Fracture Healing

Imaging Gallery

Click to expand

Click to expand

Click to expand

Overview Fracture healing is the process of bone regeneration. Unlike other tissues which heal by scar formation, bone heals by regeneration of normal tissue structure. It is a complex cascade of cellular and biochemical events that restores the integrity of the bone.

Primary (Direct) Healing

• Definition: Bone healing without callus formation.
• Prerequisites: Absolute Stability (Strain less than 2%) + Anatomic Reduction.
• Mechanism (Gap less than 0.01 mm): Cutting Cones (Osteoclasts bore tunnels, Osteoblasts fill with osteoid).
• Gap Mechanism (Gap less than 1 mm): Gap healing (Woven bone to Refined by Cutting Cones).

Secondary (Indirect) Healing

• Definition: The natural form of healing involving callus.
• Prerequisites: Relative Stability (Strain 2-10%) + Vitality.
• Phases:
  1. Inflammation: Hematoma, MSC recruitment.
  2. Soft Callus: Cartilage formation (Enchondral ossification).
  3. Hard Callus: Mineralization (Woven bone).
  4. Remodeling: Wolff's Law (Lamellar bone).

Biology of Bone Before understanding healing, one must understand the players.

Cellular Components

1. Osteoblasts ("Build"):
   • Secrete Osteoid (Type I Collagen) and regulate mineralization.
   • Express RANK-L to control osteoclasts.
   • Derived from Mesenchymal Stem Cells (MSCs).
2. Osteocytes ("Sense"):
   • Mechanosensors trapped in lacunae deep within the mineralized matrix.
   • Communicate via canaliculi.
   • Secrete Sclerostin (inhibits bone formation). Mechanical loading inhibits Sclerostin (allowing bone formation).
3. Osteoclasts ("Chew"):
   • Multinucleated giant cells derived from Monocyte/Macrophage lineage (Hematopoietic).
   • Resorb bone via acid secretion (HCL) and proteases (Cathepsin K).
   • Activated by RANK-L. Inhibited by OPG.

The Matrix

• Inorganic (65%): Hydroxyapatite (Calcium Phosphate crystals). Provides compressive strength.
• Organic (35%):
  • Collagen Type I (90%): Provides tensile strength. Triple helix structure.
  • Non-Collagenous Proteins: Osteocalcin (marker of turnover), Osteopontin (cell attachment), BMPs (growth factors).

Blood Supply

• Centrifugal Flow (Normal): Marrow → Cortex → Periosteum. (Inside to Outside).
• Centripetal Flow (Post-Fx): Periosteum → Cortex → Marrow. (Outside to Inside). The Periosteal blood supply becomes dominant after medullary disruption (e.g., reaming). This highlights the importance of preserving the soft tissue envelope (periosteum) during surgery.

Biophysics of Stimulation

• Piezoelectricity:
  • Stress on collagen generates electric potentials.
  • Compression side: Electronegative → Stimulates Osteoblasts (Bone Formation).
  • Tension side: Electropositive → Stimulates Osteoclasts (Bone Resorption).
• Streaming Potentials: Fluid flow in canaliculi stimulates osteocytes.

Biomechanics (Strain Theory)

Perren's Strain Theory: Tissues can only exist if they can withstand the strain of the gap.

• Strain Formula: Change in Gap / Original Gap.
• Bone: Ruptures at 2% Strain.
• Cartilage/Granulation: Tolerates greater than 10% Strain.
• Conclusion: To form bone (Primary), strain must be less than 2%. To heal via callus (Secondary), granulation tissue first stiffens the gap, reducing strain to allow cartilage, then bone.

History

• Pain: Resolution of pain is the first sign of union.
• Function: Ability to weight bear. Return to activities of daily living.
• Risk Factors: Ask about smoking, diabetes, steroid use, NSAIDs.

Physical Exam

• Tenderness: No tenderness at fracture site (Clinical Union).
• Motion: No abnormal mobility (Clinical Union).
• Stress: Painless stressing of the fracture.
• Soft Tissue: Assess status of the envelope (healed wounds, skin grafts).

