Supraclavicular and infraclavicular exploration, avulsion versus rupture differentiation, grafting and transfers
- Preganglionic root avulsion is distinguished from postganglionic rupture by absent paraspinal and serratus anterior denervation on EMG, preserved sensory nerve action potentials despite complete anaesthesia, and pseudomeningoceles on MRI — these injuries have no proximal stump for grafting and require nerve transfers.
- Closed traction injuries are explored at 3 to 6 months if there is no clinical or electrodiagnostic recovery; sharp penetrating injuries warrant early exploration within days to weeks for primary repair or grafting before retraction and scarring complicate reconstruction.
- Reconstructive priorities follow a proximal-to-distal ladder: shoulder stability and external rotation first (spinal accessory to suprascapular), then elbow flexion (Oberlin ulnar fascicle to biceps or double fascicular transfer), then hand function if donors remain (intercostal or contralateral C7 transfers).
- Intraoperative nerve stimulation confirms viability — direct stimulation of a postganglionic stump produces distal muscle contraction, whereas avulsed roots show no response and often demonstrate a positive histamine test or meningocele on imaging.
- Obtain proximal and distal control of the subclavian artery and vein and identify the phrenic nerve on the anterior scalene BEFORE any plexus dissection — vascular injury is the most immediate life-threatening complication and phrenic division causes permanent hemidiaphragm paralysis.
- Plan sural nerve harvest in advance: about 30 to 40 cm is available per leg and multiple cable grafts are needed for each root or trunk gap — always confirm a sural SNAP preoperatively as a donor-site baseline.
When & Why
Indication. Operative exploration and reconstruction of a traumatic brachial plexus injury. The timing depends on mechanism: a sharp or penetrating injury is explored within days to two weeks (primary repair or early grafting before retraction); a closed traction injury without recovery is explored at 3 to 6 months (allowing neurapraxia to resolve while staying inside the reinnervation window); a complete flail arm with imaging and EMG confirming avulsion proceeds to exploration and transfer planning at about 3 months; and a progressive neurological deficit or expanding haematoma mandates urgent exploration regardless of mechanism. Absolute indications
- Traumatic root avulsion confirmed by pseudomeningoceles, preserved SNAPs, and paraspinal denervation
- Postganglionic rupture with no clinical or electrodiagnostic recovery by 3 to 6 months
- Associated vascular injury requiring repair, explored together with the plexus Relative indications
- Incomplete recovery with a plateau on serial examination and EMG
- A patient who wants reconstruction after being counselled on realistic outcomes and donor morbidity
- Paediatric brachial plexus palsy failing to recover spontaneously by 3 to 6 months Contraindications
- Absolute: life-threatening associated injuries precluding prolonged anaesthesia; complete motor endplate degeneration beyond 18 to 24 months with no viable targets; patient refusal or inability to comply with rehabilitation.
- Relative: isolated neurapraxia expected to recover (serial EMG shows improving conduction); poor donor nerve availability or comorbidities increasing surgical risk. The one decision that matters — match the operation to the lesion. Every reconstruction begins with exposure and intraoperative confirmation of avulsion versus rupture; what you then do depends on what you find:
A graftable proximal stump exists. Reconstruct with tension-free sural nerve cable grafts — best results when gaps are short and the repair tension-free.
No proximal stump — grafting is impossible. Reconstruct with nerve transfers: spinal accessory to suprascapular and Oberlin for elbow flexion are the workhorses.
Combine grafting of ruptured elements with transfers for avulsed roots, allocated by available donors and targets.
Consent for realistic partial recovery, donor morbidity (sural sensory loss, spinal accessory shoulder droop, possible ulnar weakness), the likelihood of multiple procedures, and a 12 to 24 month rehabilitation timeline. Setup. Supine, head turned away from the operative side, arm abducted 30 to 45 degrees on an arm board. Prep and drape the entire arm, neck, chest and both legs for sural harvest. General endotracheal anaesthesia with muscle relaxant used only for induction — no paralytics during the nerve-stimulation phase — and intraoperative nerve monitoring set up. Loupe magnification (3.5x) or operating microscope, bipolar cautery, nerve stimulator, vessel loops and microsurgical instruments.
