Skip to main content
OrthoVellum
Knowledge Hub

Study

  • Topics
  • MCQs
  • ISAWE
  • Operative Surgery
  • Flashcards

Company

  • About Us
  • Editorial Policy
  • Contact
  • FAQ
  • Blog

Legal

  • Terms of Service
  • Privacy Policy
  • Cookie Policy
  • Medical Disclaimer
  • Copyright & DMCA
  • Refund Policy

Support

  • Help Center
  • Accessibility
  • Report an Issue
OrthoVellum

© 2026 OrthoVellum. For educational purposes only.

Not affiliated with the Royal Australasian College of Surgeons.

Navicular Fractures

Back to Topics
Contents
0%

Navicular Fractures

Comprehensive guide to tarsal navicular fractures covering anatomy, classification, clinical assessment, and management including stress fractures for orthopaedic examination preparation.

complete
Updated: 2024-12-16
High Yield Overview

TARSAL NAVICULAR FRACTURES

Medial Column Keystone | AVN Risk | Sangeorzan Classification | Athletes at Risk

47%Avulsion fractures (most common)
25%AVN rate in body fractures
86%Union rate with early treatment
6-8 wksNon-weight-bearing for stress fractures

SANGEORZAN CLASSIFICATION (BODY FRACTURES)

Type 1
PatternCoronal fracture, dorsal fragment, no forefoot angulation
TreatmentORIF if displaced greater than 1mm or unstable
Type 2
PatternDorsomedial to plantar-lateral, forefoot displacement
TreatmentORIF - restore medial column length
Type 3
PatternComminuted, central or lateral fragmentation
TreatmentORIF with possible bone grafting

Critical Must-Knows

  • Precarious blood supply - central third is watershed zone (AVN risk)
  • CT scan essential for body fractures - assess articular displacement
  • Stress fractures - often missed initially, high index of suspicion in athletes
  • Medial column length must be restored - avoid shortening
  • 6-8 weeks non-weight-bearing minimum for stress fractures

Examiner's Pearls

  • "
    Blood supply: dorsal and plantar arteries, central zone relatively avascular
  • "
    Sangeorzan Type 2 most common body fracture pattern
  • "
    Stress fractures: central third, sagittal orientation, bone scan/MRI to diagnose
  • "
    Associated injuries: cuboid, cuneiforms, tarsometatarsal joint
  • "
    Malunion leads to planovalgus deformity and midfoot arthritis

Viva Danger Zones

Classic Viva Scenarios:

  1. High-energy midfoot trauma - systematic assessment of Chopart/Lisfranc complex
  2. Athlete with vague midfoot pain - navicular stress fracture until proven otherwise
  3. Displaced navicular body fracture - surgical approach and fixation options
  4. Post-operative AVN - recognition and salvage options
  5. Malunion with planovalgus - reconstructive options

Never Say:

  • "X-rays are sufficient for surgical planning"
  • "Weight-bear as tolerated for stress fractures"
  • "Accept any displacement of navicular body fractures"
  • "The navicular has good blood supply like other tarsal bones"

At a Glance Table

Navicular Fracture Types: Quick Reference

FeatureAvulsionBodyStressTuberosity
Frequency47% (most common)26%3%24%
MechanismCapsule avulsionHigh-energy axial loadRepetitive loadingPTT avulsion/direct trauma
Typical PatientAny age, low energy20-40 years, traumaAthletes (track/basketball)Older patients or trauma
Key ImagingX-rays sufficientCT essential for planningMRI gold standardX-rays, CT if large
TreatmentConservative if smallORIF if displaced over 1mmNWB 6-8 weeksORIF if large/displaced
AVN RiskVery low25% (high)Variable (central worse)Low
Nonunion RiskRareModerateHigh (central location)Low
Return to Activity6-8 weeks4-6 months4-6 months8-12 weeks
PrognosisExcellentGood-Fair (type dependent)Good if early treatmentGood
Mnemonic

NAVICULAR

N
No good blood supply to central third
AVN risk
A
Athletes at risk
for stress fractures
V
Very important for medial arch
keystone
I
Imaging with CT
essential for body fractures
C
Classification
Sangeorzan for body fractures
U
Union problematic in
central stress fractures
L
Length of medial
column must be maintained
A
Avulsion fractures most common
47%
R
Rest and non-weight-bearing
for stress fractures

Memory Hook:The NAVICULAR is critical for arch support but has fragile blood supply

Mnemonic

SANGEORZAN

S
Single fragment dorsally
Type 1 (coronal plane)
A
Angulation of forefoot (dorsomedial-plantarlateral)
Type 2
N
Numerous fragments (comminuted)
Type 3
G
Greater displacement =
higher type = worse prognosis
E
Each type increases
AVN and nonunion risk
O
ORIF indicated for
all displaced body fractures
R
Restore medial column
alignment
Z
Zone of comminution
affects outcome
A
Articular congruity must
be restored
N
Non-anatomic reduction leads
to arthritis

Memory Hook:Types 1-2-3: Coronal-Oblique-Comminuted (increasing severity)

Mnemonic

STRESS

S
Sagittal orientation
vertical fracture line
T
Track and field
athletes most at risk
R
Rest
non-weight-bearing) for 6-8 weeks
E
Early CT/MRI as
X-rays often negative
S
Surgery if displaced
or failed conservative
S
Slow healing due
to poor blood supply

Memory Hook:STRESS fractures need REST - 6-8 weeks non-weight-bearing

Overview

Tarsal Navicular Fractures

The tarsal navicular is a key bone of the midfoot, serving as the keystone of the medial longitudinal arch. Fractures range from minor avulsions to complex body fractures with significant displacement and associated injuries.

