Arthroplasty Imaging: Assessment & Complications

Why zones. Describing a lucent line or an area of osteolysis by its zone makes loosening assessment systematic and reproducible. The femoral stem is divided into seven Gruen zones and the acetabular component into three DeLee-Charnley zones.

Reading the femoral zones. For a cemented stem, lucency in zones 1 and 7, proximal lateral and proximal medial, is the classic loosening pattern, and complete lucency in all zones is definite loosening. A pedestal of cement at zone 4 suggests that load is being transferred distally while the stem loosens proximally.

Reading the acetabular zones. Lucency in all three zones is definite loosening, and progressive lucency greater than 2 mm in any zone is concerning. Migration of the cup, superiorly (wear through) or medially (protrusion), indicates failure.

View larger

What a line means. A thin line under 2 mm, parallel to the implant, non-progressive and confined to a single zone is usually a stable fibrous membrane rather than loosening. Incomplete lucency in one or two zones is monitored closely. Lucency that is thicker on the newer film than on the older one, lucency in every zone (all three DeLee-Charnley zones, or a complete Gruen envelope) and any change in component position are the findings that mean loosening, and migration is the most specific single sign. Width and progression together raise concern, and the fourth question is whether the radiographic change correlates with the patient's symptoms.

Cemented and uncemented stems fail differently. A cemented stem loosens with lucency at the cement-bone interface, fracture of the cement mantle and component migration. An uncemented stem shows lucency at the implant-bone interface, a lack of bone ongrowth, shedding, and stem subsidence greater than 3 mm in the first 2 years.

Stress shielding is not loosening. Reduced bone density in the proximal femur around an uncemented stem is due to load bypass. It is not true loosening but indicates altered biomechanics, and it is more common with extensively coated stems.

View larger

Grade the mantle, do not just describe the line. The systematic read includes grading the femoral cement mantle, the "C" of the A-B-C-D-E-F read, on the immediate post-operative radiograph. The Barrack classification grades the quality of a cemented femoral mantle and is a recognised predictor of subsequent loosening: a uniform, complete mantle of adequate thickness with cement-bone "white-out" is the radiographic signature of good cementing technique, whereas a deficient or incomplete mantle predisposes to debonding and early failure. Barrack's original work linked inadequate (Grade C-D) mantles to markedly higher early femoral loosening than Grade A-B.

How to measure it. Compare the position of the femoral head with the centre of the cup and measure the minimum distance from head to cup margin. Serial films allow the wear rate to be calculated, and CT can assess volumetric wear more accurately. Wear precedes osteolysis by years and becomes clinically important before gross component migration, so inspect the same films for the lucencies of particle disease.

View larger

Who is at risk. The recognised risk factors:

• Male sex
• Post-traumatic osteoarthritis
• Hypertrophic osteoarthritis
• Previous heterotopic ossification
• Ankylosing spondylitis

Prevention and excision. Prophylaxis is an NSAID (indomethacin 75 mg daily for 6 weeks) or radiation (a single dose of 700 cGy within 72 hours). Excision waits 12-18 months for the bone to mature.

View larger

Cup position. Inclination (abduction) is measured between the plane of the cup opening and the horizontal inter-teardrop line on the AP pelvis, with a target of about 40°; anteversion is best quantified on a cross-table lateral or CT. The Lewinnek safe zone is inclination 40° ± 10° and anteversion 15° ± 10°, and a cup outside it (abduction over 55°, or mal-anteversion) carries higher dislocation and edge-loading risk.

What the zone does not mean. In 9,784 THAs, 58% of the hips that dislocated had a cup inside the zone. Being outside the zone is a problem; being inside it is not a guarantee, and the rest of the answer lies in the other risk factors tabulated below.

View larger

View larger

The decision is the stem. Around a hip stem, the question that separates B1 from B2 and B3 is whether the stem is loose, because that determines whether it is kept or revised. On the film, look for pre-existing lucencies, a change in component position and subsidence. If uncertain, obtain prior films for comparison or proceed to intra-operative assessment.

View larger

Choose the test by the question. Each modality answers a different question around a metal implant:

• Plain radiograph - first line, and the least artefact
• CT with metal artefact reduction - bone detail: osteolysis volume, component version and mapping of bony defects
• MRI with metal artefact reduction (including STIR) - soft tissue: adverse local tissue reaction, abductor and tendon integrity, soft-tissue masses
• Ultrasound - no metal artefact; fluid collections and tendons
• Nuclear medicine - WBC/marrow scan or three-phase bone scan when prosthetic joint infection is suspected

Adverse local tissue reaction. In metal-on-metal bearings, MRI with metal artefact reduction is the gold standard. Look for pseudotumour, solid or cystic masses, fluid collections, muscle atrophy and tendon damage. Ultrasound is useful for fluid-predominant lesions, and blood metal ion levels guide surveillance frequency.

View larger

Read the film with the bloods. A painful joint replacement is a common clinic scenario, and the imaging must be interpreted alongside the clinical picture and the inflammatory markers, because the single most important diagnosis to exclude, prosthetic joint infection, can produce radiographs that look identical to aseptic loosening.

Arthroplasty surveillance is informed by national joint registries and society guidance worldwide. Imaging recommendations converge on serial plain radiographs as the backbone, with risk-stratified cross-sectional imaging for specific failure modes.

Unicompartmental knee. Assess component alignment, progression of osteoarthritis in the opposite compartment, and overhang, because a medial tibial component that overhangs may irritate the MCL. The common failures are progression of arthritis in the unreplaced compartments and tibial loosening.

Reverse shoulder arthroplasty. The key measurements are the glenosphere position relative to the inferior glenoid, which should be low, and baseplate inclination. Watch for scapular notching, graded in the next section, acromial fractures and component loosening.

Revision arthroplasty. Classify the bone loss (Paprosky for the hip, AORI for the knee) and assess the remaining bone stock. Look for previous cement and hardware, and plan for longer stems, augments or structural grafts.

View larger

What notching is. Scapular notching is impingement wear: the polyethylene humeral cup contacts the inferior scapular neck in adduction, a feature of the medialised Grammont design, and erodes it. It is graded, not just described, with the Sirveaux-Nerot classification on a true AP (Grashey) view.

Why the grade matters. Higher grades (3-4) are associated with poorer functional outcomes and possible glenoid component loosening. The radiographic strategies that reduce notching, inferior glenosphere positioning, inferior tilt, and a larger or lateralised glenosphere, are the things to mention alongside the grade.

View larger

The radiographic frameworks used at the viva table - Gruen and DeLee-Charnley zones, the Lewinnek safe zone, the Brooker grade and the Vancouver classification - each originate from a specific paper. Knowing the source, the cohort and the modern caveats demonstrates depth.