Click to expand

Click to expand

Radiographic Assessment (RUST Score)

• Radiographic Union Scale for Tibial fractures (RUST).
• Methodology: Review AP and Lateral X-rays. Identify the 4 cortices (Anterior, Posterior, Medial, Lateral).
• Scoring Per Cortex:
  • 1 Point: Fracture line visible, No callus. (Unhealed)
  • 2 Points: Fracture line visible, Callus present. (Healing)
  • 3 Points: Fracture line invisible, Bridging callus. (Healed)
• Interpretation:
  • Minimum Score: 4 (Unhealed).
  • Maximum Score: 12 (Fully United).
  • clinical Definition of Union: Score of greater than 10 usually correlates with mechanical stability and ability to weight bear without pain.
• General Signs: Bridging bone on 3 of 4 cortices. Blurring of fracture line. Remember: X-rays lag behind clinical signs.

Assessment of Non-Union

• CT Scan: Gold standard to assess bridging. Can differentiate bony union from fibrous non-union.
• Labs: Vitamin D, PTH, Calcium, ESR/CRP (Infection).
• MRI: Assessing infection (osteomyelitis) vs sterile non-union.

Biomaterials and Healing The stiffness of the implant dictates the strain at the fracture site.

• Stress Shielding: If an implant is too stiff (e.g., thick steel plate), it takes all the load. The bone beneath it senses no load (strain less than 2%) but also no "need" for strength. This causes bone resorption (Wolff's Law in reverse) and porosis under the plate.
• Titanium: Being less stiff (closer to bone), it allows some load transfer, reducing stress shielding.
• Carbon Fiber: Even closer modulus to bone. Used in oncology (radiolucent).

Casting Principles

• Three-Point Molding: To maintain reduction, pressure must be applied at the apex of the curve and counter-pressure at the proximal/distal ends.
• Functional Bracing (Sarmiento):
  • Allows joint motion.
  • Hydrostatic containment of soft tissues stabilizes the fracture.
  • Micro-motion stimulates callus (Secondary Healing).
  • Common for: Humeral shaft, Tibial shaft.

When biology is poor (Atrophic Non-union), we augment it.

Bone Grafts

1. Autograft (Self):
   • Source: Iliac Crest (Gold Standard), RIA (Reamer Irrigator Aspirator - Femur).
   • Properties: Osteogenic (Cells) + Osteoinductive (Signals) + Osteoconductive (Scaffold).
   • Cons: Donor site morbidity (pain, infection, nerve injury).
2. Allograft (Cadaver):
   • Source: Bone bank (structural struts or morcellized chips).
   • Properties: Osteoconductive strictly. (No cells, minimal signals).
   • Cons: Disease transmission (rare 1 in 1 million), slower incorporation, immune reaction (minor).
3. Synthetics (Ceramics/TCP):
   • Properties: Osteoconductive (Scaffold).
   • Cons: Brittle, expensive, can cause seroma.

Growth Factors

• BMP-2 (Infuse):
  • Potent Osteoinductor. Indicated for Acute Open Tibia fractures.
  • Mechanism: Recruits MSCs to differentiate into osteoblasts.
  • Risks: Swelling (C-spine airway compromise), Heterotopic ossification, Cost.
• BMP-7 (OP-1): Historic use for non-unions.
• PRP/BMAC: Bone Marrow Aspirate Concentrate. Rich in MSCs and growth factors (PDGF, TGF-beta).

Healing does not always go to plan.

1. Delayed Union

• Definition: Healing that takes longer than expected for the specific fracture and host (typically 3-6 months), but is still progressing.
• Management:
  • Conservative: Functional bracing, LIPUS (Low Intensity Pulsed Ultrasound), Nutrition.
  • Surgical: Dynamization (remove locking screws) to increase load/strain.

