PEDIATRIC SPONDYLOLYSIS
Pediatric Spine | Pars Defect | Stress Fracture | Extension Pain
TYPE (Wiltse)
Critical Must-Knows
- Definition: A defect (stress fracture) in the pars interarticularis.
- Mechanism: Repetitive hyperextension (Gymnasts, Fast Bowlers, Linebackers).
- Presentation: Extension-based low back pain. Tight hamstrings.
- Scottie Dog: Visible on Oblique X-rays (Collared dog = fracture).
- Imaging: MRI is now gold standard (STIR edema = acute). SPECT is sensitive but high radiation.
Examiner's Pearls
- "The 'Scottie Dog' sign is classic but oblique views are high radiation and often skipped for MRI.
- "Hamstring tightness is a cardinal sign (Phalen-Dickson sign is for Spondylolisthesis, but tightness present in lysis too).
- "Unilateral lysis often results in sclerosis of the CONTRALATERAL pedicle (Wilkinson syndrome).
- "Direct Repair (Buck's) is preferred over Fusion for isolated L5 lysis.
Clinical Imaging
Imaging Gallery




Radiation Risk
SPECT/CT
High Dose. A SPECT/CT carries significant radiation (equivalent to ~500 CXRs). Use MRI (STIR sequence) as first line for diagnosis in children to spare gonads.
Oblique X-rays
Avoid Routinely. Oblique lumbar views increase radiation dose significantly and have low sensitivity compared to MRI/SPECT.
At a Glance: Imaging Modalities
| Modality | Pros | Cons | Role |
|---|---|---|---|
| X-ray (AP/Lat) | Cheap, fast, shows grade of slip | Low sensitivity for lysis | Screening |
| MRI (STIR) | No radiation, shows acute edema | Can miss chronic non-union | Gold Standard Diagnosis |
| CT scan | Best for bony detail (healing) | Radiation | Assessment of healing |
| SPECT | Highest sensitivity for turnover | High radiation | Problem solving only |
SPORTRisk Factors
Memory Hook:SPORTs that extend the spine break the pars.
PARSDiagnosis
Memory Hook:PARS defect causes the pain.
SPECTImaging Strategy
Memory Hook:SPECT is sensitive but Radiation is high. MRI First!
Overview and Epidemiology
Pediatric Spondylolysis is a stress fracture of the pars interarticularis (isthmus). It represents a fatigue failure of the bone from repetitive extension and rotation.
Key Associations:
- Inuit Population: Extremely high prevalence (~50%).
- Spina Bifida Occulta: Associated with S1 occulta.
- Scheuermann's: Increased incidence of lysis.
Definitions
Depending on the pathology, the terminology changes:
- Spondylolysis: A defect in the pars interarticularis. No slip.
- Spondylolisthesis: Translation of one vertebra on another.
- Isthmic Spondylolisthesis: A slip CAUSED by a lysis (pars defect). The L5 body slips forward, leaving the posterior elements behind.
- Dysplastic Spondylolisthesis: A slip caused by congenital facet insufficiency. The pars is often intact.
- Spondyloptosis: Complete (greater than 100%) dislocation of L5 in front of the sacrum.
In children, we are mostly dealing with Isthmic or Dysplastic types. Degenerative slips are for adults.
Pathophysiology and Mechanisms
The Pars Interarticularis:
- The bridge of bone between the superior and inferior articular facets.
- It is the "weak link" in the neural arch.
- Biomechanics: In extension, the inferior facet of the cephalad vertebra impacts the pars of the caudal vertebra (Nutcracker mechanism).
- L5 Vulnerability: The L5 pars is susceptible due to the high shear forces at the lumbosacral junction and the transition from mobile spine to fixed pelvis.
Spino-Pelvic Parameters
The geometry of the pelvis plays a crucial role in the etiology and progression of lysis/listhesis.
-
Pelvic Incidence (PI):
- An anatomical constant (Morphology).
