Non-Contact Border Incision | NV Bundle Volar | Cleland/Grayson Planes
Surgical Imaging
The incision must be placed on the non-contact border of the digit. For the index and middle fingers this is the ulnar border; for the ring and little fingers it is the radial border. This keeps the scar away from the contact surface during pinch and grasp. Placing the incision on the wrong side risks a painful scar on the working surface of the finger.
The digital neurovascular bundle lies immediately volar to the mid-axial line. The incision is made dorsal to the bundle. The bundle must be identified early, gently retracted volarly with a vessel loop, and protected throughout. Injury causes permanent sensory loss and cold intolerance in the affected hemidigit.
Cleland ligaments lie dorsal to the neurovascular bundle and connect the phalanx to the skin. Grayson ligaments lie volar to the bundle and connect the flexor sheath to the skin. Dissection dorsal to Cleland or volar to Grayson allows safe access to the flexor sheath or bone without injuring the bundle.
The incision is placed exactly at the dorsal-most point of each flexion crease (the apex). This ensures the scar lies in the mid-axial line and does not cross the creases obliquely, which would create a contracture. The line joining these apices defines the safe mid-axial plane.
All skin, subcutaneous tissue and fascial layers of the digit are supplied by the digital nerves. There is no classical internervous plane. Safety comes from staying dorsal to the neurovascular bundle and using the natural planes created by Cleland and Grayson ligaments rather than dividing innervated structures.
The approach gives excellent access to the phalanx, flexor sheath and PIP joint collateral ligaments. It does not provide access to the extensor mechanism (use dorsal approach) or the volar pulp (use Bruner or volar zigzag). Extension is limited proximally by the web space and distally by the nail fold.
At a Glance
The mid-axial approach to the digit provides safe access to the phalanx, flexor tendon sheath and PIP joint collateral ligaments while protecting the digital neurovascular bundle. The incision is placed on the non-contact border of the finger, joining the dorsal-most points of the flexion creases. The digital artery and nerve remain volar to the incision and are identified and protected early. Dissection proceeds either dorsal to Cleland ligament or volar to Grayson ligament to reach the target structures. This approach is ideal for phalangeal fracture fixation, PIP joint surgery, collateral ligament repair and excision of tumours or mucous cysts on the side of the digit. It avoids the contact surface of the finger and therefore minimises the risk of painful scar contracture during pinch and grasp.
MIDAXIALMID-AXIAL INCISION - Key Principles
Hook:MIDAXIAL approach keeps the NV bundle safe and the scar off the contact surface.
PROTECTDIGITAL NV BUNDLE - Protection Sequence
Hook:PROTECT the digital bundle at every step - it is the most important structure.
CLELAND GRAYSONCLELAND VERSUS GRAYSON - Dissection Planes
Hook:CLELAND is dorsal, GRAYSON is volar - choose your plane to protect the bundle.
Indications and Approach Selection
Primary Indications:
- Phalangeal shaft or neck fractures requiring open reduction and internal fixation
- PIP joint fracture-dislocations needing collateral ligament repair or volar plate arthroplasty
- Collateral ligament injuries of the PIP or DIP joint requiring direct repair or reconstruction
- Excision of mucous cysts, giant cell tumours of tendon sheath or other lateral masses
- Flexor tendon sheath exploration or pulley release when volar access is contraindicated
- Osteomyelitis or septic arthritis drainage of the phalanx or PIP joint
Why This Approach is Chosen:
The mid-axial incision provides direct access to the lateral aspect of the phalanx and the flexor sheath while keeping the scar on the non-contact border. It avoids the volar pulp and therefore prevents painful scar contracture that would impair pinch and grasp. The digital neurovascular bundle is protected by remaining dorsal to it throughout the dissection. This approach is particularly useful when the pathology is lateral or when a volar Bruner incision would place the scar on the working surface of the finger.
Contraindications:
- Pathology requiring dorsal access (use dorsal approach for extensor mechanism or dorsal lip fractures)
- Volar pulp or fingertip pathology (use volar zigzag or straight volar incision)
- Previous scarring or infection on the planned mid-axial line
- Need for circumferential access (consider two mid-axial incisions or Bruner)
Alternative Approaches:
- Dorsal approach: For extensor tendon repair, dorsal lip fractures, or central slip injuries
- Bruner volar zigzag: For flexor tendon repair, volar plate exposure, or pulley reconstruction
- Volar straight incision: For limited volar access when mid-axial exposure is insufficient
- Lateral approach with nail fold elevation: For distal phalanx or nail bed pathology
Overview
Mid-Axial Approach to the Digit provides direct lateral access to the phalanx, flexor tendon sheath and PIP joint collateral ligaments through an incision placed on the non-contact border of the finger.
