MSIS Diagnostic Criteria for PJI
Major Criteria (need 2 or more):
- Sinus tract communicating with prosthesis
- Synovial fluid analysis: WBC over 3000 cells/µL OR PMN percentage over 80%
- Serum markers: ESR over 30 mm/h AND CRP over 10 mg/L
- Positive cultures: 2 or more separate samples with same organism
- Histology: Over 5 polymorphonuclear leukocytes per high-power field (400×) in 5 separate fields
Minor Criteria (supportive but not diagnostic alone):
- Single positive culture
- Elevated synovial CRP over 10 mg/L
- Elevated alpha-defensin
- Elevated synovial leukocyte esterase
- Positive synovial C6 peptide
Exam Pearl
Exam Key: MSIS criteria revised in 2018 - need 2 or more major criteria OR score-based system using minor criteria. Sinus tract is pathognomonic (definite infection). Tissue culture more sensitive than fluid culture (94% vs 70% for multiple samples). Hold antibiotics 2 weeks pre-op to maximize culture yield from 60% to 80%.
Antibiotic Holiday Protocol
Rationale: Antibiotics suppress bacteria but don't eradicate biofilm - creates false negative cultures
Stage 1: Stop antibiotics 2 weeks before surgery
- Improves culture yield from 60% to 80%
- Allows identification of causative organism
- Risk: systemic sepsis if highly virulent organism (monitor clinically)
Stage 2: Stop antibiotics 2 weeks before reimplantation
- Unmasks persistent infection
- Improves aspiration sensitivity from 40% to 75%
- If aspiration positive after holiday: abort Stage 2, repeat debridement
Exam Pearl
Exam Key: Antibiotic holiday critical at BOTH stages. Unknown organism reduces two-stage success by 20% (unable to target antibiotics). False reassurance from antibiotics masking persistent infection at Stage 2 leads to 50% failure rate.
Imaging Assessment for Bone Loss
Radiographs:
- AP pelvis and lateral hip
- Judet views (obturator oblique, iliac oblique) for acetabular assessment
- Full-length femur AP/lateral if previous fracture or extensive osteolysis
CT Scan:
- Assess acetabular bone stock (Paprosky classification)
- Identify pelvic discontinuity
- Measure bone defects for reconstruction planning
- Plan custom implants if needed (triflange)
Paprosky Acetabular Classification:
- Type I: Intact rim, minimal migration, intact teardrop/Kohler's line
- Type IIA: Superior-medial wear, intact rim, Kohler's line intact
- Type IIB: Superior migration under 3cm, medial wall intact, ischial lysis
- Type IIC: Medial wear, Kohler's line disrupted, intact columns
- Type IIIA: Severe superior migration over 3cm, less than 50% host bone contact
- Type IIIB: Pelvic discontinuity, severe medial/global deficiency
Paprosky Femoral Classification:
- Type I: Minimal metaphyseal bone loss, intact diaphysis
- Type II: Extensive metaphyseal damage, intact diaphysis
- Type IIIA: Metaphyseal damage, 4cm or more diaphyseal contact available
- Type IIIB: Extensive metaphyseal and diaphyseal damage, under 4cm contact
- Type IV: Extensive damage, nonsupportive isthmus, scarce diaphyseal contact
Pre-operative Planning Essentials
- Order antibiotic cement components (vancomycin 4g vials, tobramycin 2.4g)
- Cell saver CONTRAINDICATED in infection (disseminates bacteria)
- Consent for ETO, nerve injury, recurrent infection, salvage procedures (Girdlestone, arthrodesis, amputation)
- Ensure availability of revision implants: augments, cages, modular stems, dual mobility
- Infectious Disease consultation for antibiotic selection
Patient Positioning and Draping
Lateral Decubitus Position:
- Affected side up
- Pelvis perpendicular to floor (confirmed with positioning rod or fluoroscopy)
- Anterior pelvic support at ASIS
- Posterior support at sacrum
- Bean bag or dedicated pelvic positioner
- All bony prominences padded (fibular head, medial malleolus, dependent shoulder)
- Axillary roll under dependent axilla (prevent brachial plexus injury)
Stability Check:
- Table tilt test to confirm secure positioning
- Patient must not shift during reduction maneuvers
- Pelvic obliquity causes cup malposition (anteversion/inclination errors)
Draping:
- Prepare entire leg from iliac crest to toes
- Wide circumferential prep for extensile exposure if needed
- Mark greater trochanter, PSIS, femoral shaft
Exam Pearl
Technical Tip: Pelvis perpendicular to floor is CRITICAL - obliquity causes systematic cup malposition. Use positioning rod or fluoroscopy to confirm. Anterior support prevents patient rolling forward during acetabular exposure/reaming. Wide prep allows extension for ETO or challenging exposure.
