Pediatric Elbow | Avulsion Fracture | Elbow Dislocation | Fragment Entrapment | ORIF Indications
- Ossification order CRITOL: Capitellum, Radial head, Internal (medial) epicondyle, Trochlea, Olecranon, Lateral (external) epicondyle
- Association with elbow dislocation: 50% of medial epicondyle fractures occur with elbow dislocation - fragment may become entrapped in joint
- Ulnar nerve at risk: Runs posterior to medial epicondyle - 10-16% ulnar nerve symptoms
- Surgery indications: Intra-articular fragment, greater than 5mm displacement (relative, absolute controversial), high-level throwing athlete, ulnar nerve dysfunction
- “Compare to contralateral elbow - medial epicondyle appears at age 5-7, fuses at 15-17
- “If trochlea visible but NO medial epicondyle seen, it is entrapped in joint
- “Stress X-rays may show valgus instability from avulsed UCL origin
- “Always assess ulnar nerve function pre-operatively
Elbow ossification sequence: Capitellum (1yr), Radial head (3yr), Internal (medial) epicondyle (5yr), Trochlea (7yr), Olecranon (9yr), Lateral epicondyle (11yr). If trochlea is present but medial epicondyle is not visible, the fragment is INCARCERATED IN THE JOINT.
15-18% of medial epicondyle fractures have fragment entrapment. Associated with elbow dislocation when joint reduces. Look for fragment in ulnohumeral joint space on AP X-ray. Often at posteromedial aspect. Incarcerated fragment = mandatory ORIF.
Ulnar nerve runs posterior to medial epicondyle. 10-16% have ulnar nerve symptoms at presentation. Assess intrinsic function (first dorsal interosseous, little finger abduction) and sensation (ulnar 1.5 digits). Nerve commonly subluxates over epicondyle in throwing athletes.
Absolute: Incarcerated fragment, open fracture. Relative: Displacement greater than 5mm (controversial), high-level throwing athlete, ulnar nerve dysfunction, valgus instability. Many advocate for conservative treatment up to 10-15mm displacement with good outcomes.
- Conservative
- Less than 5mm
- Consider ORIF
- 5-10mm
- Mandatory ORIF
- Incarcerated
- Conservative
- Congruent
- Consider ORIF
- Congruent
- Mandatory ORIF
- Fragment in joint
- Conservative
- Non-throwing athlete
- Consider ORIF
- High-level thrower
- Mandatory ORIF
- Any
- Conservative
- Normal
- Consider ORIF
- Symptoms
- Mandatory ORIF
- Dysfunction
- Conservative
- Splint 1-2 weeks, early ROM
- Consider ORIF
- ORIF with screw or K-wires
- Mandatory ORIF
- Extraction + ORIF
CRITOLCRITOL - Elbow Ossification Order
Hook:CRITOL: Capitellum 1, Radial head 3, Internal epicondyle 5, Trochlea 7, Olecranon 9, Lateral epi 11 (odd years 1-3-5-7-9-11).
TRAPTRAP - Fragment Incarceration Signs
Hook:Don't fall into the TRAP - look for the incarcerated fragment!
MISSX-ray Signs of Incarceration
Hook:Don't MISS the incarcerated fragment!
Overview and Epidemiology
Medial epicondyle fractures are avulsion injuries occurring through the apophysis of the medial epicondyle. The flexor-pronator mass and ulnar collateral ligament (UCL) originate here, and traction through these structures causes the avulsion during falls or throwing.
Epidemiology:
- Peak incidence 9-14 years (during apophyseal stage before fusion)
- More common in males (75%)
- 11-20% of pediatric elbow fractures
- 50% associated with elbow dislocation
- Common in throwing sports (baseball, cricket, javelin)
Two mechanisms: (1) Direct valgus stress to extended elbow with sudden muscle contraction (throwing). (2) Elbow dislocation - posterolateral force avulses epicondyle via UCL and flexor-pronator traction. During reduction of dislocation, the fragment may become trapped in the joint.