Key Characteristics:
- Incision joins the dorsal apices of the flexion creases
- Digital neurovascular bundle remains volar and protected
- Cleland and Grayson ligaments define the safe dissection planes
- No true internervous plane exists in the digit
- Scar avoids the contact surface of pinch and grasp
Why This Approach Matters:
- Most common approach for phalangeal ORIF in the finger
- Essential for PIP joint collateral ligament repair
- Allows access to flexor sheath without crossing the volar pulp
- Minimises risk of scar contracture on the working surface
- High-yield surgical approach for hand surgery examinations
Exam Relevance:
- Classic question on digital neurovascular anatomy
- Distinction between Cleland and Grayson ligaments is frequently tested
- Understanding of non-contact border selection is mandatory
Anatomy
Bony Anatomy:
The phalanges of the fingers are tubular bones with a proximal base, shaft and distal head. The PIP joint is a hinge joint with collateral ligaments that are tight in flexion and lax in extension. The mid-axial line runs along the lateral aspect of each phalanx, connecting the dorsal-most points of the flexion creases. The flexor digitorum profundus and superficialis tendons lie volar to the phalanx within the flexor sheath.
Ligamentous Anatomy:
Cleland ligaments are thick fibrous bands that run from the phalangeal periosteum dorsal to the neurovascular bundle to the dorsal skin. They form a barrier that can be dissected to reach the bone or extensor apparatus. Grayson ligaments run from the flexor sheath volar to the neurovascular bundle to the volar skin. They form the volar boundary of the safe plane around the bundle.
Neurovascular Anatomy:
Each digit has two digital arteries and two digital nerves running along its sides, just volar to the mid-axial line. The arteries lie dorsal to the nerves. The bundle is enveloped by a thin layer of fat and fascia. The nerve supplies sensation to the hemidigit and the artery supplies the pulp and skin. Injury to either structure causes permanent deficit.
Flexor Sheath Anatomy:
The flexor sheath is a fibro-osseous tunnel extending from the metacarpal head to the distal phalanx. The A2 and A4 pulleys are critical for flexor tendon function and must be preserved or reconstructed if divided. The sheath is reached by dissecting either dorsal to Cleland ligament or volar to Grayson ligament, keeping the neurovascular bundle protected.
Internervous Plane
Deep Internervous Plane:
There is no true internervous plane in the mid-axial approach. All skin, subcutaneous tissue, fascia and periosteum of the digit are supplied by branches of the digital nerves. Safety is achieved by remaining dorsal to the neurovascular bundle and using the natural fascial planes created by Cleland and Grayson ligaments rather than dividing innervated muscle or fascia.
Superficial Dissection:
The skin and subcutaneous fat are incised directly down to the level of the dorsal margin of the neurovascular bundle. No muscle is divided. The digital nerve and artery are identified within the subcutaneous fat just volar to the incision line and are gently retracted volarly.
The mid-axial approach is an example of an interfascial rather than internervous dissection. The critical safety principle is to stay dorsal to the digital neurovascular bundle at all times. Once the bundle is identified and protected, the surgeon chooses either the plane dorsal to Cleland ligament (to reach bone or extensor apparatus) or the plane volar to Grayson ligament (to reach the flexor sheath). Both planes are safe provided the bundle is retracted volarly and protected.
Structures at Risk in Each Layer:
- Structure
- Digital neurovascular bundle
- Protection Strategy
- Identify early, vessel loop, gentle retraction
- Structure
- Extensor apparatus
- Protection Strategy
- Stay subperiosteal, avoid dorsal over-dissection
- Structure
- Flexor tendons and sheath
- Protection Strategy
- Preserve A2 and A4 pulleys when possible
- Structure
- Collateral ligaments
- Protection Strategy
- Repair or reconstruct if divided for access
Positioning and Patient Setup
Position: Supine with Hand on Hand Table
Pre-positioning Checklist:
- Confirm tourniquet is available and functional
- Loupe magnification (2.5x or greater) confirmed
- Hand table attached and radiolucent if fluoroscopy needed
- Arm board positioned for comfortable access
- Lead hand or lead weights available for positioning
Positioning Details:
- Patient supine with affected arm on hand table
- Tourniquet applied to upper arm, inflated to 250 mmHg (or 100 mmHg above systolic)
- Hand exsanguinated with Esmarch bandage before tourniquet inflation
- Fingers positioned with lead hand or rolled towels for stability
- Operating microscope or loupes available throughout
Tourniquet time should not exceed 120 minutes for hand surgery. Document tourniquet time at regular intervals. Release the tourniquet before closure if the procedure exceeds 90 minutes to allow reperfusion and haemostasis assessment.
