First MTP arthrodesis combined with lesser metatarsal surgery (Hoffmann or Weil) and claw toe correction | advanced
- The rheumatoid forefoot triad: hallux valgus deformity of the first ray, dorsal subluxation or dislocation of the lesser MTP joints with clawed toes, and painful plantar metatarsal head prominences with intractable keratoses. The pathophysiology is progressive synovitis causing MTP joint capsular distension, volar plate attenuation, and extensor tendon dorsal subluxation that drives the MTP joint into dorsolateral subluxation and eventual dislocation.
- First MTP arthrodesis is the keystone of reconstruction — it replaces the older Keller excision arthroplasty as the preferred technique because it provides a stable, plantigrade medial column, corrects hallux valgus, and offloads the lesser rays by restoring proper first-ray weight-bearing. Union rates are 85-95%; position the fusion at 15 degrees valgus, 10-15 degrees dorsiflexion relative to the floor, and neutral rotation.
- Lesser ray surgery must restore the metatarsal parabola: the Hoffmann procedure (metatarsal head resection) is simpler and effective but can cause transfer metatarsalgia if excessive bone is removed; the Weil shortening osteotomy preserves the MTP joint surface and is preferred when joint preservation is possible, but carries greater risk of stiffness and avascular necrosis of the metatarsal head.
- Perioperative management of the immunosuppressed rheumatoid patient is critical — DMARDs (particularly methotrexate) may be continued perioperatively in most patients, but biologic agents (TNF inhibitors, rituximab, tocilizumab) should be held in coordination with rheumatology before major foot reconstruction because of wound-healing and infection risks. Cervical spine instability screening is mandatory before any procedure under general anaesthesia in long-standing rheumatoid arthritis.
- “The first MTP fusion position dictates forefoot mechanics for life — too much dorsiflexion causes hallux elevatus and transfer load to the lesser rays; too little dorsiflexion causes impingement at the interphalangeal joint; aim for 10-15 degrees dorsiflexion relative to the floor.
- “The metatarsal parabola is the key to preventing transfer metatarsalgia after lesser ray surgery — the second metatarsal must remain longest, with a gentle symmetric cascade to the fifth; residual prominence of any metatarsal head will produce a focal plantar keratosis.
- “In the exam, if asked about Keller arthroplasty versus first MTP arthrodesis for rheumatoid hallux valgus: Keller is simpler but produces a weak, short hallux with transfer metatarsalgia risk; arthrodesis is the gold standard for functional reconstruction in ambulatory rheumatoid patients.
- “Cervical spine screening (flexion-extension radiographs) must be completed before general anaesthesia in rheumatoid patients — atlantoaxial subluxation can cause cord compression with intubation. Spinal anaesthesia or regional block avoids this risk and is preferred for forefoot reconstruction.
When & Why
Indication. Reconstruction is offered for the symptomatic rheumatoid forefoot that has failed at least six months of appropriate non-operative care — wide toe-box, rocker-bottom footwear, custom moulded orthoses with a metatarsal dome or bar, optimised medical management (DMARDs and biologics), podiatric callus care, and intra-articular corticosteroid injection for acute flares. Absolute indications for surgery: - Intractable plantar metatarsalgia with painful callosities beneath dislocated or subluxated lesser MTP joints causing significant functional limitation
- Severe hallux valgus with first MTP joint destruction (joint-space loss, erosions, subluxation) producing pain unresponsive to shoe modification
- Fixed lesser toe deformities (claw or hammer toes with MTP dislocation) interfering with footwear or causing ulceration Relative indications: progressive hallux valgus with early medial column collapse despite medical management; lesser MTP synovitis with dorsal subluxation that is not yet dislocated (correction before fixed dislocation yields better outcomes); painful callosities recurring despite regular podiatric care; patient preference for reconstruction to return to enclosed footwear. Contraindications. Absolute: active foot or systemic infection; inadequate soft-tissue envelope (ulceration, active rheumatoid vasculitis); critical ischaemia with absent pedal pulses not restorable by vascular intervention; medical unfitness for anaesthesia or prolonged rehabilitation. Relative: severe osteopenia or fractures through osteoporotic metatarsals (consider staging); an active rheumatoid flare (optimise medical management first); likely non-compliance with non-weight-bearing; the non-ambulatory or bedbound patient (conservative care preferred). The four-part decision. Every reconstruction pairs a first-ray operation with a lesser-ray operation. The choices, and who each suits:
The keystone. Provides a stable plantigrade medial column, corrects hallux valgus, and offloads the lesser rays by restoring first-ray weight-bearing. Gold standard for ambulatory patients (union 85-95%).