- Angle between the line perpendicular to the sacral plate and the line connecting the sacral midpoint to the femoral head axis.
- High PI (greater than 60 deg): Predisposes to Spondylolisthesis. The sacrum is more vertical, creating higher shear forces at L5-S1.
- Low PI: Protective against slip, but may cause impingement.
-
Sacral Slope (SS):
- The angle of the sacral plate to the horizontal.
- High PI usually results in High SS (greater than 50 deg).
- A steep sacral slope increases the anterior shear component of gravity (The "Ski Slope" effect).
-
Pelvic Tilt (PT):
- A compensatory mechanism.
- As the body tries to maintain balance with a high slip, the pelvis retroverts (High PT).
- This leads to the characteristic "crouched gait" and flattened lumbar lordosis above the slip.
Understanding PI is essential for surgical planning, especially if fusion is considered.
Classification
Wiltse Classification of Spondylolysis/Listhesis
-
Dysplastic (Type I):
- Congenital deficiency of the S1 dome or L5 arch.
- The facets are often oriented axially/sagittally, allowing slip.
- Highly associated with Spina Bifida Occulta.
- High risk of progression to high-grade slip.
-
Isthmic (Type II):
- The classic stress fracture lesion in the pars.
- IIA: Lytic stress fracture. The bone fails under tension/shear. This is the common form in athletes.
- IIB: Elongated pars. The bone "heals" with fibrous tissue that lengthens over time, allowing the body to slip forward. The pars is intact but attenuated.
- IIC: Acute fracture. A traumatic event triggers the break (Rare).
-
Degenerative (Type III):
- Adult instability.
- L4/5 is most common level (vs L5/S1 for isthmic).
- Due to facet joint and disc degeneration.
- Rare in pediatric population.
-
Traumatic (Type IV):
- High energy fracture (MVA, Fall).
- Often associated with other spinal fractures.
-
Pathologic (Type V):
- Tumor (Osteoid Osteoma? Metastasis?).
- Infection (Osteomyelitis).
-
Iatrogenic (Type VI):
- Post-surgical destabilization.
- Removal of too much pars/facet during laminectomy.
Wiltse classification is the standard.
Clinical Assessment
Clinical Features
- Pain: Low back pain, worse with extension (Stork test).
- Radiation: Usually localized to belt-line, occasionally to buttocks/thighs.
- Radiculopathy: Rare in lysis (unless high grade slip).
- Hyperlordosis: Posture.
- Palpation: Step-off (if slip present). Tenderness at L5/S1.
- Hamstrings: TIGHTness is universal. Popliteal angle measurement.
- Stork Test: One-legged hyperextension test. Pain implies lysis on the standing side.
Cauda Equina / High Grade Slip
Red Flag Symptoms:
- Saddle anesthesia (perineal numbness).
- Bladder retention or incontinence (overflow).
- Bowel incontinence.
- Bilateral significant lower limb weakness.
Mechanism:
- In high grade slips (Dysplastic), the lumbosacral kyphosis creates a "pincer" effect on the cauda equina between the L5 body and S1 posterior elements.
- Action: Immediate MRI and Surgical Decompression.
Investigations
Imaging Strategy
| Modality | Finding | Indication |
|---|---|---|
| X-ray (Oblique) | Scottie Dog with collar | Historical standard. Often low yield. |
| MRI (STIR/T2) | High signal in Pars (Edema) | First line for active pain. Detects stress reaction before fracture. |
| SPECT Bone Scan | Increased uptake (Hot spot) | Problem solving if MRI normal but suspicion high. |
| CT Scan | Fracture line (Sharp/Sclerotic) | To assess HEALING. Rounded sclerotic margins = non-union. |
Management Algorithm

The Mainstay of Treatment
Success Rate: greater than 90%.
- Rest: Cessation of sport (the "offending agent") for 3-6 months.
- Analgesia: NSAIDs.
- Bracing:
- Boston Overlap Brace (Antilordotic).
- Role: Symptom control and immobilization?
