Positioning and Preparation
Patient Position: Supine with foot at end of table, bump under ipsilateral hip for neutral foot rotation
Anesthesia: Ankle block (preferred - allows immediate post-op assessment) or general anesthesia
Tourniquet: Ankle tourniquet (250mmHg) or thigh (300mmHg), exsanguinate with elevation
Equipment
- Small fragment set with 2.5-3.0mm headless compression screws
- Sagittal saw with 0.5-1.0mm blade
- K-wires for provisional fixation
- Fluoroscopy (optional but helpful)
- Microsagittal saw for Akin if planned
Setup: Elevate foot on sterile towels or dedicated foot holder for access
Operative Steps
Step 1: Incision & Superficial Dissection
Technique: Medial longitudinal incision 6-8cm extending from mid-proximal phalanx to mid-metatarsal shaft, centered over first metatarsal. Position 2-3mm dorsal to joint line to avoid plantar digital nerve.
Key Points
- Longer incision than chevron (need shaft exposure)
- Sharp dissection through subcutaneous tissue
- Identify and protect dorsomedial cutaneous nerve branches
- Use self-retaining retractors for exposure
Exam Pearl
Technical Tip: "I make a medial longitudinal incision 6-8cm - longer than chevron because I need exposure of the entire metatarsal shaft for the scarf. I stay 2-3mm dorsal to the joint line to avoid the plantar digital nerve and carefully identify and protect the dorsomedial cutaneous nerve which crosses the field."
Dangers at this step
- Dorsomedial cutaneous nerve injury (5-10% incidence) - runs 2-3mm dorsal
- Medial plantar digital nerve if incision too plantar (8-10mm plantar to joint)
- Inadequate incision length limiting osteotomy exposure
Step 2: Capsulotomy & Exposure
Technique: Inverted-L or linear capsulotomy along dorsomedial aspect of metatarsal and MTP joint. Extend proximally along entire metatarsal shaft to planned proximal osteotomy site. Preserve capsular flaps for later repair.
Key Points
- Full-length exposure critical for scarf
- Identify and protect lateral capsule (preserve for sesamoid stability)
- Expose medial eminence, metatarsal neck, and shaft
- Palpate and identify plantar cortex (guides osteotomy)
- Minimal periosteal stripping laterally (AVN risk)
Exam Pearl
Technical Tip: "I perform capsulotomy extending the full length of the metatarsal shaft - this complete exposure is critical for scarf osteotomy. I carefully preserve capsular tissue for closure and identify the plantar cortex which will guide my osteotomy orientation to prevent troughing."
Dangers at this step
- Excessive soft tissue stripping increases AVN risk (1-2%)
- Lateral capsule damage destabilizes sesamoids
- Loss of capsular tissue compromises closure and recurrence risk
Step 3: Medial Eminence Resection
Technique: Remove medial eminence with sagittal saw in line with medial border of metatarsal shaft. Typical resection 3-4mm. Smooth edges with rongeur. Palpate plantarly to ensure no plantar prominence.
Key Points
- Cut in line with shaft (not excessive resection)
- Over-resection destabilizes sesamoid complex
- Increases hallux varus risk
- Check no plantar prominence with finger
Exam Pearl
Technical Tip: "I resect the eminence in line with the medial shaft border - typically 3-4mm. Over-resection destabilizes the sesamoid complex and significantly increases hallux varus risk. I smooth the edges and confirm there is no plantar prominence that could cause ongoing symptoms."
Dangers at this step
- Over-resection causing sesamoid instability and varus (2-5%)
- Plantar digital nerve if cut extends plantarly
- Thermal injury from saw - use irrigation
Step 4: Scarf Osteotomy Planning - CRITICAL STEP
Technique: Plan Z-shaped osteotomy with THREE cuts:
- HORIZONTAL LIMB: Longitudinal along shaft, 2:1 ratio dorsal-to-plantar (dorsally based), PARALLEL to plantar cortex
- PROXIMAL VERTICAL LIMB: 60° angle, exits DORSALLY
- DISTAL VERTICAL LIMB: 60° angle, exits PLANTARLY
Length covers middle 60-70% of metatarsal (typically 25-30mm). Mark carefully with methylene blue or electrocautery.