Reserved for elderly, low-demand or non-ambulatory patients. Reliable pain relief, but a weak shortened hallux with loss of push-off and transfer metatarsalgia in 15-30%.
For dislocated or destroyed lesser MTP joints. Simple and reliable. Resect a consistent 4-6 mm and preserve the parabola to avoid transfer lesions; the MTP joint is sacrificed.
For subluxated but reducible lesser MTP joints. Preserves the articular surface. Dorsal oblique cut with proximal translation; risks avascular necrosis (2-10%) and stiffness.
Consent specifically for nonunion of the first MTP fusion (5-10%), transfer metatarsalgia (5-15%), wound infection (2-5%, higher when immunosuppressed), prolonged swelling over 3-6 months, vascular compromise of the lesser toes, and the possibility of subsequent procedures for recurrent or residual deformity. Setup & perioperative preparation. Supine with a sandbag under the ipsilateral buttock to internally rotate the foot into neutral or slight valgus. A calf tourniquet is preferred (allows bilateral access without repositioning), inflated to 250 mmHg (300 mmHg thigh) after Esmarch exsanguination, maximum two hours. - Anaesthesia: regional (spinal, or popliteal sciatic plus ankle block) is strongly preferred to avoid the cervical spine at intubation. If general anaesthesia is unavoidable, flexion-extension cervical radiographs must already have been reviewed and intubation performed awake, fibreoptic, with cervical precautions.
- Antibiotics: single intravenous dose of cefazolin at induction (clindamycin if penicillin-allergic); redose if tourniquet time exceeds four hours.
- Perioperative immunosuppression: coordinate with rheumatology. Continue methotrexate perioperatively — withholding it increases disease flare without clearly reducing wound complications. Leflunomide, sulfasalazine and hydroxychloroquine are generally continued. Hold biologics (TNF inhibitors, rituximab, tocilizumab, abatacept, JAK inhibitors) — plan surgery roughly four to six weeks after the last TNF-inhibitor dose (two to three half-lives); rituximab timing is individualised.
- Cervical spine: flexion-extension films are mandatory before any general anaesthetic. An anterior atlantodens interval greater than 3 mm is abnormal and greater than 9 mm is a relative contraindication to standard intubation; obtain MRI for any neurological symptoms.
- Bilateral disease: one-stage bilateral reconstruction is feasible under regional anaesthesia but demands strict non-weight-bearing on both feet (wheelchair for six weeks); two-stage surgery six to twelve weeks apart suits patients with significant comorbidities or poor balance.
The Operation
The goal: fuse the first MTP in a functional position through the dorsomedial approach, restore the metatarsal parabola across the lesser rays (by Hoffmann resection or Weil shortening), correct the claw toes, and close thin rheumatoid skin without devascularising it. The exposure is laid out in full below — and in depth on the dorsomedial approach to the first MTP joint and the dorsal approach to the lesser metatarsals pages.

Operative sequence
- Supine, sandbag under the ipsilateral buttock to internally rotate the foot into neutral or slight valgus; foot at the end of the table.
- Calf tourniquet (preferred — allows bilateral access); exsanguinate with an Esmarch and inflate to 250 mmHg (300 mmHg thigh), maximum two hours.
- Regional anaesthesia — spinal, or popliteal sciatic plus ankle block — to avoid cervical-spine intubation risk.