2. Non-Union

• Definition: Failure to heal by 6-9 months, or no progression on X-rays for 3 consecutive months (FDA definition).
• Types:
  • Septic Non-Union: Infection until proven otherwise. Check CRP/ESR. MRI.
  • Hypertrophic: Good Biology, Poor Stability. (Needs Stability). Elephant Foot appearance.
  • Atrophic: Poor Biology. (Needs Biology + Stability). Pencil Tip appearance.
  • Oligotrophic: Intermediate.
• Workup:
  • History: Smoking, Diabetes, NSAIDs.
  • Exam: Mobility at fracture site? Sinus?
  • Imaging: CT Scan (Gold Standard for union).
  • Labs: Infection markers, Vitamin D, Ca/PO4, PTH.

3. Malunion

• Definition: Healed but in a non-anatomic position.
• Parameters: Shortening, Rotation, Angulation.
• Tolerance:
  • Humeral Shaft: Tolerates huge deformity (20 deg angulation, 3cm shortening).
  • Forearm: Zero tolerance (loss of pronation/supination).
  • Tibia: Tolerates minimal varus/valgus (less than 5 deg).

4. Synostosis

• Definition: Fusion between two adjacent bones (e.g., Radius/Ulna, Tibia/Fibula).
• Cause: Disruption of Interosseous Membrane (IOM) + High Energy + Same approach (single incision).
• Consequence: Loss of rotation (Forearm).

Planning for Union

• Patient: Stop smoking, Optimize diabetes, Nutrition.
• Implant: Choose load-sharing (Nail) vs load-bearing (Plate) based on fracture pattern and soft tissue.
• Biology: Preserve soft tissue (Open reduction vs Closed).

Early Phase (0-2 weeks)

• Elevation: Reduce edema.
• Motion: Early ROM (if fixation allows) to prevent stiffness and stimulate blood flow.
• Review: Wound check.

Middle Phase (2-6 weeks)

• Loading: Proprioceptive weight bearing. Wolff's law stimulation.
• X-rays: Check alignment and maintenance of reduction.

Late Phase (6-12 weeks)

• Strengthening: Restore muscle mass.
• Full Weight Bearing: When hard callus visible (3/4 cortices).

Time to Union (Average)

• Upper Limb: 6-8 weeks.
• Lower Limb: 12-16 weeks.
• Tibia: Slowest bone to heal (poor blood supply). 16-20 weeks common for open fractures.

Non-Union Rates

• Tibia: 10-15% (especially open). The most common long bone non-union.
• Femur: 1-2% (with IM nail). Success story of modern orthopaedics.
• Clavicle: 5-10% (conservative).
• Scaphoid: High rate due to retrograde blood supply.

Factors Predicting Poor Outcome

• Smoking (Odds ratio greater than 3).
• Open fracture (Gustilo III).
• Infection.
• NSAID use (Prolonged).

Key Differences

1. Speed: Heals twice as fast. High osteogenic potential of thick, vascular periosteum.
2. Remodeling Potential:
   • Can correct Angulation (in plane of motion).
   • Cannot correct Rotation.
   • Overgrowth: Femur fractures stimulate growth (1-2cm leg length discrepancy common) due to hyperemia.
3. Physeal Injuries:
   • Growth arrest (Physeal bar) → Deformity.
   • Salter-Harris Classification.

Children are not just small adults.

Historical Evolution

1. Ancient Era: Splinting and casting (Egyptians).
2. 1950s (AO Foundation):
   • Founded by Mueller, Allgower, et al.
   • Emphasis on Anatomic Reduction and Rigid Fixation.
   • Result: Primary healing, but high non-union rate due to biological stripping.
3. 1990s (Biological Fixation):
   • Shift to MIPO (Minimally Invasive Plate Osteosynthesis) and IM Nails.
   • Emphasis on Biology (Blood supply) over Anatomy.
   • Acceptance of secondary healing (Callus).
4. Future: Gene therapy (BMP), 3D printed scaffolds, Stem Cells.
   • Gene Therapy: Viral vectors delivering BMP-2 genes to local cells.
   • 3D Printing: Custom scaffolds matching the defect, seeded with MSCs.
   • Biophysical Stimulation:
     • LIPUS: Low Intensity Pulsed Ultrasound. Mechanical vibration stimulates integrins.
     • PEMF: Pulsed Electromagnetic Fields. Induces electrical currents (streaming potentials) to stimulate calcification. NOTE: Contraindicated in patients with pacemakers.

