Deltopectoral Approach | Tenotomy vs Peel vs Lesser-Tuberosity Osteotomy | Bone-to-Bone Healing Wins
- Deltopectoral interval is the internervous plane (deltoid = axillary nerve; pectoralis major = pectoral nerves)
- Axillary nerve lies at the inferior border of the subscapularis - protect during capsular release and inferior retraction
- Lesser-tuberosity osteotomy gives bone-to-bone healing - the most reliable subscapularis restoration
- Subscapularis failure causes anterior instability, internal-rotation weakness and a positive belly-press
- Restore tension and version - an overtight subscapularis limits external rotation; a loose one fails
When & Why
What it is. Subscapularis management in shoulder arthroplasty is the controlled detachment and repair of the subscapularis tendon from the lesser tuberosity during anatomic glenohumeral arthroplasty through the deltopectoral approach. The subscapularis arises from the subscapular fossa of the scapula, crosses the anterior glenohumeral joint, and inserts on the lesser tuberosity; the bicipital groove separates this insertion from the greater-tuberosity insertions of supraspinatus, infraspinatus and teres minor. The tendon must be taken down to enter the joint and deliver the humeral head, and the chosen takedown-and-repair technique directly governs postoperative internal-rotation strength, the belly-press and lift-off examination, and anterior stability. Three established techniques exist: tenotomy, subscapularis peel and lesser-tuberosity osteotomy. Indications. - Anatomic total shoulder arthroplasty for glenohumeral osteoarthritis with an intact, repairable rotator cuff
- Shoulder hemiarthroplasty for arthritis or avascular necrosis when the glenoid is preserved
- Selected proximal humeral fractures managed through the deltopectoral approach (the tuberosity is already fractured, so a separate osteotomy is not performed)
- Revision shoulder arthroplasty requiring re-exposure of the glenohumeral joint Contraindications to anatomic arthroplasty (a different strategy is needed): - Irreparable massive rotator cuff tear with cuff-tear arthropathy - reverse total shoulder arthroplasty is preferred, and a deficient subscapularis cannot be managed in the standard way
- Severe subscapularis fatty infiltration or tear at the index operation - peel or osteotomy may not be feasible
- Active infection Alternative exposure. The anterosuperior (deltoid-on) approach is used by some surgeons for anatomic arthroplasty and leaves the subscapularis largely undisturbed, but the deltopectoral approach remains the workhorse exposure taught in examinations and is the focus of this page.
The subscapularis is the only anterior rotator cuff muscle and the primary internal rotator, a dynamic anterior stabiliser and a depressor of the humeral head. Its integrity drives the belly-press and lift-off tests and anterior stability. Subscapularis failure produces anterior instability, weakness and a poor outcome - and is largely preventable with a sound repair.
Tendon-to-tendon healing (tenotomy) is the least reliable interface. A peel restores tendon-to-bone healing, and a lesser-tuberosity osteotomy restores bone-to-bone healing - the strongest of the three. The healing hierarchy is the core biomechanical reason to move from a simple tenotomy toward a peel or an osteotomy.
Comparing the three techniques. The three options differ in how the tendon is separated from bone and, crucially, in the healing interface they create.
| Technique | How the tendon is taken down | Healing interface | Repair construct | Relative strength |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Tenotomy | Tendon cut about 1 cm medial to the lesser tuberosity | Tendon-to-tendon (or tendon-to-bone) | End-to-end sutures, bone tunnels or suture anchors | Weakest |
| Subscapularis peel | Tendon elevated sharply off the lesser-tuberosity footprint | Tendon-to-bone | Suture anchors or transosseous tunnels at the footprint | Intermediate |
| Lesser-tuberosity osteotomy | A bone fragment of the lesser tuberosity raised with the tendon | Bone-to-bone | Cerclage sutures around the humeral stem and neck, plus figure-of-eight | Strongest |
Healing hierarchy. Reliability follows a clear order: bone-to-bone (osteotomy) is stronger than tendon-to-bone (peel), which is stronger than tendon-to-tendon (tenotomy). This single fact is the rationale for choosing a peel or an osteotomy over a simple tenotomy, and it is the most commonly asked viva point on the topic. How to choose. A peel or lesser-tuberosity osteotomy is preferred when subscapularis integrity is critical - typically a younger, higher-demand patient - because of superior healing. A tenotomy remains acceptable in lower-demand patients and is the simplest and fastest option; Z-lengthening is added to a tenotomy only when the subscapularis is tight and limits external rotation. An osteotomy is avoided in fracture arthroplasty, where the tuberosity is already fractured and should be repaired directly. A deficient or irreparable subscapularis shifts the decision toward a reverse total shoulder arthroplasty rather than an anatomic design.
