NUTCRACKER FRACTURES
Cuboid Compression | Lisfranc Association | Lateral Column Shortening
FRACTURE PATTERNS
Critical Must-Knows
- Nutcracker fracture = cuboid compression between calcaneus and 4th/5th metatarsals during forced plantarflexion and abduction
- Often associated with Lisfranc injuries - Nutcracker fracture suggests midfoot instability, always check for Lisfranc injury
- Lateral column shortening - Compression causes impaction and bone loss, leading to lateral column shortening and midfoot collapse
- ORIF with bone graft required - Restore lateral column length with bone graft, prevent midfoot collapse
- Bone graft essential - Compression mechanism causes impaction, bone loss requires structural graft to restore length
Examiner's Pearls
- "Nutcracker = compression between calcaneus and metatarsals
- "Always check for Lisfranc injury
- "Bone graft essential for impaction
- "Restore lateral column length
Critical Nutcracker Fracture Exam Points
Nutcracker Mechanism
Nutcracker fracture = cuboid compression - Compression between calcaneus and 4th/5th metatarsals during forced plantarflexion and abduction. Causes impaction and bone loss. Classic mechanism for cuboid fractures.
Lisfranc Association
Nutcracker fracture suggests midfoot instability - Often associated with Lisfranc injuries (30-40% of cases). Always check for Lisfranc injury if nutcracker fracture present. Both injuries require ORIF.
Lateral Column Shortening
Compression causes impaction and shortening - Bone loss leads to lateral column shortening and midfoot collapse. ORIF with bone graft required to restore length and prevent collapse.
Bone Graft Essential
Structural bone graft required - Compression mechanism causes impaction and bone loss. Autograft from calcaneus or iliac crest. Allograft acceptable. Essential to restore lateral column length.
Nutcracker Fractures - Quick Decision Guide
| Pattern | Impaction | Treatment | Outcome |
|---|---|---|---|
| Type I | Isolated cuboid compression | ORIF with bone graft | 80-85% good results |
| Type II | With Lisfranc injury | ORIF both injuries | 75-85% good results |
| Type III | Severe impaction | ORIF with structural graft | 70-80% good results |
NUTCRACKERNutcracker Fracture Features
Memory Hook:NUTCRACKER: Nutcracker mechanism, Usually associated with Lisfranc, Tarsal cuboid compression, Compression injury, Restore lateral column, Abduction mechanism, Calcaneus compression, Keystone of lateral column, Examine for Lisfranc, Restore with ORIF and bone graft!
GRAFTTreatment Decision
Memory Hook:GRAFT: Graft essential, Restore lateral column length, Anatomic reduction, Fixation with screws or plate, Treatment is ORIF!
ALWAYSLisfranc Association
Memory Hook:ALWAYS: Always check for Lisfranc, Lisfranc injury, With nutcracker fracture, Associated in 30-40%, Yes check always, Surgery for both!
Overview and Epidemiology
Nutcracker fractures are compression injuries of the cuboid bone resulting from the nutcracker mechanism - compression between the calcaneus and 4th/5th metatarsals during forced plantarflexion and abduction. These fractures are often associated with Lisfranc injuries and require ORIF with bone graft to restore lateral column length.
Definition
Nutcracker fracture: Compression fracture of the cuboid bone, which:
- Mechanism: Nutcracker (compression between calcaneus and metatarsals)
- Location: Lateral midfoot (cuboid)
- Impaction: Causes bone loss and shortening
- Association: Often with Lisfranc injuries
Nutcracker mechanism:
- Compression: Between calcaneus and 4th/5th metatarsals
- Forced plantarflexion and abduction: Classic mechanism
- Impaction: Causes bone loss and lateral column shortening
- Lisfranc: Often associated with midfoot instability
Epidemiology
- Incidence: Less than 1% of foot fractures
- Age: Peak 20-40 years (trauma population)
- Gender: No clear predominance
- Mechanism: High-energy trauma, forced plantarflexion and abduction
- Associated injuries: Lisfranc injuries (30-40%), other midfoot trauma
Nutcracker Mechanism
Nutcracker fracture = cuboid compression - Compression between calcaneus and 4th/5th metatarsals during forced plantarflexion and abduction. Causes impaction and bone loss. Often associated with Lisfranc injuries (30-40%) - always check for midfoot instability.
Anatomy and Pathophysiology
Cuboid Anatomy
Cuboid bone:
- Location: Lateral midfoot
- Function: Keystone of lateral column
- Articulations: Calcaneus (proximal), 4th/5th metatarsals (distal), navicular (medial), lateral cuneiform (medial)
- Blood supply: Branches from dorsalis pedis and lateral plantar arteries
Lateral column:
- Components: Calcaneus, cuboid, 4th/5th metatarsals
- Function: Lateral foot stability and weight bearing
- Cuboid role: Keystone, maintains lateral column length
Nutcracker mechanism:
- Compression: Between calcaneus and 4th/5th metatarsals
- Forced plantarflexion and abduction: Classic mechanism
- Impaction: Causes bone loss and shortening
Pathophysiology
Injury mechanism:
- Forced plantarflexion and abduction: Classic mechanism
- Compression: Cuboid compressed between calcaneus and metatarsals
- Impaction: Causes bone loss and lateral column shortening
- Lisfranc association: Often associated with midfoot instability (30-40%)
Why impaction matters:
- Bone loss: Compression causes impaction and bone loss
- Lateral column shortening: Loss of length causes midfoot collapse
- Arthritis risk: Shortening leads to lateral column arthritis
Why bone graft essential:
- Restore length: Bone graft restores lateral column length
- Prevent collapse: Prevents midfoot collapse
- Structural support: Provides structural support for articular surface
Classification Systems
Pattern-Based Classification
Type I (Isolated cuboid compression):
- Isolated nutcracker fracture
- Impaction with bone loss
- Treatment: ORIF with bone graft
- