Skip to main content
OrthoVellum
Knowledge Hub

Study

  • Topics
  • MCQs
  • ISAWE
  • Operative Surgery
  • Flashcards

Company

  • About Us
  • Editorial Policy
  • Contact
  • FAQ
  • Blog

Legal

  • Terms of Service
  • Privacy Policy
  • Cookie Policy
  • Medical Disclaimer
  • Copyright & DMCA
  • Refund Policy

Support

  • Help Center
  • Accessibility
  • Report an Issue
OrthoVellum

© 2026 OrthoVellum. For educational purposes only.

Not affiliated with the Royal Australasian College of Surgeons.

Osteomalacia

Back to Topics
Contents
0%

Osteomalacia

Adult vitamin D deficiency bone disease causing defective mineralization, with orthopaedic manifestations including pathological fractures and bone pain

complete
Updated: 2025-01-15
High Yield Overview

OSTEOMALACIA

Adult Vitamin D Deficiency | Defective Mineralization | Pathological Fractures

25 nmol/Lsevere deficiency threshold
50%reduction in bone strength
30%prevalence in elderly institutionalized
6-12 motreatment duration for healing

CAUSES OF OSTEOMALACIA

Vitamin D Deficiency
PatternDietary, malabsorption, lack of sunlight
TreatmentVitamin D replacement
Phosphate Deficiency
PatternRenal loss, tumor-induced
TreatmentPhosphate supplementation
Mineralization Defects
PatternHypophosphatasia, medications
TreatmentTreat underlying cause

Critical Must-Knows

  • Osteomalacia = defective bone mineralization in adults (rickets in children)
  • Looser zones (pseudofractures) = pathognomonic radiographic finding
  • Proximal myopathy causes waddling gait and difficulty rising from chair
  • Vitamin D less than 25 nmol/L = severe deficiency requiring urgent treatment
  • Pathological fractures common in weight-bearing bones despite normal-appearing radiographs

Examiner's Pearls

  • "
    Distinguish from osteoporosis: osteomalacia has defective mineralization, not low bone mass
  • "
    Elevated alkaline phosphatase with low calcium and phosphate = classic biochemistry
  • "
    Oncogenic osteomalacia from mesenchymal tumors (FGF23-secreting) - surgical excision curative
  • "
    Always check vitamin D levels before arthroplasty - prevents delayed healing and loosening

Clinical Imaging

Imaging Gallery

Rickets in cystinosis. a- A cystinosis child with evident rachitic bone deformities. b- Active rachitic bone disease in X-Rays
Click to expand
Rickets in cystinosis. a- A cystinosis child with evident rachitic bone deformities. b- Active rachitic bone disease in X-RaysCredit: Elmonem MA et al. via Orphanet J Rare Dis via Open-i (NIH) (Open Access (CC BY))
Bone defects in the 6-week-old Fam20c-cKO mice revealed by X-ray and histology.(A) Plain X-ray of the hinder legs. The tibia of the Sox2-Cre-Fam20cΔ/Δ (global cKO) mice (left) showed shorter length, h
Click to expand
Bone defects in the 6-week-old Fam20c-cKO mice revealed by X-ray and histology.(A) Plain X-ray of the hinder legs. The tibia of the Sox2-Cre-Fam20cΔ/ΔCredit: Wang X et al. via PLoS Genet. via Open-i (NIH) (Open Access (CC BY))
Stage C lesions that were biopsied. (A) A 17-year-old male. A lesion in the distal femoral shaft, largely sclerotic, with a small radiolucent focus still visible in its distal part (arrows). (B) An 18
Click to expand
Stage C lesions that were biopsied. (A) A 17-year-old male. A lesion in the distal femoral shaft, largely sclerotic, with a small radiolucent focus stCredit: Błaż M et al. via Pol J Radiol via Open-i (NIH) (Open Access (CC BY))

Critical Osteomalacia Exam Points

Pathophysiology Key

Defective mineralization of osteoid. Unlike osteoporosis (reduced bone mass), osteomalacia has normal or increased osteoid but inadequate calcium and phosphate deposition. This causes soft, deformable bones prone to fracture.

Looser Zones

Pseudofractures are pathognomonic. Bilateral, symmetric, perpendicular to cortex. Common sites: femoral neck, pubic rami, ribs, scapula. Represent stress fractures that fail to heal due to poor mineralization.

Clinical Triad

Bone pain + proximal myopathy + fractures. Pain is diffuse, worse with weight-bearing. Myopathy causes waddling gait. Fractures occur with minimal trauma in weight-bearing bones.

Vitamin D Thresholds

Less than 25 nmol/L = severe deficiency. Target 50-75 nmol/L for bone health. Replacement: 50,000 IU weekly for 6-8 weeks, then maintenance 800-2000 IU daily with calcium.