The Exposure
Work down through the deltopectoral interval, protect the axillary nerve at the inferior border, take the subscapularis down by the chosen technique, deliver and prepare the joint, then repair the tendon with a construct matched to the takedown and close loosely.
Intra-operative diagram of the deltopectoral approach to the anterior shoulder showing the internervous interval between deltoid (retracted laterally) and pectoralis major (retracted medially), the cephalic vein in the groove, the conjoined tendon retracted medially, and the subscapularis exposed over the lesser tuberosity with the axillary nerve marked at its inferior border.
Context: A verified image is being sourced for this exposure.
Exposure sequence
- Beach-chair (semi-upright) position with the arm draped free so an assistant can rotate and traction the humerus; interscalene block plus general anaesthesia
- Pad all pressure points (sacrum, heels, contralateral elbow), secure the head neutral with eyes protected, and plan C-arm access if imaging is needed
- Palpate and mark the coracoid (medial border of the dissection), the acromion and anterolateral corner (superior extent), the deltopectoral groove, and the bicipital groove and lesser tuberosity
- A longitudinal deltopectoral incision from just below the coracoid toward the deltoid insertion, 10 to 15 cm long, placed slightly lateral to the coracoid so the deep interval opens directly into the groove
- Deepen through subcutaneous fat to fascia and develop the interval between deltoid (laterally, axillary nerve) and pectoralis major (medially, pectoral nerves) - a true internervous plane
- Identify the cephalic vein in the groove and either preserve and retract it laterally with the deltoid or ligate it cleanly
- Open down to the clavipectoral fascia and incise it lateral to the conjoined tendon
- Retract the conjoined tendon (short head of biceps and coracobrachialis) medially with the coracoid
- Ligate the anterior humeral circumflex vessels as they are encountered inferiorly
- The subscapularis and anterior capsule are now exposed over the front of the joint; identify the biceps tendon in its groove as a landmark
- Externally rotate the arm to put the subscapularis under tension and bring the lesser tuberosity into view
- Before any takedown, palpate the axillary nerve along the inferior capsule where it wraps around the surgical neck, at the inferior border of the subscapularis
- Keep all retractors on bone; never place a retractor blindly deep to the inferior subscapularis
- Perform any inferior capsular release under direct vision
- Detach the tendon from the lesser tuberosity using the chosen technique: tenotomy (cut about 1 cm medial to the insertion), subscapularis peel (elevate sharply off the footprint), or lesser-tuberosity osteotomy (raise a bone fragment with the tendon)
- Incise the capsule in line with, or separately from, the subscapularis and enter the glenohumeral joint
- Deliver the humeral head into the wound by extension and external rotation so preparation can proceed
- Use the bicipital groove and native retroversion to plan the humeral head osteotomy, cut in about 20 to 30 degrees of retroversion relative to the epicondylar axis so the prosthetic head sits anatomically and the subscapularis repair is tensioned correctly; prepare the canal and trial the stem and head
- Retract the humeral head posteriorly to expose the glenoid; address the labrum, biceps anchor and osteophytes, then prepare and trial the glenoid
- Assess soft-tissue tension, version and stability with the trials in place before final fixation
- Repair using the construct matching the takedown: transosseous bone tunnels or suture anchors for tenotomy or peel, or cerclage sutures (typically two heavy non-absorbable sutures around the humeral stem and neck, plus figure-of-eight) for a lesser-tuberosity osteotomy
- Set the tension so the arm rests in slight external rotation without strain on the repair and without slack
- Re-check tension and humeral version after fixation
- Close the deltopectoral interval loosely (a tight closure can constrain motion)
- Close the subcutaneous layer with absorbable suture and the skin with sutures or a subcuticular absorbable monofilament
- Apply a sterile dressing and a sling or shoulder immobiliser with the arm in neutral to slight external rotation to off-load the repair
The axillary nerve runs along the inferior border of the subscapularis and then wraps around the surgical neck of the humerus. It is the single most important structure at risk during subscapularis takedown, inferior capsular release and inferior retraction. Protect it by staying on bone, by palpating it along the inferior capsule, by never placing a retractor blindly deep to the inferior subscapularis, and by performing any inferior release under direct vision. Injury weakens deltoid abduction and teres minor external rotation.
