Comprehensive Wrist and Hand Assessment
- Gilula lines: Three smooth arcs on PA view. Disruption indicates carpal malalignment.
- Scapholunate angle: 30-60° normal. Greater than 70° = DISI (dorsal lunate tilt).
- Scaphoid views: If scaphoid fracture suspected, standard views insufficient. Add scaphoid series.
- Terry Thomas sign: Widened scapholunate interval greater than 3mm indicates SL ligament injury.
- Occult scaphoid fracture: MRI or CT if X-ray negative but clinical suspicion. MRI within 24h is most sensitive.
- “Capitolunate angle greater than 30° is abnormal (normally co-linear on lateral).
- “DISI: Lunate tilts dorsal, SL angle increased (SL ligament injury). VISI: Lunate tilts volar (LT injury).
- “Perilunate dislocations: Lunate stays with radius, carpus displaces dorsally.
- “Lunate dislocations: Lunate tilts volar into carpal tunnel, carpus aligned with radius.
- “Scaphoid nonunion: Humpback deformity, proximal pole sclerosis, cystic change.
Initial X-rays miss 15-20% of scaphoid fractures. If clinical suspicion exists (snuffbox tenderness, scaphoid tubercle tenderness, pain with axial load of thumb), treat as fracture and obtain MRI or CT within 2 weeks, or repeat X-ray at 10-14 days. Early MRI within 24 hours is now preferred to detect or exclude fracture definitively.
ABCSWrist X-ray Systematic Review
Hook:Always Be Checking Systematically
Overview & Principles
Wrist and hand imaging rewards a disciplined, anatomy-led search pattern more than any other extremity. The carpus is a tightly packed three-dimensional structure of eight bones in two rows, and important injuries (occult scaphoid fracture, scapholunate dissociation, perilunate dislocation) are frequently missed when films are scanned rather than systematically read. The guiding principles are:
- Match modality to the question: radiographs for fractures and alignment, CT for fine bone detail and union, MRI for soft tissue (TFCC, intrinsic ligaments) and radiographically occult fractures and avascular necrosis.
- Never accept a single view: a minimum of two orthogonal views, with dedicated scaphoid views whenever a scaphoid fracture is plausible.
- Read alignment before bone: most carpal disasters are alignment problems (disrupted arcs, abnormal angles) visible on a correctly positioned lateral, not isolated fracture lines.
- Clinical suspicion overrides a normal radiograph: the occult scaphoid fracture defines the imaging pathway for the whole region.
Kienbock Disease and the Lichtman Classification
Kienbock disease (osteonecrosis of the lunate) appears in the MRI table and underpins the Lichtman-reliability evidence card, but the staging it depends on is never set out. The Lichtman classification stages the disease radiographically (with MRI for the earliest stage) and drives management.
- Radiograph / MRI
- Normal radiograph; MRI shows diffuse low T1 marrow signal
- Key point
- Diagnosed on MRI alone - radiograph is normal
- Radiograph / MRI
- Lunate SCLEROSIS (increased density), no collapse, shape preserved
- Key point
- Density change without loss of height
- Radiograph / MRI
- Lunate COLLAPSE without fixed scaphoid rotation; carpal height maintained
- Key point
- Lunate still potentially salvageable
- Radiograph / MRI
- Lunate collapse WITH fixed scaphoid rotation (ring sign), carpal-height loss, proximal capitate migration
- Key point
- Radioscaphoid angle over about 60 degrees separates IIIB from IIIA (Goldfarb)
- Radiograph / MRI
- Lunate collapse with pancarpal (radiocarpal and midcarpal) osteoarthritis
- Key point
- End-stage - salvage only
The IIIA-versus-IIIB distinction is the management-critical one: in IIIA the lunate may be preserved (joint-levelling for negative variance, or revascularisation), whereas from IIIB onward fixed scaphoid rotation means the lunate is no longer salvageable and salvage procedures (proximal row carpectomy or limited fusion) are considered. Quote the radioscaphoid angle (over about 60 degrees) to make the IIIA/IIIB call reproducible, and remember NEGATIVE ulnar variance is the classic association.