Critical Geometry
- Horizontal cut MUST be parallel to plantar cortex (prevents troughing)
- 2:1 dorsal:plantar ratio = cut in dorsal 2/3 of shaft
- Opposite orientations of vertical cuts provide stability
- Adequate length prevents stress risers
Exam Pearl
Technical Tip: "The scarf is Z-shaped with critical geometry. The HORIZONTAL limb must be at 2:1 dorsal-to-plantar ratio - this dorsally biased position prevents troughing which is the most common complication. The proximal limb exits DORSALLY while the distal limb exits PLANTARLY at 60° angles. This opposite orientation provides inherent stability and prevents dorsiflexion malunion."
Dangers at this step
- Wrong ratio (1:1 or plantar-based) = TROUGHING malunion (5-10%)
- Non-parallel cuts = instability and malunion
- Horizontal limb too short = stress riser fracture (2-5%)
- Incorrect angles alter stability
Step 5: Horizontal Longitudinal Cut
Technique: Using 0.5-1.0mm sagittal saw blade, make horizontal longitudinal cut along metatarsal shaft. Cut must be PARALLEL to plantar cortex. Place in DORSAL 2/3 of metatarsal (2:1 ratio). Length typically 25-30mm covering middle shaft. Continuous irrigation to prevent thermal necrosis.
Key Points
- Palpate plantar cortex continuously during cutting
- Blade parallel to plantar surface throughout
- Incomplete cut (stop before full penetration of far cortex)
- Copious irrigation prevents thermal injury
Exam Pearl
Technical Tip: "The horizontal cut must be PARALLEL to the plantar cortex - this is THE key technical point to prevent troughing which is the most common scarf complication at 5-10%. I continuously palpate the plantar cortex with my finger as I cut to ensure I'm maintaining parallel orientation. I place the cut in the dorsal 2/3 at exactly 2:1 ratio. Continuous irrigation prevents thermal necrosis."
Dangers at this step
- Non-parallel cut = troughing (dorsiflexion malunion) - most common error
- Thermal necrosis without irrigation causes AVN
- Complete inadvertent fracture if saw exits unintentionally
- Plantar penetration risks neurovascular bundle
Step 6: Proximal Vertical Cut
Technique: Make proximal vertical cut exiting DORSALLY at approximately 60° to horizontal cut. Connect to proximal end of horizontal cut. Complete through both cortices. Creates proximal arm of Z.
Key Points
- 60° angle to horizontal
- Exit point on dorsal cortex
- Complete cut through both cortices
- Confirms mobility after cut
Exam Pearl
Technical Tip: "The proximal cut exits dorsally at 60° angle to the horizontal limb. This creates the proximal arm of the Z. I ensure complete cuts through both cortices - incomplete cuts make translation difficult and risk intraoperative fracture during manipulation."
Dangers at this step
- Incomplete cut = difficulty with translation, fracture risk during manipulation
- Exit point too far dorsal or plantar alters geometry and stability
- Propagation of cut beyond intended endpoint
Step 7: Distal Vertical Cut
Technique: Make distal vertical cut exiting PLANTARLY at 60° to horizontal cut. Connect to distal end of horizontal cut. Complete Z-shaped osteotomy. Capital fragment now mobile.
Key Points
- 60° angle opposite to proximal
- Exit point on plantar cortex (carefully)
- Confirm fragment mobility
- Opposite orientations provide stability
Exam Pearl
Technical Tip: "The distal cut exits plantarly at 60° - opposite orientation to the proximal cut. This completes the Z configuration. I confirm the capital fragment is mobile before attempting translation. The opposite orientations of the vertical cuts provide inherent rotational stability which is a key advantage of scarf geometry."
Dangers at this step
- Cut too plantar = sesamoid injury risk
- Incomplete cut = fracture during manipulation (2-5%)
- Loss of proper cut orientation = loss of stability
- Plantar neurovascular bundle at risk if cut too deep
Step 8: Translation & Multi-Planar Correction
Technique: Translate capital fragment LATERALLY - amount depends on IMA severity (typically 5-8mm, up to 10mm or 70% shaft width possible).
Multi-planar capability (advantage of scarf):
- TRANSLATION: Primary correction for IMA (lateral shift)
- ROTATION: Correct DMAA abnormality
- SHORTENING: Reduce soft tissue tension if needed
- PLANTARFLEXION: Slight plantar translation prevents transfer metatarsalgia
Impaction of fragments provides initial stability.
