Metastatic Bone Disease
Most Common Bone Malignancy
Common Primary Tumors
Critical Must-Knows
- BPLTK Primaries: Breast (female), Prostate (male), Lung (poor prognosis), Thyroid, Kidney.
- Mirels Score: 4 parameters (Site, Pain, Lesion, Size) - above 8 needs prophylactic fixation.
- Blastic Metastases: Prostate (most), breast (treated), small cell lung.
- Lytic Metastases: Kidney, thyroid, lung - structurally weaker.
- Vascular Tumors: Kidney and thyroid - MUST embolize before surgery.
Examiner's Pearls
- "BPLTK for common primaries
- "Mirels above 8 = prophylactic fixation
- "Kidney and thyroid are VASCULAR - embolize
- "Blastic = prostate; Lytic = kidney
- "Surgical goal is PALLIATION, not cure
Clinical Imaging
Imaging Gallery




Mirels Score is the Key Exam Concept
Mirels Score predicts pathological fracture risk.
- 4 Parameters: Site (upper/lower/peritrochanteric), Pain (mild/moderate/functional), Lesion (blastic/mixed/lytic), Size (under 1/3, 1/3-2/3, over 2/3 cortex).
- Score 1-3 for each (total range 4-12).
- Score above 8: Greater than 33% fracture risk → PROPHYLACTIC FIXATION indicated.
- Score 9+: Greater than 50% fracture risk → DEFINITE fixation.
- Peritrochanteric location and lytic lesions score highest risk.
Mirels Scoring System
| Parameter | Score 1 | Score 2 | Score 3 |
|---|---|---|---|
| Upper limb | Lower limb | Peritrochanteric | |
| Mild (not affected by activity) | Moderate (some relief with rest) | Functional (pain with weight-bearing) | |
| Blastic (sclerotic) | Mixed | Lytic (destructive) | |
| Under 1/3 diameter | 1/3 to 2/3 diameter | Over 2/3 diameter |
Mirels 7 or Under
Mirels 8
Mirels 9+
Vascular Tumors
At a Glance
Metastatic bone disease is the most common malignancy affecting bone, far exceeding primary bone tumors. The BPLTK primaries (Breast, Prostate, Lung, Thyroid, Kidney) account for most cases, with metastases preferentially affecting the axial skeleton following red marrow distribution. The Mirels scoring system predicts pathological fracture risk using 4 parameters (Site, Pain, Lesion type, Size)—scores greater than 8 indicate prophylactic fixation due to greater than 33% fracture risk. Blastic lesions suggest prostate (most common), while lytic lesions (kidney, thyroid, lung) are structurally weaker. Kidney and thyroid metastases are highly vascular and require preoperative embolization. Management is palliative with durable constructs allowing immediate weight-bearing.
Common Primaries - BPLTK
Memory Hook:BPLTK (Bad Places Leak To Kidneys) - the 5 common primaries that metastasize to bone.
Mirels Score - SPLS
Memory Hook:SPLS - Site, Pain, Lesion, Size. Above 8 = Fix, above 9 = Definitely fix.
Blastic vs Lytic - PBS
Memory Hook:PBS (Prostate, Breast, Small cell) make bone STRONGER (blastic). Everything else is LYTIC and weak.
Vascular Metastases - TK
Memory Hook:TK (Total Knockout) - Thyroid and Kidney will knock you out with blood loss. Embolize 24-48h before surgery.
Overview and Epidemiology
Metastatic bone disease is the most common malignancy affecting bone, far exceeding primary bone tumors in frequency.