- Protocol: Full time for 3-6 months vs Symptomatic wear.
- Controversy: Does bracing actually heal the defect or just stop pain?
- Physical Therapy:
- Hamstring stretching (Crucial).
- Core strengthening (Abdominals).
- Pelvic tilt exercises.
- Williams Flexion Exercises:
- Pelvic Tilt.
- Single Knee to Chest.
- Double Knee to Chest.
- Partial Sit-ups.
- Hamstring stretch.
- Hip Flexor stretch.
- Squat.
- Avoid hyperextension exercises (McKenzie) initially. Use flexion bias to open the neural foramen and unload the pars.
Return to sport: When pain-free and full ROM.
Fibrous union is an acceptable outcome.
Surgical Technique
Pars Repair (Buck's / Scott's)
Idea: Reconnect the broken bone without fusing the joint. Preserves motion. Indication: L1-L4 lysis (L5 is hard due to depth), No slip (Grade 0), Healthy disc (MRI).
Techniques:
- Buck's Repair: Screw directly across the defect (Lag screw).
- Scott's Wiring: Wire around transverse process to spinous process.
- Pedicle Screw-Hook: Screw in pedicle, rod/hook on lamina. Compression.
Buck's Technique
- Midline incision. Expose lamina/pars.
- Debride the fibrous tissue in the defect (pseudarthrosis).
- Drill to bleeding bone.
- Bone graft (local/iliac) into defect.
- Graft Choice:
- Iliac Crest Bone Graft (ICBG) is Gold Standard.
- Local bone from lamina is often insufficient.
- BMP is generally Contraindicated in direct repair (risk of stenosis/overgrowth in canal).
- Insert screw from inferior lamina, across the pars, into the pedicle/body.
- Compress the defect.
Complications
Risks of Surgery
| Complication | Specifics | Prevention |
|---|---|---|
| Non-union (Pseudoarthrosis) | Failure of defects to heal | Adequate debridement, compression, bone graft. |
| Implant Failure | Screw breakage/pullout | Don't oversize screws. Avoid excessive torque. |
| Nerve Injury | L5 root at risk | Careful dissection. |
Postoperative Care and Rehabilitation
Recovery Pathway
- Goal: Allow bone/fibrous healing. Symptom control.
- Brace: TLSO with thigh extension (Antilordotic). Worn 23hrs/day? (Controversial).
- Activity: Walking allowed. No sports. No PE.
- Restrictions: No BLT (Bending, Lifting, Twisting).
- Goal: Restore core strength and flexibility.
- Wean Brace: Over 2 weeks.
- PT:
- Hamstring stretching (Gentle).
- Transversus abdominis activation.
- Dead bugs / Bird-dog exercises (Neutral spine).
- Imaging: CT scan at 12 weeks to assess union? (Only if contemplating return to contact sport or if pain persists).
- Goal: Sport specific reconditioning.
- Progression:
- Jogging to Running to Sprinting.
- Sport specific drills (Non-contact).
- E.g. Cricket: Batting to Bowling (reduced run-up).
- Return to Contact:
- Pain free.
- Full ROM.
- Normal strength.
- Radiographic Union? (Debated. Asymptomatic non-union allows play in many leagues, but risk of refracture/progression exists).
Outcomes
Prognosis:
- Excellent for most adolescents.
- Cessation of sport is the hardest part.
- Unilateral defects have virtually 100% healing rate.
- Bilateral defects have lower healing rates but high asymptomatic rates.
