Surgical discectomy via approach tailored to herniation location | cord must NEVER be retracted | advanced
Surgical Imaging

The trap: Counting ribs or vertebral bodies from surface anatomy (C7 prominence, T12 rib) is unreliable — up to 15% of thoracic spine procedures have incorrect level localisation in some series. The T2 vertebra is difficult to identify on an intraoperative lateral because the shoulders overlap.
The fix: Use a preoperative full-length localiser radiograph. Place a localising needle, k-wire or towel clip in a spinous process at the intended level and confirm with AP + lateral X-ray or CT before incision. Cross-reference with preoperative MRI by counting from T1 (which articulates with the first rib) on a sagittal localiser. Never rely on a single radiographic view alone.
Mechanism: The thoracic spinal cord has a watershed blood supply in the mid-thoracic region (T4-T9), where the anterior spinal artery is narrowest and receives the fewest radicular feeders. Even gentle retraction can cause cord ischaemia and permanent motor loss.
Prevention: Choose an approach that allows the herniation to be resected without any contact with the cord. For lateral discs, a transpedicular or costotransversectomy approach reaches the disc lateral to the cord. For central/broad-based discs, an anterior (transthoracic) or lateral extracavitary approach provides direct visualisation without cord retraction.
Location: Most commonly arises from a left posterior intercostal artery between T9 and T11 (75% of individuals), but can arise from T5-L4 and from the right in up to 25%. It joins the anterior spinal artery and supplies the anterior two-thirds of the lower thoracic and upper lumbar cord.
Risk: Sacrifice of the segmental vessel feeding the artery of Adamkiewicz during a transthoracic or lateral approach risks anterior spinal artery syndrome — flaccid paraplegia with preserved posterior column function (vibration and proprioception). Prevention: Preoperative CT angiography or MRA in all patients undergoing anterior or lateral approaches to the lower thoracic spine. If the artery arises at or adjacent to the herniation level, consider a different approach or temporary clamping with neuromonitoring.
Risk: Calcified thoracic discs adhere to the ventral dura in a significant proportion of cases. In the series by Stillerman, up to 30% of calcified discs demonstrated some degree of dural penetration at surgery. The disc and dura may be inseparable.
Management: Plan for intentional durotomy with en-bloc resection of the disc and adherent dura, followed by primary dural repair (6-0 Prolene or Gore-Tex suture) or patching with autologous fascia, bovine pericardium or dural substitute. Apply sealant and drain management. Conversion to a more extensile approach (lateral extracavitary or transthoracic) provides better access for repair than a narrow posterolateral corridor.
The error: Attempting a posterolateral (transpedicular/costotransversectomy) approach for a central, broad-based or calcified disc that cannot be safely resected without manipulating the cord. The narrow working angle through the pedicle and facet pushes the instruments toward the cord.
The fix: Classify the herniation on axial MRI (and CT if calcified) in relation to the cord. Lateral/foraminal herniations — posterolateral approach. Central, broad-based or calcified herniations — anterior (transthoracic, thoracoscopic) or lateral extracavitary approach. A midline central disc cannot be safely resected from a unilateral posterolateral window without unacceptable cord risk.
Risk: The transthoracic (transpleural) approach requires lung deflation (double-lumen endotracheal tube), rib resection or spreading, and pleural entry. Specific complications include: persistent air leak (5-10%), haemothorax, intercostal neuralgia from rib retraction, pleural effusion, pneumonia, and chest-tube-related complications.
Mitigation: Meticulous pleural closure at the end of the procedure with a water-tight seal. Place a chest tube (24-28 Fr) under water seal with -20 cm H2O suction. Remove when output is less than 100-150 mL/24 hours and no air leak is present on water seal trial. Consider an intercostal nerve block at the time of closure to reduce postoperative pain and pulmonary morbidity.