Posterior Approach and Exposure
Incision:
- Use previous posterior scar (typically 8-15cm)
- Extend proximally toward PSIS or distally 5cm beyond GT if needed
- Anticipate indurated scar tissue from previous surgery and infection
Dissection:
- Deepen through subcutaneous tissue (may be fibrous)
- Incise fascia lata in line with femur
- Split gluteus maximus in line of fibers (internervous plane between superior and inferior gluteal nerves)
CRITICAL: Early sciatic nerve identification
- Blunt dissection with finger palpation
- Nerve may be adherent in scar tissue
- May be displaced medially by subsided stem
- Protect throughout with finger or Hohmann retractor
- 2-5% injury rate in revision vs 0.2% in primary THA
Capsule and Short External Rotators:
- Usually scarred and thickened
- Release from posterior trochanter to femoral neck insertion
- Excise thickened posterior capsule completely (biofilm harbor)
- Tag for later repair
Hip Dislocation: Posterior with flexion, adduction, internal rotation
Nerve Protection
- Sciatic nerve HIGHEST RISK in revision THA
- Identify early with blunt dissection
- Use finger protection throughout
- Avoid limb lengthening over 4cm (nerve stretch injury)
- Superior gluteal nerve: avoid dissection above piriformis
- Femoral nerve anterior: at risk with anterior reaming
Tissue Sampling Protocol
BEFORE any debridement (critical for uncontaminated cultures):
- Obtain 5-6 tissue samples from different sites:
- Capsule/pseudocapsule
- Femoral interface membrane
- Acetabular interface membrane
- Femoral bone
- Acetabular bone
- Soft tissue from different quadrant
Technique:
- Use separate instruments for each sample
- Avoid superficial contamination
- Send in separate sterile containers
Laboratory:
- Aerobic culture (14-day hold)
- Anaerobic culture (14-day hold)
- Fungal culture if immunosuppressed
- Hold 14 days for slow-growing organisms (Cutibacterium/Propionibacterium)
- Histology: 1-2 samples for frozen and permanent sections
Exam Pearl
Evidence: Multiple tissue samples CRUCIAL - single culture 70% sensitivity vs 94% with multiple samples. Need 2 or more positive cultures with same organism for MSIS diagnosis. Tissue culture more sensitive than fluid. Cutibacterium causes 10% of PJI and requires extended culture (14 days).
Component Removal and ETO
Acetabular Cup Removal:
- Curved osteotomes around cup-bone interface circumferentially
- Start at superior dome, work around 360 degrees
- Leverage out with broad osteotome
- Preserve bone stock
Femoral Stem Removal:
If cemented or well-fixed: Perform EXTENDED TROCHANTERIC OSTEOTOMY
ETO Technique:
- Mark anterolateral femur, 8-10cm length
- One-third circumference (preserve posterior 2/3)
- Preserve vastus lateralis attachment posteriorly (blood supply from lateral circumflex femoral artery)
- Three cuts with oscillating saw:
- Anterior vertical cut
- Distal horizontal cut
- Posterior vertical-oblique cut (connects to distal)
- Hinge open like a book with abductors attached
- Stem now accessible for removal
Cement Removal:
- Ultrasonic cement removal system (UCRS) preferred
- OR high-speed burr with long thin carbide bits
- Remove ALL cement down to canal
- Work systematically from proximal to distal
- Finger in anterior joint to detect perforation
- Headlamp and loupes for visualization
Exam Pearl
Technical Tip: ETO essential for complete cement removal - attempting without ETO has 30% perforation risk. ETO allows direct visualization and removal of all cement (biofilm harbor). Technique: preserve vastus lateralis posteriorly (blood supply), 8-10cm length adequate for most cases, 90% union rate with proper fixation (3+ cables).
Radical Debridement
Principles: Aggressive debridement is KEY to success - inadequate debridement causes 50% of recurrent infections
Soft Tissue:
- Complete synovectomy (remove ALL synovium)
- Excise entire interface membrane (biofilm harbor)
- Remove all PMMA debris, cement fragments
- Remove all metal debris, polyethylene particles
- Excise any sinus tract completely to skin
Bone:
- Debride non-viable bone (grey, sclerotic, avascular)
- High-speed burr for sclerotic areas
- Curettes for membrane
- Rongeurs for osteolytic bone
- Ream acetabulum to bleeding bone
- Ream femoral canal to bleeding bone
- Aim for "Paprika sign" (healthy bleeding bone bed)
Balance: Adequate debridement vs preserving bone stock for reimplantation
Debridement Risks
- Inadequate debridement of biofilm causes persistent infection (50% recurrence)
- Excessive bone loss compromises reimplantation (may need structural graft, cage, or salvage)
- Femoral or acetabular perforation during aggressive debridement
- Quadrilateral plate breach during acetabular debridement (intrapelvic injury)
High-Volume Irrigation and Decontamination
Irrigation Protocol:
- Minimum 9 litres normal saline (some institutions use 12-15L)
- Body temperature saline (37°C)
- High pressure pulse lavage initially (mechanical debridement)
- Then low pressure (avoid driving bacteria into bone)
- Irrigate all recesses (acetabulum, femoral canal, soft tissue pockets)
NO additives: No antibiotics, Betadine, chlorhexidine, hydrogen peroxide
- Cytotoxic to osteoblasts
- Impairs bone healing
- Mechanical removal more effective than chemical
CHANGE ALL:
- After lavage: change gloves, gowns, instruments
- Re-drape if possible
- Use FRESH IMPLANT SETS for spacer insertion
- Simulates "new operation" - reduces bacterial load
Exam Pearl
Evidence: Minimum 9L irrigation reduces bacterial load 100-fold. Mechanical removal more important than additives. CHANGE ALL after lavage reduces bacterial load further - acts like starting fresh case. Antiseptic additives (Betadine, chlorhexidine, H2O2) are cytotoxic to osteoblasts and impair bone healing at reimplantation.