The Tibial Shaft (The "Unforgiving Bone")

• Anatomy: One third is subcutaneous (anteromedial surface). Poor blood supply.
• Healing: Slow (16-20 weeks).
• Management: IM Nail (standard) vs Plate (distal/proximal).
• Pearl: Reamed nailing creates a "bonfire" of growth factors and autograft.

The Scaphoid (Retrograde Flow)

• Anatomy: Blood enters distal pole. Proximal pole depends on intraosseous flow.
• Risk: Proximal pole fracture → Avascular Necrosis (AVN).
• Healing: Compression screw (Herbert screw) buried in bone.

The Clavicle (S-Shaped Strut)

• Anatomy: Membranous bone formation (unique).

• Malunion: Shortening greater than 2cm affects shoulder biomechanics (scapular dyskinesis).

• Non-Union: Atrophic common in smokers.

• Non-Union: Atrophic common in smokers.

The Femoral Neck (Intracapsular)

• Anatomy: Synovial fluid washes away hematoma (no clot = no callus).
• Result: Must heal by Primary Healing (Compression).
• Risk: AVN due to medial circumflex artery damage.

The Humeral Shaft (Holing Time)

• Healing: Typically 8-12 weeks.
• Acceptance: Accepts up to 20 degrees anterior angulation and 30 degrees varus/valgus due to shoulder range of motion compensation.
• Nerve: Radial nerve palsy (Holstein-Lewis fracture in distal third). 90% resolve spontaneously. Watch and wait for 3 months if closed injury.

The Distal Radius (Colles)

• Healing: 6 weeks for bony union.
• Remodeling: Limited in adults. Malunion (shortening) leads to ulnar impaction syndrome.
• Management: Volar locking plate allows early motion.

The Ankle (Weber B)

• Mortise: 1mm shift = 42% decrease in contact area.
• Healing: 6 weeks NWB (Syndesmosis) or 2 weeks NWB then boot (stable).
• Risk: Post-traumatic arthritis if articular step greater than 2mm.

The Pelvis (Ring)

• Healing: Cancellous bone heals fast (6-8 weeks).
• Weight Bearing: Depends on posterior ring stability (Sacrum/SIJ).
• Complication: Venous Thromboembolism (highest risk in orthopaedics).

The Fifth Metatarsal (Jones Fracture)

• Zone 2: Metaphyseal-Diaphyseal junction.
• Physics: Adductor longus traction creates tension side failure.
• Healing: Poor blood supply. High non-union rate.
• Management: Screw fixation often required for athletes.

• Bone Stimulators (LIPUS): Not subsidized by PBS/Medicare generally, but available privately (approx $4000). Evidence is weak (TRUST Trial showed no benefit).
• BMPs: Indication specific (Open Tibia) via PBS Authority. Requires specialist approval.
• Smoking Cessation:
  • Quitline (13 7848): Referral service for counseling.
  • PBS Pharmacotherapy:
    • Nicotine Replacement Therapy (NRT).
    • Varenicline (Champix) - currently unavailable/restricted.
    • Bupropion (Zyban).
  • Pre-Operative: Elective osteotomies/fusions should be delayed until 6 weeks of cessation confirmed (COTININE urine test).

The Next Frontier The future of fracture healing lies in targeted biological intervention.

• Personalized Medicine: Genetic profiling for non-union risk.
• Smart Implants: Sensors embedded in plates to measure strain and notify patients when to weight bear.
• Bio-printing: 3D printed vascularized bone grafts.