Heel slides, SLR with brace.

Progressive MotionWeek 2-6

Increase ROM goal to 90° by week 4. Weight bearing as tolerated in brace. Pool therapy if available.

StrengtheningWeek 6-12

Discard brace as strength improves. Quadriceps strengthening progresses. Stationary biking.

Return to ActivityMonth 3-6

Return to normal activity if X-ray shows union. Running at 3-4 months. Sport-specific by 4-6 months.

Why Early Motion?

Tension band fixation is designed for early active motion. Knee flexion creates compression at articular surface, promoting healing. Prolonged immobilization leads to stiffness and poor outcomes.

Outcomes and Prognosis

Functional Outcomes

Outcomes by Pattern and Treatment

Pattern/TreatmentUnion RateGood FunctionKey Issues
Transverse + TBW95-98%85-90%Hardware removal common (50%)
Transverse + screws95-98%85-90%Lower removal rate (10%)
Comminuted + ORIF85-95%70-80%Depends on articular restoration
Partial patellectomyN/A70-80%Up to 30% excision well tolerated
Non-operative (stable)95%+85-90%For undisplaced, intact mechanism

Prognostic Factors

Favorable Factors

Simple transverse pattern, Minimal articular comminution, Anatomic reduction achieved, Early ROM rehabilitation, Compliant patient

Unfavorable Factors

Comminuted pattern, Significant articular damage, Malreduction (over 2mm step-off), Prolonged immobilization, Open fracture or infection

Long-term Outcomes

Most patients achieve satisfactory outcomes with proper treatment. The main long-term issue is patellofemoral osteoarthritis, which develops in 40-50% of patients by 10-20 years. Hardware irritation requiring removal is the most common early complication with TBW. Extensor mechanism function is generally well preserved with modern fixation techniques. Total knee arthroplasty may eventually be required for severe post-traumatic arthritis.

Evidence Base and Key Trials

TBW vs Cannulated Screws - Meta-Analysis

2
Dy CJ et al. • J Knee Surg (2012)
Key Findings:
  • Meta-analysis comparing TBW and screw fixation
  • Similar union rates and functional outcomes
  • TBW higher hardware removal rate (50% vs 10%)
  • Screws lower profile preferred by patients
Clinical Implication: Cannulated screws have lower hardware complications. Consider for simple transverse fractures with good bone quality.
Limitation: Heterogeneous studies, variable techniques.

Partial Patellectomy Outcomes

3
Marder RA et al. • Clin Orthop Relat Res (1993)
Key Findings:
  • Retrospective review of partial patellectomy
  • Excision up to 30% gives good functional results
  • Quadriceps strength preserved if under 50%
  • Total patellectomy has poor outcomes
Clinical Implication: Partial patellectomy with tendon repair is preferable to total excision for non-reconstructable polar fractures.
Limitation: Older study, retrospective.

Locking Plates for Patella

3
Thelen S et al. • J Orthop Trauma (2013)
Key Findings:
  • Prospective study of mesh/basket locking plates
  • Useful for comminuted fractures
  • Lower hardware removal than TBW in comminuted
  • Maintains fragments in position
Clinical Implication: Consider locking mesh plates for comminuted fractures where TBW alone is insufficient.
Limitation: Small numbers, newer technique.

Operative vs Non-Operative Thresholds

3
Carpenter JE et al. • J Orthop Trauma (1997)
Key Findings:
  • 2-3mm displacement used as threshold
  • Articular step over 2mm affects outcomes
  • Intact active extension alone not sufficient criterion
  • Serial X-rays needed for non-operative
Clinical Implication: Use 2-3mm displacement and 2mm step as operative thresholds. Monitor non-operative closely for secondary displacement.
Limitation: Consensus-based thresholds, limited RCT evidence.

Cable Pin System

Yang KH et al. • Clin Orthop Relat Res (2003)
Key Findings:
  • Alternative to TBW with lower profile
  • Cable through bone tunnels and around pins
  • Lower irritation rate than K-wires
  • Biomechanically similar
Clinical Implication: Cable systems may reduce hardware irritation compared to traditional TBW with K-wires.
Limitation: Equipment availability varies.

Exam Viva Scenarios

Practice these scenarios to excel in your viva examination

VIVA SCENARIOStandard

Scenario 1: Displaced Transverse Patella Fracture

EXAMINER

"A 35-year-old man falls off a ladder onto his knee. He cannot straighten his leg. X-ray shows a transverse patella fracture with 5mm of displacement. He is otherwise healthy. What is your management?"