Clinical Significance

The navicular's tenuous blood supply makes it susceptible to avascular necrosis (AVN), similar to the scaphoid in the wrist. The central third is a watershed zone with limited vascularity, explaining the high nonunion rate in navicular stress fractures.

Classification by Location:

  1. Avulsion fractures - Most common (47%)
  2. Body fractures - Significant injuries, high complication rate
  3. Stress fractures - Important in athletes
  4. Tuberosity fractures - Posterior tibial tendon insertion

Epidemiology:

  • Rare injuries - navicular fractures comprise 3-5% of all foot fractures
  • Body fractures often associated with high-energy trauma
  • Stress fractures common in athletes (track and field, basketball, football)
  • Male predominance in body fractures
  • Peak age: 20-40 years

Anatomy and Blood Supply

Navicular Anatomy - Know Cold for Viva

The navicular bone:

  • Location: Keystone of medial longitudinal arch
  • Articulations: Talus (proximally), three cuneiforms (distally), cuboid (laterally)
  • Insertions: Posterior tibial tendon on tuberosity (major dynamic arch support)
  • Shape: Boat-shaped (Latin: navicula = little boat)

Key relationships:

  • Part of Chopart (transverse tarsal) joint with talus
  • Forms talonavicular joint - critical for hindfoot motion
  • Spring ligament supports plantar surface

Blood Supply - Critical Exam Topic

Watershed Zone

The navicular's blood supply is tenuous and similar to the scaphoid:

Arterial Supply:

  • Dorsalis pedis artery - dorsal branches
  • Medial plantar artery - plantar branches
  • These vessels enter from the periphery (medial and lateral)

Watershed Zone:

  • The central third of the navicular body is relatively avascular
  • Blood supply enters peripherally and does not reach central zone reliably
  • This explains high AVN rate in body fractures (25%) and stress fractures

Clinical Implication:

  • Central stress fractures have high nonunion rate
  • Displaced body fractures disrupt peripheral blood supply
  • Open reduction should preserve soft tissue attachments

Functional Anatomy

Medial Column:

  • Navicular is the "cornerstone" of the medial column
  • Medial column: talus → navicular → medial cuneiform → first metatarsal
  • Maintains longitudinal arch height
  • Shortening leads to planovalgus deformity

Talonavicular Joint:

  • Provides 80% of hindfoot inversion/eversion
  • Essential for gait adaptation to uneven surfaces
  • Loss of motion significantly affects function

Fracture Types by Location

Fracture TypePercentageMechanismKey Features
Avulsion (dorsal lip)47%Talonavicular capsule pullLow energy, good prognosis
Tuberosity24%PTT avulsion or direct traumaMay need fixation if large
Body26%High-energy axial loadHigh complication rate
Stress3%Repetitive loadingAthletes, central location

Classification Systems

Sangeorzan Classification for Body Fractures

The Sangeorzan classification (1989) categorizes navicular body fractures based on fracture pattern and degree of displacement.

Type 1

Coronal plane fracture

  • Transverse fracture line
  • Dorsal fragment
  • No forefoot angulation
  • Talonavicular joint intact
  • Treatment: ORIF if displaced
  • Prognosis: Good if reduced

Type 2

Dorsomedial to plantar-lateral

  • Main fracture oblique
  • Forefoot displaced dorsally
  • Medial column shortened
  • Most common pattern
  • Treatment: ORIF essential
  • Prognosis: Moderate - AVN risk

Type 3

Comminuted

  • Central/lateral comminution
  • Severe articular damage
  • Often high-energy
  • Associated injuries common
  • Treatment: ORIF + bone graft
  • Prognosis: Poor - high AVN/arthritis

Clinical Application:

  • Higher type = worse prognosis
  • Type 2 most common in clinical practice
  • All require CT for surgical planning

These fracture patterns guide treatment decisions and prognosis estimation.

Stress Fracture Classification

Location-Based Classification:

TypeDescriptionImagingTreatment
Type 1 (Partial)Dorsal cortical break onlySclerosis, no complete lineNWB 6-8 weeks
Type 2 (Complete non-displaced)Full fracture, no displacementComplete fracture line on CTNWB 8-12 weeks
Type 3 (Complete displaced)Full fracture with displacementGap, displacement on CTConsider ORIF

Zone-Based Classification (Prognostic):

Peripheral Zone

  • Better blood supply
  • Lower nonunion risk
  • Heal well with conservative treatment
  • Earlier return to sport

Central Zone (Watershed)

  • Tenuous blood supply
  • High nonunion rate (up to 25%)
  • May require surgical treatment
  • Prolonged recovery

Location is the key prognostic factor in stress fractures.