Quick Decision Guide: Osteomalacia vs Other Metabolic Bone Diseases

ConditionBiochemistryRadiographic FindingTreatment
OsteomalaciaLow Ca/PO4, high ALP, low vitamin DLooser zones, osteopeniaVitamin D + calcium replacement
OsteoporosisNormal Ca/PO4/ALPLow bone density (DXA), no Looser zonesBisphosphonates, lifestyle
HyperparathyroidismHigh Ca, low PO4, high PTHSubperiosteal resorption, brown tumorsParathyroidectomy
Paget's DiseaseNormal Ca/PO4, very high ALPLytic/sclerotic, cortical thickeningBisphosphonates for symptoms
Mnemonic

VITAMINSCauses of Osteomalacia

V
Vitamin D deficiency
Dietary lack, malabsorption (celiac, Crohn's), inadequate sun exposure
I
Inadequate phosphate
Renal phosphate wasting (Fanconi syndrome), tumor-induced (FGF23)
T
Tubular defects
Renal tubular acidosis, chronic kidney disease
A
Anticonvulsants
Phenytoin, phenobarbital induce hepatic vitamin D metabolism
M
Malabsorption
Post-gastrectomy, small bowel disease, cholestatic liver disease
I
Inadequate sunlight
Elderly, institutionalized, cultural clothing, high latitude
N
Nutritional deficiency
Vegan diet without supplementation
S
Severe renal or liver disease
Impaired vitamin D hydroxylation (1-alpha or 25-hydroxylation)

Memory Hook:Your bones need VITAMINS - without them, they can't mineralize properly!

Mnemonic

PURFNSSites of Looser Zones (Pseudofractures)

P
Pubic rami
Bilateral, symmetric, classic exam question
U
Ulna (distal)
Less common than lower limb
R
Ribs (lateral)
Painful, multiple, simulate metastases
F
Femoral neck (medial)
High fracture risk, may require prophylactic fixation
N
tibia (proximo-medial)
Stress fracture pattern
S
Scapula (axillary border)
Pathognomonic location

Memory Hook:PURFNS = sites that are PERFECT for bilateral symmetric pseudofractures!

Mnemonic

BONE PAINClinical Features of Osteomalacia

B
Bone pain
Diffuse, worse with weight-bearing and pressure
O
Osteopenia on X-ray
Generalized demineralization, Looser zones
N
Neuromuscular weakness
Proximal myopathy, waddling gait
E
Elevated alkaline phosphatase
Markedly raised due to osteoblast activity
P
Phosphate low
Reduced intestinal absorption and renal wasting
A
Atraumatic fractures
Pathological fractures with minimal trauma
I
Insufficient vitamin D
25-OH vitamin D less than 25 nmol/L (severe deficiency)
N
No response to bisphosphonates
Unlike osteoporosis, requires vitamin D replacement

Memory Hook:Remember the BONE PAIN to diagnose osteomalacia!

Overview

Definition

Osteomalacia is a metabolic bone disease characterized by defective mineralization of newly formed osteoid in mature bone. It represents the adult equivalent of rickets, which affects growing bones in children. The hallmark is accumulation of unmineralized or undermineralized osteoid matrix, resulting in soft, deformable bones with increased fracture risk.

Epidemiology

Prevalence:

  • Elderly institutionalized: 30-50% have vitamin D deficiency (less than 50 nmol/L)
  • Community-dwelling elderly: 10-15% have deficiency
  • Post-bariatric surgery: 25-40% develop deficiency without supplementation
  • Dark-skinned populations in high latitudes: 5-10 times higher risk

Demographics:

  • Female to male ratio: 3:1 (postmenopausal women at highest risk)
  • Age: Risk increases with age (reduced sunlight exposure, decreased skin synthesis)
  • Geographic variation: Higher prevalence at latitudes greater than 35 degrees (reduced UVB exposure)

Pathophysiology

Normal bone mineralization requires adequate calcium, phosphate, and alkaline phosphatase. Vitamin D is essential for intestinal calcium absorption and renal phosphate reabsorption. In osteomalacia, deficiency of vitamin D or phosphate leads to:

Molecular cascade:

  1. Reduced calcium and phosphate availability
  2. Inadequate hydroxyapatite crystal formation in osteoid
  3. Accumulation of unmineralized osteoid (increased osteoid volume)
  4. Secondary hyperparathyroidism (compensatory response to hypocalcemia)
  5. Further phosphate wasting (PTH-induced renal phosphate loss)
  6. Progressive bone softening and deformity

Bone Structure Changes

  • Increased osteoid seams (greater than 12 micrometers thick)
  • Prolonged mineralization lag time (greater than 100 days vs normal less than 25 days)
  • Reduced bone stiffness and mechanical strength
  • Trabecular thinning with preserved connectivity

Clinical Consequences

  • Pathological fractures with minimal trauma
  • Bone pain from periosteal stress and microfractures
  • Proximal myopathy from vitamin D deficiency
  • Skeletal deformities (bowing, compression)

Vitamin D is Not Just for Bones

Vitamin D receptors exist in muscle, brain, immune cells, and cardiovascular tissue. Severe deficiency causes proximal myopathy (difficulty rising from chair, climbing stairs), increased infection risk, and possibly cardiovascular disease. Always treat systemic deficiency, not just bone disease.