The deltopectoral approach uses the deltoid (axillary nerve) / pectoralis major (pectoral nerves) internervous plane. The subscapularis (upper and lower subscapular nerves) is then the structure deliberately taken down - it is not itself an internervous interval. Examiners commonly ask for the internervous plane (deltoid versus pectoralis major) and then for the structure that must be divided to enter the joint (the subscapularis).
Dangers & Extensions
Structures at risk, by layer
| Layer | Structure at risk | Protection |
|---|---|---|
| Superficial | Cephalic vein in the deltopectoral groove | Identify in the groove; retract laterally with the deltoid or ligate cleanly |
| Deep medial | Musculocutaneous nerve (enters coracobrachialis 3 to 8 cm distal to the coracoid) | Gentle retraction of the conjoined tendon; stay on its lateral aspect |
| Deep inferior | Axillary nerve (inferior border of the subscapularis, around the surgical neck) | Stay on bone; palpate during inferior release; no blind inferior retractors |
| Capsular inferior | Anterior humeral circumflex artery and veins | Controlled coagulation or ligation as encountered inferiorly |
| Bony landmark | Biceps tendon in the bicipital groove | Identify and protect, or tenodese as planned |
Extensile options. Extend proximally along the groove toward the coracoid and clavicle to reach the rotator interval, the coracoid, the conjoined tendon and the acromioclavicular joint (useful for combined rotator-cuff repair or coracoplasty). Extend distally along the humeral shaft toward the deltoid insertion to reach the proximal humeral diaphysis (rarely needed for arthroplasty, but useful in fracture or revision with stem extension). The posterior cuff and posterior glenoid are not addressed by this approach alone and may require adjunct windows or repositioning in complex revisions. Postoperative protection of the repair (approximately 6 weeks). - Sling or shoulder immobiliser, with the arm in neutral to slight external rotation
- Passive and active-assisted forward flexion as prescribed, with pendulums
- Limit passive external rotation beyond the safe intra-operative range
- Avoid active internal rotation against resistance (for example, pushing up from a chair) for 6 weeks Rehabilitation phases. - Phase 1 (0 to 6 weeks): protection and passive or active-assisted motion; pendulums; no resisted internal rotation
- Phase 2 (6 to 12 weeks): progressive active motion and gentle strengthening; restore rotation
- Phase 3 (3 months and beyond): progressive resistance and return to function Complications | Complication | Prevention | Management | |--------------|------------|------------| | Subscapularis failure / anterior instability | Sound repair, correct tension and version, 6-week protection | Bracing; revision repair; pectoralis major transfer for chronic insufficiency | | Axillary nerve injury | Stay on bone, palpate the nerve, no blind inferior retractors | Observe for neurapraxia; explore if no recovery; rehabilitation | | Musculocutaneous nerve injury | Gentle medial retraction of the conjoined tendon | Observe; most recover; rehabilitation | | Stiffness | Early controlled motion within limits | Physiotherapy; manipulation under anaesthesia or release if persistent | | Infection | Aseptic technique, prophylactic antibiotics | Irrigation and debridement; component retention or revision as indicated | | Osteotomy nonunion or migration (LTO) | Precise technique, secure cerclage | Revision fixation if symptomatic |
Procedures Through This Approach
- Anatomic total shoulder arthroplasty - the principal operation done through this exposure
- Shoulder hemiarthroplasty for arthritis or avascular necrosis with the glenoid preserved
- Selected proximal humeral fracture fixation or arthroplasty (the tuberosity is already fractured, so no separate osteotomy)
- Revision shoulder arthroplasty - re-exposure of the glenohumeral joint
- Not addressed by this approach alone: the posterior cuff and posterior glenoid (may require adjunct windows or repositioning in complex revisions)
Viva & Exam Focus
During anatomic shoulder arthroplasty through the deltopectoral approach, the subscapularis must be taken down from the lesser tuberosity to enter the glenohumeral joint, and the chosen repair governs postoperative internal-rotation strength, the belly-press examination and anterior stability. Three established techniques exist. Tenotomy cuts the tendon and repairs it tendon-to-tendon or tendon-to-bone; it is simple but has the weakest healing. A subscapularis peel elevates the tendon off its footprint and repairs it tendon-to-bone with anchors or transosseous tunnels. A lesser-tuberosity osteotomy (Gerber) raises bone with the tendon and fixes it with cerclage, healing bone-to-bone - the strongest interface. The healing hierarchy is bone-to-bone stronger than tendon-to-bone stronger than tendon-to-tendon. The axillary nerve at the inferior border of the subscapularis is the critical at-risk structure and is protected by staying on bone and avoiding blind inferior retractors.