The Operation
The goal is to expose the plexus (supraclavicularly, infraclavicularly, or both), differentiate avulsion from rupture by intraoperative stimulation, and reconstruct following a fixed priority ladder: shoulder stability and external rotation first, then elbow flexion, then hand function. The exposure is laid out in full as the opening steps of the sequence below. Reconstructive priorities
- Shoulder stability and external rotation — spinal accessory to suprascapular.
- Elbow flexion — Oberlin or double fascicular transfer.
- Shoulder abduction — axillary nerve grafting or transfer if donors available.
- Hand sensation and basic grasp — intercostal or contralateral C7 transfers.
- Wrist and finger extension — if donors remain.

Operative sequence
- Supine, head turned away, arm abducted 30 to 45 degrees on an arm board; prep and drape the arm, neck, chest and both legs (for sural harvest).
- General anaesthesia with relaxant for induction only — none during the nerve-stimulation phase; intraoperative monitoring set up.
- Loupe magnification (3.5x) or microscope, bipolar cautery, nerve stimulator, vessel loops, microsurgical instruments; Foley and arterial line for a long case.
- Transverse incision about 2 cm above the clavicle, from the posterior border of sternocleidomastoid laterally toward the trapezius; extend in an L-shape along the clavicle if infraclavicular access is also needed.
- Divide platysma; identify and ligate external jugular vein branches; retract sternocleidomastoid laterally.
- Identify the phrenic nerve on the anterior scalene surface — it courses obliquely lateral-to-medial and flickers with respiration.
- Place a vessel loop and protect it throughout. Division causes permanent hemidiaphragm paralysis.
- Divide the anterior scalene transversely, protecting the phrenic nerve.
- Expose C5 and C6 forming the upper trunk (superficial); C7, C8 and T1 lie deeper and more medial, closer to the subclavian vessels. Note any neuromas or ruptures.
- Identify the subclavian artery and vein anterior and inferior to the lower trunk.
- Obtain proximal and distal control with vessel loops before any further plexus dissection — vascular injury is the most immediate life-threatening complication.
- Deltopectoral incision from the coracoid to the axilla; develop the deltopectoral interval and ligate cephalic vein tributaries.
- Divide pectoralis minor from the coracoid to expose the lateral, posterior and medial cords around the axillary artery.
- A clavicular osteotomy or division gives combined supra-infraclavicular access for pan-plexus lesions.
- Stimulate each root and trunk directly. A postganglionic rupture produces distal muscle contraction; an avulsed root produces no response.
- Document findings and confirm the sural SNAP baseline if not already recorded.
- Viable postganglionic stump — sural nerve grafting.
- Preganglionic avulsion — nerve transfers.
- Mixed pattern — combine grafting and transfers per available donors and targets.
- Harvest the sural nerve (about 30 to 40 cm per leg); confirm the sural SNAP preoperatively as a donor-site baseline.
- Cable graft each root or trunk gap with tension-free coaptation under the microscope using 9-0 or 10-0 nylon.
- Identify the spinal accessory nerve at the posterior border of sternocleidomastoid, 2 to 3 cm above the clavicle.
- Harvest only the distal branch to trapezius, leaving the proximal branch to upper trapezius intact.
- Coapt to the suprascapular nerve in the supraclavicular fossa — restores shoulder abduction and external rotation with minimal donor morbidity.
- Upper-arm incision medial to biceps; identify the median and ulnar nerves.
- Stimulate ulnar fascicles; select the largest motor fascicle producing strong wrist flexion without intrinsic hand weakness.
- Transfer it to the biceps motor branch. For a double fascicular transfer, add a median fascicle to brachialis.
- Harvest 3 to 4 intercostal nerves (T3 to T6) through a chest or axillary incision.
- Coapt to musculocutaneous, axillary or radial targets. Donor morbidity: chest-wall numbness and reduced respiratory reserve.
- Haemostasis and layered closure; confirm distal pulses and capillary refill.
- Immobilise the shoulder in an abduction sling or brace for 4 to 6 weeks to protect grafts and transfers.
- Phrenic nerve on the anterior scalene — division causes permanent hemidiaphragm paralysis; identify and loop it before dividing scalene.
- Subclavian vessels anterior and inferior to the lower trunk — obtain proximal and distal control before any plexus dissection; uncontrolled bleeding is rapidly fatal.
- Stellate ganglion at C8 to T1 — excessive retraction or root avulsion here causes Horner syndrome.
- Never mistake an avulsed root for a rupture and graft into a non-existent proximal stump.