Systematic Approach
Gilula Lines (Carpal Arcs)
Arc 1: Proximal articular surface of proximal row (scaphoid, lunate, triquetrum)
Arc 2: Distal articular surface of proximal row
Arc 3: Proximal articular surface of capitate and hamate
Disruption indicates:
- Carpal dislocation
- Ligament injury with malalignment
- Fracture-dislocation
Arcs should be smooth, continuous curves

Lateral View Assessment
Radius-lunate-capitate should be co-linear
- Lunate sits in lunate fossa
- Capitate articulates with lunate
- Draw lines through long axes
Scapholunate angle: 30-60° normal Capitolunate angle: Less than 30° (nearly co-linear)
DISI (Dorsal Intercalated Segment Instability):
- SL angle greater than 70°
- Lunate tilts dorsally
- Associated with SL ligament injury
VISI (Volar Intercalated Segment Instability):
- SL angle less than 30°
- Lunate tilts volarly
- Associated with LT ligament injury
Key Measurements
- Normal
- Less than 3mm
- Abnormal Indicates
- Greater than 3mm = Terry Thomas sign (SL injury)
- Normal
- 30-60°
- Abnormal Indicates
- Greater than 70° = DISI, less than 30° = VISI
- Normal
- Less than 30°
- Abnormal Indicates
- Greater than 30° = carpal instability
- Normal
- 22-23°
- Abnormal Indicates
- Loss with distal radius fracture malunion
- Normal
- 11-12mm
- Abnormal Indicates
- Loss indicates radial shortening
- Normal
- 11-12° volar
- Abnormal Indicates
- Dorsal tilt with fracture malunion
Carpal Injuries
Scaphoid Fractures
Initial imaging:
- Standard wrist series PLUS scaphoid views
- PA ulnar deviation elongates scaphoid
- 15-20% of fractures not visible initially
If X-ray negative but clinically suspicious:
- MRI (most sensitive, within 24-48h ideal)
- CT (good for bone detail, slightly less sensitive)
- Repeat X-ray at 10-14 days (bone resorption makes fracture visible)
Immobilize pending further imaging - do not discharge without follow-up plan
Carpal Dislocations
Perilunate dislocation (more common):
- Lunate remains aligned with radius
- Rest of carpus (capitate) displaces dorsally
- Lateral view: Capitate posterior to lunate
Lunate dislocation (end-stage perilunate):
- Lunate tilts volarly, rotates into carpal tunnel
- Rest of carpus aligned with radius
- Lateral view: "Spilled teacup" sign
Both may have associated fractures (trans-scaphoid perilunate)
Check for median nerve symptoms (carpal tunnel compression)
Scapholunate Ligament Injury
PA view findings:
- Terry Thomas sign: SL gap greater than 3mm
- Scaphoid appears foreshortened (rotates into flexion)
- Cortical ring sign (scaphoid seen end-on)
Lateral view findings:
- DISI pattern: Increased SL angle (greater than 70°)
- Lunate tilted dorsally
Stress views: Clenched fist PA may widen SL gap
MRI/MR arthrography: Direct ligament visualization
Hand Radiographs
Standard Views
- Technique
- Hand flat on cassette
- Key Assessment
- Metacarpals, phalanges, joint spaces
- Technique
- 45° pronation
- Key Assessment
- Metacarpal heads, overlapping structures
- Technique
- True lateral
- Key Assessment
- Dorsal/volar displacement, thumb
- Technique
- Isolated thumb views
- Key Assessment
- CMC joint, Bennett fracture
Common Hand Fractures
Boxer fracture: 5th MC neck
- Assess apex dorsal angulation
- Acceptable angulation varies by digit
Bennett fracture: 1st MC base
- Intra-articular fracture-dislocation
- Small volar fragment stays with trapezium
- Shaft displaces dorsally/radially
Rolando fracture: Comminuted Bennett
Mallet finger: Avulsion dorsal P3 base
- May be bony or tendinous
- Greater than 30% articular = consider fixation
Volar plate avulsion: Volar P2/P3 base
- Hyperextension injury
Gamekeeper/Skier thumb: UCL injury
- Stress views may show instability
- MRI for soft tissue assessment
CT and MRI
CT Applications

Indications:
- Occult scaphoid fracture (if MRI unavailable)
- Carpal fracture characterization
- Union assessment (scaphoid nonunion)
- Hook of hamate fractures
- Carpal boss, coalition
- Surgical planning
Protocol: Thin slices (0.5-1mm), multiplanar reconstructions
Advantage: Superior bone detail Limitation: Cannot assess soft tissue (ligaments, TFCC)
MRI Applications
- Sequence
- T1 + STIR/T2 FS
- Key Findings
- Marrow edema, fracture line
- Sequence
- T2 FS coronal, MRA
- Key Findings
- Signal in triangular fibrocartilage
- Sequence
- T2 FS, MRA
- Key Findings
- Ligament disruption, gap, DISI
- Sequence
- T1 (low signal)
- Key Findings
- Proximal pole signal change
- Sequence
- T1, T2
- Key Findings
- Lunate signal change, collapse
TFCC Assessment
Normal appearance: Low signal on all sequences
Tear signs on MRI:
- Increased signal within TFCC substance
- Discontinuity
- Fluid extending through tear
- Associated DRUJ instability signs
Classification (Palmer):
- Class 1: Traumatic tears (1A-1D by location)
- Class 2: Degenerative (2A-2E by severity)
MR arthrography: Improves sensitivity for tears
Ulnar Variance and Ulnar Impaction Syndrome
The TFCC discussion and viva invoke ulnar variance and ulnar impaction syndrome, but neither the measurement nor the pathology is developed. Ulnar variance is the relative length of the distal ulna compared with the radius at the ulnar corner of the lunate fossa, measured on a STANDARDISED PA radiograph (shoulder abducted 90 degrees, elbow flexed 90 degrees, neutral rotation).