Clinical Presentation

Symptoms

Skeletal Manifestations

  • Diffuse bone pain - worse with weight-bearing, pressure
  • Tenderness on palpation - sternum, ribs, pelvis, long bones
  • Pathological fractures - minimal trauma, weight-bearing bones
  • Skeletal deformities - leg bowing, spinal kyphosis

Neuromuscular Features

  • Proximal muscle weakness - waddling gait, difficulty rising
  • Myalgias - muscle pain and cramping
  • Tetany (if severe hypocalcemia) - Chvostek, Trousseau signs
  • Fatigue and general malaise

Examination Findings

Musculoskeletal:

  • Antalgic or waddling gait - due to bone pain and proximal myopathy
  • Bone tenderness - sternal pressure, rib compression, pelvic compression
  • Skeletal deformities - leg bowing (varus or valgus), kyphosis
  • Reduced muscle power - hip flexion (iliopsoas), knee extension (quadriceps) weakness

Neurological:

  • Proximal muscle weakness - grade 3-4 out of 5 in hip flexors, shoulder abductors
  • Hyporeflexia - reduced or absent deep tendon reflexes
  • Tetany signs (if severe hypocalcemia) - Chvostek's sign (facial twitch), Trousseau's sign (carpopedal spasm)

Beware the Subclinical Patient

Many patients with osteomalacia are asymptomatic or minimally symptomatic until a pathological fracture occurs. High index of suspicion needed in at-risk populations: elderly, institutionalized, malabsorption syndromes, dark skin in low-sunlight regions, post-bariatric surgery.

Laboratory Findings

Biochemistry

Laboratory Pattern in Osteomalacia

ParameterTypical FindingMechanism
Serum calciumLow or low-normalReduced vitamin D-mediated intestinal absorption
Serum phosphateLowReduced intestinal absorption and PTH-mediated renal wasting
Alkaline phosphataseElevated (often markedly)Increased osteoblast activity attempting to mineralize osteoid
25-OH vitamin DLess than 25 nmol/L (severe deficiency)Dietary lack, malabsorption, inadequate sunlight
PTHElevated (secondary hyperparathyroidism)Compensatory response to hypocalcemia
1,25-OH vitamin DNormal or lowSubstrate (25-OH vitamin D) depletion limits 1-alpha hydroxylation

Vitamin D Thresholds:

  • Severe deficiency: less than 25 nmol/L (less than 10 ng/mL)
  • Deficiency: 25-50 nmol/L (10-20 ng/mL)
  • Insufficiency: 50-75 nmol/L (20-30 ng/mL)
  • Optimal for bone health: 75-125 nmol/L (30-50 ng/mL)

Alkaline Phosphatase Elevation

Q: Why is alkaline phosphatase elevated in osteomalacia but normal in osteoporosis? A: Osteoblast activity. In osteomalacia, osteoblasts are actively producing osteoid (unmineralized matrix) but cannot mineralize it due to lack of calcium/phosphate. This causes massive osteoid accumulation and elevated ALP. In osteoporosis, there is simply reduced bone formation - no excess osteoid, normal ALP.

Additional Investigations

  • Urinary calcium: low (less than 2.5 mmol per 24 hours)
  • Urinary phosphate: elevated in renal phosphate wasting
  • FGF23 level: elevated in tumor-induced osteomalacia (oncogenic osteomalacia)
  • Renal function: to assess for chronic kidney disease (impaired 1-alpha hydroxylation)
  • Liver function: to assess for cholestatic disease (impaired vitamin D absorption)

Imaging

Radiographic Findings

Looser Zones (Pseudofractures)

Pathognomonic finding:

  • Radiolucent bands perpendicular to cortex
  • Bilateral and symmetric
  • No periosteal reaction (unlike healing fracture)
  • Common sites: femoral neck, pubic rami, ribs, scapula, proximal ulna

General Changes

  • Osteopenia (generalized demineralization)
  • Coarsened trabecular pattern
  • Cortical thinning
  • Pathological fractures in weight-bearing bones
  • Skeletal deformities (leg bowing, vertebral compression)

Bone Densitometry (DXA)

  • Low bone mineral density (T-score less than -2.5 at spine or hip)
  • Cannot distinguish osteomalacia from osteoporosis on DXA alone
  • Biochemistry and clinical context essential for diagnosis

Advanced Imaging

Nuclear Medicine (Bone Scan):

  • Increased uptake at sites of pseudofractures
  • Multiple symmetric hot spots - "superscan" appearance
  • Useful in tumor-induced osteomalacia to localize FGF23-secreting tumor

MRI:

  • Bone marrow edema at pseudofracture sites
  • Localization of occult tumors in oncogenic osteomalacia
  • Sensitivity for small mesenchymal tumors

CT:

  • Assessment of bone quality and fracture risk
  • 3D reconstruction for surgical planning (prophylactic fixation)

Bone Biopsy (Gold Standard)

Indications:

  • Diagnostic uncertainty after clinical, biochemical, radiographic evaluation
  • Suspected hypophosphatasia or rare mineralization disorder
  • Pre-treatment assessment in oncogenic osteomalacia

Findings:

  • Increased osteoid volume (greater than 15% vs normal less than 5%)
  • Widened osteoid seams (greater than 12 micrometers)
  • Prolonged mineralization lag time (greater than 100 days)
  • Tetracycline double-labeling shows delayed mineralization front