EXCEPTIONAL ANSWER
This is a displaced transverse patella fracture in a young healthy man - a clear operative indication. My assessment confirms: First, he cannot actively extend the knee, indicating **extensor mechanism disruption**. Second, 5mm displacement exceeds the 2-3mm threshold for surgery. Third, he is young with good bone quality and high functional demands. For surgical management, I would perform **ORIF within 1-2 weeks**. My preferred technique for this simple transverse pattern would be either **cannulated screw fixation** or **tension band wiring**. For cannulated screws: two 4.0mm parallel lag screws from inferior to superior pole, which provides good compression and has lower hardware prominence. I may add a cerclage wire through the screw heads if I want additional tension band effect. Alternatively, classic TBW with two parallel K-wires and figure-8 cerclage wire remains reliable. The key principle is the **tension band** - the wire/construct must be anterior to the fracture axis so that knee flexion compresses the articular surface. Post-operatively, I would allow **early ROM** from day one as the tension band construct allows motion. He would be in a hinged brace, weight bearing as tolerated, and progress to full motion by 6 weeks.
KEY POINTS TO SCORE
5mm displacement + lost extension = clear surgical indication
Tension band principle: anterior wire converts tension to compression
Options: cannulated screws (lower profile) or TBW (reliable, versatile)
Early ROM is key - tension band construct allows motion
Counsel about 50% hardware removal rate if using TBW
COMMON TRAPS
✗Attempting non-operative with 5mm displacement - will fail
✗Not explaining tension band principle
✗Forgetting to counsel about hardware removal
✗Prolonged immobilization post-op - leads to stiffness
LIKELY FOLLOW-UPS
"How would you modify your technique if this were a 75-year-old with osteoporosis?"
"What if the fracture was comminuted?"
"Describe the steps of TBW technique"
VIVA SCENARIOChallenging

Scenario 2: Comminuted Inferior Pole Fracture

EXAMINER

"A 50-year-old woman trips and falls onto her knee. X-ray shows a comminuted inferior pole patella fracture with multiple small fragments (largest 1cm). She cannot actively extend. CT confirms 4 small fragments making up the inferior 25% of the patella. How would you manage this?"

EXCEPTIONAL ANSWER
This is a comminuted inferior pole patella fracture involving approximately 25% of the patella - the fragments are too small to reconstruct with standard techniques. My management would be: First, confirm the clinical assessment - she cannot actively extend, confirming extensor mechanism disruption requiring surgery. Second, review the CT carefully - are any fragments large enough to fix? With 4 small fragments and the largest being 1cm, reconstruction would be challenging and unlikely to hold. Third, my recommended treatment is **partial inferior patellectomy with patellar tendon repair**. The technique involves: excising the comminuted fragments, creating a flat bone surface on the remaining patella, drilling two or three transosseous tunnels, and passing heavy non-absorbable sutures (e.g., FiberWire or Ethibond) through the patellar tendon and through the tunnels. I would tension the repair with the knee at 30 degrees flexion and match patellar height to the contralateral side using intraoperative fluoroscopy. Evidence shows that excision of up to **30% of the patella** gives satisfactory functional outcomes, and since she has 25% involvement, this is within acceptable limits. Post-operatively, she would be protected in a hinged brace, with ROM beginning at 2-3 weeks, but avoiding resisted extension for 6 weeks to protect the repair.
KEY POINTS TO SCORE
Small comminuted fragments cannot be reconstructed reliably
Partial patellectomy with tendon repair indicated
Up to 30% inferior pole excision has good outcomes
Transosseous suture technique for tendon to bone
Protect repair from resisted extension for 6 weeks
COMMON TRAPS
✗Attempting to fix tiny fragments with multiple screws - will fail
✗Total patellectomy - unnecessary and poor functional outcome
✗Not tensioning repair appropriately - leads to patella alta
✗Early resisted extension - risks re-rupture
LIKELY FOLLOW-UPS
"What if the comminution involved 50% of the patella?"
"How do you prevent patella alta after this procedure?"
"What is the long-term prognosis after partial patellectomy?"
VIVA SCENARIOCritical

Scenario 3: Non-Displaced Patella Fracture

EXAMINER

"A 65-year-old diabetic woman presents after tripping on a rug. She has painful knee swelling but can actively extend her knee (demonstrated straight leg raise in ED before analgesia was given). X-ray shows a transverse patella fracture with approximately 1-2mm of displacement. How would you manage this?"