Pathophysiology and Mechanisms
Medial Epicondyle Anatomy
- Attachment/Course
- Originates from medial epicondyle
- Clinical Relevance
- Traction causes avulsion fracture
- Attachment/Course
- Originates from medial epicondyle
- Clinical Relevance
- Valgus stability, thrower's elbow
- Attachment/Course
- Posterior to medial epicondyle in cubital tunnel
- Clinical Relevance
- At risk in fracture and surgery
- Attachment/Course
- Separate ossification center
- Clinical Relevance
- Appears age 5-7, fuses 15-17
Ossification Centers
- Capitellum: 1 year
- Radial head: 3 years
- Internal (medial) epicondyle: 5 years
- Trochlea: 7 years
- Olecranon: 9 years
- Lateral epicondyle: 11 years
- Ages are approximate; females earlier
- Medial epicondyle appears BEFORE trochlea
- If trochlea visible but no medial epicondyle → fragment is in joint (incarcerated)
- Always compare to contralateral elbow
- Fusion occurs 15-17 years
If you see trochlea ossification but cannot identify the medial epicondyle, it must be INCARCERATED IN THE JOINT. Per CRITOL, the medial epicondyle (I) appears before the trochlea (T). This is a common exam question and missed diagnosis.
The reason a medial epicondyle fracture is treated more aggressively in a thrower is its role in valgus stability. The restraint hierarchy at the elbow is:
- The anterior bundle of the ulnar (medial) collateral ligament is the PRIMARY static restraint to valgus stress - and it originates from the medial epicondyle, so a displaced or un-united avulsion effectively detaches the thrower's main valgus stabiliser.
- The radial head (radiocapitellar joint) is the most important SECONDARY valgus restraint - which is why radial head excision worsens valgus instability.
- The bony ulnohumeral articulation contributes mainly in full extension and full flexion, and the flexor-pronator mass (also originating from the medial epicondyle) is the principal DYNAMIC stabiliser.
Overhead throwing generates enormous valgus load in the late-cocking / early-acceleration phase, repeatedly stressing exactly this medial column. That is why restoring the medial epicondyle (UCL plus flexor-pronator origin) anatomically is argued to matter most in the elite thrower, and why persistent medial pain after the fracture has healed should raise suspicion of UCL insufficiency.
Classification Systems
Classification by Displacement
There is no universally accepted classification. Commonly described by displacement:
- Displacement
- Minimally displaced (less than 5mm)
- Management Tendency
- Conservative
- Displacement
- Moderately displaced (5-10mm)
- Management Tendency
- Controversial - varies by patient factors
- Displacement
- Severely displaced (greater than 10mm)
- Management Tendency
- Often surgical, but some advocate conservative
- Displacement
- Incarcerated in joint
- Management Tendency
- Mandatory ORIF
Note: The 5mm threshold has been historically used for surgical decision-making but is increasingly controversial. Many centers report good outcomes with conservative treatment up to 10-15mm.
Clinical Assessment
Systematic Examination
- Mechanism: Fall on outstretched hand, elbow dislocation event, throwing injury
- Immediate symptoms: Pain, swelling, inability to flex wrist/fingers
- Sport involvement: Level of throwing activity (baseball, cricket)
- Hand dominance: Affects treatment decisions
- Swelling: Medial elbow
- Ecchymosis: Medial soft tissues
- Deformity: If associated dislocation
- Open wound: Exclude open fracture
- Medial epicondyle tenderness: Point tenderness over avulsed fragment
- Gap or defect: May feel defect if displaced
- Crepitus: Avoid excessive manipulation
- ULNAR NERVE - Critical!
- Motor: First dorsal interosseous (finger abduction), hypothenar
- Sensory: Little finger and ulnar half of ring finger
- Document function BEFORE any intervention
- Also assess median and radial nerve
- Vascular: Pulse, capillary refill, color
Always document ulnar nerve function pre-operatively. The nerve lies immediately posterior to the medial epicondyle. 10-16% have ulnar nerve symptoms at presentation. Post-operative neuropraxia may be iatrogenic or from the injury - baseline documentation is medicolegally important.