Other Navicular Fracture Types

Avulsion Fractures (47% of navicular fractures):

  • Dorsal lip avulsion: Talonavicular capsule avulsion
  • Plantar avulsion: Spring ligament attachment
  • Generally treated conservatively if small (less than 2mm)
  • ORIF if large fragment or instability

Tuberosity Fractures (24%):

TypeDescriptionTreatment
Type IExtra-articular avulsion of PTT insertionConservative if small
Type IILarge fragment extending into navicular bodyORIF if displaced or large

Special Considerations:

  • Tuberosity fractures may affect posterior tibial tendon function
  • Large fragments require fixation to prevent malunion
  • Associated with hindfoot valgus injuries

Treatment is based on fragment size and displacement.

Clinical Assessment

History

Body Fractures:

  • High-energy mechanism (MVA, fall from height)
  • Axial loading through foot
  • Immediate inability to weight-bear
  • Associated injuries common (25%)

Stress Fractures:

  • Insidious onset of midfoot pain
  • Worse with activity, improves with rest
  • Often delay in presentation (weeks to months)
  • Athletes: recent increase in training intensity
  • May recall specific incident when "stress" became "complete"

Examination

Inspection:

  • Swelling over dorsum of midfoot
  • Ecchymosis (body fractures)
  • May appear grossly normal (stress fractures)
  • Assess overall foot alignment

Palpation:

  • N spot - focal tenderness over navicular body (dorsal, medial, plantar)
  • Tuberosity tenderness (posterior tibial tendon insertion)
  • Assess adjacent joints (talonavicular, cuneonavicular)

Special Tests:

  • Single-leg hop test (stress fractures) - reproduces pain
  • Navicular compression test
  • Assess posterior tibial tendon function
  • Assess hindfoot alignment

The N Spot

Navicular Stress Fracture Sign: The "N spot" is focal tenderness over the proximal dorsal navicular at the junction of the proximal and middle thirds - this is the site of stress fractures in the watershed zone.

Sensitivity: 81% Specificity: 100%

If N spot tenderness present in an athlete with activity-related midfoot pain, pursue advanced imaging even with negative X-rays.

Associated Injuries

Body fractures often occur with:

  • Cuboid fractures (nutcracker injury)
  • Cuneiform fractures
  • Lisfranc injuries
  • Talus fractures
  • Chopart joint injuries

Assessment:

  • Examine entire foot systematically
  • Compare to contralateral side
  • Document neurovascular status
  • Check for compartment syndrome (rare)

Investigations

Imaging Protocol

X-Rays (Standard Foot Series):

  • AP, lateral, oblique views
  • Body fractures usually visible
  • Stress fractures often negative initially (up to 70%)
  • Look for subtle cortical break or sclerosis

CT Scan:

  • Essential for body fractures - surgical planning
  • Assess articular displacement
  • Identify comminution pattern
  • Evaluate adjacent injuries
  • Sangeorzan classification confirmed

MRI:

  • Gold standard for stress fractures
  • T2 bone marrow edema before cortical break
  • 97% sensitivity for stress fractures
  • Also evaluates soft tissue injury

Bone Scan:

  • Alternative to MRI for stress fractures
  • Highly sensitive (early uptake)
  • Less specific than MRI
  • "Hot" navicular in stress fracture/reaction

Imaging Findings

Body Fractures on CT:

  • Fracture pattern (Sangeorzan type)
  • Articular step-off measurement
  • Comminution assessment
  • Medial column length

Stress Fractures on MRI:

  • T1: Low signal linear fracture line
  • T2/STIR: High signal bone marrow edema
  • Location: Central third, sagittal orientation
  • Assess for complete vs partial fracture

CT vs MRI

Choose based on fracture type:

  • Body fractures: CT for surgical planning
  • Stress fractures: MRI for diagnosis and staging
  • Both: May be needed for complete evaluation

CT shows bone detail; MRI shows stress reaction before cortical break.

Management Algorithm

📊 Management Algorithm
navicular fractures management algorithm
Click to expand
Management algorithm for navicular fracturesCredit: OrthoVellum

Body Fracture Management

Non-Operative Treatment:

Indications:

  • Non-displaced fractures (less than 1mm articular step-off)
  • No medial column shortening
  • Stable fracture pattern
  • Patient able to comply with restrictions

Protocol:

  • Short leg cast, non-weight-bearing for 6-8 weeks
  • X-rays at 2, 4, 6 weeks to assess alignment
  • CT at 6 weeks to confirm union
  • Transition to weight-bearing boot at 8-10 weeks
  • Progressive rehabilitation

Operative Treatment:

Surgical Indications

Absolute indications:

  • Displacement greater than 1mm articular step-off
  • Medial column shortening
  • Unstable fracture pattern (Sangeorzan 2 and 3)
  • Open fracture

Relative indications:

  • Associated midfoot injuries requiring surgery
  • High-demand patient
  • Inability to comply with non-weight-bearing

Fixation Options:

  • Screws: 3.5mm or 4.0mm cortical lag screws
  • K-wires: Temporary or definitive for small fragments
  • Mini-fragment plates: 2.0-2.4mm for comminuted fractures
  • Bridge plating: Talonavicular to cuneiforms for severe comminution
  • External fixation: Severely comminuted with soft tissue compromise

Choice depends on fracture pattern and comminution degree.