- Cefazolin at induction (clindamycin if penicillin-allergic); redose if tourniquet time exceeds four hours.
- Dorsomedial longitudinal incision, 5-8 cm, centred on the first MTP joint just medial to the EHL tendon, between EHL and the medial dorsal cutaneous nerve.
- Identify the dorsalis pedis artery and deep peroneal nerve in the EHL–EDL interval and retract them laterally with the EHL before deepening the approach.
- Handle the skin gently — rheumatoid skin on long-term steroids is thin and devascularised; avoid undermining the medial flap.
- Open the dorsal capsule longitudinally; retract the extensor hallucis brevis.
- Release the lateral structures early — the lateral collateral ligament, the adductor hallucis from the lateral sesamoid, and any contracted dorsal capsule — to mobilise the hallux into valgus correction without force.
- Preserve the medial capsule and the sesamoid apparatus intact.
- Flat saw cuts: concave on the metatarsal head, flat or slightly convex on the proximal phalanx base, so the surfaces sit congruently.
- Minimal resection — only enough to remove eroded cartilage and expose bleeding subchondral bone. Excessive resection leaves a gap that risks nonunion.
- If the metatarsal head is sclerotic, perforate the subchondral plate with 2 mm drill holes to encourage bleeding before reduction.
- Preserve the sesamoid complex and flexor hallucis brevis beneath the head.
- Reduce at 15 degrees valgus, 10-15 degrees dorsiflexion relative to the floor (not the metatarsal shaft), and neutral rotation.
- The plantar surface of the hallux must rest flush with the floor; correct the intermetatarsal angle to less than 5 degrees.
- Hold with temporary K-wires and assess the position from multiple views with the foot flat against a firm surface — never hanging free — before fixation.
- Pre-contoured low-profile titanium dorsal plate (2.4 or 2.7 mm): three screws into the metatarsal, two to three into the proximal phalanx.
- Interfragmentary lag screw (3.5 or 4.0 mm), dorsal-proximal to plantar-distal, placed first for compression; the plate then neutralises.
- Use locking screws in poor-quality bone (common in rheumatoid patients on steroids).
- Contour the plate flush to the dorsal cortex — a prominent plate causes shoe irritation and later removal.
- Two longitudinal dorsal incisions — one between the second and third rays, one between the fourth and fifth — rather than a single long transverse incision (which has higher breakdown risk in thin rheumatoid skin).
- Identify the dorsalis pedis artery and deep peroneal nerve at the first intermetatarsal space before any deeper dissection.
- Retract the extensor tendons (EDL, EDB) longitudinally, never transversely, to avoid tendon injury.
- Open the dorsal MTP capsule; dorsally dislocate the proximal phalanx to expose the metatarsal head.
- Resect the head through the neck with the oscillating saw — a consistent 4-6 mm from the distal neck, perpendicular to the shaft axis, at every ray.
- Round the cut edge with a rongeur; palpate the plantar surface of each stump through the sole — no single stump more prominent than its neighbour.
- Dorsal oblique osteotomy of the metatarsal neck at 20-30 degrees to the shaft, starting 1-2 mm distal to the condyles and exiting the plantar cortex 3-4 mm proximal to the dorsal start.
- Translate the capital fragment proximally (dorsally) 4-6 mm — the same amount at each ray to preserve the parabola.
- Fix with one or two 2.0 mm screws dorsal-to-plantar, engaging the plantar cortex of the capital fragment.
- Resect the prominent dorsal shelf of the shaft so it cannot impinge on the extensor mechanism; preserve the plantar vascular pedicle to avoid avascular necrosis.
- Fixed claws: PIP resection arthroplasty through a dorsal incision, excising the head of the proximal phalanx and releasing the collaterals; pass a retrograde 0.8 or 0.9 mm K-wire from the toe tip through the DIP, PIP and across the MTP into the metatarsal shaft, holding the correction for four to six weeks.
- Flexible claws: extensor release over the PIP plus a percutaneous long-flexor (FDS and FDP) tenotomy at the base of the proximal phalanx.
- Girdlestone-Taylor flexor-to-extensor transfer when the MTP remains unstable after metatarsal surgery.
- Irrigate all wounds; close the dorsal capsules with 2-0 Vicryl, subcutis with 3-0 Vicryl, skin with interrupted 3-0 nylon.
- Non-adherent dressings to each incision; bulky wool and crepe with the foot neutral; below-knee plaster back-slab or a rigid post-operative shoe.
- Deflate the tourniquet, wait at least five minutes, and check capillary refill in every toe before leaving theatre.
The dorsalis pedis artery runs in the EHL–EDL interval in the proximal foot, then passes lateral to EHL toward the first webspace; the deep peroneal nerve lies lateral to the artery and supplies first-webspace sensation. Both the dorsomedial first-MTP incision and the lesser-ray dorsal incisions cross them. Identify and protect them with vessel loops at the start of every dorsal approach, before any deeper dissection — laceration causes heavy bleeding and compromises the already tenuous vascularity of rheumatoid toes.
The medial (tibial) and lateral (fibular) sesamoids sit within the flexor hallucis brevis beneath the first metatarsal head and form the plantar fulcrum for push-off. During articular-surface preparation the sesamoids and FHB must be preserved; disruption removes the weight-bearing fulcrum and causes major functional impairment.
After tourniquet deflation, wait at least five minutes and confirm brisk capillary refill in every toe. The rheumatoid toe has tenuous vascularity — a K-wire impaling a plantar digital bundle, over-shortening, or prolonged tourniquet time can cause ischaemia. If a toe is pale: remove the K-wires immediately, warm and elevate, and recheck at five to ten minutes. Ischaemia that does not resolve is an indication for primary amputation of that toe rather than risking post-operative gangrene.
Over-resection in Hoffmann or over-shortening in Weil shifts load to the adjacent ray, producing a new focal plantar keratosis — the most common reason for reoperation. Resect a consistent 4-6 mm, translate the same amount at each ray, keep the second metatarsal longest, and palpate the plantar profile before closing so no single head is prominent.
Aim for 10-15 degrees dorsiflexion relative to the weight-bearing surface of the foot, not the first metatarsal shaft. Too much dorsiflexion gives hallux elevatus and transfers load to the lesser rays; too little causes interphalangeal impingement on push-off. Temporarily K-wire the position and assess it with the foot flat against a firm surface — never hanging free — before committing to fixation.
After lesser-ray resection or Weil translation, palpate the sole: each metatarsal stump should sit evenly, none prominent. A single prominent head will become a focal plantar keratosis. Take an extra 1-2 mm from any prominent stump until the plantar profile is even — this single intra-operative check prevents most transfer lesions.
Aftercare & Complications
Rehabilitation | Phase | Timing | Immobilisation | Milestones | |-------|--------|-----------------|------------| | Immediate | 0-2 weeks | Below-knee non-weight-bearing cast or rigid shoe, crutches | Elevate above heart for 48-72 hours; pin-site care; multimodal analgesia | | Early | 2-6 weeks | Below-knee cast boot, strict non-weight-bearing | Wound review and suture removal at 2 weeks; K-wires remain 4-6 weeks | | Intermediate | 6-12 weeks | Progressive weight-bearing in cast boot as consolidation allows | 6-week weight-bearing AP and lateral radiographs; lesser-MTP range-of-motion exercises | | Late | 3-12 months | Wide supportive shoe; night splint if needed | Gait re-education, proprioception, scar management; custom orthoses | Most patients return to a wide, supportive shoe by 8-12 weeks. Full recovery — resolution of oedema and functional adaptation — takes 6-12 months; rheumatoid patients commonly have mild forefoot swelling for 6-9 months. Custom moulded insoles with metatarsal support and a wide, deep toe-box, rocker-bottom shoe are often needed long-term. Complications
- Incidence
- 5-10%
- Recognition
- Persistent pain at the fusion site beyond 6 months; movement on stress; widening radiolucency with no bridging trabeculae; broken hardware
- Prevention and management
- Minimal resection, rigid plate-plus-lag fixation, correct position, protected weight-bearing. If symptomatic after 6 months, revision arthrodesis with autograft (distal tibia or iliac crest) and augmented fixation
- Incidence
- 5-15%
- Recognition
- New focal plantar pain and keratosis beneath a previously asymptomatic metatarsal head, usually the third or fourth ray
- Prevention and management
- Consistent resection or translation at each ray; intraoperative plantar palpation; preserve the parabola (second longest). Orthoses with a metatarsal dome; refractory cases revised with further shortening
- Incidence
- 2-5%, higher when immunosuppressed
- Recognition
- Erythema, warmth, dehiscence or purulent discharge at dorsal incisions; fever; raised inflammatory markers
- Prevention and management
- Minimise skin undermining, longitudinal incisions, coordinate perioperative DMARD or biologic management, single-dose antibiotic prophylaxis. Superficial — dressings and oral antibiotics; deep — washout, deep cultures, prolonged IV antibiotics
- Incidence
- 3-8%
- Recognition
- Hallux in excessive valgus (greater than 20 degrees), varus, elevatus or plantarflexion; pain with shoe wear or push-off
- Prevention and management
- Check position with the foot flat against a firm surface before fixation; temporary K-wires. Symptomatic malunion — revision arthrodesis; mild deformity — shoe modification
- Incidence
- Less than 2%, higher with Weil
- Recognition
- Pale or dusky toes after tourniquet deflation; capillary refill greater than 3 seconds; pain out of proportion
- Prevention and management
- Minimise tourniquet time; check perfusion before closing; avoid over-shortening; careful K-wire placement. Remove K-wires immediately, warm and elevate; persistent ischaemia — exploration or primary amputation to prevent gangrene
- Incidence
- 5-10% long-term
- Recognition
- Progressive recurrence of hallux valgus or claw toe after initial satisfactory correction
- Prevention and management
- Optimise medical management of the underlying disease; solid first MTP fusion; adequate soft-tissue release. Revision surgery if symptomatic
- Incidence
- 2-10%
- Recognition
- Progressive collapse of the capital fragment; pain and stiffness; fragmentation at 6-12 weeks
- Prevention and management
- Preserve the plantar vascular pedicle; avoid over-manipulation of the fragment; single saw pass. If symptomatic with joint destruction, convert to Hoffmann-type resection
- Incidence
- 5-15%
- Recognition
- Toe sits elevated off the ground with no purchase during gait, usually after Hoffmann or aggressive Weil shortening
- Prevention and management
- Repair or reconstruct the plantar plate when possible; limit shortening to the minimum. Flexor tenodesis; refractory cases — ray amputation with transposition
Viva & Exam Focus
F.O.R.E.F.O.O.TFOREFOOT — recognising the rheumatoid forefoot
F.U.S.I.O.NFUSION — first MTP arthrodesis key points
Clinical Decision Scenarios
Practise clinical reasoning and management decisions out loud
“A 52-year-old woman with seropositive rheumatoid arthritis on adalimumab and methotrexate presents with progressive forefoot pain, hallux valgus of 35 degrees, and painful plantar callosities beneath the second and third metatarsal heads. Radiographs show first MTP joint destruction with erosions, dorsal subluxation of the second and third MTP joints, and periarticular osteopenia. She has failed 12 months of orthopaedic shoes and custom orthoses. She asks what surgery you would recommend.”
“You have just completed a first MTP arthrodesis with Hoffmann lesser metatarsal head resections for a 65-year-old woman with rheumatoid arthritis. After tourniquet deflation, you notice the second and third toes are pale with delayed capillary refill. What do you do?”
“A 58-year-old man with rheumatoid arthritis had a first MTP arthrodesis and lesser metatarsal Weil osteotomies 9 months ago. He presents with ongoing pain beneath the first MTP joint, worse with push-off. Radiographs show no bridging trabeculae at the fusion site with a visible radiolucent gap and a broken screw. How do you manage this?”
