Question 1

What is meniscal transplantation and who needs it?

Accepted Answer

Meniscal transplantation is surgical replacement of a previously removed meniscus (knee cartilage) with donor tissue from a deceased organ donor. The meniscus is the C-shaped cartilage cushion between the thigh bone (femur) and shin bone (tibia) - each knee has two menisci (medial on inside, lateral on outside). The meniscus acts as a shock absorber and distributes load across the knee joint. When the meniscus is completely removed (total meniscectomy), the knee loses this protection and develops pain and early arthritis. Meniscal transplant is for YOUNG patients (typically age 18-50) who had their meniscus removed years ago (usually from sports injury) and now have chronic knee pain and early arthritis, but are too young for knee replacement. Common scenario: ACL tear + meniscus tear at age 20 → meniscus removed → knee pain develops by age 30-35 → meniscal transplant performed to reduce pain and delay need for knee replacement for another 10-15 years. This is a HIGHLY SELECTIVE procedure - only 5-10% of patients who've had meniscectomy are suitable candidates. Strict criteria include: minimal existing arthritis, normal knee alignment (or willing to have corrective osteotomy), stable ligaments (or willing to have ACL reconstruction), and realistic expectations that transplant improves symptoms and buys time but does NOT restore a normal knee.

Question 2

How successful is meniscal transplantation?

Accepted Answer

Meniscal transplant has GOOD but not EXCELLENT success rates - this is a 'buying time' procedure, not a permanent solution. SHORT-TERM SUCCESS (2-5 years): 80-90% patients report significant pain reduction and improved function. 70-80% return to sports and recreational activities. 10-15% graft failure requiring revision or removal. MEDIUM-TERM SUCCESS (5-10 years): 70-85% continue to have good pain relief and function. 60-75% remain active in sports (though often at reduced level). 15-25% graft failure (graft tears, shrinks, or displaces). 20-30% require additional surgery (arthroscopy for graft problems, manipulation for stiffness). LONG-TERM OUTCOMES (10-15 years): Transplant DELAYS arthritis progression but does NOT prevent it. Average delay: 10-15 years before knee replacement needed (compared to 5-10 years post-meniscectomy WITHOUT transplant). Therefore, transplant extends the 'functional lifespan' of the knee by approximately 5-10 years. 40-60% eventually progress to knee replacement by 15-20 years post-transplant. FACTORS AFFECTING SUCCESS: Best results in: young patients (20-35 years), minimal existing arthritis (Outerbridge grade 0-1), normal alignment, stable ligaments, good compliance with rehab. Worse results in: older patients (40-50 years), existing cartilage damage (grade 2-3), obesity (BMI over 30), return to high-impact sports, smoking. Bottom line: Transplant is worthwhile for SELECTED young patients with disabling symptoms, as it typically provides 10-15 years of good function before knee replacement becomes necessary. For a 30-year-old, this means potentially delaying knee replacement until age 40-45 rather than needing it at age 35.

Question 3

What does recovery from meniscal transplant involve?

Accepted Answer

Recovery from meniscal transplant is LONG (9-12 months) and requires strict adherence to weight-bearing restrictions and rehab protocol. PHASE 1 (Weeks 0-6) - GRAFT PROTECTION: Non-weight-bearing or toe-touch weight-bearing only (crutches). Knee brace locked in extension (straight) when walking. Remove brace 3-5 times daily for gentle range of motion exercises (0-90 degrees only). Goal: Protect graft while it incorporates into surrounding tissue. Graft is VERY FRAGILE during first 6 weeks - early weight-bearing will tear the graft. PHASE 2 (Weeks 6-12) - PROGRESSIVE LOADING: Gradual progression to full weight-bearing over 4-6 weeks. Wean off crutches. Progress range of motion to full (0-135 degrees). Start gentle stationary bike, pool walking. PHASE 3 (Months 3-6) - STRENGTHENING: Progressive resistance exercises (leg press, squats, lunges). Return to daily activities (walking, stairs, light work). Start light jogging on treadmill at 4-5 months (if cleared by surgeon). PHASE 4 (Months 6-9) - RETURN TO ACTIVITY: Progress running program. Straight-line running at 6 months. Cutting, pivoting, jumping at 8-9 months. PHASE 5 (Months 9-12) - RETURN TO SPORT: Gradual return to unrestricted sport at 9-12 months (individual variation). Requires clearance from surgeon and physiotherapist. CHALLENGES: Long period of restricted activity (6 months minimum). Muscle wasting (quadriceps loses 20-30% mass during first 6 weeks). Risk of stiffness (5-10% patients require manipulation under anesthesia). High re-injury risk if return to sport too early. WORK: Sedentary job: 6-8 weeks off work. Manual labor: 3-6 months off work. Heavy labor (construction, trades): may need job modification permanently. Overall timeline is LONGER than most orthopedic surgeries - patients must commit to 12-month recovery process.

Question 4

What are the costs and availability of meniscal transplant in Australia?