Key Points
- Primary goal: lateral translation for IMA correction
- Rule of thumb: 1mm translation ≈ 2° IMA correction
- Up to 70% shaft width translation possible
- Avoid excessive translation (AVN risk)
- Slight plantarflexion prevents transfer metatarsalgia
- Rotation addresses DMAA
Exam Pearl
Technical Tip: "Scarf allows true multi-planar correction which is its major advantage over chevron. My PRIMARY correction is lateral translation 5-8mm to address the IMA - roughly 1mm translation corrects 2° IMA. SECONDARY corrections include: rotation to address DMAA abnormality, shortening to reduce tension in tight soft tissues, and slight plantarflexion to prevent transfer metatarsalgia. Impaction of the fragments provides excellent initial stability."
Dangers at this step
- Excessive translation more than 70% width = instability and AVN risk
- Dorsiflexion malposition = transfer metatarsalgia (10-15%)
- Overcorrection = hallux varus (2-5%)
- Loss of bony contact = nonunion risk
Step 9: Provisional Fixation Assessment
Technique: Hold correction manually or with K-wire and assess:
- Alignment in all planes
- Sesamoid reduction under head
- No rotational deformity
- Appropriate metatarsal length
- Capital fragment sits flush on shaft (no step-off)
- Fluoroscopy confirms position if available
Key Points
- Check before definitive fixation
- Sesamoid reduction critical
- No step-off dorsally or plantarly
- Appropriate alignment
Exam Pearl
Technical Tip: "Before final fixation I carefully check: good alignment in all planes, sesamoids reduced under the metatarsal head, no rotational deformity, and appropriate metatarsal length. Fluoroscopy is helpful to confirm position before screw insertion - much easier to adjust now than after screws are placed."
Dangers at this step
- Fixing malpositioned fragments requires revision
- Missing step-off creates prominence and pain
- Unreduced sesamoids = high recurrence risk
Step 10: Screw Fixation
Technique: TWO SCREWS perpendicular to osteotomy plane. Headless compression screws preferred (2.5-3.0mm diameter). Insert PROXIMAL screw first for control, then DISTAL screw. Both achieve bicortical purchase. Lag screw technique for compression across osteotomy.
Key Points
- Two screws required (longer osteotomy than chevron)
- Perpendicular to osteotomy plane maximizes compression
- Headless screws avoid prominence and removal
- Proximal screw first gives control
- Lag technique provides compression
- Bicortical purchase for stability
Exam Pearl
Technical Tip: "I fix the scarf with TWO headless compression screws perpendicular to the osteotomy plane. I insert the proximal screw first which gives me control of the capital fragment, then the distal screw. Perpendicular placement is critical to achieve compression across the osteotomy. I use headless screws which avoid prominence and don't require routine removal - much better patient satisfaction."
Dangers at this step
- Screw prominence if not headless (patient dissatisfaction)
- Loss of correction if screws not perpendicular to osteotomy
- Screw penetration into MTP joint space
- Intraoperative fracture during screw insertion
- Inadequate purchase in osteoporotic bone
Step 11: Check Correction & Sesamoid Position
Technique: Assess final correction:
- Clinical: Straight alignment, toe points straight ahead, appropriate length, no rotation
- Radiographic: Fluoroscopy confirms hardware position, alignment, sesamoid reduction
- Critical endpoint: Sesamoids reduced under metatarsal head
Key Points
- Sesamoid reduction is CRITICAL endpoint
- If not reduced: need lateral soft tissue release
- Confirm no hardware complications
- Check alignment in all planes
Exam Pearl
Technical Tip: "I confirm the sesamoids are reduced under the metatarsal head - this is a critical endpoint that predicts long-term success. If the sesamoids are not reduced despite bony correction, I need to perform a lateral soft tissue release. Fluoroscopy confirms final alignment and proper hardware position without joint penetration."
Dangers at this step
- Unreduced sesamoids = very high recurrence risk (up to 50%)
- Missing rotational malalignment (subtle but important)
- Hardware malposition into joint or with prominence
Step 12: Lateral Release (if indicated)
Technique: If sesamoids not reduced after bony correction: lateral soft tissue release required.