Stress Fracture Management

First-Line Conservative Treatment:

  • Strict non-weight-bearing for 6-8 weeks (critical)
  • Short leg cast or CAM boot
  • Serial imaging: X-rays at 4 weeks, CT/MRI at 6-8 weeks
  • Gradual return to activity over 4-6 weeks
  • Address training errors and biomechanics
  • Correct footwear and orthotics as needed

Surgical Indications:

  • Failed conservative treatment (3-6 months with no healing)
  • Displaced fracture
  • Complete fracture with sclerotic margins
  • Nonunion with pain
  • High-level athlete requiring expedited return (controversial)

Surgical Options:

  • Percutaneous cannulated screw fixation
  • Open reduction with screw fixation and bone grafting
  • Debridement of sclerotic bone with grafting for nonunion

Surgery reserved for failed conservative treatment or displaced fractures.

Avulsion and Tuberosity Fracture Management

Small Avulsion Fractures:

  • Conservative treatment if less than 2mm displacement
  • Weight-bearing boot for 4-6 weeks
  • Good prognosis

Large Avulsion/Tuberosity Fractures:

  • ORIF if fragment greater than 20% of joint surface
  • ORIF if posterior tibial tendon avulsion with displacement
  • Screw or plate fixation depending on size
  • Non-weight-bearing 6 weeks post-surgery

Most avulsion fractures have excellent prognosis with appropriate treatment.

Mnemonic

FIXATION

F
Fix displaced fractures
greater than 1mm step-off
I
Incision dorsomedial to
preserve blood supply
X
X-rays intraoperatively to
confirm reduction
A
Anatomic articular reduction
essential
T
Temporary K-wires to
hold reduction while screwing
I
Interfragmentary compression if
pattern allows
O
ORIF with screws
or mini-plates
N
Non-weight-bearing postoperatively 6-8
weeks

Memory Hook:FIXATION principles guide surgical treatment of navicular body fractures

Surgical Technique

Preoperative Planning

Essential Steps:

  • Review CT scan for fracture pattern and comminution
  • Assess soft tissue envelope - may need staged surgery
  • Plan approach based on fracture location
  • Prepare for bone grafting if comminution present

Patient Positioning

  • Supine with bump under ipsilateral hip
  • Thigh tourniquet
  • Image intensifier positioned for AP and lateral views

Thorough planning ensures optimal surgical execution.

Dorsomedial Approach

Incision:

  • Curvilinear incision over dorsomedial aspect of navicular
  • Between tibialis anterior (medial) and EHL (lateral)
  • 6-8cm incision centered over navicular

Deep Dissection:

  • Protect superficial peroneal nerve branches
  • Identify and protect dorsalis pedis artery
  • Identify deep peroneal nerve lateral to artery
  • Incise talonavicular capsule
  • Expose fracture fragments

Vascular Danger Zone

The dorsalis pedis artery runs between EHL and tibialis anterior tendons

  • Always identify before deep dissection
  • Vessel loops for protection during reduction
  • Extensive soft tissue stripping increases AVN risk
  • Preserve periosteal attachments where possible

Careful dissection protects vital neurovascular structures.

Reduction Technique

Step-by-Step:

  1. Irrigate fracture site - remove hematoma
  2. Identify key fragments - especially articular surface
  3. Provisional reduction with pointed reduction forcers
  4. Restore medial column length - compare to contralateral
  5. K-wire joysticks in fragments for manipulation
  6. Temporary K-wire fixation - hold reduction
  7. Check reduction with fluoroscopy (AP, lateral, oblique)

Fixation Methods

Screw Fixation (most common):

  • 3.5mm or 4.0mm cortical screws
  • Lag screw technique for interfragmentary compression
  • Countersink screw heads (avoid prominence)
  • Typically 2-3 screws for body fractures
  • Perpendicular to fracture line if possible

Plate Fixation (comminuted fractures):

  • 2.0-2.4mm mini-fragment plates
  • Bridge plating for severe comminution
  • Spans talonavicular to cuneonavicular joints
  • Acts as buttress for articular fragments

Bone Grafting:

  • Indicated for metaphyseal defects or comminution
  • Autograft from calcaneus or iliac crest
  • Pack defects after reduction
  • Improves healing in high-risk fractures

Closure

  • Repair talonavicular capsule
  • Layered closure
  • Posterior splint in plantigrade position
  • Strict elevation protocol

Anatomic reduction and stable fixation are paramount for good outcomes.