Antibiotic Spacer Fabrication and Insertion
Spacer Type: ARTICULATING preferred over static
Advantages:
- Maintains limb length and offset
- Prevents soft tissue contracture
- Preserves ROM
- Allows weight-bearing mobilization (WBAT)
- Easier Stage 2 reimplantation
- Preserves bone (avoids stress shielding)
- Similar infection control rate to static
Disadvantages:
- 13-15% dislocation rate (vs 5% static) - acceptable
- 5-10% fracture rate (usually late, over 3 months)
- More technically complex
Static Spacer: Reserved for severe instability or abductor deficiency
Options for Articulating Spacer:
- Preformed commercial: PROSTALAC, Spacer-G (expensive, good quality)
- Hand-made: Femoral head mold for acetabular component, stem mold for femoral, 36-40mm metal head on femoral component
HANSSEN HIGH-DOSE ANTIBIOTIC CEMENT PROTOCOL:
- 4g vancomycin powder + 2.4g tobramycin powder per 40g cement
- This is 3× standard dosing
- Use Palacos or Simplex cement (high fatigue strength)
- Hand-mix or vacuum-mix
Rationale:
- Achieves local concentration 200× MIC
- Bactericidal against biofilm bacteria
- Minimal systemic absorption (low toxicity)
- Vancomycin covers Gram-positive (including MRSA)
- Tobramycin covers Gram-negative
Organism-Specific Antibiotics (if known):
- VRE: Daptomycin 4g per 40g cement
- Pseudomonas: Ceftazidime or tobramycin
- Fungi: Voriconazole or amphotericin
Insertion Technique:
- Insert acetabular spacer first (mushroom shape, 2-3mm larger than native)
- Insert femoral component with metal head
- Reduce hip
- Ensure spacer is STABLE but retrievable
- Avoid excess cement keying into canal (makes removal difficult)
- Trial stability - should resist dislocation but not too tight
Exam Pearl
High-Yield: ARTICULATING spacer benefits over static: maintains length/offset, prevents contracture, allows WBAT, easier reimplantation, similar infection control. Dislocation rate 13-15% acceptable. HIGH-DOSE antibiotics (Hanssen): 4g vancomycin + 2.4g tobramycin per 40g cement provides 200× MIC local concentration with low systemic toxicity.
ETO Repair and Wound Closure
If ETO performed:
-
Reduce trochanteric fragment anatomically
- Greater trochanter should align with femoral shaft contour
- Restore normal abductor lever arm
-
Fix with minimum 3 CERCLAGE CABLES:
- 18-gauge stainless steel or titanium cables
- Pass cables around intact femur proximal to osteotomy
- Pass cables around intact femur distal to osteotomy
- Tighten sequentially to achieve compression
- May add vertical cable longitudinally if unstable
- Specialized ETO claw plate for severe instability
-
Test stability by pulling on abductors
- Must be rigid to permit union
- 90% union rate if properly fixed
Soft Tissue Repair:
- Repair posterior capsule remnants
- Repair short external rotators to posterior trochanter
- Re-establish posterior soft tissue restraint (prevents dislocation)
- Close gluteus maximus
- Close fascia lata
- Subcutaneous absorbable sutures
- Skin (staples or subcuticular)
Drains: Debated
- Some avoid in infection setting
- Some use closed suction for 24 hours
ETO Fixation Critical
- Need 3 or more cables for union
- Must achieve stable compression
- Protected weight-bearing until union (6-8 weeks)
- Non-union rate 5-10%
- Risk factors: infection, inadequate fixation, smoking, non-compliance
- Non-union requires ORIF with plate + cables + bone graft if symptomatic
Stage 1 Postoperative Management
IV Antibiotics: 6 weeks minimum (extend to 12 weeks for difficult organisms)
Organism-Specific (once cultures return):
- MRSA/MSSA: Vancomycin IV 15mg/kg q12h (MRSA) OR flucloxacillin 2g q6h (if sensitive)
- Gram-negative: Fluoroquinolone (ciprofloxacin 400mg IV q12h) or 3rd-generation cephalosporin
- Polymicrobial: Broad spectrum (vancomycin + ceftriaxone or meropenem)
- Fungi: Amphotericin or echinocandin (caspofungin)
RIFAMPICIN: ESSENTIAL for ALL Staphylococcal PJI
- 300-450mg PO twice daily
- Start AFTER wound healed (day 5-7)
- Excellent biofilm penetration
- Bactericidal against slow-growing organisms
- MUST pair with fusidic acid or fluoroquinolone (prevent resistance)
- NEVER monotherapy (resistance develops within days)
Monitoring:
- Weekly CRP and ESR
- Should trend downward (CRP halves weekly)