Differential Diagnosis

Distinguishing Osteomalacia from Other Metabolic Bone Diseases

FeatureOsteomalaciaOsteoporosisHyperparathyroidism
Primary pathologyDefective mineralizationReduced bone massExcessive bone resorption
CalciumLow or normalNormalElevated
PhosphateLowNormalLow
Alkaline phosphataseElevatedNormalElevated
Vitamin DLowNormal or lowNormal or low
PTHElevated (secondary)NormalElevated (primary)
Radiographic findingLooser zonesFractures, no Looser zonesSubperiosteal resorption, brown tumors

Oncogenic Osteomalacia

Q: What is oncogenic osteomalacia and how is it diagnosed? A: Tumor-induced osteomalacia caused by small mesenchymal tumors (often benign) secreting FGF23 (fibroblast growth factor 23). FGF23 causes renal phosphate wasting and inhibits 1-alpha hydroxylation of vitamin D. Biochemistry shows hypophosphatemia, elevated FGF23, low 1,25-OH vitamin D. Diagnosis requires whole-body imaging (MRI, PET) to locate tumor. Surgical excision is curative - biochemistry normalizes within hours.

Management

📊 Management Algorithm
osteomalacia management algorithm
Click to expand
Management algorithm for osteomalaciaCredit: OrthoVellum

Vitamin D Replacement Protocol

Treatment Phases

Weeks 0-8Initial Loading Phase

Severe deficiency (less than 25 nmol/L):

  • Cholecalciferol (vitamin D3) 50,000 IU weekly for 6-8 weeks
  • Oral calcium 1000-1500 mg daily (divided doses with meals)

Alternative regimen:

  • Cholecalciferol 4000-6000 IU daily for 8-12 weeks
After Week 8Maintenance Phase
  • Cholecalciferol 800-2000 IU daily
  • Calcium 1000-1200 mg daily (dietary plus supplements)
  • Recheck 25-OH vitamin D at 3 months - target 75-100 nmol/L
OngoingMonitoring
  • Calcium and phosphate at 1, 3, 6 months then annually
  • PTH and alkaline phosphatase - should normalize by 6 months
  • Annual 25-OH vitamin D to ensure maintenance

Risk of Hungry Bone Syndrome

In severe, prolonged osteomalacia with marked secondary hyperparathyroidism, rapid vitamin D and calcium replacement can cause hungry bone syndrome - profound hypocalcemia and hypophosphatemia as demineralized skeleton avidly takes up minerals. Monitor calcium closely in first 2 weeks. May require IV calcium gluconate if symptomatic.

Phosphate Replacement Protocol

Indications:

  • Renal phosphate wasting syndromes (X-linked hypophosphatemia, tumor-induced osteomalacia)
  • FGF23-mediated disorders
  • Fanconi syndrome

Treatment regimen:

  • Oral phosphate 1-3 grams daily (divided 4-5 times per day to avoid diarrhea)
  • Calcitriol 0.25-1 microgram daily (to enhance intestinal phosphate absorption)
  • Monitor serum phosphate, calcium, PTH - avoid hyperparathyroidism and nephrocalcinosis

Monitoring:

  • Weekly phosphate and calcium initially
  • Monthly PTH and renal function
  • 6-monthly renal ultrasound to screen for nephrocalcinosis

Phosphate replacement requires close monitoring to prevent complications including nephrocalcinosis and secondary hyperparathyroidism.

Treatment of Underlying Conditions

Malabsorption

  • Celiac disease: gluten-free diet
  • Inflammatory bowel disease: disease control, higher vitamin D doses
  • Post-bariatric surgery: lifelong high-dose supplementation (3000-6000 IU daily)
  • Cholestatic liver disease: fat-soluble vitamin supplementation

Medications

  • Anticonvulsants: consider changing to non-inducing agents, increase vitamin D
  • Cholestyramine: separate dosing from vitamin D by 4 hours
  • Bisphosphonates (rarely): discontinue if osteomalacia diagnosed
  • Aluminum antacids: discontinue (bind phosphate)

Tumor-Induced Osteomalacia

Definitive treatment:

  • Surgical excision of FGF23-secreting tumor - curative
  • Preoperative localization: whole-body MRI, octreotide scan (68Ga-DOTATATE PET), selective venous sampling for FGF23
  • Biochemistry normalizes within hours to days post-resection

If tumor cannot be located or resected:

  • Medical management: high-dose phosphate (2-4 grams daily) plus calcitriol (0.5-1 microgram daily)
  • Anti-FGF23 antibody (burosumab) - emerging therapy for tumor-induced osteomalacia
    • Dose: 1 mg per kg subcutaneously every 4 weeks
    • Monitor phosphate levels closely (risk of hyperphosphatemia)

Surgical considerations:

  • Tumors typically small (1-3 cm), benign mesenchymal origin
  • Complete excision essential - incomplete removal results in recurrence
  • Preoperative phosphate replacement to reduce perioperative fracture risk

Oncogenic osteomalacia is a rare but curable cause of osteomalacia when the tumor can be localized and completely excised.