The rheumatoid forefoot triad
- Hallux valgus of the first ray — MTP synovitis, medial capsular failure, lateral deviation with medial bunion
- Dorsal subluxation or dislocation of the lesser MTP joints — collateral ligaments and plantar plate destroyed, extensor tendons subluxate dorsolaterally, toes claw
- Intractable plantar callosities beneath prominent metatarsal heads — displaced plantar fat pad exposes the heads to direct pressure
- Metatarsal parabola disruption — uneven lengths produce focal plantar pressure overload
First MTP arthrodesis — the keystone
- Gold standard for rheumatoid hallux valgus in ambulatory patients — replaces Keller excision arthroplasty
- Dorsomedial approach, 5-8 cm incision; protect the dorsalis pedis artery and deep peroneal nerve
- Fusion position: 15 degrees valgus, 10-15 degrees dorsiflexion relative to the FLOOR (not the metatarsal shaft), neutral rotation
- Fixation: pre-contoured dorsal plate plus interfragmentary lag screw; locking screws in poor bone
- Union rate 85-95%; nonunion 5-10% (risks: smoking, excessive resection, poor bone stock, inadequate fixation)
- Keller arthroplasty reserved for elderly, low-demand, non-ambulatory patients — causes weak hallux and transfer metatarsalgia
Lesser ray surgery
- Hoffmann procedure (head resection): for dislocated or severely destroyed MTP joints; resect 4-6 mm consistently across all rays
- Weil osteotomy (shortening): for subluxated but reducible MTP joints; dorsal oblique cut, proximal translation, screw fixation, dorsal shelf resection
- Avascular necrosis risk with Weil (2-10%); transfer metatarsalgia with both techniques (5-15%) if the parabola is not restored
- Floating toe common after Hoffmann; manage with flexor tenodesis or ray amputation if refractory
- Claw toe correction: PIP resection arthroplasty with longitudinal K-wire (4-6 weeks); flexor-to-extensor transfer for unstable MTP
Surgical anatomy — danger structures
- Dorsalis pedis artery: in the EHL–EDL interval; protect in ALL dorsal approaches; laceration compromises toe vascularity
- Deep peroneal nerve: lateral to the dorsalis pedis artery; supplies first-webspace sensation
- Sesamoid complex: preserve during first MTP preparation — loss removes the plantar fulcrum for push-off
- Medial dorsal cutaneous nerve: crosses the dorsomedial first MTP approach; injury causes medial hallux numbness
- Cervical spine: atlantoaxial subluxation in up to 30% of RA patients — flexion-extension films mandatory before any GA
Perioperative immunosuppression
- Methotrexate: generally CONTINUED perioperatively — withholding causes flare without reducing wound complications
- Biologics (TNF inhibitors, rituximab, tocilizumab): HOLD perioperatively in coordination with rheumatology — 2-3 half-lives before surgery
- Regional anaesthesia (spinal, popliteal block) PREFERRED — avoids cervical spine risk during intubation
- Wound healing: slow in steroid-dependent patients; minimise skin undermining, use longitudinal incisions, delay suture removal to 14-18 days
Complications
- Nonunion of first MTP (5-10%): broken screw is pathognomonic; revise with bone graft and new fixation; smoking is the major risk factor
- Transfer metatarsalgia (5-15%): the most common reason for reoperation; caused by uneven resection — intraoperative plantar palpation prevents it
- Wound breakdown (2-5%): higher when immunosuppressed; longitudinal incisions reduce risk; coordinate biologic management
- Toe ischaemia (less than 2%): remove K-wires first; if persistent, primary amputation is safer than waiting for gangrene
- Avascular necrosis of the capital fragment (2-10% with Weil): preserve the plantar vascular pedicle; convert to Hoffmann if symptomatic
- Recurrent deformity (5-10%): optimise DMARD or biologic management; revision surgery if symptomatic
Post-operative rehabilitation