SUBSCAPSUBSCAP - the three techniques and healing
DANGERDANGER - structures at risk
Exam Viva Scenarios
Practise clinical reasoning and management decisions out loud
“During an anatomic total shoulder arthroplasty through the deltopectoral approach, describe how you would manage the subscapularis, the techniques available, and how you decide between them.”
“What is the internervous plane of the deltopectoral approach, which structure must be divided to enter the joint, and which nerves are at risk?”
“A patient returns 4 months after an anatomic total shoulder arthroplasty with anterior shoulder instability and a positive belly-press test. What has happened and how do you manage it?”
Position & approach
- Beach-chair position with the arm free for rotation
- Deltopectoral incision from the coracoid toward the deltoid insertion
- Internervous plane: deltoid (axillary nerve) and pectoralis major (pectoral nerves)
- Cephalic vein in the groove - preserve or ligate
- Conjoined tendon retracted medially with the coracoid
The three techniques
- Tenotomy: tendon cut 1 cm medial to insertion; tendon-to-tendon or tendon-to-bone; weakest healing
- Subscapularis peel: tendon off the footprint; tendon-to-bone; anchors or tunnels
- Lesser-tuberosity osteotomy: bone with tendon; cerclage; bone-to-bone; strongest
- Z-lengthening added to tenotomy when the subscapularis is tight
- Avoid osteotomy in fracture arthroplasty (tuberosity already fractured)
Healing hierarchy & biomechanics
- Bone-to-bone stronger than tendon-to-bone stronger than tendon-to-tendon
- Rationale for choosing peel or osteotomy over tenotomy
- Restore tension: overtight limits external rotation, loose fails
- Humeral version sets cuff tension - match native retroversion
- Re-check tension and version after the repair
Axillary nerve & danger structures
- Axillary nerve at the inferior border of the subscapularis - most important
- Protect by staying on bone and palpating during inferior release
- Never place a retractor blindly deep to the inferior subscapularis
- Musculocutaneous nerve 3 to 8 cm distal to the coracoid - protect conjoined tendon
- Anterior humeral circumflex vessels inferiorly - ligate as needed
Closure & postoperative care
- Repair subscapularis per the chosen construct
- Close the deltopectoral interval loosely
- Sling with arm in neutral to slight external rotation
- Limit passive external rotation for 6 weeks
- Avoid resisted internal rotation (pushing up from a chair) for 6 weeks
Function, failure & salvage
- Subscapularis is the primary internal rotator and anterior stabiliser
- Integrity assessed by belly-press and lift-off tests
- Failure causes anterior instability and internal-rotation weakness
- Salvage: pectoralis major transfer for irreparable insufficiency
- Reverse arthroplasty if soft tissues not reconstructable
References
Guidelines, Registries & Global Practice Management of the subscapularis in anatomic shoulder arthroplasty is governed by surgical-biomechanical principles that converge across examination systems. The deltopectoral approach, protection of the axillary nerve at the inferior border, and the healing hierarchy (bone-to-bone stronger than tendon-to-bone stronger than tendon-to-tendon) are universally taught. Arthroplasty registry evidence (for example the National Joint Registry and the Australian Orthopaedic Association National Joint Replacement Registry) principally reports survivorship and revision rather than subscapularis-specific technique, but revision for instability is captured and is relevant to subscapularis failure. Side-by-side principles (where guidance converges): | Body | Position on subscapularis management |
|------|--------------------------------------| | AAOS (US) | Secure subscapularis repair and protection are essential to anterior stability after anatomic arthroplasty; technique is surgeon-dependent but bone-to-bone/tendon-to-bone constructs are favoured for higher-demand patients | | BESS / BOA / EFORT | The deltopectoral approach is standard; the axillary nerve at the inferior border must be protected; lesser-tuberosity osteotomy or peel preferred when subscapularis integrity is critical | | AO Foundation | Restoration of soft-tissue tension and version is part of balanced arthroplasty; protect the repair and limit early external rotation and resisted internal rotation | Registry / population evidence: - Arthroplasty registries report shoulder arthroplasty revision rates broadly in the single-digit percent range at mid-term follow-up, with instability a recognised mode of failure after anatomic designs