Approach options:
- Through medial incision if accessible
- Separate dorsal incision between 1st-2nd metatarsals (preferred)
Release: Lateral capsule, adductor hallucis tendon from lateral base proximal phalanx
Critical: PROTECT lateral digital neurovascular bundle (5mm lateral to capsule)
Key Points
- Indicated if sesamoids unreduced
- Release lateral capsule and adductor
- Stay on capsular layer
- Protect neurovascular bundle 5mm lateral
- Recheck sesamoid position after release
Exam Pearl
Technical Tip: "I perform lateral release if sesamoids remain unreduced after bony correction. I release the lateral capsule and detach the adductor hallucis tendon from the base of the proximal phalanx. The critical danger is the lateral digital neurovascular bundle which runs 5mm lateral to the capsule - injury causes numbness and chronic pain. I stay on the capsular layer and use gentle dissection."
Dangers at this step
- Lateral digital neurovascular injury (5mm from capsule) causes numbness
- Overcorrection if too aggressive = hallux varus (2-5%)
- Vascular compromise to hallux from excessive release
Step 13: Akin Osteotomy (adjunct procedure)
Technique: Add Akin osteotomy if:
- Residual HVA greater than 15° after scarf correction
- DASA greater than 10° (interphalangeal valgus component)
- To optimize final correction and alignment
Medial-based closing wedge at proximal phalanx base, 2-3mm wedge. Fix with single headless screw or staple.
Key Points
- Common adjunct (30-40% of cases)
- Addresses interphalangeal component
- Small wedge (2-3mm adequate)
- Single screw or staple fixation
- Avoid overcorrection
Exam Pearl
Technical Tip: "Akin osteotomy is a common adjunct to scarf - I add it in about 30-40% of cases when there's residual HVA greater than 15° after the metatarsal correction or when DASA is elevated above 10° indicating interphalangeal valgus. It's a medial closing wedge at the base of the proximal phalanx, typically 2-3mm. I must be careful not to overcorrect which causes interphalangeal varus deformity."
Dangers at this step
- Overcorrection = interphalangeal varus deformity
- Inadequate fixation = displacement
- IP joint stiffness from periosteal stripping
- Neurovascular injury if dissection too aggressive
Step 14: Capsular Repair
Technique: MEDIAL CAPSULE REEFING critical for soft tissue balance. Imbricate (overlap) medial capsule using "pants-over-vest" or "vest-over-pants" technique. Balance tension - adequate to maintain correction but not causing stiffness. Use absorbable sutures (2-0 or 3-0 Vicryl).
Key Points
- Soft tissue balance as important as bone
- Overlap capsule for imbrication
- Balanced tension (not too tight, not too loose)
- Too loose = recurrence from laxity
- Too tight = stiffness, overcorrection
- Multiple interrupted sutures
Exam Pearl
Technical Tip: "I reef the medial capsule to address the soft tissue laxity and maintain the correction - this soft tissue component is as important as the bony correction. I overlap the capsular edges (imbrication) with carefully balanced tension. Too loose allows recurrence from medial laxity, too tight causes stiffness and possible overcorrection. I aim for the toe to rest in slight overcorrection but still mobile."
Dangers at this step
- Overtightening = stiffness, limited ROM, overcorrection
- Inadequate closure = recurrence from persistent medial laxity (5-10%)
- Devascularization from excessive handling
Step 15: Closure & Bunion Dressing
Technique:
- Subcutaneous closure with absorbable sutures (3-0 Vicryl)
- Skin with subcuticular 4-0 Monocryl or interrupted 4-0 nylon
- BUNION DRESSING essential:
- Gauze between 1st and 2nd toes
- Toe maintained in corrected position with gauze padding
- Circumferential compression wrap (not too tight)
- Stiff-soled postoperative shoe
Key Points
- Layered closure
- Bunion dressing maintains correction
- Gauze between toes prevents drift
- Compression controls swelling
- Postop shoe protects osteotomy
Exam Pearl
Technical Tip: "I close in layers and apply a proper bunion dressing which is essential to maintain the toe in corrected alignment during early healing. I place gauze between the 1st and 2nd toes to prevent drift back into valgus, apply circumferential compression to control swelling, and provide a stiff-soled postoperative shoe which protects the osteotomy for the critical first 6 weeks."
Dangers at this step
- Wound dehiscence (5-10%) - especially in thin skin overlying eminence
- Loss of correction if inadequate dressing applied
- Vascular compromise from overly tight dressing
- Skin necrosis from pressure points