Epidemiology
- Incidence: 25-30x more common than primary bone tumors
- Prevalence: Found at autopsy in 70-85% of patients with breast/prostate cancer
- Age: Typically middle-aged to elderly (reflecting primary cancer demographics)
- Impact: 350,000-400,000 people living with bone metastases in USA
Common Primary Tumors (BPLTK)
- Breast: Most common source overall and in women
- Prostate: Most common source in men
- Lung: Third most common; poor prognosis
- Thyroid: Differentiated carcinoma has better prognosis
- Kidney: Renal cell carcinoma; very vascular
Less Common Primaries
- Gastrointestinal (colon, stomach)
- Bladder
- Melanoma
- Unknown primary (10-15% of cases)
Distribution (Red Marrow Distribution)
- Spine: 70% - most common site (thoracic greater than lumbar greater than cervical)
- Pelvis: 40%
- Proximal Femur: 25%
- Ribs: 25%
- Skull: 15%
- Proximal Humerus: 15%
Pathophysiology
Mechanisms of Bone Metastasis
Metastatic Cascade:
- Primary Tumor Growth: Cancer cells proliferate in organ of origin
- Local Invasion: Tumor penetrates basement membrane
- Intravasation: Entry into bloodstream or lymphatics
- Circulation: Survival in circulation (most cells die)
- Extravasation: Exit from vessels at distant site
- Colonization: Establish growth in bone microenvironment
Why Bone?
- Hematogenous Spread: Most common route to bone
- Batson's Venous Plexus: Valveless vertebral venous system allows retrograde flow
- Explains predilection for spine and axial skeleton
- Low-pressure system facilitates tumor cell lodging
- Red Marrow Distribution: Sites with active hematopoiesis
- Rich blood supply
- Growth factors present
- Supportive microenvironment
The Vicious Cycle
Seed and Soil Hypothesis (Paget 1889): Cancer cells (seed) preferentially grow in bone microenvironment (soil)
The Cycle:
- Tumor cells arrive in bone marrow
- Tumor cells secrete factors (PTHrP, IL-6, TNF) → stimulate osteoclasts
- Osteoclasts resorb bone → release growth factors (TGF-β, IGF, BMPs)
- Growth factors stimulate tumor → more factor secretion
- Cycle perpetuates → progressive bone destruction
Lytic vs Blastic Metastases
Lytic Lesions (Bone Destruction):
- Kidney, thyroid, lung
- Osteoclast activation dominant
- Structurally weak bone
- High fracture risk
- Mechanisms: PTHrP, IL-1, IL-6, TNF-α
Blastic Lesions (Bone Formation):
- Prostate (most), treated breast, small cell lung
- Osteoblast activation dominant
- Dense but disorganized bone (structurally weak)
- Lower fracture risk
- Mechanisms: Endothelin-1, BMPs, Wnt signaling
Mixed Lesions:
- Breast (untreated), GI cancers
- Both processes active
Role of RANK/RANKL Pathway
- RANK: Receptor on osteoclast precursors
- RANKL: Ligand secreted by osteoblasts and tumor cells
- RANKL binding to RANK: Osteoclast activation and differentiation
- OPG (osteoprotegerin): Decoy receptor, inhibits RANKL
- Therapeutic target: Denosumab (RANKL inhibitor)
Clinical Features
History
- Known Cancer: 85% have known primary at presentation
- Unknown Primary: 15% bone metastasis is first presentation of cancer
- Pain: Most common symptom
- Night pain (classic)
- Activity-related (mechanical instability)
- Rest pain (tumor growth)
- Pathological Fracture: May be presenting feature
- Neurological: Spinal cord compression (weakness, sensory changes, bladder/bowel)
- Constitutional: Weight loss, fatigue, anorexia
Physical Examination
Examination Approach
-
Local Assessment
- Point tenderness over lesion
- Palpable mass (large lesions)
- Surrounding soft tissue swelling
-
Fracture Assessment
- Deformity, shortening
- Inability to weight-bear
- Crepitus (do not elicit if suspected)
-
Neurological Assessment (Spine)
- Motor: Power in myotomes
- Sensory: Dermatomal distribution
- Reflexes: Hyperreflexia (UMN) or hyporeflexia
- Bladder/bowel function
- Rectal tone, perianal sensation
-
Systemic Assessment
- Breast examination
- Prostate examination (DRE)
- Thyroid palpation
- Lymphadenopathy
- Abdominal masses
- General condition, performance status
Red Flags for Cord Compression
- New back pain in cancer patient
- Bilateral leg symptoms
- Bladder/bowel dysfunction
- Progressive weakness
- Sensory level
Spinal Cord Compression - Oncological Emergency
Metastatic spinal cord compression is an EMERGENCY. Early recognition critical as neurological recovery correlates with pre-treatment function. MRI whole spine urgently. High-dose dexamethasone, urgent oncology/spinal referral for decompression/radiation.