Obtain subclavian vessel loops before touching the plexus. Stimulate every root and trunk systematically and document which produce distal contraction. If a root shows no response and MRI showed a pseudomeningocele, classify it as avulsion and move to transfer planning rather than futile grafting.
Always identify and loop the phrenic nerve on the anterior scalene before any scalene division. Its oblique lateral-to-medial course and respiratory flicker identify it; protecting it is the single step that prevents permanent hemidiaphragm paralysis.
Aftercare & Complications
Rehabilitation | Phase | Timing | Immobilisation | Therapy | |-------|--------|----------------|---------| | 1 | 0 to 6 weeks | Abduction sling or brace | Gentle passive ROM of elbow, wrist and hand from day 1; no active shoulder or elbow loading; wound, oedema and scar care from 2 weeks | | 2 | 6 weeks to 6 months | Removable as transfers heal | Active-assisted ROM; electrical stimulation of target muscles once reinnervation is detected; strengthening from MRC grade 3; clinical and EMG review every 3 months | | 3 | 6 to 24 months | Support as needed | Task-specific training for shoulder stability, elbow flexion and hand function; consider secondary tendon transfers or arthrodesis once recovery plateaus | Expected outcomes
- Elbow flexion MRC grade 3 or better: 80 to 95 percent with an Oberlin transfer within 6 months.
- Shoulder abduction greater than 30 degrees: 60 to 75 percent with a spinal accessory to suprascapular transfer.
- Intercostal transfers: useful elbow flexion in 60 to 75 percent but with higher donor morbidity.
- Sural nerve grafting of ruptures: shoulder and elbow function restored in 60 to 80 percent when gaps are short and the repair tension-free.
- Useful hand function: 30 to 50 percent with multiple transfers; many patients achieve only protective sensation.
- Overall: 60 to 70 percent report meaningful functional improvement despite incomplete recovery. Complications
- Recognition
- Sudden bleeding, loss of distal pulse
- Prevention
- Obtain proximal and distal subclavian control before plexus dissection
- Management
- Immediate vascular repair or shunt; involve vascular surgery early
- Recognition
- Postoperative elevated hemidiaphragm on chest radiograph, dyspnoea
- Prevention
- Identify and protect the phrenic throughout scalene division
- Management
- Supportive; permanent paralysis if complete division
- Recognition
- Ptosis, miosis, anhidrosis
- Prevention
- Gentle handling near the stellate ganglion at C8 to T1
- Management
- Usually transient; permanent if T1 root avulsed
- Recognition
- Shoulder droop, scapular winging, difficulty overhead
- Prevention
- Harvest only the distal branch; leave proximal trapezius innervation intact
- Management
- Physical therapy; rarely scapulothoracic fusion
- Recognition
- Plateau in motor recovery before MRC grade 3
- Prevention
- Operate within 6 months; tension-free coaptation; avoid postoperative stretch
- Management
- Secondary tendon transfers or arthrodesis
- Recognition
- Tender Tinel at the repair site, burning or shooting pain
- Prevention
- Careful handling, tension-free repair, bury the proximal stump in muscle if avulsed
- Management
- Neuropathic medications, nerve capping or relocation, spinal cord stimulation if refractory
- Recognition
- Sural: permanent lateral foot numbness (universal), painful neuroma (5 percent); ulnar fascicle: intrinsic weakness if wrong fascicle; intercostal: chest anaesthesia, reduced respiratory reserve
- Prevention
- Confirm sural SNAP preoperatively; stimulate ulnar fascicles; selective harvest
- Management
- Therapy; rarely re-exploration
- Recognition
- Erythema, discharge, deep infection around grafts
- Prevention
- Standard sterile technique and wound care
- Management
- Antibiotics; return to theatre for washout if deep
Viva & Exam Focus
AVULSEAVULSE — preganglionic versus postganglionic differentiation
REPAIRREPAIR — reconstructive priorities and options
Critical danger structures and exam traps
The trap is assuming every flail arm is graftable — a root avulsion produces no proximal stump, so grafting fails. MRI pseudomeningoceles, preserved SNAPs despite anaesthesia, and absent paraspinal and serratus EMG activity confirm avulsion; these require transfers, not grafts. Always obtain EMG and MRI before exploration.
The subclavian artery and vein lie immediately anterior and inferior to the lower trunk and divisions in the supraclavicular fossa. Uncontrolled bleeding from a vessel laceration during plexus dissection can be rapidly fatal. Proximal and distal control with vessel loops must be obtained before any plexus manipulation.