- Weeks 0-6: strict non-weight-bearing in a below-knee cast boot; elevate for 48-72 hours; K-wires for 4-6 weeks
- Weeks 6-12: progressive weight-bearing as consolidation allows; transition to a wide supportive shoe
- 3-6 months: full recovery expected; persistent mild swelling common in rheumatoid patients for 6-9 months
- Long-term: custom orthoses with metatarsal support; wide, deep toe-box footwear; rocker-bottom sole
Background & Evidence
Epidemiology. Forefoot involvement is the most common foot presentation of rheumatoid arthritis and is frequently bilateral; the lesser MTP joints are the earliest sites of rheumatoid erosion in the foot. Deformity is most prevalent in long-standing seropositive disease and is the symptom complex — painful plantar callosities and deformed toes — that most often drives the patient to seek surgical reconstruction. Pathophysiology — the cascade of deformity. MTP synovitis is the initiating event: pannus erodes articular cartilage, distends the joint capsule, and destroys the collateral ligaments and plantar plate. Volar plate attenuation then allows the proximal phalanx to subluxate dorsally; the extensor tendons migrate dorsolaterally and reinforce the deformity. The MTP joint progresses from dorsal subluxation to dislocation — the proximal phalanx rides dorsally over the metatarsal head, the plantar fat pad is dragged distally with it, and the metatarsal head is exposed to direct plantar pressure, producing intractable keratoses. Loss of intrinsic stabilisation (interossei and lumbricals) produces the claw toe posture (MTP extension with PIP and DIP flexion). Hallux valgus of the first ray is driven by MTP synovitis and medial capsular failure, and the resulting first-ray instability transfers load to the lesser metatarsals, worsening the cycle. Surgical anatomy that matters. At the first MTP, the dorsalis pedis artery and deep peroneal nerve run in the EHL–EDL interval and must be protected on every dorsal approach; the sesamoid complex within the flexor hallucis brevis forms the plantar fulcrum for push-off and is preserved during arthrodesis preparation. Across the lesser rays, the metatarsal parabola — the second metatarsal longest with a symmetric decline to the fifth — distributes plantar pressure evenly and is the structure every lesser-ray operation must restore. The plantar fat pad, held by the plantar aponeurosis septa, is displaced distally by chronic MTP dislocation and is not fully restored by reconstruction. At the craniocervical junction, rheumatoid pannus destroys the transverse ligament (the primary restraint to anterior C1-on-C2 translation) in up to 30% of patients; granulomatous tissue around the odontoid can compress the cord, and neck extension at intubation narrows the canal further. Radiographic assessment. Weight-bearing AP, lateral and oblique views are mandatory. Measure the hallux valgus angle (pathological greater than 15-20 degrees), the intermetatarsal angle (pathological greater than 9-10 degrees), and the degree of lesser MTP subluxation (dislocation when greater than 75% of the proximal phalanx base lies dorsal to the metatarsal head). The lateral view shows dorsal subluxation, sesamoid position and first-ray dorsiflexion; the oblique view reveals lateral metatarsal head erosions and cysts. Arthrodesis versus Keller — the evidence. First MTP arthrodesis is the gold standard for the ambulatory rheumatoid patient: it restores a stable plantigrade medial column, corrects hallux valgus, and offloads the lesser rays, with sustained pain relief in 85-95%. Keller excision arthroplasty — resection of the metatarsal head and proximal half of the proximal phalanx — gives reliable pain relief but a shortened weak hallux, loss of push-off, and transfer metatarsalgia in 15-30%, and is reserved for elderly low-demand or non-ambulatory patients.