- If plateau or rise: suspect persistent infection
Mobilization:
- WBAT if articulating spacer stable
- Hip precautions (avoid flexion over 90°, adduction, internal rotation)
- Walker or crutches
Interval Before Stage 2:
- Minimum 6-8 weeks from Stage 1
- Some wait 12+ weeks for difficult organisms (fungi, resistant bacteria)
- ANTIBIOTIC HOLIDAY 2 weeks before Stage 2 (critical - unmasks persistent infection)
Exam Pearl
Protocol: 6 weeks IV antibiotics standard, extend to 12 weeks if needed. Rifampicin ESSENTIAL for Staph PJI - start AFTER wound healed (skin necrosis risk). Pair with fusidic acid or fluoroquinolone (prevent resistance). Monitor CRP weekly - should drop 50%/week. Antibiotic holiday 2 weeks pre-Stage 2 CRITICAL - unmasks persistent infection, improves aspiration sensitivity from 40% to 75%.
Criteria for Proceeding to Stage 2
Essential Requirements:
- Completed antibiotic course: 6-12 weeks IV antibiotics
- Normalized inflammatory markers:
- CRP under 10 mg/L
- ESR under 30 mm/h
- Trending downward if not normalized
- Well-healed wound: No drainage, no erythema, no tenderness
- Patient medically optimized: Nutritional status, comorbidities controlled
- Minimum interval: 6-8 weeks from Stage 1 (extend to 12+ weeks for difficult organisms)
If Doubt Exists:
ASPIRATION after 2-week antibiotic holiday:
- Send for cell count, culture (aerobic/anaerobic/fungal)
- Synovial WBC over 3000 or PMN over 80% suggests persistent infection
- Positive culture = ABORT Stage 2
Options if Aspiration Positive:
- Repeat debridement + new spacer + extended antibiotics
- Chronic suppression (indefinite oral antibiotics)
- Salvage procedures (Girdlestone, arthrodesis, amputation)
Exam Pearl
Decision Point: Timing Stage 2 requires normalized CRP (under 10), ESR (under 30), minimum 6-8 weeks interval, healed wound. Antibiotic holiday 2 weeks before assessment CRITICAL. If doubt: aspirate after holiday - positive culture means either repeat debridement + new spacer or chronic suppression. Reimplanting with active infection drops success from 85-90% to under 50%.
Spacer Complications During Interval
Dislocation (13-15% with articulating):
- Management: Closed reduction, hip precautions, abduction brace
- If recurrent: consider revising to static spacer or expedite Stage 2
- Most occur within first 6 weeks
Spacer Fracture (5-10%):
- Usually late (over 3 months)
- Management: If late, indicates time for Stage 2 (cement fatigue from normal timeframe)
- If early (under 3 months): revise spacer, investigate cause
Persistent Drainage:
- Suggests inadequate debridement
- Culture drainage
- May need repeat debridement
Medical Deterioration:
- Optimize before Stage 2
- May need prolonged interval
- Consider chronic suppression if unfit for surgery
Red Flags During Interval
- Rising or plateau CRP/ESR despite adequate antibiotics (persistent infection)
- Persistent wound drainage (sinus tract, inadequate debridement)
- Recurrent spacer dislocation (soft tissue incompetence, abductor failure)
- Spacer fracture early (under 3 months) - infection, excessive loading
- Medical deterioration (may preclude Stage 2, consider chronic suppression)
Antibiotic Holiday Rationale
Purpose: Unmask persistent infection that antibiotics suppress but don't eradicate
Protocol:
- Stop ALL antibiotics 2 weeks before Stage 2
- Clinical monitoring (fever, wound changes, pain)
- Inflammatory markers (CRP, ESR) at 1 week and 2 weeks
- Hip aspiration at 2 weeks
Interpretation:
- CRP/ESR remain low, aspiration negative: Proceed to Stage 2
- CRP/ESR rise, aspiration positive: Persistent infection - abort Stage 2
- CRP/ESR rise, aspiration negative: Investigate (imaging, repeat aspiration)
Risk:
- Systemic sepsis if highly virulent organism (rare)
- Monitor patient clinically
- Restart antibiotics if sepsis develops
Exam Pearl
Evidence: Antibiotic holiday improves aspiration sensitivity from 40% to 75% for detecting persistent infection. Antibiotics suppress bacteria creating false reassurance. False negative aspiration occurs if on antibiotics - leads to reimplanting with active infection (50% failure rate vs 10% if infection controlled). Holiday is low risk (sepsis rare) with high benefit (accurate diagnosis).