Complications

Common Complications

Early Complications

  • Wound dehiscence
  • Infection
  • Hardware prominence
  • Neurovascular injury
  • Compartment syndrome (rare)

Late Complications

  • Avascular necrosis (25%)
  • Nonunion (especially stress fractures)
  • Malunion and planovalgus
  • Post-traumatic arthritis
  • Chronic pain

Avascular Necrosis

AVN - Major Complication

Risk Factors for AVN:

  • Sangeorzan Type 2 and 3 fractures
  • Delayed treatment
  • Open reduction with extensive soft tissue stripping
  • Associated injuries disrupting blood supply

Presentation:

  • Persistent pain despite apparent healing
  • Progressive collapse on imaging
  • Sclerosis followed by fragmentation

Management:

  • Early: Protected weight-bearing, may revascularize
  • Established AVN with collapse:
    • Bone grafting (vascularized or non-vascularized)
    • Talonavicular fusion
    • Triple arthrodesis (severe cases)

Nonunion

Risk Factors:

  • Central stress fractures (watershed zone)
  • Inadequate immobilization
  • Smoking
  • Delayed diagnosis
  • Poor blood supply

Treatment:

  • Bone stimulator (electrical/ultrasound)
  • Surgical fixation with bone grafting
  • Consider vascularized bone graft for resistant cases

Malunion

Consequences:

  • Medial column shortening → planovalgus deformity
  • Talonavicular arthritis
  • Altered gait mechanics
  • Chronic midfoot pain

Treatment:

  • Osteotomy and bone grafting (rarely successful)
  • Typically requires talonavicular fusion
  • May need triple arthrodesis for severe deformity

Postoperative Care

Immediate Postoperative Period (0-2 weeks)

Hospital Care:

  • Posterior splint, strict elevation above heart
  • Non-weight-bearing with crutches
  • Ice and analgesia
  • Neurovascular checks
  • DVT prophylaxis if high risk

Discharge Instructions:

  • Maintain non-weight-bearing status
  • Keep splint dry and clean
  • Elevation as much as possible
  • Watch for excessive pain, swelling, numbness

Early Phase (2-6 weeks)

Week 2:

  • Wound check, suture removal
  • Convert to short leg cast or CAM boot
  • Continue strict non-weight-bearing
  • Begin ankle pumps and toe exercises

Week 4:

  • X-rays to assess alignment
  • Continue non-weight-bearing
  • If stable, may begin gentle ankle ROM in boot

Week 6:

  • X-rays to assess early healing
  • CT if healing questionable
  • Continue non-weight-bearing until bridging callus seen

Mid Phase (6-12 weeks)

Week 8:

  • If healing progressing, begin progressive weight-bearing
  • Weight-bearing as tolerated in boot
  • Physical therapy: ROM, proprioception
  • Pool therapy if available

Week 10-12:

  • Transition to supportive shoe
  • Continue progressive weight-bearing
  • Advance strengthening exercises
  • Address gait abnormalities

Late Phase (3-6 months)

Months 3-4:

  • Full weight-bearing in supportive footwear
  • Sport-specific rehabilitation begins
  • Impact activities avoided

Months 4-6:

  • Gradual return to running (if athlete)
  • Sport-specific drills
  • Full return to sport if pain-free and full ROM
  • Hardware removal if prominent (rarely needed)

Red Flags During Recovery

Concerning Signs

  • Persistent pain despite adequate healing time - consider AVN
  • Loss of reduction on serial X-rays - may need revision
  • No progression of healing at 12 weeks - nonunion risk
  • Wound complications - infection risk
  • Progressive collapse on imaging - AVN developing

Return to Sport Criteria

Must achieve before clearance:

  • Pain-free weight-bearing and walking
  • Full or near-full ROM compared to contralateral
  • Radiographic union (bridging callus on CT)
  • Successful completion of sport-specific drills
  • Single-leg hop test equal to contralateral
  • Psychological readiness

Typical timeline:

  • Office workers: 8-12 weeks
  • Manual laborers: 12-16 weeks
  • Athletes (non-impact): 4-6 months
  • Athletes (impact/running): 6-9 months

Outcomes and Prognosis

Overall Outcomes by Fracture Type

Body Fractures - Operative

Good-Excellent Outcomes: 70-85%

  • Type 1 (coronal): 85-90% good outcomes
  • Type 2 (oblique): 70-80% good outcomes
  • Type 3 (comminuted): 50-60% good outcomes
  • AVN rate: 16-25%
  • Arthritis rate: 20-30% at 5 years

Stress Fractures

Union Rate: 86-95% with early treatment

  • Partial fractures: 95% union
  • Complete non-displaced: 85-90% union
  • Central location: Higher nonunion rate
  • Return to sport: 80-90% of athletes
  • Recurrence rate: 10-15%

Prognostic Factors

Good Prognosis Indicators:

  • Early diagnosis and treatment (within 2 weeks)
  • Anatomic reduction achieved
  • Non-displaced or minimally displaced fractures
  • Peripheral location (stress fractures)
  • Younger age
  • Non-smoker
  • Good compliance with rehabilitation

Poor Prognosis Indicators:

  • Delayed treatment (beyond 3 weeks)
  • Sangeorzan Type 3 (comminuted)
  • Severe articular damage
  • Associated injuries (cuboid, cuneiforms)
  • Central stress fracture location
  • Smoking
  • Poor soft tissue envelope

Functional Outcomes

Return to Work:

  • Sedentary work: 8-12 weeks
  • Light manual work: 12-16 weeks
  • Heavy manual work: 16-24 weeks

Return to Sport:

  • Low-impact activities: 3-4 months
  • Running/jumping sports: 6-9 months
  • Elite athletes: May require 9-12 months
  • 10-20% of athletes unable to return to pre-injury level

Long-Term Complications

5-Year Follow-up Data:

  • Post-traumatic arthritis: 20-40% (body fractures)
  • Chronic pain: 15-25%
  • Reduced activity level: 20-30%
  • Need for fusion surgery: 5-10%

AVN Natural History:

  • Develops within first 2 years post-injury
  • May revascularize in 30% of cases
  • Progressive collapse in 50-70% if severe
  • Often requires salvage fusion procedures

Quality of Life

Patient Counseling

Key messages for patients:

  1. Body fractures: "Most patients do well with surgery, but there is a 1 in 4 chance of blood supply problems (AVN) and a 1 in 5 chance of arthritis developing over time."

  2. Stress fractures: "With strict rest for 6-8 weeks, 9 out of 10 athletes heal and return to sport. The bone heals slowly because of limited blood supply."

  3. Time off sport: "Expect 6-9 months before full return to impact sports. Rushing increases risk of re-fracture or failure to heal."

Evidence Base

Sangeorzan Classification (1989)

Level IV - Case Series
Sangeorzan BJ, Benirschke SK, Mosca V, et al • Foot Ankle (1989)
Key Findings:
  • Classification of 21 navicular body fractures into 3 types based on fracture pattern. Type 2 most common. Higher type associated with worse outcomes. 25% AVN rate overall.
Clinical Implication: Standard classification for body fractures. Guides surgical planning and prognosis counseling. Higher types require more aggressive fixation.

Navicular Stress Fractures - Khan Review

Level IV - Case Series
Khan KM, Fuller PJ, Brukner PD, et al • Am J Sports Med (1992)
Key Findings:
  • 22 athletes with navicular stress fractures. 86% union rate with early treatment (non-weight-bearing 6-8 weeks). Delayed treatment had significantly worse outcomes.
Clinical Implication: Early diagnosis and strict non-weight-bearing are critical. High index of suspicion in athletes with midfoot pain.

Surgical Treatment of Navicular Body Fractures

Level IV - Case Series
Schildhauer TA, Nork SE, Sangeorzan BJ • Foot Ankle Int (2004)
Key Findings:
  • 25 displaced body fractures treated with ORIF. 76% good/excellent outcomes. Type 3 fractures had significantly worse results. AVN in 16%.
Clinical Implication: ORIF provides reasonable outcomes for displaced fractures. Comminuted fractures have guarded prognosis despite anatomic reduction.

CT-Based Assessment of Navicular Fractures

Level III - Retrospective Comparative
Richter M, Thermann H, von Rheinbaben H, et al • Foot Ankle Int (2004)
Key Findings:
  • CT identified additional fracture lines in 67% of cases and changed surgical plan in 43%. Better assessment of articular involvement.
Clinical Implication: CT is essential for surgical planning of body fractures - X-rays alone are insufficient.

Return to Sport After Navicular Stress Fractures

Level IV - Case Series
Torg JS, Pavlov H, Cooley LH, et al • Am J Sports Med (1982)
Key Findings:
  • 10 athletes with navicular stress fractures. Those treated with cast immobilization and non-weight-bearing had better outcomes than those with activity restriction alone.
Clinical Implication: Strict non-weight-bearing is mandatory - activity restriction alone is insufficient for healing.

Viva Scenarios

Exam Viva Scenarios

Practice these scenarios to excel in your viva examination

VIVA SCENARIOStandard

EXAMINER

"A 25-year-old track athlete presents with 6 weeks of worsening midfoot pain during running. The pain localizes to the dorsum of the foot over the navicular. X-rays appear normal."