Investigations
Imaging
Plain Radiographs:
- First-line investigation
- Lytic (dark, destructive) vs Blastic (white, sclerotic) vs Mixed
- Need 30-50% cortical destruction to be visible
- Assess fracture risk, deformity
CT Scan:
- Better cortical assessment than X-ray
- Quantify bone destruction
- CT chest/abdomen/pelvis for staging
- CT-guided biopsy planning
MRI:
- Most sensitive for marrow involvement
- Essential for spinal metastases
- Assesses soft tissue extension
- Whole spine MRI if cord compression suspected
Bone Scintigraphy (Bone Scan):
- Whole-body screening
- Highly sensitive but low specificity
- May miss pure lytic lesions (kidney, myeloma)
- Superscan = widespread metastases
PET-CT:
- Increasingly used for staging
- Assesses metabolic activity
- Helps identify unknown primary
- Monitors treatment response
Laboratory Investigations
- Full Blood Count: Anaemia, pancytopenia (marrow infiltration)
- Biochemistry: Calcium (hypercalcemia), ALP (elevated), LDH
- Tumor Markers: PSA (prostate), CEA (GI, breast), AFP (germ cell), thyroglobulin
- Serum/Urine Protein Electrophoresis: Exclude myeloma
- Iron Studies: Chronic disease pattern
Biopsy
Indications:
- Unknown primary tumor
- Solitary lesion (could be primary bone tumor)
- Atypical presentation
- Clinical doubt about diagnosis
Technique:
- Image-guided core needle biopsy (preferred)
- Align biopsy tract with potential surgical approach
- Tissue for histology, immunohistochemistry, molecular studies
Exam Pearl
A solitary bone lesion in a patient with known cancer is NOT always metastatic. 10% of solitary lesions in cancer patients are primary bone tumors or benign. Biopsy if any doubt.
Management

Management Principles
Goals of Treatment:
- Palliation - NOT cure
- Pain relief
- Restore/maintain function
- Prevent pathological fracture
- Improve quality of life
- Durable solution (patient may outlive implant)
Multidisciplinary Approach:
- Medical oncology
- Radiation oncology
- Orthopaedic surgery
- Palliative care
- Pain management
- Physiotherapy
Factors Affecting Treatment:
- Primary tumor type and responsiveness
- Expected survival
- Performance status
- Extent of metastatic disease
- Fracture risk (Mirels score)
- Patient wishes
Complications
Skeletal-Related Events (SREs)
Definition: Major complications from bone metastases requiring intervention
Types of SREs:
- Pathological Fracture: Most common SRE
- Spinal Cord Compression: Neurological emergency
- Bone Pain Requiring Radiation: Severe uncontrolled pain
- Hypercalcemia of Malignancy: Metabolic emergency
- Surgery to Bone: Stabilization or reconstruction
Pathological Fracture
Incidence: 10-30% of patients with bone metastases
Risk Factors:
- Lytic lesions (higher risk than blastic)
- Large lesion size (greater than 2/3 cortex)
- Peritrochanteric location
- Weight-bearing bones
- Mirels score above 8
Management:
- Urgent surgical stabilization
- Durable construct allowing immediate weight-bearing
- Post-operative radiation
- Worse outcomes than prophylactic fixation
Spinal Cord Compression
Oncological Emergency - Time-sensitive intervention
Incidence: 5-10% of cancer patients
Clinical Features:
- Back pain (95% - often first symptom)
- Motor weakness (75%)
- Sensory changes (50%)
- Bladder/bowel dysfunction (50%)
- Ambulatory status predicts outcome
Management:
- High-dose dexamethasone (10mg IV, then 16mg daily)
- Urgent MRI whole spine
- Neurosurgical/spinal consult
- Decompression + stabilization vs radiation
- HOURS matter - neurological recovery correlates with pre-treatment function
Prognostic Factors:
- Pre-treatment ambulatory status (most important)
- Time to develop motor deficit
- Extent of cord compression
- Primary tumor type
Hypercalcemia of Malignancy
Metabolic Emergency
Mechanism:
- Osteoclastic bone resorption (lytic metastases)
- PTHrP secretion by tumor (humoral)