The phrenic nerve runs on the anterior scalene muscle surface, medial and deep to the C5 and C6 roots. Division produces permanent hemidiaphragm paralysis. Identify it by its oblique course and respiratory contraction before dividing the scalene, and protect it throughout the supraclavicular exposure.
The spinal accessory nerve is identified at the posterior border of sternocleidomastoid, 2 to 3 cm above the clavicle. Complete harvest produces shoulder droop and scapular winging. Use only the distal branch to trapezius and leave the proximal branch to upper trapezius intact.
The ulnar nerve at the upper arm contains motor fascicles to FCU and FDP; the largest, most redundant fascicle is selected for transfer to biceps. Harvesting the wrong fascicle produces permanent ulnar intrinsic weakness. Intraoperative stimulation must confirm strong wrist flexion without finger abduction or adduction before division.
Motor endplates degenerate 12 to 18 months after denervation; reinnervation after this window has low success. Operating after 9 months on a closed injury risks futile exploration with poor functional return. Document the time since injury and consider palliative tendon transfers or arthrodesis if the patient is beyond the window.
Clinical Decision Scenarios
Practise clinical reasoning and management decisions out loud
“A 28-year-old man is referred 4 months after a motorcycle accident with a flail left arm. MRI shows pseudomeningoceles at C6, C7 and C8. EMG shows preserved median and ulnar SNAPs, absent paraspinal and serratus activity, and no motor unit potentials. How do you classify the injury and plan reconstruction?”
“You are exploring a brachial plexus 5 months after a closed traction injury. Intraoperative stimulation of C5 and C6 produces no distal contraction, MRI showed pseudomeningoceles, and the patient has complete anaesthesia in the C6 distribution with an intact median SNAP. What is your diagnosis and next step?”
“During supraclavicular exploration you inadvertently divide the phrenic nerve. The patient is stable but you recognise the error intraoperatively. What do you do?”
Preoperative differentiation
- Preganglionic avulsion: preserved SNAPs despite anaesthesia, pseudomeningoceles on MRI, paraspinal and serratus denervation on EMG, no response to intraoperative stimulation
- Postganglionic rupture: absent SNAPs, no meningocele, response to stimulation, graftable proximal stump
- Timing: sharp injury explore early (days to weeks); closed traction at 3 to 6 months if no recovery
- Beyond 9 to 12 months: motor endplate degeneration reduces reinnervation success — consider palliative options
Supraclavicular approach
- Incision: transverse above the clavicle from the posterior border of sternocleidomastoid laterally
- Identify the phrenic on the anterior scalene before dividing the muscle — protect throughout
- Obtain subclavian artery and vein control before plexus manipulation
- Stimulate every root and trunk; document which produce distal contraction
- Avulsed roots show no response and often have a visible meningocele or neuroma
Reconstructive priorities
- 1. Shoulder stability and external rotation — spinal accessory to suprascapular transfer
- 2. Elbow flexion — Oberlin ulnar fascicle to biceps (or double fascicular with median)
- 3. Shoulder abduction — axillary nerve grafting or transfer if donors available
- 4. Hand sensation and grasp — intercostal or contralateral C7 transfers
- Select donors based on availability and minimise morbidity by partial harvest
Key transfers — technical points
- Spinal accessory: harvest only the distal branch to trapezius; leave the proximal branch intact
- Oberlin: stimulate ulnar fascicles; select the largest motor fascicle producing wrist flexion without intrinsic weakness
- Intercostal: harvest T3 to T6; coapt to musculocutaneous or axillary targets
- Sural graft: multiple cables for each gap; confirm the sural SNAP preoperatively
- Tension-free coaptation under the microscope with 9-0 or 10-0 nylon
Danger zones
- Phrenic nerve on the anterior scalene — division causes permanent hemidiaphragm paralysis
- Subclavian vessels anterior to the lower trunk — obtain control before dissection
- Stellate ganglion at C8 to T1 — Horner syndrome with excessive retraction or root avulsion
- Spinal accessory complete harvest — shoulder droop and scapular winging
- Incorrect ulnar fascicle in Oberlin — permanent intrinsic hand weakness
Complications
- Vascular injury: 1 to 3 percent — control the subclavian vessels first
- Phrenic injury: 2 to 5 percent — identify and loop before scalene division