EXCEPTIONAL ANSWER
This is a minimally displaced transverse patella fracture with intact active extension - a patient who may be suitable for non-operative management, but requires careful consideration. Key factors in my decision: First, she demonstrated active straight leg raise before analgesia, confirming the **retinaculae are intact** and she has functional extension. Second, the displacement is borderline (1-2mm) - at the threshold. Third, she is 65 with diabetes, which increases surgical and healing risks. My management would lean toward **non-operative treatment** given: borderline displacement, intact extension, comorbidities. The protocol would be: (1) Cylinder cast or hinged brace locked in extension for 4-6 weeks. (2) **Serial X-rays weekly for first 2 weeks** - critical to detect secondary displacement which occurs in up to 10-20%. (3) Weight bearing as tolerated in brace. (4) If any increased displacement or loss of extension, convert to surgery. If she remains stable at 2 weeks, begin ROM exercises in the brace. I would emphasize patient education - she must understand that secondary displacement means surgery. I would also monitor her diabetes closely as it affects wound healing if surgery becomes necessary.
KEY POINTS TO SCORE
1-2mm displacement with intact extension = consider non-operative
Intact SLR indicates functional retinaculae
Serial X-rays essential - secondary displacement occurs
Low threshold to convert to surgery if displacement increases
Patient selection: compliant patient, able to follow protocol
COMMON TRAPS
✗Automatic surgery for all patella fractures
✗Non-operative without close monitoring (missing displacement)
✗Not checking X-rays at 1-2 weeks
✗Not discussing surgical backup if displacement occurs
LIKELY FOLLOW-UPS
"At 1 week follow-up, X-ray shows the gap has increased to 4mm. What now?"
"What are the risks of non-operative treatment?"
"How long does patella fracture take to heal?"

MCQ Practice Points

Anatomy Question

Q: By how much does the patella increase the extensor mechanism moment arm? A: 30-50%. The patella acts as a lever (sesamoid) that increases the quadriceps moment arm, improving efficiency. Patellectomy significantly weakens extension.

Operative Threshold Question

Q: What displacement threshold indicates need for surgical fixation of patella fractures? A: Greater than 2-3mm fracture displacement or greater than 2mm articular step. Loss of active extension is also an absolute indication regardless of displacement.

Fixation Question

Q: What is the principle behind tension band wiring? A: The wire is placed on the tension side (anterior) of the patella. During knee flexion, the tensile forces are converted to compressive forces at the articular surface, promoting healing.

Complication Question

Q: What percentage of patients require hardware removal after TBW? A: Up to 50%. This is mainly due to K-wire prominence causing anterior knee pain. Cannulated screw fixation has lower removal rates due to lower profile.

Partial Patellectomy Question

Q: What percentage of the patella can be safely excised without significant functional loss? A: Up to 30% of the inferior pole. Beyond 50% excision, extensor strength is significantly compromised. Total patellectomy results in 30% strength loss.

Pattern Question

Q: What is the most common patella fracture pattern? A: Transverse fracture (50%). This is followed by comminuted (30%), polar fractures (10-15%), and vertical (5%). Transverse fractures are typically fixed with TBW or screws.

Australian Context

Epidemiology

  • Common in falls (elderly) and MVA (young)
  • Work-related injuries - WorkCover implications
  • Sports injuries (AFL, rugby) in athletes
  • Increasing cycling-related injuries

Healthcare Funding

  • Public waiting lists for hardware removal
  • Private insurance covers most procedures

Medicolegal Considerations

Key documentation: (1) Active extension tested BEFORE analgesia given, (2) Displacement measurements from good-quality lateral X-ray, (3) Informed consent including hardware removal discussion (particularly for TBW), (4) Serial X-ray protocol for non-operative management. Missed secondary displacement in non-operative cases is a potential litigation risk.

PATELLA FRACTURES

High-Yield Exam Summary

Key Anatomy

  • •Largest sesamoid bone
  • •Increases extensor moment arm by 30-50%
  • •Blood supply: genicular arteries, anterior
  • •Thickest articular cartilage (5-7mm)

Operative Indications (GAPS)

  • •Gap over 2-3mm displacement
  • •Active extension lost (failed SLR)
  • •Patellofemoral step over 2mm
  • •Surgery for any of the above

Tension Band Principle

  • •Wire placed ANTERIOR to fracture
  • •Converts tensile to compressive force
  • •Allows early ROM (motion = compression)
  • •Only works if posterior cortex intact

Fixation Options

  • •TBW: K-wires + figure-8 wire (classic)
  • •Cannulated screws: lower profile, less removal
  • •Basket plates: for comminuted fractures
  • •Partial patellectomy: non-reconstructable poles

Complications

  • •Hardware removal: 50% for TBW
  • •Patellofemoral OA: 40-50% long-term
  • •Stiffness: if immobilized too long
  • •Extensor lag: if lengthened mechanism

Important Numbers

  • •2-3mm: displacement threshold for surgery
  • •2mm: step-off threshold for surgery
  • •30%: pole excision acceptable
  • •50%: hardware removal rate TBW
Quick Stats
Reading Time102 min
Related Topics

Acetabular Fractures

Acromioclavicular Joint Injuries

Acute Compartment Syndrome

Ankle Fractures