- Vitamin D production (lymphoma)
Clinical Features:
- Confusion, lethargy
- Nausea, vomiting, constipation
- Polyuria, polydipsia
- Dehydration
- Cardiac arrhythmias
Management:
- IV hydration (4-6L normal saline)
- Bisphosphonates (zoledronic acid)
- Calcitonin (rapid but short-lived effect)
- Denosumab if bisphosphonates fail
- Treat underlying cancer
Bone Pain
Impact:
- Occurs in 75% of patients with bone metastases
- Severe impact on quality of life
- Limits mobility and function
Mechanisms:
- Periosteal stretching
- Microfractures
- Tumor growth
- Inflammatory mediators
- Nerve compression
Management:
- WHO pain ladder (simple analgesics → opioids)
- Radiation therapy (80% response rate)
- Bisphosphonates/denosumab
- Interventional pain management
- Neurolytic procedures for refractory pain
Surgical Complications
Intraoperative:
- Massive hemorrhage (especially kidney/thyroid)
- Cement extravasation
- Neurovascular injury
- Fat embolism
Post-operative:
- Wound complications (15-20%)
- Infection (5-10% - higher than non-cancer surgery)
- Implant failure
- Local tumor progression
- DVT/PE (high risk population)
Minimizing Complications:
- Preoperative embolization (vascular tumors)
- Meticulous surgical technique
- Adequate bone cement use
- Post-operative radiation
- DVT prophylaxis
- Multidisciplinary approach
Long-term Complications
Radiation Effects:
- Impaired fracture healing
- Radiation-induced fractures (rare)
- Soft tissue fibrosis
Bone-Targeted Agent Toxicity:
- Osteonecrosis of jaw (ONJ): 1-2% risk
- Atypical femur fractures (rare)
- Renal impairment (bisphosphonates)
Disease Progression:
- Local recurrence despite treatment
- New skeletal lesions
- Visceral metastases
- Declining performance status
Special Considerations
Unknown Primary
- 10-15% of bone metastases have no known primary
- Workup: CT CAP, PET, tumor markers, serum/urine electrophoresis
- Biopsy essential for diagnosis and treatment planning
- Immunohistochemistry directs investigation
Solitary Metastasis
- May represent oligometastatic disease
- Consider aggressive local treatment
- Wide resection + adjuvant therapy in selected cases
- Better prognosis than polymetastatic disease
Renal Cell Carcinoma (Special Case)
- Very vascular - MUST embolize
- May be radiosensitive (modern targeted therapy)
- Solitary metastasis: Consider nephrectomy + metastasectomy
- Targeted therapy (TKIs, immunotherapy) have improved outcomes
Pathological Fracture vs Impending Fracture
- Actual fracture: Fix urgently, control pain
- Impending fracture: Elective prophylactic fixation
- Better outcomes with prophylactic surgery than fracture fixation
Evidence Base
- Developed scoring system for pathological fracture risk
- 4 parameters: Site, Pain, Lesion, Size
- Score above 8 correlates with 33% fracture risk
- Widely adopted as clinical decision-making tool
- Validated Mirels criteria
- Sensitivity 91%, specificity 35%
- High sensitivity - good for ruling out fracture risk
- Low specificity - over-predicts fracture risk
- Multidisciplinary approach essential
- Prophylactic fixation better outcomes than fracture fixation
- Bisphosphonates/denosumab reduce skeletal events
- Radiation improves local control
- Embolization reduces blood loss by 50-80%
- Kidney and thyroid metastases most vascular
- Optimal timing 24-48 hours before surgery
- Low complication rate in experienced hands
- Denosumab superior to zoledronic acid for preventing skeletal events
- 18% relative risk reduction
- Similar rates of ONJ
- Subcutaneous administration more convenient
Viva Scenarios
Practice these scenarios to excel in your viva examination
Impending Pathological Fracture
"A 68-year-old woman with breast cancer presents with painful right thigh. X-ray shows a large lytic lesion in the proximal femur involving 60% of the cortex. She has functional pain on weight-bearing. Mirels score is 9."