T.H.O.R.A.C.I.CTHORACIC — Key Principles of Thoracic Discectomy
D.I.S.C. H.E.R.N.I.ADISC HERNIA — Approach Selection
Surgical Indications
Absolute Indications
- Progressive myelopathy due to thoracic disc herniation — the presence of cord signal change, gait disturbance, lower limb hyperreflexia, clonus, or bladder/bowel dysfunction constitutes a surgical urgency
- Acute paraplegia from a compressive thoracic disc herniation — requires urgent decompression
- Intractable radiculopathy with radicular pain or intercostal neuralgia that has failed a trial of non-operative care (analgesics, activity modification, intercostal nerve blocks) for 6-12 weeks
- Cord compression with significant spinal canal compromise (greater than 40% canal encroachment or cord deformation on MRI) even without dense myelopathy — due to risk of progression
Relative Indications
- Persistent radiculopathy without cord signs that significantly impairs quality of life
- Herniation discovered incidentally in a patient undergoing surgery at an adjacent level — if accessible through the same approach
- Progressive deformity or segmental instability developing from the disc height loss and endplate changes
Contraindications
Absolute:
- Asymptomatic thoracic disc herniation found incidentally on MRI — the vast majority of thoracic disc herniations are asymptomatic and require no treatment
- Active systemic infection or uncontrolled coagulopathy
- Medical comorbidities precluding the planned approach (poor pulmonary reserve for transthoracic approach; severe osteoporosis for any instrumented reconstruction)
Relative:
- Multilevel degenerative disease where the symptomatic level cannot be confidently identified
- Previous ipsilateral thoracotomy or chest pathology (pleural adhesions) making transthoracic approach hazardous — consider contralateral approach or alternative approach
- Morbid obesity (BMI greater than 40) — increases technical difficulty of all approaches and wound complication risk
Evidence for Non-Operative Treatment
Observation and Conservative Care
- The natural history of asymptomatic thoracic disc herniations is generally benign — most do not progress or become symptomatic (Wood, 1995)
- For patients with radiculopathy alone, a trial of observation, simple analgesics (paracetamol, NSAIDs), activity modification and physiotherapy is reasonable for 6-12 weeks
- Neuropathic pain agents (gabapentinoids, amitriptyline) may help radicular symptoms but have no effect on cord compression — their use must not delay surgical referral if myelopathy develops
- There are no RCTs directly comparing operative and non-operative management for symptomatic thoracic disc herniation — all evidence is from case series
Intercostal Nerve Blocks and Epidural Steroid Injections
- Image-guided (CT or fluoroscopic) intercostal nerve blocks can provide temporary relief of radicular symptoms and help confirm the symptomatic level
- Transforminal epidural steroid injections at the thoracic level carry a higher risk of spinal cord injury than in the lumbar spine and are not routinely recommended
- Chelation (chemonucleolysis) has no role in the thoracic spine
Evidence for Surgery
Outcomes by Approach
- Transthoracic approach: Stillerman (1998) reported a good/excellent outcome in 82% of 82 patients undergoing anterior decompression for thoracic disc herniation, with the best outcomes in patients with myelopathy or radiculopathy without preoperative deficit longer than 6 months
- Posterolateral approaches: Borm (2004) reported satisfactory outcomes in 80% of patients undergoing transpedicular discectomy, with lower morbidity than transthoracic approaches but limited application to lateral/foraminal herniations
- Lateral extracavitary approach: An extensile option that provides ventral access without entering the pleural cavity — useful for herniations at the thoracolumbar junction and for revision cases
Prognostic Factors
- Duration of symptoms: Patients with preoperative myelopathy for less than 6 months have significantly better neurological recovery than those with longer-standing deficits (Levi, 1999)
- Disc calcification: Calcified discs have higher complication rates (dural tear, incomplete resection) but equivalent clinical outcomes when completely resected via an appropriate anterior approach
- Age: Younger patients (less than 50 years) have better functional recovery, but surgical decompression is effective across all age groups
Key Evidence
Experience in the surgical management of 82 symptomatic herniated thoracic discs and review of the literature
Thoracic disc herniation: operative approaches and results
Video-assisted thoracoscopic surgery for thoracic disc disease: classification and outcome study of 100 consecutive cases with a 2-year minimum follow-up
The natural history of asymptomatic thoracic disc herniations
Clinical Decision Scenarios
Practise clinical reasoning and management decisions out loud
“A 52-year-old woman presents with a 3-month history of bilateral lower limb weakness, gait unsteadiness and urinary urgency. MRI shows a large central, broad-based T8-T9 disc herniation with cord compression and cord signal change. CT shows the disc is heavily calcified. She is otherwise fit and healthy. How would you manage her surgically?”
“A 38-year-old man presents with a 6-month history of right-sided intercostal neuralgia at the T6-T7 level. MRI shows a right-sided lateral T6-T7 disc herniation with foraminal extension. There is no myelopathy, no cord compression. CT shows no calcification. He has failed 8 weeks of conservative treatment. How would you manage him surgically?”
“During a transthoracic discectomy for a calcified T10-T11 disc herniation, the calcified disc material is adherent to the ventral dura. As you attempt to dissect the disc off the dura, a 4 mm dural defect occurs with visible CSF egress. The disc fragment is still partially attached to the dura. How do you manage this intraoperative complication?”