Evidence brief
Multicenter ACL Revision Study (MARS) Group Outcomes
Revision ACL has worse outcomes than primary
Meniscal status at revision critical for outcome
Allograft higher failure rate than autograft in revision
Tunnel position assessment essential
Staging may be necessary for bone loss
MARS data guides revision ACL surgery planning. Graft choice (autograft preferred), tunnel assessment, and meniscal status are key determinants of revision success.
For revision ACL viva: Know failure modes (technical, biological, traumatic). Assess tunnels (CT scan), alignment, previous graft. MARS shows autograft superior for revision. Discuss staging for tunnel bone loss.
Level II
Lesser quality RCT or prospective comparative study