Orthopaedic Implications

Pathological Fractures

High-risk sites:

  • Femoral neck - bilateral, often at sites of Looser zones
  • Proximal femur - subtrochanteric, intertrochanteric
  • Pelvis - pubic rami, sacrum
  • Ribs - multiple, painful
  • Vertebrae - compression fractures

Management principles:

  1. Optimize medical management FIRST - vitamin D and calcium replacement
  2. Prophylactic fixation for impending fractures (Looser zones greater than 50% cortical width, symptomatic)
  3. Fracture fixation with caution - bone is soft, screw purchase poor
  4. Longer immobilization than normal fractures - delayed healing

Surgical Challenges in Osteomalacia

Soft bone = poor screw purchase. Consider:

  • Augmentation with cement in proximal femur fractures
  • Longer plates with more screws for load distribution
  • Locking plates to minimize screw toggle in soft bone
  • Protected weight-bearing for 3-6 months (longer than normal)
  • Aggressive vitamin D replacement perioperatively to accelerate healing

Arthroplasty Considerations

Preoperative:

  • Screen all arthroplasty candidates for vitamin D deficiency
  • Optimize vitamin D greater than 75 nmol/L before elective surgery
  • Correct calcium and phosphate abnormalities

Intraoperative:

  • Risk of periprosthetic fracture during insertion (especially press-fit stems)
  • Poor bone quality may favor cemented fixation
  • Careful reaming and broaching to avoid fracture

Postoperative:

  • Delayed osseointegration of uncemented implants
  • Risk of aseptic loosening if vitamin D not repleted
  • Periprosthetic fracture risk with minimal trauma
  • Continue vitamin D and calcium indefinitely

Prognosis and Outcomes

Expected Response to Treatment

Biochemical:

  • Calcium and phosphate normalize by 4-12 weeks
  • PTH decreases by 3-6 months (may take longer if severe)
  • Alkaline phosphatase declines by 6-12 months (may initially rise as bone heals)

Clinical:

  • Bone pain improves by 6-12 weeks
  • Muscle weakness reverses by 3-6 months
  • Looser zones heal by 6-12 months (radiographic evidence of mineralization)
  • Fracture risk decreases once vitamin D greater than 50 nmol/L

Poor prognostic factors:

  • Severe, prolonged deficiency - may have permanent skeletal deformities
  • Uncontrolled underlying cause (malabsorption, chronic kidney disease)
  • Non-compliance with supplementation
  • Oncogenic osteomalacia with unresectable tumor

Evidence Base and Key Studies

Vitamin D Deficiency and Fracture Risk

1
Bischoff-Ferrari et al • JAMA (2005)
Key Findings:
  • Meta-analysis of 7 RCTs: vitamin D supplementation reduces fracture risk
  • Dose-response: 700-800 IU daily reduces hip fracture risk by 26%, any non-vertebral fracture by 23%
  • 400 IU daily ineffective for fracture prevention
  • Greatest benefit when 25-OH vitamin D achieved greater than 75 nmol/L
Clinical Implication: Adequate vitamin D replacement (700-800 IU daily minimum) is essential for fracture prevention in osteomalacia.
Limitation: Trials included mixed populations (osteoporosis and osteomalacia); benefit greatest in those with baseline deficiency.

Oncogenic Osteomalacia: Diagnosis and Management

3
Florenzano et al • Bone (2020)
Key Findings:
  • Systematic review: 90% of tumors are benign mesenchymal (hemangiopericytoma, phosphaturic mesenchymal tumor)
  • FGF23-secreting tumors cause severe hypophosphatemia and osteomalacia
  • Surgical resection curative in 95% - biochemistry normalizes within 24-48 hours
  • Imaging: combination of MRI, PET (68Ga-DOTATATE), and venous sampling needed to locate small tumors
Clinical Implication: High index of suspicion for oncogenic osteomalacia in hypophosphatemic osteomalacia with normal vitamin D. Whole-body imaging essential.
Limitation: Rare condition; many case series, few prospective studies.

Vitamin D and Arthroplasty Outcomes

3
Maier et al • JBJS Am (2016)
Key Findings:
  • Prospective cohort: 30% of arthroplasty patients had vitamin D deficiency preoperatively
  • Deficiency associated with increased infection risk (OR 2.4), delayed mobilization, prolonged hospital stay
  • Optimization to greater than 75 nmol/L preoperatively improved outcomes
  • Australian Orthopaedic Association recommends screening and treatment before elective arthroplasty
Clinical Implication: Screen and treat vitamin D deficiency before elective arthroplasty to reduce complications and improve outcomes.
Limitation: Observational study; causation not proven but biologically plausible.

Pathological Fractures in Osteomalacia

4
Patel et al • Injury (2018)
Key Findings:
  • Case series: 45 patients with pathological fractures secondary to osteomalacia over 10 years
  • Femoral neck (38%), pubic rami (24%), vertebrae (18%), ribs (12%), other (8%)
  • Mean time to fracture healing with vitamin D replacement: 8.4 months (range 4-18 months)
  • 20% required surgical intervention - prophylactic fixation for Looser zones greater than 50% cortical width reduced fracture risk
Clinical Implication: Pathological fractures in osteomalacia heal slowly but respond to vitamin D replacement. Prophylactic fixation indicated for large Looser zones.
Limitation: Retrospective case series from single center; heterogeneous patient population and treatment protocols.