EXCEPTIONAL ANSWER

Differential Diagnosis:

  1. Navicular stress fracture - most likely given history and location
  2. Midfoot sprain/ligament injury
  3. Posterior tibial tendinopathy
  4. Stress reaction (pre-fracture)
  5. Extensor tendinopathy

Clinical Assessment:

  • Test for N spot tenderness - dorsal navicular at proximal-middle third junction
  • Single-leg hop test - positive if reproduces pain
  • Assess posterior tibial tendon function
  • Examine entire midfoot

Imaging:

  • X-rays often negative in early stress fractures (up to 70%)
  • MRI is investigation of choice - shows bone marrow edema before cortical break
  • CT if MRI confirms fracture - assess displacement

Management if Stress Fracture Confirmed:

  • Strict non-weight-bearing for 6-8 weeks - critical for healing
  • Short leg cast or CAM boot
  • Repeat imaging at 6 weeks to confirm healing
  • Gradual return to activity over 4-6 weeks
  • Address training errors and biomechanics
KEY POINTS TO SCORE
Navicular stress fracture - high index of suspicion
N-spot tenderness is specific sign
MRI is gold standard (X-rays often negative)
Strict Non-Weight Bearing (6-8 wks)
COMMON TRAPS
✗Diagnosing 'midfoot sprain' without imaging
✗Allowing weight-bearing in a boot (high nonunion risk)
✗Missing the central location (watershed zone)
LIKELY FOLLOW-UPS
"Why is the central third prone to nonunion?"
"When is surgery indicated for stress fractures?"
"What is the N-spot?"
VIVA SCENARIOChallenging

EXAMINER

"A 35-year-old man is brought to ED after a motorcycle accident. He has a swollen, deformed midfoot. X-rays show a displaced navicular body fracture with associated cuboid fracture. CT shows a Sangeorzan Type 2 pattern with 5mm of medial column shortening."

EXCEPTIONAL ANSWER

Preoperative Assessment:

  • ATLS assessment - exclude other injuries
  • Neurovascular exam of foot
  • Assess soft tissue envelope - may need staged surgery
  • CT review: Sangeorzan Type 2, medial column shortening, cuboid involvement

Surgical Planning:

  • Timing: Ideally within 2 weeks if soft tissues allow
  • Approach: Dorsomedial for navicular, separate lateral approach for cuboid
  • Goals: Restore medial column length, anatomic articular reduction

Surgical Technique:

  1. Dorsomedial incision between tibialis anterior and EHL
  2. Protect dorsalis pedis artery and deep peroneal nerve
  3. Identify and expose fracture fragments
  4. Reduce medial column length with distraction
  5. Temporary K-wire fixation
  6. Definitive fixation: 3.5mm lag screws or mini-fragment plate
  7. Address cuboid through lateral approach
  8. Intraoperative fluoroscopy to confirm reduction

Postoperative:

  • Posterior splint, strict non-weight-bearing
  • 6-8 weeks NWB, then progressive weight-bearing
  • Monitor for AVN - common in Type 2 fractures
KEY POINTS TO SCORE
High energy injury - check Compartment Syndrome
Medial Column Shortening leads to Planovalgus deformity
Sangeorzan Type 2 (Dorsomedial to Plantar-lateral)
ORIF required: Restore length and articular surface
COMMON TRAPS
✗Fixing navicular but leaving medial column short
✗Missing the associated Nutcracker cuboid fracture
✗Damaging dorsalis pedis during approach
LIKELY FOLLOW-UPS
"What is the Sangeorzan classification?"
"How does malunion affect foot biomechanics?"
"What approach would you use?"
VIVA SCENARIOAdvanced

EXAMINER

"A 30-year-old athlete is 4 months post-operatively from navicular body fracture ORIF. She has persistent midfoot pain. X-rays show sclerosis and partial collapse of the navicular. What is your diagnosis and management?"

EXCEPTIONAL ANSWER

Diagnosis:

  • Avascular necrosis (AVN) of the navicular
  • Incidence: 25% in body fractures, higher in Type 2/3
  • Confirm with MRI: T1 hypointensity, lack of enhancement

Classification and Staging:

  • Stage 1: Normal X-rays, MRI changes only
  • Stage 2: Sclerosis without collapse
  • Stage 3: Partial collapse, subchondral fracture
  • Stage 4: Complete collapse, secondary arthritis

Management Options:

Early AVN (Stage 1-2):

  • Protected weight-bearing - may allow revascularization
  • Core decompression (limited evidence)
  • Observation with serial imaging

Established AVN with Collapse (Stage 3-4):

  • Bone grafting: Non-vascularized or vascularized (medial femoral condyle)
  • Talonavicular fusion: If articular destruction, provides pain relief
  • Triple arthrodesis: Severe deformity, pantalar involvement

Counseling:

  • Prognosis guarded for return to high-level sport
  • May require activity modification long-term
  • Fusion procedures eliminate talonavicular motion
KEY POINTS TO SCORE
AVN is common (25%) due to watershed supply
Diagnosis: MRI confirms early, CT shows collapse
Early: NWB and observation
Late (collapse): Fusion (Talonavicular or Triple)
COMMON TRAPS
✗Confusing AVN with infection
✗Promising full return to elite sport after fusion
✗Ignoring adjacent joint arthritis
LIKELY FOLLOW-UPS
"What are the stages of AVN?"
"What is the blood supply of the navicular?"
"Why is the central third vulnerable?"