Diagnosis: This is a metastatic breast cancer lesion with high risk of pathological fracture (Mirels score 9). The Mirels parameters are: Site (peritrochanteric = 3), Pain (functional = 3), Lesion (lytic = 3), Size (over 2/3 diameter would be 3, but she has 60% which is 2/3 so = 2).
Mirels Score Calculation:
- Site: Lower limb = 2 (or peritrochanteric = 3)
- Pain: Functional = 3
- Lesion: Lytic = 3
- Size: 60% = 1/3-2/3 = 2
- Total = 9-10 (above 8 = prophylactic fixation indicated)
Management:
- Staging: CT CAP, bone scan if not recent
- MDT Discussion: Oncology, radiation, surgical planning
- Surgical Options:
- If femoral head/neck spared: Cephalomedullary nail (long, protects whole femur)
- If head/neck involved: Endoprosthetic replacement (long-stem cemented prosthesis)
- Post-op: Radiation to lesion for local control
- Systemic: Continue oncological management
Key Principles: Goal is palliation - pain relief, immediate weight-bearing, durable construct. Prophylactic fixation has better outcomes than waiting for fracture.
Vascular Metastasis
"A 72-year-old man with known renal cell carcinoma has a painful proximal humerus lesion. X-ray shows a large lytic lesion. You're planning surgery. What additional steps are needed?"
Key Issue: Renal cell carcinoma is HIGHLY VASCULAR. Without preoperative embolization, there is risk of massive intraoperative hemorrhage.
Preoperative Preparation:
- EMBOLIZATION - MANDATORY for RCC
- Timing: 24-48 hours before surgery
- Interventional radiology referral
- Selective embolization of feeding vessels
- Blood bank: Cross-match adequate blood products
Staging Workup:
- CT CAP - assess extent of disease, other metastases
- Is primary tumor controlled? Nephrectomy status?
- PET scan if staging unclear
- Oncology input - targeted therapy options (TKIs, immunotherapy)
Surgical Planning:
- Options: Endoprosthetic replacement vs reconstruction nail
- Depends on extent of bone destruction
- If large defect: Endoprosthetic reconstruction
- If small lesion: Nail with cement augmentation
- Cell saver NOT recommended (tumor cells)
Post-operative:
- Radiation therapy
- Systemic therapy as per oncology
- Surveillance imaging
Unknown Primary with Bone Metastasis
"A 65-year-old man presents with back pain and pathological fracture of L3. No cancer history. X-ray shows lytic destruction. How would you investigate and manage?"
Diagnosis: This is a pathological fracture from presumed metastatic disease with unknown primary. Approximately 10-15% of bone metastases present without known primary.
Urgent Assessment:
- Neurological status: Is there cord compression?
- If neurological deficit: EMERGENCY MRI, high-dose dexamethasone, urgent decompression
- If neurologically intact: Can proceed with workup
Investigations to Find Primary:
- History and Exam: Smoking, weight loss, GI symptoms, breast exam, DRE
- Bloods: PSA (prostate), CEA (GI), AFP (germ cell), thyroglobulin, serum/urine electrophoresis (myeloma)
- CT CAP: Chest, abdomen, pelvis - most common primaries
- PET-CT: If CT negative - highly sensitive for occult primary
- Bone scan: Assess for other skeletal metastases
- Biopsy: CT-guided core biopsy of vertebral lesion
Biopsy Importance:
- Guides systemic treatment
- Could be lymphoma (non-surgical management)
- Could be myeloma (different workup)
- Immunohistochemistry helps identify primary
Management:
- If stable and awaiting diagnosis: Bracing, analgesia
- If unstable or neurological compromise: Surgical stabilization
- Once primary identified: Systemic therapy, radiation, MDT approach
MCQ Practice Points
Exam Pearl
Q: Which primary cancers most commonly metastasize to bone? A: Breast, prostate, lung, thyroid, and kidney (mnemonic: "BLT with a Kosher Pickle"). These five primaries account for over 80% of skeletal metastases. Breast and prostate are the most common sources overall.