Differential Diagnosis
The medial-sided paediatric elbow injury that most often catches candidates out is the incarcerated fragment masquerading as a "reduced" dislocation. Systematically exclude the look-alikes below.
- Discriminating Features
- Apophyseal age 9-14, valgus or dislocation mechanism, medial point tenderness
- Key Pitfall / Distinguisher
- Apply CRITOL - confirm the epicondyle is in its normal position, not the joint
- Discriminating Features
- Block to motion, widened ulnohumeral space, 'missing' epicondyle with trochlea visible
- Key Pitfall / Distinguisher
- Easily missed on the post-reduction film - mandatory ORIF if present
- Discriminating Features
- Lateral tenderness, Salter-Harris IV pattern, high nonunion if missed
- Key Pitfall / Distinguisher
- Intra-articular and often needs fixation - different limb side, different risk profile
- Discriminating Features
- Under 3 years, whole epiphysis displaced, often non-accidental
- Key Pitfall / Distinguisher
- Capitellum/radius maintain alignment with each other but not the humerus; consider safeguarding
- Discriminating Features
- Asymptomatic, smooth corticated margin, symmetrical with other side
- Key Pitfall / Distinguisher
- Compare to the contralateral elbow before calling a fracture
- Discriminating Features
- Chronic throwing pain, widened/fragmented apophysis without acute avulsion
- Key Pitfall / Distinguisher
- Overuse, not acute trauma - managed with rest and activity modification
The acute avulsion sits at one end of a spectrum; the chronic end is "Little League elbow" - medial epicondyle apophysitis, a traction (overuse) injury of the same apophysis in the skeletally immature thrower. Instead of a single avulsing event, repetitive valgus tension produces apophysitis with widening, sclerosis or fragmentation of the medial epicondyle apophysis (compare with the asymptomatic contralateral side), gradual-onset medial elbow pain, and reduced throwing velocity/distance - without an acute fracture line. It can progress to a frank avulsion if throwing continues.
Management is overwhelmingly non-operative: relative rest from throwing, correction of pitching mechanics, and a graduated interval throwing programme - with the key preventive lever being pitch-count and rest-day limits (USA Baseball / Little League guidelines cap pitches per game and mandate rest days by age). Surgery is reserved for an associated displaced avulsion or a symptomatic non-union. The examinable contrast: chronic apophysitis = rest and prevention; acute displaced/incarcerated avulsion = (often) fixation.
Investigations
Clinical Imaging


Elbow X-rays in two planes are usually sufficient. Always compare to the contralateral side in children, especially if ossification status is uncertain. If the medial epicondyle is not in its normal position, look for it in the joint.
- When Used
- All suspected fractures
- What to Look For
- Fragment position, joint congruity, incarceration
- When Used
- Uncertainty about ossification
- What to Look For
- Normal appearance of contralateral elbow
- When Used
- Further characterization
- What to Look For
- Fragment position, articular involvement
- When Used
- Chronic/old injury, instability assessment
- What to Look For
- Widening of medial joint space (UCL laxity)
- When Used
- Complex injury, fragment localization
- What to Look For
- Precise fragment position if uncertain on X-ray
- When Used
- Chronic valgus instability, UCL injury
- What to Look For
- UCL integrity, soft tissue injury
Key Radiographic Signs of Incarceration:
- Widening of ulnohumeral joint space on AP
- Ossific density in the joint space (look carefully)
- Medial epicondyle ossification center not in normal position
- Use CRITOL - if trochlea is visible, medial epicondyle should be too
Management Algorithm
Non-Operative Management
- Minimally displaced fractures (less than 5mm)
- No fragment incarceration
- Non-throwing athlete or low-demand patient
- Intact ulnar nerve function
- Joint congruent
- Above-elbow splint or cast with elbow at 90°, forearm neutral
- Duration: 1-2 weeks immobilization
- Then begin progressive ROM exercises
- Avoid valgus stress for 6 weeks
- Return to throwing: 8-12 weeks, gradual progression
- Good functional outcomes in most cases
- Fibrous union common (not bony) but this is functionally acceptable
- Low rates of symptomatic non-union
Even up to 10-15mm displacement, some centers report excellent outcomes with conservative treatment.