- Definition
- Ulna and radius level at the lunate fossa
- Association
- Normal
- Definition
- Ulna longer than the radius
- Association
- Ulnar impaction (ulnocarpal abutment); degenerative central Palmer Class 2 TFCC tears
- Definition
- Ulna shorter than the radius
- Association
- Associated with Kienbock disease
- Definition
- Variance increases with grip and pronation
- Association
- A pronated grip view reveals 'dynamic positive variance' not seen on the neutral film
Chronic ulnocarpal load transfer (driven by POSITIVE ulnar variance) produces a recognisable pattern: subchondral cysts and sclerosis in the ULNAR aspect of the lunate and the triquetrum, central TFCC wear or perforation, and lunotriquetral ligament degeneration. The radiograph shows positive variance with ulnar-sided lunate/triquetral cysts; MRI shows the corresponding subchondral marrow oedema and cysts and the TFCC change. It is managed by unloading the ulnar column - an ulnar shortening osteotomy (or arthroscopic wafer) - which is why measuring variance changes management.
Differential Diagnosis: Radial-Sided Wrist Pain After a Fall
Snuffbox or radial-sided wrist tenderness with normal initial radiographs is one of the highest-stakes diagnostic moments in extremity imaging. The differential is wide, and the imaging strategy is driven by which diagnosis you most fear missing (occult scaphoid fracture). Use the discriminating features below to direct targeted imaging rather than reflexively imaging everything.
- Key clinical clue
- Snuffbox + tubercle tenderness, axial thumb load pain
- Best imaging
- MRI (T1 + STIR)
- Discriminating imaging feature
- Linear marrow oedema crossing a cortex; T1 hypointense line
- Key clinical clue
- Dorsal SL tenderness, Watson shift test positive
- Best imaging
- PA + clenched-fist views, MRA
- Discriminating imaging feature
- SL gap over 3mm (Terry Thomas), DISI, cortical ring sign
- Key clinical clue
- Dorsal wrist pain, FOOSH
- Best imaging
- CT
- Discriminating imaging feature
- Cortical step or impaction not seen on plain film
- Key clinical clue
- Focal styloid tenderness
- Best imaging
- PA radiograph / CT
- Discriminating imaging feature
- Oblique intra-articular line through styloid; Mayfield avulsion
- Key clinical clue
- Pain over 1st extensor compartment, Finkelstein positive
- Best imaging
- Ultrasound / MRI
- Discriminating imaging feature
- Fluid and tendon sheath thickening, no marrow oedema
- Key clinical clue
- Older patient, grind test positive, chronic
- Best imaging
- PA radiograph
- Discriminating imaging feature
- Joint space loss, osteophytes, subchondral sclerosis
- Key clinical clue
- Diffuse tenderness, resolving pain
- Best imaging
- MRI (if done)
- Discriminating imaging feature
- Patchy marrow oedema WITHOUT a fracture line
The single most useful negative clinical finding is the ABSENCE of anatomical snuffbox tenderness — it makes a scaphoid fracture very unlikely and is the only examination finding with a meaningful negative likelihood ratio in the pooled literature. A bone contusion shows marrow oedema WITHOUT a discrete fracture line, which is why MRI both rules in and rules out: it does not merely show "something is wrong."