- Subscapularis failure is a contributor to instability-related revision, which underlines the preventive value of a sound repair Global practice variation. In well-resourced settings, suture anchors, anatomic implants and lesser-tuberosity osteotomy are widely available. In resource-limited settings, the same biomechanical principles are applied with transosseous bone tunnels and standard implants; a simple tenotomy with a meticulous repair remains a reasonable, lower-cost option. Consent (globally applicable). Discuss subscapularis dysfunction or failure with possible anterior instability, axillary nerve injury with deltoid weakness, stiffness, infection, and the potential need for revision (including pectoralis major transfer or conversion to a reverse design) if the subscapularis fails.
For the Operative Surgery station, be able to describe subscapularis management systematically: the deltopectoral internervous plane, the three takedown techniques and their healing interfaces, the axillary nerve at the inferior border, restoration of tension and version, and postoperative protection. Know the healing hierarchy and the salvage options for subscapularis failure.
Lesser Tuberosity Osteotomy for Total Shoulder Arthroplasty
- Introduced lesser-tuberosity osteotomy for anatomic total shoulder arthroplasty, elevating the subscapularis with a bone fragment to achieve bone-to-bone healing
- Clinical and imaging assessment showed preserved subscapularis integrity and strength at follow-up, supporting bone-to-bone healing as a reliable restoration
- Described fixation of the osteotomy fragment with cerclage sutures around the humeral stem
- Established lesser-tuberosity osteotomy as an alternative to tenotomy and peel for preserving subscapularis function
Instability of the Shoulder After Arthroplasty
- Identified instability as a recognised complication of total shoulder arthroplasty
- Attributed most cases of anterior instability to subscapularis failure or devitalisation at the time of surgery
- Emphasised that a secure, well-vascularised subscapularis repair and postoperative protection are essential to prevent instability
- Established the principle that subscapularis integrity is central to anterior stability after shoulder arthroplasty
Loss of Subscapularis Function After Total Shoulder Replacement: A Seldom Recognized Problem
- Showed that subscapularis dysfunction after total shoulder replacement is under-recognised, even when the tendon appears intact
- Used the belly-press and lift-off tests to detect objective subscapularis weakness following tenotomy repair
- A meaningful subset of patients had abnormal subscapularis function despite a presumed satisfactory tendon repair
- Highlighted that tenotomy repair does not reliably restore full subscapularis strength
A Biomechanical Comparison of Three Surgical Techniques for Subscapularis Repair
- Compared the biomechanical strength of three subscapularis takedown-and-repair constructs used in shoulder arthroplasty
- Tendon-to-bone and bone-to-bone repairs (peel and osteotomy) generally resisted cyclic loading and load-to-failure better than a simple tendon-to-tendon tenotomy repair
- Provided the mechanical justification that bone-to-bone and tendon-to-bone constructs are sturdier than tendon-to-tendon
- Supported the modern biomechanical rationale for preferring a peel or lesser-tuberosity osteotomy over tenotomy
Outcome of Pectoralis Major Transfer for the Treatment of Subscapularis Insufficiency Secondary to Anterior Shoulder Surgery
- Reported the outcome of pectoralis major transfer for symptomatic subscapularis insufficiency following prior anterior shoulder surgery
- Showed that pectoralis major transfer can improve pain and anterior stability in selected patients with irreparable subscapularis failure
- Underscored the significant functional morbidity of subscapularis insufficiency, which is why prevention via a sound repair is paramount
- Serves as the salvage benchmark when subscapularis repair fails after arthroplasty