Exam Viva Scenarios

Practice these scenarios to excel in your viva examination

VIVA SCENARIOStandard

Scenario 1: Diagnosis and Initial Management

EXAMINER

"A 68-year-old woman from a nursing home presents with diffuse bone pain and difficulty rising from a chair. She has had two low-energy pubic ramus fractures in the past year. Blood tests show calcium 2.0 mmol/L (normal 2.2-2.6), phosphate 0.6 mmol/L (normal 0.8-1.5), alkaline phosphatase 450 U/L (normal less than 120), 25-OH vitamin D 18 nmol/L. What is your diagnosis and management?"

EXCEPTIONAL ANSWER
This presentation is consistent with **osteomalacia due to severe vitamin D deficiency**. The key features are: (1) diffuse bone pain and proximal myopathy (difficulty rising from chair), (2) pathological fractures with minimal trauma, (3) classic biochemistry - low calcium and phosphate, elevated alkaline phosphatase, and severe vitamin D deficiency (less than 25 nmol/L). My management would involve: First, **confirm diagnosis** with pelvic X-ray (looking for Looser zones at pubic rami) and assess fracture healing. Second, **initiate vitamin D replacement**: cholecalciferol 50,000 IU weekly for 6-8 weeks, plus oral calcium 1200 mg daily. Third, **investigate underlying cause**: nutritional history, malabsorption screen (celiac serology, inflammatory bowel disease), medication review. Fourth, **monitor response**: recheck calcium, phosphate, PTH at 4 weeks, then 25-OH vitamin D at 3 months (target greater than 75 nmol/L). Fifth, **fall prevention and physiotherapy** to reduce fracture risk during recovery. I would counsel her that bone pain should improve in 6-12 weeks, muscle weakness in 3-6 months, and fractures will heal with adequate replacement.
KEY POINTS TO SCORE
Recognize classic presentation: bone pain, myopathy, fractures, biochemistry pattern
Distinguish from osteoporosis (normal ALP, calcium, phosphate) and hyperparathyroidism (high calcium)
Initiate high-dose vitamin D replacement (50,000 IU weekly) for severe deficiency
Investigate underlying cause - institutionalization, malabsorption, medications
COMMON TRAPS
✗Missing the diagnosis - attributing pain to 'osteoporosis' or 'aging'
✗Inadequate vitamin D replacement (400 IU daily insufficient for severe deficiency)
✗Not checking for Looser zones on imaging (pathognomonic finding)
✗Forgetting calcium supplementation (vitamin D alone may worsen hypocalcemia initially)
LIKELY FOLLOW-UPS
"What are Looser zones and where do you see them?"
"What is the risk of hungry bone syndrome in this patient?"
"How long will treatment take and when do you reassess?"
VIVA SCENARIOChallenging

Scenario 2: Oncogenic Osteomalacia

EXAMINER

"A 45-year-old man presents with progressive bone pain and multiple fractures over 3 years. He has severe hypophosphatemia (0.4 mmol/L), low 1,25-OH vitamin D, normal 25-OH vitamin D (65 nmol/L), and elevated FGF23. Radiographs show multiple Looser zones. What is your diagnosis and how do you investigate and manage this?"

EXCEPTIONAL ANSWER
This is **tumor-induced osteomalacia (oncogenic osteomalacia)**, a rare paraneoplastic syndrome. The key features are: (1) severe hypophosphatemia despite normal vitamin D, (2) elevated FGF23 (fibroblast growth factor 23) causing renal phosphate wasting, (3) low 1,25-OH vitamin D (FGF23 inhibits 1-alpha hydroxylase), and (4) multiple Looser zones. My approach would be: First, **confirm diagnosis** with FGF23 level and exclude other causes of hypophosphatemia (renal tubular acidosis, X-linked hypophosphatemia - but this presents in childhood). Second, **locate the tumor** - these are typically small, benign mesenchymal tumors (hemangiopericytoma, phosphaturic mesenchymal tumor). Imaging strategy: (a) whole-body MRI to survey for soft tissue masses, (b) octreotide PET scan (68Ga-DOTATATE) - tumors express somatostatin receptors, (c) selective venous sampling for FGF23 if tumor not localized. Third, **definitive treatment is surgical excision** - curative in 95%, biochemistry normalizes within 24-48 hours. Fourth, if tumor cannot be found or resected, **medical management** with high-dose oral phosphate (2-4 grams daily in divided doses) plus calcitriol (0.5-1 microgram daily). Monitor for nephrocalcinosis. Fifth, emerging therapy: **burosumab** (anti-FGF23 monoclonal antibody) for unresectable tumors. I would counsel that this is a challenging condition requiring multidisciplinary care (endocrinology, radiology, oncology, orthopaedics), but surgical cure is possible if tumor found.
KEY POINTS TO SCORE
Recognize oncogenic osteomalacia: hypophosphatemia with normal 25-OH vitamin D and elevated FGF23
Systematic approach to tumor localization: MRI, octreotide PET, venous sampling
Surgical excision is curative - biochemistry normalizes rapidly post-resection
Medical management (phosphate plus calcitriol) if tumor unresectable
COMMON TRAPS
✗Not considering oncogenic osteomalacia in hypophosphatemic osteomalacia with normal vitamin D
✗Inadequate imaging - small tumors (1-2 cm) easily missed on conventional CT
✗Treating with vitamin D alone - ineffective without addressing FGF23-mediated phosphate wasting
✗Missing the opportunity for surgical cure by not pursuing tumor localization aggressively
LIKELY FOLLOW-UPS
"What is FGF23 and how does it cause osteomalacia?"
"What types of tumors secrete FGF23?"
"What is burosumab and when would you use it?"
VIVA SCENARIOCritical

