Exam Prep

The Mindset Shift: Transitioning from Written to Clinical Exams

Passing the written exam is only halftime. The clinical exam requires a completely different skillset. Learn how to pivot from 'knowledge accumulation' to 'performance art'.

D
Dr. Study Smart
5 January 2026
4 min read

Quick Summary

Passing the written exam is only halftime. The clinical exam requires a completely different skillset. Learn how to pivot from 'knowledge accumulation' to 'performance art'.

Visual Element: A comparative table titled "The Pivot," contrasting "Written Exam Traits" (Speed, Detail, Convergence, Isolation) with "Clinical Exam Traits" (Pace, Safety, Divergence, Communication).

You passed Part 1. Now the real work begins.

There is a dangerous period in surgical training: the week after passing the Written Examination. The relief is immense. The dopamine hits. You feel like you know everything. But the Written Exam and the Clinical Exam are different sports.

  • The Written Exam is a Sprint. It tests knowledge recall, speed, and facts.
  • The Clinical Exam is a Dance. It tests judgment, safety, communication, and persona.

Many candidates who top the Written Exam fail the Clinical. Why? Because they refuse to change their game.

The Three Fatal Errors

1. The "Fact Vomit"

In a written exam, knowing the 14th cause of hypercalcemia gets you a mark. In a clinical viva, listing 14 causes of hypercalcemia when the patient has a metastatic femur fracture makes you look dangerous. It shows a lack of prioritization.

  • The Shift: Move from Comprehensive to Relevant.

2. The "Student" Mindset

Registrars are trained to ask permission. "Boss, can I fix this?" In the exam, you are the boss. The examiners are your colleagues.

  • The Shift: Stop asking. Start deciding. "I will fix this using..." not "I would think about..."

3. The "Robot" Persona

You can get 100% on an MCQ without smiling. In a clinical exam, if you are cold, robotic, or arrogant, you will fail the "Professionalism" domain.

  • The Shift: You are a doctor treating a human. Show empathy. Introduce yourself. Wash your hands. Smile.

The Anatomy of a Clinical Answer

You must restructure how you speak.

The "Headline" Method

Journalists put the most important news in the headline, not the last paragraph.

  • Written Style: "Well, looking at the bloods, the CRP is up, and the X-ray shows gas, so..." (Rambling).
  • Clinical Style: "This is Necrotizing Fasciitis. It is a surgical emergency." (Headline). "My reasons are..." (Details).

Handling Ambiguity

MCQs have one right answer. Patients have many. The Clinical Exam tests your ability to handle the "Grey Zone."

  • "There are two valid options here: Fixation or Replacement. In a 65-year-old active postman, I would favor Replacement because..."
  • Examiners love this. It shows Clinical Reasoning.

Non-Verbal Communication

Experts estimate that 70% of the mark in a viva is decided in the first minute.

  • Dress: Conservative suit. Polished shoes. You are applying for a $300k+ job.
  • Stance: Plant your feet. Don't fidget. Hands in lap or on the table.
  • Eye Contact: Look at the examiner, not the ceiling.

Practical Steps for the Transition

1. Change Your Study Habitat

Stop studying in the library. It is quiet and safe. Study in the Hospital Cafeteria or the Mess. It is loud and distracting. You need to learn to think when there is noise, just like in the real exam.

2. The "Hot Seat"

You cannot learn clinicals alone. You need a group.

  • The Rule: One person is in the "Hot Seat." They cannot break character. The others grill them.
  • Record It: Video yourself. You will be horrified by your "Ums," "Ahs," and fidgeting. This is the fastest way to fix it.

3. Visit Other Hospitals

Your consultants love you. They are used to your quirks. They go easy on you. Go to a different hospital where nobody knows you. Ask the consultants there to viva you. The fear of strangers simulates the exam day adrenaline.

Conclusion

The transition from Written to Clinical is a transition from Science to Art. You have the knowledge (you passed Part 1). Now you need the delivery. Be safe. Be kind. Be a consultant.

References

  1. Gifford, R. "The Arms of the Starfish: A strategy for the clinical exam."
  2. RACS. "Guide to the Fellowship Examination."

Found this helpful?

Share it with your colleagues

Discussion

The Mindset Shift: Transitioning from Written to Clinical Exams | OrthoVellum