MCQ Practice Points

High-Yield Facts for MCQs

Stress Fracture Diagnosis

Q: A young athlete has vague midfoot pain but normal X-rays. What is the next step? A: MRI - X-rays are negative in 70% of early stress fractures. MRI is the gold standard (97% sensitive) showing bone marrow edema before a cortical break appears.

N-Spot Tenderness

Q: What is the 'N-Spot' and what does it signify? A: Dorsal Navicular Tenderness - Located at the junction of the proximal and middle thirds. It is 81% sensitive and 100% specific for navicular stress fractures.

Watershed Zone

Q: Why do central navicular fractures have a high nonunion rate? A: Poor Vascularity - The central third is a watershed zone between the dorsalis pedis and medial plantar arterial supplies. This tenuous blood supply impairs healing.

Sangeorzan Classification

Q: Which Sangeorzan type is the most common? A: Type 2 - The fracture line runs from dorsomedial to plantar-lateral. It results in forefoot medialization and dorsal displacement, requiring ORIF to restore length.

Treatment of Stress Fractures

Q: What is the critical management principle for navicular stress fractures? A: Variables: Strict NWB vs Surgery - Conservative management requires 6-8 weeks of strict non-weight-bearing in a cast. Weight-bearing leads to nonunion or recurrence.

Surgical Threshold

Q: When is surgery indicated for a navicular body fracture? A: Greater than 1mm Displacement - Any articular step-off greater than 1mm or loss of medial column length warrants ORIF to prevent post-traumatic arthritis and deformity.

Australian Context

Australian Epidemiology

Navicular fractures in Australia show similar patterns to international data, but with some unique considerations:

Sports-Related Injuries:

  • Australian Rules Football (AFL) players have increased stress fracture risk due to high running volumes and repeated jumping
  • Rugby Union and Rugby League also see navicular stress fractures in forwards and backs
  • Track and field athletes (particularly middle-distance runners) represent significant proportion of stress fracture cases
  • Cricket fast bowlers occasionally present with navicular stress fractures

Workplace Injuries:

  • Construction and mining industries account for high-energy body fractures
  • WorkCover claims for navicular fractures typically require 12-24 weeks off work for manual laborers
  • Return-to-work programs should emphasize graduated loading

Australian Guidelines and Resources

Imaging:

  • MRI is widely available through public and private systems for suspected stress fractures
  • Medicare rebate available for MRI foot when appropriate clinical indication documented
  • CT scans for surgical planning are standard of care in major trauma centers

Treatment Access:

  • Operative treatment for displaced navicular fractures available at all major trauma centers
  • Orthopedic foot and ankle specialists in major cities (Sydney, Melbourne, Brisbane, Perth, Adelaide)
  • Regional centers may require transfer for complex cases

Rehabilitation:

  • Sports medicine physicians and physiotherapists experienced in stress fracture management widely available
  • Australian Institute of Sport (AIS) protocols for return to running applicable
  • Bone density screening recommended for recurrent stress fractures (osteoporosis considerations)

Follow-Up and Outcomes

Public vs Private:

  • Public system follow-up typically at 2, 6, 12 weeks post-surgery
  • Private practice may offer more frequent review
  • CT at 6-8 weeks standard for assessing union in body fractures

Return to Work:

  • WorkCover may fund extended physiotherapy for manual workers
  • Graduated return-to-work programs recommended for heavy laborers
  • Desk-based workers typically return at 8-10 weeks with fracture boot

Considerations for Australian Practitioners

Indigenous Australians:

  • Higher rates of diabetes may affect fracture healing
  • Access to care in remote communities may be limited
  • Telemedicine follow-up increasingly used for remote patients

Sports Medicine:

  • AFL and NRL clubs have dedicated medical teams - early referral for suspected stress fractures
  • State sports institutes provide high-level rehabilitation
  • Return to elite sport decisions often involve multi-disciplinary teams

Navicular Fractures - Exam Day Essentials

High-Yield Exam Summary

Key Numbers

  • •47% = Avulsion fractures (most common type)
  • •25% = AVN rate in body fractures
  • •6-8 weeks = Non-weight-bearing for stress fractures
  • •86% = Union rate with early stress fracture treatment

Critical Anatomy

  • •Central third is watershed zone with poor vascularity
  • •Blood supply from dorsalis pedis and medial plantar artery
  • •Navicular is keystone of medial longitudinal arch
  • •Posterior tibial tendon inserts on navicular tuberosity

Classifications

  • •Sangeorzan Type 2 is most common body fracture pattern
  • •Type 1: Coronal, Type 2: Oblique, Type 3: Comminuted
  • •Stress fractures are sagittal orientation in central third
  • •Higher Sangeorzan type = Worse Prognosis

Common Mistakes

  • •Planning surgery from X-rays alone (need CT)
  • •Weight-bearing too early for stress fractures
  • •Ignoring medial column length restoration
  • •Not having high enough suspicion for stress fractures in athletes
Quick Stats
Reading Time96 min
Related Topics

Acetabular Fractures

Acromioclavicular Joint Injuries

Acute Compartment Syndrome

Ankle Fractures