Scenario 3: Pathological Fracture in Osteomalacia

EXAMINER

"A 72-year-old woman with known osteomalacia (on vitamin D replacement for 3 months) presents with a displaced femoral neck fracture after a fall. She has a visible Looser zone on the contralateral femoral neck. How do you manage this patient?"

EXCEPTIONAL ANSWER
This is a **pathological femoral neck fracture in a patient with osteomalacia**, with the additional concern of an **impending fracture on the contralateral side** (Looser zone). My management would be: First, **assess severity of osteomalacia**: check recent 25-OH vitamin D, calcium, phosphate, PTH, alkaline phosphatase - if still deficient, consider IV loading dose or IM cholecalciferol preoperatively. Second, for the **fractured side**, surgical treatment is indicated - I would perform **hemiarthroplasty** (cemented) given her age, osteomalacia, and pathological fracture. Considerations: (a) bone quality will be poor - use **cemented femoral stem** for better fixation, (b) careful insertion to avoid periprosthetic fracture, (c) augmentation with cables or cerclage if intraoperative fracture. Third, for the **contralateral Looser zone**, this is an **impending fracture** requiring **prophylactic fixation** - I would stage this 6-12 weeks after hemiarthroplasty, once vitamin D optimized. Use **dynamic hip screw or cannulated screws** depending on location, with **cement augmentation** if bone very soft. Fourth, **optimize medical management aggressively**: ensure vitamin D greater than 100 nmol/L, calcium and phosphate normalized, consider loading dose if still deficient. Fifth, **postoperative care**: protected weight-bearing for 3-6 months (delayed healing in osteomalacia), thromboprophylaxis, physiotherapy. I would counsel about prolonged rehabilitation, risk of periprosthetic fracture, importance of compliance with vitamin D replacement, and need for second surgery for contralateral side.
KEY POINTS TO SCORE
Manage acute fracture and prevent contralateral fracture (Looser zone = impending fracture)
Cemented arthroplasty preferred in osteomalacia due to poor bone quality
Prophylactic fixation of Looser zones greater than 50% cortical width to prevent fracture
Aggressive vitamin D optimization pre- and postoperatively to accelerate healing
COMMON TRAPS
✗Attempting internal fixation of pathological femoral neck fracture in elderly patient (low success rate, poor bone quality)
✗Not addressing contralateral Looser zone - high risk of fracture during recovery
✗Inadequate vitamin D replacement perioperatively - delayed healing, loosening
✗Unprotected weight-bearing early - risk of periprosthetic fracture or fixation failure
LIKELY FOLLOW-UPS
"Why cemented vs uncemented arthroplasty in osteomalacia?"
"What defines an 'impending fracture' and when do you prophylactically fix?"
"How does osteomalacia affect fracture healing and what is your postoperative protocol?"

MCQ Practice Points

Biochemistry Question

Q: A patient presents with bone pain, low calcium (2.0 mmol/L), low phosphate (0.6 mmol/L), elevated alkaline phosphatase (450 U/L), and low 25-OH vitamin D (20 nmol/L). What is the most likely diagnosis? A: Osteomalacia due to vitamin D deficiency. The classic biochemical pattern is low calcium and phosphate (reduced absorption), elevated alkaline phosphatase (osteoblast activity trying to mineralize osteoid), and low 25-OH vitamin D. This distinguishes it from osteoporosis (normal biochemistry) and primary hyperparathyroidism (elevated calcium).

Radiology Question

Q: What are Looser zones and where are they most commonly seen? A: Looser zones (pseudofractures) are radiolucent bands perpendicular to the cortex, representing insufficiency fractures that fail to heal due to defective mineralization. They are bilateral, symmetric, and pathognomonic for osteomalacia. Common sites (mnemonic PURFNS): Pubic rami, Ulna (distal), Ribs (lateral), Femoral neck (medial), tibia (proximal-medial), Scapula (axillary border).

Treatment Question

Q: What is the appropriate vitamin D replacement regimen for severe deficiency (25-OH vitamin D less than 25 nmol/L)? A: Cholecalciferol 50,000 IU weekly for 6-8 weeks, followed by maintenance 800-2000 IU daily. Alternative: 4000-6000 IU daily for 8-12 weeks. Always add calcium 1000-1500 mg daily. Recheck 25-OH vitamin D at 3 months - target greater than 75 nmol/L for bone health.