- Failed reinnervation: 20 to 40 percent — operate within 6 months, tension-free repair
- Neuroma and neuropathic pain: 10 to 20 percent — careful handling, bury stumps
- Donor morbidity: sural numbness (universal), spinal accessory droop (5 to 15 percent if complete harvest)
Postoperative priorities
- Shoulder immobilisation for 4 to 6 weeks to protect transfers
- Serial clinical and EMG monitoring every 3 months
- Electrical stimulation once reinnervation is detected
- Secondary tendon transfers or arthrodesis once a plateau is reached at 18 to 24 months
- Realistic goal: elbow flexion and shoulder stability in the majority; hand function limited
Background & Evidence
Epidemiology. Traumatic brachial plexus injuries are high-energy traction injuries, classically sustained by young men in motorcycle crashes; closed traction dominates, with a smaller proportion of sharp or penetrating lacerations. The injury pattern ranges from a single root or trunk to complete pan-plexus avulsion, and the prognosis is driven by whether the lesion is pre- or post-ganglionic. Surgical anatomy. Supraclavicularly, the upper trunk (C5-C6 union) lies superficial in the posterior triangle; the middle trunk (C7) and lower trunk (C8-T1) sit progressively deeper and closer to the subclavian vessels. The dorsal scapular nerve (C5) and long thoracic nerve (C5-C7) arise proximally, so their denervation on EMG confirms a preganglionic injury. Infraclavicularly, the divisions lie behind the clavicle and the cords surround the axillary artery in the deltopectoral groove — the lateral cord gives the musculocutaneous and lateral pectoral nerves, the posterior cord the axillary and radial nerves, and the medial cord the ulnar, medial pectoral and medial cutaneous nerves of arm and forearm. Classification — avulsion versus rupture. The single most important distinction, because it determines whether grafting is even possible:
- Preganglionic avulsion
- Preserved despite complete anaesthesia
- Postganglionic rupture
- Absent
- Preganglionic avulsion
- Denervation (proximal to dorsal scapular and long thoracic nerves)
- Postganglionic rupture
- Spared
- Preganglionic avulsion
- Pseudomeningoceles (pathognomonic)
- Postganglionic rupture
- No meningocele
- Preganglionic avulsion
- No distal contraction
- Postganglionic rupture
- Distal muscle contraction
- Preganglionic avulsion
- None — grafting impossible
- Postganglionic rupture
- Graftable stump present
- Preganglionic avulsion
- Nerve transfers
- Postganglionic rupture
- Sural nerve grafting
Key evidence. Early exploration (less than 3 months) for a closed injury risks operating on neurapraxia that would recover, while exploration beyond 6 to 9 months yields poorer regeneration as motor endplates fibrose. The strategy follows the lesion type: postganglionic ruptures have a graftable proximal stump and are reconstructed with tension-free sural cable grafts, whereas preganglionic avulsions have no proximal stump and require nerve transfers. The spinal accessory to suprascapular and Oberlin ulnar fascicle transfers are the workhorse procedures with the strongest evidence; intercostal and contralateral C7 transfers extend the donor pool for pan-plexus avulsions.
References
Nerve transfer to biceps muscle using a part of ulnar nerve for C5-C6 avulsion of the brachial plexus: anatomical study and report of four cases
Original description of the Oberlin transfer, demonstrating reliable elbow flexion recovery with minimal donor morbidity in upper trunk avulsions. It remains the most commonly performed transfer and revolutionised elbow flexion reconstruction.
Intercostal nerve transfer of the musculocutaneous nerve in avulsed brachial plexus injuries: evaluation of 66 patients
Large series of 66 patients establishing intercostal nerves as reliable donors for musculocutaneous and elbow flexion reconstruction in avulsion injuries, expanding the donor pool for multiple root avulsions.
Spinal accessory neurotization for restoration of elbow flexion in avulsion injuries of the brachial plexus
Demonstrated reliable restoration of elbow flexion with spinal accessory nerve transfer and documented acceptable donor morbidity, establishing it as a valuable option in avulsion injuries.
Double nerve transfer versus triple nerve transfer for elbow flexion restoration in C5-C6 traumatic brachial plexus injuries
Compared double versus triple nerve transfers for elbow flexion in C5-C6 injuries, providing modern evidence supporting multiple nerve transfers to optimise elbow flexion recovery in upper trunk injuries.