Exam Pearl
Q: What Mirels score indicates prophylactic fixation is recommended? A: Score of 9 or greater (out of 12) indicates prophylactic fixation. Mirels scoring assesses site, pain, lesion type (lytic/blastic/mixed), and size. A score of 8 has approximately 15% fracture risk, while 9 or above has greater than 33% risk.
Exam Pearl
Q: Which primary tumors typically produce osteoblastic (sclerotic) metastases? A: Prostate and breast cancer. Prostate is classically blastic (98% blastic), while breast can be lytic, blastic, or mixed. Lung, thyroid, and renal metastases are typically lytic. Multiple myeloma is also purely lytic.
Exam Pearl
Q: What is the mechanism of action of denosumab in treating bone metastases? A: RANKL inhibitor (monoclonal antibody). By blocking RANKL, denosumab prevents osteoclast activation and bone resorption. Unlike bisphosphonates, it is not renally excreted so is safer in renal impairment.
Australian Context
Metastatic bone disease management in Australia follows a multidisciplinary team approach as standard at major cancer centers. Bone-targeted agents (bisphosphonates, denosumab) are PBS-listed for bone metastases. Most bone metastasis surgery is performed at tertiary centers with access to interventional radiology for preoperative embolization.
The Cancer Council Australia (COSA) guidelines emphasize early orthopaedic referral for high-risk lesions and integration of palliative care. PET-CT is increasingly used for staging. Indigenous Australians may have higher rates of late presentation due to limited access to specialist services in remote areas, making cultural considerations important in end-of-life care planning.
METASTATIC BONE DISEASE
High-Yield Exam Summary
COMMON PRIMARIES - BPLTK
- •Breast - most common female, responsive, years survival
- •Prostate - most common male, BLASTIC, indolent
- •Lung - poor prognosis, months survival
- •Thyroid - VASCULAR, embolize, good if differentiated
- •Kidney - VASCULAR, embolize, targeted therapy
MIRELS SCORE
- •Site: Upper (1), Lower (2), Peritroch (3)
- •Pain: Mild (1), Moderate (2), Functional (3)
- •Lesion: Blastic (1), Mixed (2), Lytic (3)
- •Size: Under 1/3 (1), 1/3-2/3 (2), Over 2/3 (3)
- •SCORE ABOVE 8 = PROPHYLACTIC FIXATION
BLASTIC vs LYTIC
- •BLASTIC: Prostate (most), breast (treated), small cell
- •Blastic = dense but disorganized bone (still weak)
- •LYTIC: Kidney, thyroid, lung, most others
- •Lytic = structurally weaker = higher fracture risk
VASCULAR - EMBOLIZE
- •Kidney and Thyroid = VASCULAR
- •MUST embolize 24-48 hours before surgery
- •Reduces blood loss 50-80%
- •Cell saver contraindicated in malignancy
SURGICAL PRINCIPLES
- •Goal = PALLIATION (not cure)
- •Immediate weight-bearing
- •Durable construct
- •Protect entire bone (long nail)
- •Post-op radiation for local control
PROXIMAL FEMUR OPTIONS
- •Head/neck spared: Cephalomedullary nail (long)
- •Head/neck involved: Endoprosthetic replacement
- •Long-stem cemented prosthesis
- •Cement augmentation for defects
MEDICAL MANAGEMENT
- •Bisphosphonates or Denosumab reduce skeletal events
- •Radiation for pain (80% response)
- •Systemic therapy based on primary
- •MDT approach essential