Exposure and Spacer Removal
Approach: Same posterior approach through previous scar
Expect MORE DIFFICULT dissection than Stage 1:
- Extensive scar tissue from two previous surgeries
- Distorted anatomy from spacer subsidence
- Sciatic nerve encased in scar (highest risk)
- Indurated capsule
Technique:
- Careful dissection through scar
- Protect sciatic nerve (blunt dissection, early identification)
- Deepen to joint, excise pseudocapsule
- Dislocate hip posteriorly
- Remove spacer metal head first
- Remove acetabular component (osteotomes at interface)
- Remove femoral component (may need high-speed burr if well-fixed)
- Remove ALL spacer cement fragments (biofilm can form on retained cement)
- Light debridement of any residual membrane/synovium
- Ream acetabulum to bleeding bone (establish new bone bed)
- Ream femoral canal to bleeding bone
Exam Pearl
Technical Challenge: Stage 2 exposure often MORE challenging than Stage 1 - dense scar, distorted anatomy, nerve encased. Articulating spacer easier to remove than static (less cement, more modular). Remove ALL spacer cement - retained cement is biofilm substrate causing reinfection. Fresh debridement of bone surfaces essential - need bleeding bone bed for biological fixation.
Tissue Sampling and Frozen Section
CRITICAL SAFETY CHECK: Frozen section is final verification before reimplantation
Tissue Samples:
- Obtain 5-6 FRESH tissue samples BEFORE reimplantation:
- Capsule/pseudocapsule
- Acetabular bone interface
- Femoral bone interface
- Soft tissue from different quadrants
- Send for aerobic/anaerobic cultures (14-day hold)
- Send for permanent histology
FROZEN SECTION (mandatory):
- Send capsule/interface tissue for immediate histology
- Over 5 PMN/HPF = PERSISTENT INFECTION
- Sensitivity ~80%, specificity ~95%
If Frozen Section POSITIVE (over 5 PMN/HPF) OR gross purulence:
- ABORT reimplantation
- Place new antibiotic spacer with fresh high-dose antibiotics
- Extended IV antibiotics (12 weeks)
- Repeat CRP/ESR monitoring
- Consider chronic suppression or salvage procedures
If Frozen Section NEGATIVE (under 5 PMN/HPF) and tissues appear clean:
- Proceed with reimplantation
- Final cultures guide postoperative antibiotics (6 weeks if positive)
Exam Pearl
Critical Decision: Frozen section at Stage 2 - over 5 PMN/HPF = ABORT reimplantation, place new spacer. Sensitivity ~80%, specificity ~95%. False negatives possible (antibiotics suppress but don't eradicate, dormant bacteria). If positive or gross infection: new spacer, extended antibiotics 12 weeks, consider chronic suppression or salvage. Cultures at Stage 2 detect persistent/new infection (10-20% positive despite normalized markers).
Acetabular Reconstruction
Assess Bone Loss: Paprosky classification
Reaming: Sequential hemispherical reamers to bleeding bone, 1-2mm underream for press-fit
Reconstruction by Paprosky Type:
Type I (intact rim, minimal migration):
- Standard uncemented hemispherical revision cup
- Multiple screws (dome, posterior column)
- Highly cross-linked polyethylene liner
Type IIA (superior-medial wear, intact rim/columns):
- Standard cup, may need small augment superomedial
- Multiple screws into intact bone
Type IIB/IIC (moderate deficiency, ischial lysis):
- Jumbo cup (66-70mm) - excellent results
- OR augments (porous tantalum or titanium)
- Ensure 50% host bone contact
Type IIIA (severe superior deficiency, under 50% contact):
- Structural augment + cup
- OR cup-cage construct (Ganz ring, Burch-Schneider cage)
- Multiple screws into ilium, posterior column
Type IIIB (severe medial wall loss or pelvic discontinuity):
- Cup-cage construct (distraction cage)
- OR custom triflange implant
- OR cemented cup with cage support
- May require plating of discontinuity first
General Principles:
- Aim for 50% host bone contact for biological fixation
- Multiple screws into intact bone (posterior column, ilium, dome)
- Avoid 3 o'clock and 9 o'clock positions (external iliac vessels)
- HIGHLY CROSS-LINKED POLYETHYLENE liner
- Consider DUAL MOBILITY liner (see below)
Exam Pearl
Reconstruction Strategy: Bone loss common after two-stage (debridement + spacer subsidence). Paprosky classification guides reconstruction. Need 50% host bone contact for biological fixation. Type I/IIA: standard revision cup. Type IIB/IIC/IIIA: jumbo cup (excellent results, simpler) or augments (porous tantalum). Type IIIB: cup-cage (antiprotrusio cage) or custom triflange (expensive, long wait). Screws in SAFE ZONES (avoid 3 o'clock, 9 o'clock - vessels).