Surgical Technique
ORIF with Cannulated Screw
Standard technique for pediatric medial epicondyle fractures with adequate fragment size.
Surgical Steps
- Supine with arm on arm board
- Shoulder externally rotated, elbow flexed
- Tourniquet on upper arm (optional)
- Medial incision centered over epicondyle
- Careful dissection - identify and protect ulnar nerve
- Ulnar nerve usually left in situ unless subluxating
- If incarcerated: extract fragment from joint before reduction
- Reduce fragment anatomically to epicondyle bed
- Hold with reduction clamp or K-wire
- Place guide wire for cannulated screw (4.0 or 4.5mm)
- Measure and insert partially threaded screw
- Achieve compression but avoid over-compression
- Alternatively, use two divergent K-wires
- Check reduction and fixation with imaging
- Test elbow ROM - no mechanical block
- Verify ulnar nerve function if able
Technical Points:
- Screw should be parallel or slightly posterior to avoid articular surface
- Partially threaded screw for compression
- Washer optional if bone is soft
- K-wires may be preferred in younger children or small fragments
Ulnar nerve transposition is rarely needed but may be done if nerve is subluxating or injured.
INVUSurgical Indications
Hook:INVU = I eNVU fixing these - clear surgical indications!
Complications
- Incidence
- 10-16% (injury-related or iatrogenic)
- Prevention/Management
- Careful identification, consider transposition if at risk
- Incidence
- Variable - often asymptomatic
- Prevention/Management
- Fibrous union usually functional; ORIF for symptoms
- Incidence
- Common, usually mild
- Prevention/Management
- Early ROM, physical therapy
- Incidence
- Rare if healed
- Prevention/Management
- ORIF in throwing athletes to restore UCL origin
- Incidence
- Potentially serious
- Prevention/Management
- Apply CRITOL, comparison X-rays, high index of suspicion
- Incidence
- If screws used
- Prevention/Management
- May need removal after healing
Fibrous union is common (up to 50%) and usually asymptomatic. The flexor-pronator mass and UCL origin function well despite lack of bony union. Symptomatic non-union causing pain or instability is rare and may require late ORIF or excision with soft tissue repair.
Postoperative Care and Rehabilitation
Post-ORIF Protocol
- Posterior splint with elbow at 90°
- Gentle finger and wrist ROM
- Wound care
- Sling for comfort
- Remove splint, begin elbow ROM
- Active-assisted flexion/extension
- Avoid valgus stress
- Progress as tolerated
- Aim for full ROM
- Begin light strengthening
- Continue avoiding valgus stress
- May remove K-wires at 4-6 weeks if used
- Progressive resistance exercises
- Sport-specific conditioning
- Gradual return to non-throwing activities
- Begin graduated throwing program
- Interval throwing protocol
- Full return when painless and full strength
Conservative Treatment Rehabilitation:
- Shorter immobilization (1-2 weeks)
- Earlier ROM initiation
- Progress as tolerated
- Avoid valgus stress for 6 weeks
Outcomes
- Excellent functional outcomes in most cases
- Fibrous union common but usually asymptomatic
- May have slight loss of extension (usually not clinically significant)
- Return to sport in 6-12 weeks
- Anatomic union achieved
- Similar long-term outcomes to conservative in many studies
- May be preferred for high-level throwing athletes
- Hardware removal occasionally needed
- Most patients return to full activity
- Late valgus instability rare
- Osteoarthritic changes uncommon
Guidelines, Registries & Global Practice
Global Epidemiology:
- Medial epicondyle fractures account for approximately 11-20% of paediatric elbow fractures (about 12% in contemporary series), making them the third most common after supracondylar and lateral condyle fractures
- Peak incidence 9-14 years; male predominance (roughly 3:1); rare after physeal fusion (15-17 years)
- Up to 50% occur with elbow dislocation; intra-articular incarceration in roughly 15-18% of fractures
- Sport-related avulsions cluster in overhead/valgus-loading activities - baseball pitching, cricket bowling, javelin, gymnastics, and wrestling - while trampoline and fall mechanisms predominate in younger children