Evidence Base
MRI vs SPECT
- Compared MRI to SPECT for diagnosis of active spondylolysis
- MRI (STIR) had equivalent sensitivity to SPECT
- MRI avoided radiation
- Recommended MRI as first line investigation
Direct Repair Outcomes
- Original description of screw repair
- avoided fusion in young patients
- High union rate in properly selected cases
Natural History of Lysis
- Longitudinal study of 500 first graders
- Incidence 4.4% at age 6, rose to 6% by adulthood
- Progression to high grade slip was RARE
- Most were asymptomatic
Bracing Efficacy
- Compared rigid bracing vs rest alone
- No significant difference in clinical outcome or return to sport
- Bracing improved 'healing' on CT in some subgroups but clinical relevance debated
Sport Specific Risk
- Diving, Gymnastics, Wrestling have highest rates
- Cricket fast bowlers (extension + rotation) at extreme risk
- Modification of technique (counter-rotation) reduces risk
Long Term Outcomes
- Long term follow up (mean 13 years) of 272 children
- Progression of slip was uncommon after skeletal maturity
- Subjective symptoms were mild in most patients
- No correlation between degree of slip and low back pain
Exam Viva Scenarios
Practice these scenarios to excel in your viva examination
"A 14-year-old male gymnast presents with low back pain worsening with back handsprings. He has tight hamstrings."
"X-rays show a unilateral L5 lysis. MRI shows sclerosis of the contralateral pedicle."
"A 16-year-old cricket fast bowler has persistent pain after 9 months of rest and bracing. CT shows a bilateral L5 lysis with sclerotic margins and no slip."
MCQ Practice Points
Most Common Level
Q: Which level is most commonly affected in pediatric spondylolysis? A: L5 (90% of cases).
Scottie Dog Anatomy
Q: What structure corresponds to the 'neck' of the Scottie Dog? A: The Pars Interarticularis. (Eye = Pedicle, Nose = Transverse Process, Ear = Superior Facet, Leg = Inferior Facet).
Radiation Dose
Q: Why is SPECT/CT falling out of favor? A: High radiation dose. MRI STIR sequences can detect early stress reactions without radiation.
Bracing Mechanism
Q: What position does the Boston brace for spondylolysis hold the spine in? A: Antilordotic (Flexion). This unloads the posterior elements (pars).
Associated Anomaly
Q: What congenital anomaly is associated with spondylolysis? A: Spina Bifida Occulta (at S1).
Sclerotic Pedicle
Q: Unilateral pedicle sclerosis with contralateral lysis is called: A: Wilkinson Syndrome. (Often misdiagnosed as Osteoid Osteoma).
Pelvic Incidence
Q: Which pelvic parameter is a constant risk factor for slip progression? A: Pelvic Incidence (PI). High PI (greater than 60 deg) correlates with isthmic spondylolisthesis.
Healing Assessment
Q: Which modality is best to distinguish a visible fracture line as acute vs chronic/non-union? A: CT Scan. Rounded sclerotic margins indicate chronic non-union. Sharp irregular margins indicate acute fracture.
Australian Context
Epidemiology:
- High prevalence in young cricket fast bowlers (Cricket Australia guidelines limit bowling overs for youth).
- Cricket Australia Guidelines:
- Limits on overs per spell and per week for potential skeletally immature bowlers.
- Mandatory rest periods.
- Assessment of bowling action (Counter-rotation increases risk).
- Cricket Australia Guidelines:
- Gymnastics and Ballet also high risk groups.
- "Active adolescents" with back pain greater than 2 weeks = Lysis until proven otherwise.
Referral:
- Persistent back pain in an athlete greater than 2 weeks warrants X-ray/MRI.
- Spinal surgeons manage surgical cases, Sport Physicians often manage non-op.
- Early diagnosis prevents progression to non-union.
High-Yield Exam Summary
Diagnostic Triad
- •Extension Pain (Stork Test)
- •Tight Hamstrings
- •Pars Edema (MRI STIR)
Wiltse Classification
- •I: Dysplastic
- •II: Isthmic (Lytic)
- •III: Degenerative
- •IV: Traumatic
- •V: Pathologic
Management Rules
- •Acute: Rest + Brace (3-6m)
- •Chronic: Rehab to Surgery
- •Surgery: Repair if L1-L4, Fusion if L5?
- •Return to sport: Pain free (Union not mandatory)
- •Wilkinson Syndrome: Do NOT Biopsy