Femoral Reconstruction
Assess Bone Loss: Paprosky femoral classification
Reconstruction by Paprosky Type:
Type I (metaphyseal bone intact):
- Standard uncemented revision stem (tapered or proximally porous)
- Press-fit in metaphysis
Type II (metaphyseal compromise, intact diaphysis):
- Extensively porous coated cylindrical stem (diaphyseal fixation)
- 4-6 inches coating length
- Scratch fit in diaphysis
Type IIIA (metaphyseal damage, diaphyseal intact 4cm or more):
- Extensively porous coated stem (need 4cm scratch fit for stability, 90% success)
- OR modular tapered stem (Wagner-type, Reclaim)
- Bypass ETO site by 2 cortical diameters (10cm)
Type IIIB (extensive metaphyseal/diaphyseal damage, under 4cm fixation):
- Modular tapered fluted stem (Wagner, Reclaim, MP) - long version
- Megaprosthesis (elderly, tumor-like defects, unfit for complex reconstruction)
- OR allograft-prosthetic composite (APC) - young patients, large defects
Cemented vs Cementless (debated):
- Most prefer CEMENTLESS (no biofilm substrate)
- But some use low-dose antibiotic cement for older osteoporotic patients:
- 1g vancomycin per 40g cement (NOT high-dose like spacer)
- Provides some infection protection
- Allows cement fixation in poor bone
If ETO: Leave open until stem inserted, then reduce and cable (3+ cables)
Exam Pearl
Femoral Strategy: Bone loss from debridement, ETO, spacer subsidence. Type III defects common - need diaphyseal fixation. Type IIIA: extensively porous coated (need 4cm scratch fit for 90% success) or modular taper. Type IIIB: long modular taper (Wagner, Reclaim - good results), megaprosthesis (elderly, tumor-like), or APC (young, large defects). Cemented vs cementless debated - most prefer cementless (no biofilm). If cement needed: use antibiotic-loaded (1g vancomycin per 40g, NOT high-dose).
Instability Prevention - Dual Mobility
Dislocation Risk After Two-Stage: 10-15% (vs 2-3% primary THA)
Reasons for High Risk:
- Soft tissue damage from infection
- Abductor weakness (denervation, damage)
- Multiple surgeries (scar, contracture)
- Altered anatomy (bone loss, offset changes)
DUAL MOBILITY CUP - PREFERRED STRATEGY:
Advantages:
- Reduces dislocation from 10-15% to 2-3%
- Lower revision rate than constrained liner
- Allows larger effective head size (total travel 54-60mm)
- No risk of dissociation (unlike constrained)
- Preserves ROM
Disadvantages:
- Intraprosthetic dislocation (rare, under 1%)
- Polyethylene wear at dual articulations
- More expensive
Alternative Strategies:
-
Constrained Liner (for severe instability):
- 10° lipped or fully constrained
- Higher dissociation rate (5% at 5 years)
- Use for salvage, severe abductor deficiency
- Higher revision rate than dual mobility
-
Larger Femoral Head (if standard liner):
- 36mm or 40mm
- Increases jump distance
- Limited by liner thickness (fracture risk)
-
Optimize Offset:
- Lateralize acetabular component (eccentric reamer)
- High offset or lateralized femoral stem
- Tensions abductors
-
Adjust Leg Length:
- Slight lengthening (1-2cm) tensions soft tissues
- Avoid over 4cm (sciatic nerve palsy)
-
Meticulous Soft Tissue Repair:
- Posterior capsule reconstruction
- Short external rotators to trochanter
- May need abductor advancement if deficient
Testing Stability:
- Trial components
- Range of motion: flexion to 90°, internal rotation, adduction (Shuck test)
- Should resist dislocation with moderate force
- Ensure no impingement (neck-liner, bone-bone)
Exam Pearl
Instability Management: Dislocation rate 10-15% after two-stage (vs 2-3% primary) - soft tissue damage, abductor weakness, multiple surgeries. Prevention: DUAL MOBILITY cup PREFERRED (reduces to 2-3%, lower revision rate than constrained). Constrained liner for severe instability (collateral damage, salvage) but higher failure rate (5% dissociation at 5y). Larger head (36-40mm) helps if standard. Meticulous soft tissue repair essential. Extended hip precautions 12 weeks. Dual mobility BEST balance - protection with lower complications.