Guidelines, Registries & Global Practice
Global Epidemiology
The scaphoid is the most commonly fractured carpal bone, accounting for roughly 79% of carpal fractures, and predominantly affects young active adults (peak in males aged 15-30). Initial radiographs miss an estimated 15-20% of true fractures, which is the central driver of every imaging pathway in this topic.
Distal radius fractures are among the most common fractures worldwide, with a bimodal distribution (young high-energy and older osteoporotic/fragility). Metacarpal and phalangeal fractures together represent a large share of all hand injuries presenting to emergency departments globally, making the PA/oblique/lateral hand series a high-volume, high-yield study.
Side-by-Side Guideline Comparison
- First-line
- Dedicated scaphoid radiograph series
- If radiographs normal but clinically suspicious
- Early MRI favoured to confirm or exclude and avoid prolonged casting
- First-line
- Wrist + scaphoid radiographs
- If radiographs normal but clinically suspicious
- MRI usually most appropriate; CT acceptable alternative
- First-line
- Scaphoid series radiographs
- If radiographs normal but clinically suspicious
- MRI or CT depending on access; emphasis on definitive early diagnosis
- First-line
- Radiographs to classify and plan
- If radiographs normal but clinically suspicious
- Cross-sectional imaging (CT for bone detail) to guide fixation
The international convergence is striking: across UK, US and European guidance, the disagreement is no longer "image or wait" but "MRI or CT" for the radiographically occult scaphoid. Delayed-radiograph-only pathways are now the minority position, supported by cost-effectiveness and decision-analysis evidence.
High-Resource vs Limited-Resource Practice
- High-resource setting
- Immediate or early MRI (or CT) at first attendance
- Limited-resource setting
- Cast and repeat radiographs at 10-14 days; CT if available
- High-resource setting
- Stress fluoroscopy, MR arthrography, wrist arthroscopy
- Limited-resource setting
- Clenched-fist and stress radiographs, clinical examination
- High-resource setting
- 3T MRI / MR arthrography, arthroscopy
- Limited-resource setting
- Clinical tests, plain radiographs, ultrasound where skilled
- High-resource setting
- CT with thin slices and reconstructions
- Limited-resource setting
- Serial radiographs; bridging trabeculae as surrogate
Regardless of resource setting, the non-negotiable principle is the same worldwide: a patient with clinical signs of scaphoid fracture and normal radiographs must be immobilised and given a definitive follow-up imaging plan. The missed scaphoid fracture leading to nonunion and SNAC wrist is a recurrent medicolegal and exam theme on every continent.
Registry & Outcome Notes
Carpal and hand injuries are not tracked by the major arthroplasty registries (NJR, AJRR, AOANJRR, SHAR, NZJR), which focus on joint replacement. Evidence here therefore comes from trauma cohorts, diagnostic-accuracy meta-analyses and decision-analysis modelling rather than implant survivorship data. The practical consequence for the exam: quote diagnostic sensitivity/specificity and cost-effectiveness data, not registry revision rates, when justifying an imaging strategy for the wrist and hand.
Controversies & Areas of Uncertainty
Whether to obtain immediate MRI, immediate CT, early MRI at day 3, or delayed radiographs at 2 weeks remains debated. Decision-analysis and a single-centre randomised trial favour immediate cross-sectional imaging because it shortens unnecessary immobilisation and lost productivity, but access, cost and out-of-hours availability still drive real-world pathways. Many centres run a hybrid pathway: clinical risk stratification, then MRI for high-suspicion cases.
CT has excellent specificity but can miss non-displaced trabecular fractures and bone bruising that MRI detects. MRI has higher sensitivity but may over-call bone oedema as a "fracture", potentially leading to overtreatment. The Cochrane analysis found CT and MRI broadly comparable, with bone scintigraphy most sensitive but least specific — so test choice depends on whether your priority is avoiding a missed fracture or avoiding overtreatment.
Predynamic and dynamic scapholunate instability can have entirely normal static radiographs. Diagnosis then depends on stress (clenched-fist) views, fluoroscopy, MR arthrography or arthroscopy, the latter still regarded as the reference standard for partial ligament tears. There is no universally agreed non-invasive test, and inter-observer reliability of SL gap and angle measurements is only moderate.