Accepted Answer

Meniscal transplantation is an EXPENSIVE and LIMITED-AVAILABILITY procedure in Australia. COSTS: Total cost: $25,000-45,000 for isolated meniscal transplant. Medicare rebate: approximately $1,500-2,000 (covers only small fraction). Private health insurance: typically pays $5,000-12,000 (varies by policy and hospital agreement). OUT-OF-POCKET: $20,000-40,000 for most patients (substantial gap payment). Additional costs if combined with osteotomy or ACL reconstruction: $35,000-60,000 total. Breakdown: Surgeon fee: $8,000-15,000 (Medicare rebate ~$1,200, gap $7,000-14,000). Anesthetist fee: $2,000-3,500 (Medicare rebate ~$400, gap $1,600-3,000). Assistant surgeon: $2,000-4,000 (Medicare rebate ~$300, gap $1,700-3,700). Hospital/facility: $8,000-15,000 (private health covers most, gap $2,000-5,000). Allograft tissue: $5,000-8,000 (NOT covered by Medicare or private health in most cases). Post-op physiotherapy: $2,000-4,000 over 12 months (some private health policies include physio). AVAILABILITY: Highly specialized procedure - only performed at major metropolitan centers. Main centers: Melbourne (2-3 surgeons), Sydney (2-3 surgeons), Brisbane (1-2 surgeons). NOT available in regional/rural Australia. WAIT TIMES: Typical wait for appropriately sized allograft: 3-12 months. Tissue sourced from Australian tissue banks or imported from US tissue banks. Size matching critical - requires specific tibial plateau dimensions (measured on X-ray). Surgery scheduling: additional 2-6 months after graft sourced (surgeon and facility availability). Total time from decision to surgery: 6-18 months typically. PUBLIC HOSPITAL: Meniscal transplant generally NOT available through public system (considered semi-elective/advanced procedure). Patients requiring transplant typically need private insurance or self-pay. COST-BENEFIT CONSIDERATION: Transplant costs $20,000-40,000 out-of-pocket but potentially delays knee replacement by 10-15 years. For young patients (under 40), this may be worthwhile investment to maintain quality of life and delay more invasive surgery until older age.

Question 5

What are the alternatives to meniscal transplantation?

Accepted Answer

Several alternatives exist for young patients with post-meniscectomy syndrome, each with different indications and success rates. 1. CONSERVATIVE MANAGEMENT (activity modification, weight loss, injections): For: Patients with tolerable symptoms, low activity demands, or not suitable for surgery. Success: 30-40% achieve adequate symptom control with non-operative measures alone. Limitations: Does NOT address underlying problem (absent meniscus), only manages symptoms. 2. ARTHROSCOPIC DEBRIDEMENT (keyhole surgery to clean up knee): For: Patients with mechanical symptoms (catching, locking) from loose bodies or meniscal remnants. Procedure: Remove loose fragments, smooth rough cartilage, wash out inflammatory tissue. Success: 40-60% short-term symptom improvement (6-12 months), but does NOT prevent arthritis progression. NOT a long-term solution. 3. UNICOMPARTMENTAL KNEE REPLACEMENT (partial knee replacement): For: Older patients (typically 55+ years) with isolated medial or lateral compartment arthritis after meniscectomy. Procedure: Replace only damaged half of knee joint (medial or lateral compartment). Success: 80-90% good outcomes at 10-15 years. Better option than meniscal transplant for patients over 50-55 with established arthritis. Smaller surgery than total knee replacement, faster recovery. 4. TOTAL KNEE REPLACEMENT: For: Patients with advanced arthritis affecting entire knee (all three compartments). Success: 90-95% good outcomes at 15-20 years - gold standard for end-stage arthritis. Limitations: Generally reserved for patients over 60 years (longevity concerns in younger patients). Recovery longer than unicompartmental replacement. 5. OSTEOTOMY (realignment surgery) WITHOUT transplant: For: Patients with knee malalignment and compartmental overload. Procedure: Realign knee to offload damaged compartment (high tibial osteotomy for medial overload, distal femoral osteotomy for lateral overload). Success: 70-80% good results at 8-10 years for carefully selected patients. May delay need for knee replacement by 8-12 years. Can be combined with later transplant if symptoms persist. 6. 'WAIT AND SEE' approach: For: Younger patients (under 30) with tolerable symptoms who can modify activities. Rationale: Delay transplant or knee replacement as long as possible to maximize functional years. Risk: Arthritis progresses during waiting period, may reduce transplant success or make patient ineligible. DECISION FACTORS: Age (under 40 → consider transplant; over 55 → consider unicompartmental/total knee replacement). Arthritis severity (minimal arthritis → transplant; established arthritis → replacement). Activity level (high demands → transplant to preserve function; low demands → conservative management may suffice). Financial resources (transplant expensive with large out-of-pocket costs; knee replacement better covered by insurance/Medicare). Bottom line: Meniscal transplant is best option for YOUNG patients (20-40 years) with MINIMAL arthritis but SIGNIFICANT symptoms. For older patients or those with established arthritis, knee replacement is typically better choice.

Medical Disclaimer

Meniscal Transplantation

📖What is Meniscal Transplantation?

🔬What Causes It?

⚠️Risk Factors

You may be at higher risk if:

🛡️Prevention