Final Implantation and Closure
If Trials Stable: Proceed with final components
Acetabular:
- Insert final cup (press-fit, multiple screws in safe zones)
- Insert final liner (dual mobility or constrained as planned)
Femoral:
- Insert final stem (press-fit or cemented)
- Ensure distal fixation adequate (bypass ETO by 10cm)
Reduction:
- Reduce hip - should be stable with moderate force required
- Recheck stability with Shuck test
If ETO Performed:
- Reduce trochanteric fragment anatomically
- Fix with 3 or more cerclage cables
- May add vertical cable or specialized ETO plate if unstable
- Ensure compression achieved
Soft Tissue Repair (METICULOUS):
- Repair posterior capsule (if tissue available)
- Repair short external rotators to trochanter (piriformis, gemelli, obturators)
- Ensure gluteus maximus closure
- Adequate soft tissue tension for stability
Final Lavage: Pulse lavage 3L saline
Closure:
- Close fascia lata with absorbable sutures
- Subcutaneous with absorbable sutures
- Skin (staples or subcuticular)
- Drains optional (closed suction if used, remove 24-48h)
INTRAOPERATIVE IV ANTIBIOTICS:
- Vancomycin 1g IV
- PLUS cefazolin 2g IV
- OR organism-specific (meropenem if resistant)
Final Implantation Risks
- ETO non-union (compromised bone from infection, need 3+ cables, protected WB)
- Abductor failure (inadequate repair, avulsion, denervation) - Trendelenburg, instability
- Dislocation early postop (inadequate soft tissue repair, patient non-compliance)
- Fracture from component insertion (press-fit in weak bone - have cables/plates ready)
- Screw penetration intrapelvic (vascular injury - know safe zones)
Stage 2 Postoperative Antibiotics
CONTROVERSIAL - NO CONSENSUS
Options:
-
No Additional Antibiotics:
- If Stage 2 cultures/frozen section negative
- AND Stage 1 organism treated adequately (6-12 weeks)
- Some evidence this is safe
-
6 Weeks Organism-Specific IV Antibiotics:
- If Stage 1 cultures were positive
- Even if Stage 2 negative
- Most common practice
- Same antibiotics as Stage 1
-
CHRONIC ORAL SUPPRESSION (indefinite):
- Some institutions advocate for ALL two-stage patients
- Options: Doxycycline 100mg PO BD, fluoroquinolone, or organism-specific
- Reduces reinfection from 10-20% to 5-10% (observational data)
- Balance benefit vs risk (C. diff, resistance, tendon rupture)
Most Evidence Supports:
- At least 6 weeks post-Stage 2 if original organism virulent (MRSA, Pseudomonas)
- Chronic suppression for high-risk (immunosuppressed, previous failures)
- Consult Infectious Disease
Monitoring:
- CRP/ESR every visit for minimum 2 years
- Then annually lifelong
- If CRP rises: investigate (X-ray, aspiration, consider PET/CT)
Exam Pearl
Postop Protocol: Post-Stage 2 antibiotics debated - no RCT evidence. Most give at least 6 weeks organism-specific if Stage 1 cultures positive. Some centers advocate CHRONIC SUPPRESSION (doxycycline 100mg BD indefinitely) - reduces reinfection from 10-20% to 5-10% in observational studies. Rifampicin for Staph if biofilm concern. Monitor CRP/ESR for 2 years minimum (recurrence can be late). Counsel patient: surveillance lifelong, dental prophylaxis debated but many recommend.
Postoperative Protocol
Hip Precautions: 6-12 weeks (strict, high dislocation risk)
- Avoid flexion over 90 degrees
- Avoid adduction across midline
- Avoid internal rotation
- Abduction brace for first 6 weeks if high risk
Weight-Bearing:
If ETO performed:
- Toe-touch or 20kg partial weight-bearing until union confirmed
- Serial X-rays at 2, 4, 6, 8 weeks
- Progress to full weight-bearing when union seen (usually 6-8 weeks)
If no ETO and stable cementless fixation:
- Weight-bearing as tolerated (WBAT) immediately
- Walker or crutches for comfort
If cemented:
Physiotherapy:
- Gentle ROM initially (within precautions)
- Progressive strengthening (especially abductors)
- Gait training
- Functional exercises
- Aim for normalized gait by 3-6 months
Occupational Therapy:
- ADL education (dressing, toileting, bathing)
- Hip precautions training
- Adaptive equipment (raised toilet seat, sock aid, reacher)
- Home safety assessment
Exam Pearl
Protocol: Hip precautions 6-12 weeks (high dislocation risk from soft tissue damage). If ETO: protected WB until union (6-8 weeks), then progress. If no ETO: WBAT immediately. Aggressive physio for abductor strengthening. Extended precautions compared to primary THA due to soft tissue damage and multiple surgeries.