- Position on Displaced Isolated Fractures
- Incarceration and open injury are absolute operative indications; fixation increasingly favoured in adolescent throwing athletes
- Notes
- Driven by return-to-sport literature (Lawrence 2013)
- Position on Displaced Isolated Fractures
- Non-operative care for most minimally and moderately displaced isolated fractures; surgery for incarceration, instability or open injury
- Notes
- Emphasis on shared decision-making and accepting fibrous union
- Position on Displaced Isolated Fractures
- Anatomic reduction and stable fixation when surgery is indicated; cannulated screw in older children, smooth K-wires in younger/small fragments
- Notes
- Technique-focused rather than threshold-focused
- Position on Displaced Isolated Fractures
- Recognises the unreliability of the historical 5mm threshold; individualised decision weighting instability and demand
- Notes
- Supports CT for borderline displacement
- Medial epicondyle fractures are not implant-survivorship procedures, so they do not feature in arthroplasty registries (NJR, AJRR, AOANJRR, SHAR). Evidence therefore comes from institutional cohorts and reviews rather than national registries
- Across these cohorts the consistent signal is functional equivalence of operative and non-operative care for most fractures, with surgery reserved for incarceration, instability, open injury and selected athletes
- High-resource settings: ready CT for borderline displacement, cannulated-screw fixation, intra-operative fluoroscopy, and structured throwing-return programmes
- Limited-resource settings: greater reliance on plain radiographs and closed/cast management; K-wire fixation favoured over screws on cost grounds; the strong evidence that casting yields good long-term function (even with nonunion) makes non-operative care a defensible default where imaging and theatre access are constrained
- Universal non-negotiables regardless of setting: never miss an incarcerated fragment, always document ulnar nerve function before intervention, and reduce-and-fix open injuries urgently
Controversies & Areas of Uncertainty
This is one of the most contested fractures in paediatric orthopaedics. A strong viva answer names the controversy, states what the evidence does and does not show, and lands on a defensible, individualised position.
Surgeons cannot measure displacement reproducibly on plain films (Pappas 2010: greater than 2mm disagreement 54% of the time on AP, 87% on lateral). A fixed millimetre rule is therefore built on an unreliable number. Standardised methods and CT improve reliability but radiograph-CT discrepancy can still reach 5-6mm (Guzek 2022).
Long-term and propensity-matched data (Farsetti 2001; Axibal 2020) show equivalent function for most isolated fractures despite frequent radiographic nonunion after casting. Surgery buys bony union and stability, not necessarily a better functional result.
The historical argument for fixing the UCL origin in throwers is biomechanically intuitive, but athletes return to sport at high rates with either treatment (Lawrence 2013; Axibal 2020). Reasonable surgeons fix the elite thrower with instability or marked displacement; reflex surgery for every athlete is not evidence-based.
Fibrous nonunion is the rule after casting (Farsetti 2001) yet rarely causes symptoms or valgus instability. Radiographic nonunion should not be equated with treatment failure; the relevant endpoints are pain, stability and function.
MCQ Practice Points
Q: In what order do the elbow ossification centers appear? A: CRITOL - Capitellum (1yr), Radial head (3yr), Internal (medial) epicondyle (5yr), Trochlea (7yr), Olecranon (9yr), Lateral epicondyle (11yr).
Q: How can you identify an incarcerated medial epicondyle fragment on X-ray? A: If the trochlea is visible but the medial epicondyle is NOT seen in its normal position (per CRITOL, medial epicondyle ossifies before trochlea), the fragment is incarcerated in the joint.
Q: Which nerve is at risk in medial epicondyle fractures? A: The ulnar nerve. It runs posterior to the medial epicondyle in the cubital tunnel. 10-16% have ulnar nerve symptoms at presentation.