- First MTP Arthrodesis
- 85-95% long-term sustained
- Keller Arthroplasty
- 80-90%, may deteriorate with time
- First MTP Arthrodesis
- Restored — stable weight-bearing
- Keller Arthroplasty
- Lost — weak, shortened hallux
- First MTP Arthrodesis
- Low — first ray shares load
- Keller Arthroplasty
- 15-30% — first ray unloaded
- First MTP Arthrodesis
- Preserved or improved
- Keller Arthroplasty
- Significantly reduced
- First MTP Arthrodesis
- Improved — stable alignment
- Keller Arthroplasty
- Variable — short hallux may float
- First MTP Arthrodesis
- Nonunion 5-10%
- Keller Arthroplasty
- Transfer metatarsalgia, cock-up deformity
- First MTP Arthrodesis
- Ambulatory, functional patients
- Keller Arthroplasty
- Elderly, low-demand, non-ambulatory
Hoffmann versus Weil for the lesser rays. The choice rests on whether the lesser MTP joint is dislocated (Hoffmann) or subluxated-but-reducible (Weil). Hoffmann head resection is simple and reliable for advanced dislocation but sacrifices the joint and risks transfer lesions from uneven resection. Weil shortening preserves the articular surface and gives better motion in less severe disease, at the cost of avascular necrosis and stiffness.
- Hoffmann (Head Resection)
- Dislocated MTP joints, advanced disease
- Weil (Shortening Osteotomy)
- Subluxated but reducible MTP joints
- Hoffmann (Head Resection)
- No — head removed
- Weil (Shortening Osteotomy)
- Yes — capital fragment retained
- Hoffmann (Head Resection)
- Reliable — prominence removed
- Weil (Shortening Osteotomy)
- Reliable — pressure offloaded
- Hoffmann (Head Resection)
- 5-15% from over-resection
- Weil (Shortening Osteotomy)
- 5-10% from over-shortening
- Hoffmann (Head Resection)
- Not applicable
- Weil (Shortening Osteotomy)
- 2-10% of capital fragments
- Hoffmann (Head Resection)
- Common — no MTP joint
- Weil (Shortening Osteotomy)
- Moderate — stiffness
- Hoffmann (Head Resection)
- Moderate
- Weil (Shortening Osteotomy)
- High — precise osteotomy and fixation
- Hoffmann (Head Resection)
- 6-8 weeks
- Weil (Shortening Osteotomy)
- 6-8 weeks
References
Rheumatoid forefoot reconstruction: a long-term follow-up study
- Long-term follow-up of rheumatoid forefoot reconstruction combining first MTP arthrodesis with lesser metatarsal head resection in a consecutive series of patients
- First MTP arthrodesis provided sustained pain relief and functional improvement at long-term follow-up; hallux valgus correction was maintained
- Lesser metatarsal head resection effectively relieved plantar callosities, though transfer metatarsalgia was the most common reason for residual dissatisfaction
Arthrodesis of the first metatarsophalangeal joint for hallux valgus in rheumatoid arthritis
- Seminal series of first MTP arthrodesis in rheumatoid arthritis establishing the technique as a reliable and durable procedure for hallux valgus correction
- High fusion rate with consistent pain relief and improved ability to wear conventional shoes
- Demonstrated superiority of arthrodesis over excisional arthroplasty for functional rheumatoid patients
Weil's metatarsal osteotomy in the treatment of metatarsalgia
- Description and clinical application of the Weil metatarsal neck osteotomy for metatarsalgia and lesser ray deformity
- Demonstrated that controlled shortening of the lesser metatarsals through a dorsal oblique osteotomy with translation can restore the metatarsal parabola and relieve plantar pressure
- Highlighted the importance of consistent and symmetric shortening across rays to prevent transfer metatarsalgia
Rheumatoid forefoot deformity: a comparison study of 2 functional methods of reconstruction
- Comparative study of metatarsal head resection (Hoffmann) versus Weil dorsal closing wedge osteotomy for lesser ray correction in rheumatoid forefoot reconstruction
- Both techniques provided effective relief of plantar callosities, but the Weil osteotomy group had better MTP joint motion and lower rates of floating toe
- Transfer metatarsalgia occurred in both groups, more commonly with Hoffmann resection when the parabola was not adequately restored