Surveillance Protocol
Radiographs:
- 6 weeks post-Stage 2
- 3 months
- 6 months
- 12 months
- Then annually lifelong
Look for:
- Component loosening (radiolucent lines, migration)
- Osteolysis (bone loss around implants)
- ETO union (if performed)
- Fracture
- Heterotopic ossification
Inflammatory Markers:
- CRP and ESR at each visit for first 2 years
- Then annually lifelong
- If CRP rises above 10 or ESR above 30: investigate
If Elevated Markers:
- X-ray (loosening, osteolysis)
- Hip aspiration (cell count, culture)
- Consider advanced imaging:
- PET/CT: 95% sensitivity for infection
- MRI with metal artifact reduction (MARS)
- Bone scan + WBC scan
Clinical Assessment:
- Pain (location, character, functional limitation)
- Function (walking distance, stairs, ADLs)
- ROM
- Gait (Trendelenburg, antalgic)
- Leg length discrepancy
- Patient satisfaction
Recurrent Infection Signs
- Rising CRP/ESR (most sensitive)
- Persistent pain (especially start-up pain)
- Drainage from wound (late sinus tract)
- Fever, systemic symptoms (rare unless acute)
- Component loosening on X-ray (late sign)
- High index of suspicion - aspirate if doubt
Outcomes and Patient Counseling
Infection Eradication: 85-90% at 2 years
BUT Higher Complications than Primary THA:
Reinfection:
- 10-20% at 2 years
- Can occur 5-10+ years later (late hematogenous seeding or dormant biofilm)
- Same organism (residual biofilm) or new organism (hematogenous)
Dislocation:
- 10-15% (vs 2-3% primary THA)
- Even with dual mobility: 2-3%
- Soft tissue damage, abductor weakness
Aseptic Loosening:
- 10-15% at 10 years (vs 5% primary THA)
- Bone quality compromised by debridement
- Stress shielding from long stems
ETO Non-Union:
- 5-10% (higher with persistent infection)
- Causes pain, Trendelenburg gait
- May require ORIF if symptomatic
Chronic Pain:
- 15-20% report persistent pain
- Multifactorial (muscle damage, nerve injury, bone loss, multiple surgeries)
- Requires multimodal management
Leg Length Discrepancy:
- Common (bone loss, altered anatomy)
- Accept under 2cm if stable
- Shoe lift if symptomatic
Patient Satisfaction:
- LOWER than primary THA
- Despite infection eradication, function compromised
- Set realistic expectations pre-operatively
Dental Prophylaxis:
- Debated in literature
- Many surgeons recommend lifelong antibiotics before dental procedures
- Australian guidelines: consider for first 2 years or indefinitely if high risk
Counsel Patients:
- Not as good as primary THA (higher complications, lower satisfaction)
- Lifelong surveillance required (CRP/ESR, X-rays)
- Recurrence can occur years later
- May need further surgery (revision for loosening, dislocation, reinfection)
- Salvage options if fails (Girdlestone, arthrodesis, amputation)
Exam Pearl
Outcomes: Two-stage revision achieves infection eradication 85-90%, BUT higher dislocation (10-15% vs 2-3% primary), higher loosening (10-15% at 10y vs 5% primary), reinfection 10-20% at 2y, patient satisfaction lower. Long-term surveillance ESSENTIAL - CRP/ESR every visit first 2 years. Recurrence can occur 5-10+ years later (late hematogenous or dormant biofilm). Counsel realistic expectations - NOT as good as primary THA. Salvage options if fails.
Salvage Procedures if Two-Stage Fails
Repeat Two-Stage Revision:
- If young, good bone stock, first failure
- Success rate 60-70% (lower than first two-stage)
- Higher morbidity
Chronic Antibiotic Suppression:
- Indefinite oral antibiotics
- Doxycycline 100mg BD or fluoroquinolone
- Accept infected implant, suppress symptoms
- For elderly, poor surgical candidates
- Requires lifelong compliance
Girdlestone Procedure (Excision Arthroplasty):
- Remove ALL implants, cement, infected tissue
- Leave as pseudarthrosis
- Antibiotic spacer or antibiotic beads short-term, then remove
- Pain relief 60-70%
- Major limb shortening (3-5cm)
- Requires walker or crutches lifelong
- Poor function but infection controlled
- For elderly, low demand, poor surgical candidates
Arthrodesis (Hip Fusion):
- Fuse hip in optimal position (25° flexion, 0° abduction, 0° rotation)
- Requires good bone stock
- Infection eradication excellent (over 95%)
- Pain relief excellent
- But loss of ROM, gait abnormalities, back pain (compensatory)
- Difficult to convert to THA later
- For young, active, failed multiple revisions
Amputation:
- Last resort
- For life-threatening sepsis not controlled with debridement
- For non-functional painful limb after multiple failures
- Rare (under 1% of PJI cases)
Exam Pearl
Salvage Hierarchy: If two-stage fails - (1) Repeat two-stage if young, good bone, first failure (60-70% success), (2) Chronic suppression if elderly, poor surgical candidate (doxycycline indefinitely), (3) Girdlestone if low demand, cannot tolerate surgery (pain relief 60-70%, poor function, walker lifelong), (4) Arthrodesis if young, active, failed multiple (excellent infection control and pain relief, but loss ROM and back pain), (5) Amputation for life-threatening sepsis or non-functional limb (rare, under 1%).