Oncogenic Osteomalacia Question

Q: A patient has hypophosphatemic osteomalacia with normal 25-OH vitamin D but elevated FGF23. What is the diagnosis and treatment? A: Tumor-induced osteomalacia (oncogenic osteomalacia). FGF23-secreting tumors (typically benign mesenchymal) cause renal phosphate wasting and inhibit 1-alpha hydroxylation of vitamin D. Diagnosis requires whole-body imaging (MRI, octreotide PET) to locate tumor. Treatment: surgical excision is curative - biochemistry normalizes within 24-48 hours. If tumor not found: high-dose phosphate plus calcitriol, or emerging anti-FGF23 antibody (burosumab).

Arthroplasty Question

Q: Why should you screen for vitamin D deficiency before elective arthroplasty? A: 30% of arthroplasty patients have vitamin D deficiency preoperatively. Deficiency is associated with increased infection risk (OR 2.4), delayed mobilization, prolonged hospital stay, and risk of aseptic loosening. Australian Orthopaedic Association recommends screening and optimizing to greater than 75 nmol/L before surgery. Vitamin D is essential for bone healing, osseointegration of implants, and immune function.

Hungry Bone Syndrome Question

Q: What is hungry bone syndrome and when does it occur in osteomalacia treatment? A: Hungry bone syndrome occurs when rapid vitamin D and calcium replacement in severe, prolonged osteomalacia causes profound hypocalcemia and hypophosphatemia as the demineralized skeleton avidly takes up minerals. Risk factors: marked secondary hyperparathyroidism, severe deficiency (less than 25 nmol/L), prolonged disease. Monitor calcium closely in first 2 weeks of treatment. May require IV calcium gluconate if symptomatic tetany develops.

Australian Context

Vitamin D Deficiency Prevalence: Vitamin D deficiency is common in Australia despite high UV exposure, particularly in dark-skinned populations, elderly, institutionalised patients, and those with cultural dress practices limiting sun exposure. Screening is recommended in at-risk groups.

PBS-Subsidised Vitamin D: Cholecalciferol (vitamin D3) preparations are available on PBS for documented deficiency. Colecalciferol 1000 IU daily or 50,000 IU monthly loading doses are standard regimens.

Therapeutic Guidelines: Australian Endocrine Society and Osteoporosis Australia recommend treatment based on serum 25-OH vitamin D levels: deficiency (less than 50 nmol/L), insufficiency (50-75 nmol/L), adequate (greater than 75 nmol/L).

Calcium Supplementation: Calcium carbonate and citrate preparations are PBS-subsidised when used with vitamin D. Dietary calcium intake is preferred where possible through dairy and fortified foods.

Oncogenic Osteomalacia: Rare FGF23-secreting mesenchymal tumours require nuclear medicine imaging (Ga-68 DOTATATE PET/CT) for localisation. Surgical excision is curative when tumour is accessible.

OSTEOMALACIA

High-Yield Exam Summary

Key Pathophysiology

  • •Defective mineralization of osteoid (vs osteoporosis = reduced bone mass)
  • •Vitamin D deficiency leads to reduced calcium and phosphate absorption
  • •Accumulation of unmineralized osteoid causes soft, deformable bones
  • •Secondary hyperparathyroidism worsens phosphate wasting

Classic Biochemistry

  • •Low or low-normal calcium
  • •Low phosphate
  • •Elevated alkaline phosphatase (markedly)
  • •25-OH vitamin D less than 25 nmol/L (severe deficiency)
  • •Elevated PTH (secondary hyperparathyroidism)

Clinical Triad

  • •Diffuse bone pain (worse with weight-bearing)
  • •Proximal myopathy (waddling gait, difficulty rising from chair)
  • •Pathological fractures (minimal trauma, weight-bearing bones)
  • •Skeletal deformities (leg bowing, vertebral compression in chronic cases)

Looser Zones (Pathognomonic)

  • •Radiolucent bands perpendicular to cortex
  • •Bilateral, symmetric, no periosteal reaction
  • •Sites: Pubic rami, Ribs, Femoral neck, Scapula, proximal tibia, distal Ulna (PURFNS)
  • •Represent stress fractures that fail to heal due to poor mineralization

Treatment Protocol

  • •Loading: Cholecalciferol 50,000 IU weekly for 6-8 weeks
  • •Maintenance: 800-2000 IU daily plus calcium 1000-1500 mg
  • •Target 25-OH vitamin D greater than 75 nmol/L
  • •Monitor calcium, phosphate, PTH, ALP at 1, 3, 6 months
  • •Oncogenic osteomalacia: surgical excision of FGF23-secreting tumor (curative)

Orthopaedic Pearls

  • •Screen all arthroplasty patients for vitamin D deficiency preoperatively
  • •Soft bone = poor screw purchase - consider cemented fixation, longer plates, cement augmentation
  • •Prophylactic fixation for Looser zones greater than 50% cortical width
  • •Delayed healing - protected weight-bearing for 3-6 months
  • •Hungry bone syndrome risk with rapid replacement in severe deficiency
Quick Stats
Reading Time93 min
Related Topics

Lyme Disease - Musculoskeletal Manifestations

Orthotic Prescription Principles

Osteoporosis

Reactive Arthritis (Reiter Syndrome)