Alternative Positioning:
- Lateral decubitus with arm on padded bolster if combined procedures required
- Prone positioning rarely needed for isolated digit surgery
Surface Anatomy and Landmarks
Key Bony Landmarks:
- Proximal interphalangeal joint line - palpable as a transverse depression
- Distal interphalangeal joint line - smaller transverse depression
- Metacarpophalangeal joint - palpable at the base of the proximal phalanx
- Flexion creases - mark the level of the PIP and DIP joints
Key Soft Tissue Landmarks:
- Digital neurovascular bundle - palpable as a longitudinal ridge just volar to the planned incision when the finger is flexed
- Flexor tendon sheath - felt as a firm longitudinal structure volar to the phalanx
- Cleland ligaments - palpable as transverse bands when the skin is moved over the phalanx
Incision Planning:
- Select the non-contact border (ulnar for index and middle, radial for ring and little)
- Mark the dorsal-most point of each flexion crease (the apex)
- Join these points with a straight line along the mid-axial border
- Extend proximally into the web space or distally to the nail fold only if required
- Incision length typically 3-5 cm for a single phalanx or PIP joint exposure
Surgical Technique
Step 1: Incision
The skin incision is made precisely along the mid-axial line on the non-contact border, joining the dorsal apices of the flexion creases. The incision is carried through skin and subcutaneous fat only in the initial pass. Loupe magnification is essential.
Step 2: Identify and Protect the Neurovascular Bundle
The digital artery and nerve are identified within the subcutaneous fat immediately volar to the incision. They are gently dissected free and encircled with a vessel loop or Penrose drain. The bundle is retracted volarly and protected throughout the remainder of the procedure. Capillary refill of the fingertip is checked after retraction to confirm adequate perfusion.
Step 3: Superficial Dissection Plane Selection
Two safe planes exist once the bundle is protected:
- Dorsal to Cleland ligament: The thick fibrous Cleland ligaments are divided or elevated from the phalanx to reach the bone or extensor apparatus. This plane is used for phalangeal fracture fixation or dorsal pathology.
- Volar to Grayson ligament: The Grayson ligaments are divided to reach the flexor sheath. This plane is used for flexor tendon exploration or volar plate access.
Step 4: Deep Dissection to Target Structures
For phalangeal exposure the periosteum is incised and elevated subperiosteally. For flexor sheath exposure the sheath is visualised and the A2 or A4 pulley is preserved if possible. The collateral ligaments of the PIP joint can be divided at their volar or dorsal attachment for joint access and repaired at closure.
Step 5: Extension of the Approach
Proximal extension follows the same mid-axial line into the web space, taking care to protect the transverse digital artery at the web. Distal extension stops at the nail fold. The approach can be extended to the metacarpal head if required by continuing proximally.
Closure and Aftercare
Wound Closure:
Skin closure is performed with interrupted non-absorbable sutures. The digital neurovascular bundle is confirmed to lie in its anatomic position without kinking or tension. No attempt is made to close the flexor sheath or periosteum. If a collateral ligament was divided for joint access, it is repaired with braided suture anchored to bone or soft tissue. A bulky compressive dressing with a dorsal plaster slab maintains the finger in slight flexion at the PIP joint.
Aftercare Protocol:
- Strict elevation for 48 hours to minimise oedema
- Active range of motion exercises commence at 48-72 hours unless specific contraindications exist
- Protective splinting for 3-6 weeks depending on the underlying procedure
- Suture removal at 10-14 days
- Oedema control with compression garments once wounds are healed
- Scar massage begins at 3 weeks to prevent contracture
Rehabilitation Milestones:
- Week 0-2: Protection, oedema control, gentle active motion within safe range
- Week 2-6: Progressive active and passive motion, scar management
- Week 6+: Strengthening, functional rehabilitation, return to work or sport
Complications and Failure Modes
Approach-Specific Complications:
- Digital neurovascular injury (less than 1 percent permanent deficit with careful technique)
- Scar contracture on the contact surface if the wrong border is chosen
- Flexor tendon adhesion if the sheath is violated unnecessarily
- PIP joint stiffness from prolonged immobilisation or scarring
- Nail deformity if the approach is extended too far distally
- Web space contracture if proximal extension damages the transverse ligament
Prevention Strategies:
- Always confirm the non-contact border before marking the incision
- Identify and protect the neurovascular bundle before any deep dissection
- Preserve the A2 and A4 pulleys whenever possible
- Begin early motion within the limits of stability
- Avoid overzealous retraction on the neurovascular bundle
Management of Complications:
- Suspected nerve injury: immediate exploration if recognised intra-operatively, otherwise observe with serial sensory testing
- Flexor tendon adhesion: early tenolysis if motion plateaus
- PIP stiffness: dynamic splinting and intensive hand therapy
- Scar contracture: scar revision with Z-plasty if functionally limiting
Exam Viva Scenarios
Practise clinical reasoning and management decisions out loud
“A 28-year-old carpenter sustains a spiral fracture of the proximal phalanx of the ring finger after a fall. CT confirms a displaced spiral fracture with greater than 2 mm shortening. How would you approach this?”
“A 35-year-old athlete presents with a complete radial collateral ligament rupture of the PIP joint of the index finger after a jamming injury. The joint is unstable to stress testing in extension. How would you approach surgical repair?”
“A 40-year-old musician requires exploration of the flexor sheath of the little finger for suspected pulley rupture and bowstringing after a laceration. How would you gain safe access while preserving critical pulleys?”