Conventional MRI has variable sensitivity for peripheral TFCC tears and partial intrinsic ligament tears. MR arthrography improves accuracy but is invasive, and wrist arthroscopy remains the diagnostic gold standard. The cut-off between a degenerative (often asymptomatic) Palmer Class 2 TFCC change and a clinically relevant tear is a recurring source of over-diagnosis.
Clinical Imaging: Plain Radiograph Interpretation
Standard Views
- Technique
- Wrist pronated, shoulder abducted 90°
- Key Assessment
- Carpal alignment, Gilula arcs, joint spaces
- Technique
- True lateral, ulna superimposed
- Key Assessment
- Carpal alignment, SL angle, DISI/VISI
- Technique
- 45° pronation
- Key Assessment
- Carpometacarpal joints, trapezium
- Technique
- Wrist ulnar deviated
- Key Assessment
- Elongates scaphoid, shows waist
- Technique
- Angled view
- Key Assessment
- Alternative scaphoid profile


Clinical Decision Scenarios
Practise clinical reasoning and management decisions out loud
“A patient has snuffbox tenderness after a fall on outstretched hand. X-rays are normal. How do you proceed?”
“Describe how you assess carpal alignment on plain radiographs and the features of DISI.”
“How do you differentiate a perilunate dislocation from a lunate dislocation on X-ray?”
“A patient presents with ulnar-sided wrist pain after a fall and on rotation. How do you investigate, and how do you classify TFCC pathology?”
Key Measurements
- Scapholunate interval: Less than 3mm (greater than 3mm = Terry Thomas)
- Scapholunate angle: 30-60° (greater than 70° = DISI)
- Capitolunate angle: Less than 30°
- Radial inclination: 22-23°, Volar tilt: 11-12°
Gilula Lines (PA view)
- Arc 1: Proximal surface of proximal row
- Arc 2: Distal surface of proximal row
- Arc 3: Proximal capitate/hamate
- Disruption = dislocation or ligament injury
Scaphoid Fracture
- 15-20% missed on initial X-ray
- MRI within 24-48h preferred (or CT)
- Immobilize pending investigation
- Waist 70%, Proximal pole 20% (highest AVN risk)
Carpal Instability
- DISI: SL angle greater than 70°, dorsal lunate tilt (SL injury)
- VISI: SL angle less than 30°, volar lunate tilt (LT injury)
- Perilunate: Capitate dorsal to lunate
- Lunate dislocation: 'Spilled teacup' sign
Evidence Base
CT vs MRI vs Bone Scintigraphy for Suspected Scaphoid Fracture (Cochrane)
- Pooled summary estimates from 11 studies: CT sensitivity 0.72 and specificity 0.99; MRI sensitivity 0.88 and specificity 1.00; bone scintigraphy sensitivity 0.99 and specificity 0.86.
- Bone scintigraphy was statistically the most sensitive but its lower specificity means more overtreatment — in a cohort of 1000, bone scan over-treats 112 patients versus only 8 with CT.
- CT and MRI had comparable diagnostic accuracy; confidence intervals were wide and well-designed direct head-to-head comparisons are still needed.
Diagnostic Accuracy of Examination and Imaging for Adult Scaphoid Fracture
- Across 75 studies, point-estimate pretest probability of fracture in an adult with concerning mechanism, radial tenderness and non-diagnostic radiographs was about 25%.
- Apart from absence of snuffbox tenderness (negative likelihood ratio 0.15), history and examination alone cannot rule scaphoid fracture in or out.
- MRI was the most accurate test to both rule in and rule out scaphoid fracture; where MRI is unavailable, CT can rule in but is inadequate to rule out.
Cost-Effectiveness of Immediate MRI for Suspected Scaphoid Fracture (RCT)
- Pragmatic single-centre randomised trial comparing immediate ED MRI with standard radiograph-only care for suspected scaphoid fracture.
- Immediate MRI dominated standard care — it cost less and produced more quality-adjusted life years at 6 months.
- Probability of cost-effectiveness was 100% at conventional willingness-to-pay thresholds, and the institution changed routine practice to adopt the pathway.
Decision-Analysis of Diagnostic Strategies for Suspected Scaphoid Fracture
- Decision-tree model comparing immediate CT, day-3 MRI, day-3 bone scan, 2-week radiograph strategies and immediate MRI from a societal perspective.
- Immediate CT and immediate MRI were the most cost-effective strategies for diagnosing suspected scaphoid fractures.
- Strategies relying on delayed 2-week radiographs were dominated or extendedly dominated by the cross-sectional imaging strategies.