Q: What is an absolute indication for surgery in medial epicondyle fractures? A: Incarcerated fragment in the joint. Also, open fracture.
Medicolegal Considerations
- Pre-operative ulnar nerve examination (critical)
- Radiographic assessment including comparison views
- Discussion of treatment options and shared decision-making
- For athletes: discussion of risks/benefits for throwing
- Risk of ulnar nerve injury (pre-existing vs iatrogenic)
- Non-union (rare with fixation)
- Stiffness
- Hardware removal
- For athletes: timeline for return, no guarantee of return to prior level
The most important medicolegal point is documenting ulnar nerve function BEFORE any intervention. If the patient has post-operative ulnar symptoms and there is no baseline documentation, it is difficult to establish whether the injury was pre-existing or iatrogenic.
SPORTSPORT - Surgery Considerations
Hook:SPORT injuries in young athletes need careful assessment for surgical indications.
Clinical Decision Scenarios
Practise clinical reasoning and management decisions out loud
“A 12-year-old boy fell from a trampoline onto his outstretched left arm. X-rays show a 3mm displaced medial epicondyle fracture. The elbow is congruent and ulnar nerve function is intact.”
“An 11-year-old girl had an elbow dislocation reduced in the emergency department. Post-reduction X-ray shows a congruent elbow but the 'medial epicondyle' appears smaller than expected and there is a bony density in the ulnohumeral joint space.”
“A 14-year-old elite baseball pitcher presents with medial elbow pain after a throwing injury. X-rays show an 8mm displaced medial epicondyle fracture. The joint is congruent and ulnar nerve is intact.”
CRITOL Sequence
- Capitellum 1yr
- Radial head 3yr
- Internal (medial) epicondyle 5yr
- Trochlea 7yr
- Olecranon 9yr
- Lateral epicondyle 11yr
Key Associations
- 50% with elbow dislocation
- 15-18% fragment incarceration
- 10-16% ulnar nerve symptoms
- Flexor-pronator and UCL origin
Incarceration Detection
- Trochlea visible, epicondyle missing = in joint
- Bony density in ulnohumeral joint space
- Post-dislocation reduction - check carefully
- Mandates ORIF
Treatment Thresholds
- Less than 5mm: Conservative
- 5-10mm: Controversial, consider patient factors
- Incarcerated: Mandatory surgery
- Elite thrower: Lower threshold for ORIF
Critical Actions
- Document ulnar nerve function pre-op
- Compare to contralateral elbow
- Look for fragment in joint on post-reduction films
- Protect ulnar nerve during surgery
Evidence Base
The evidence base is dominated by retrospective series and a small number of comparative cohorts; there are no randomised trials. Two themes recur across the literature: (1) measurement of displacement on plain radiographs is unreliable, undermining the historical "5 mm rule", and (2) functional outcomes after operative and non-operative treatment are broadly similar for most fractures, with surgery reserved for intra-articular incarceration, gross instability, and selected high-demand athletes.
Farsetti 2001 - Landmark Long-Term Comparison (Cast vs ORIF vs Excision)
- 42 isolated fractures displaced greater than 5mm, reviewed at a mean of 45 years (range 30-61) after injury
- Cast without reduction (n=19): 16 good, 3 fair - nonunion in all but 2, yet all had a stable elbow on valgus stress
- ORIF with K-wire or T-nail (n=17): 15 good, 2 fair - bony union but similar function to casting
- Fragment excision (n=6): 4 poor, 2 fair - chronic pain, ulnar paraesthesiae, instability
Fowles 1990 - Elbow Dislocation with Epicondyle Avulsion / Incarceration
- 28 children with elbow dislocation plus medial epicondyle avulsion followed after closed reduction
- 19 with satisfactory closed reduction treated in plaster: 11 normal elbows, 8 lost a mean 15 degrees flexion
- 6 of the 9 operated children had intra-articular entrapment; 5 had ulnar nerve contusion/compression
- Operated group lost a mean 37 degrees flexion - reflecting selection of the most severe injuries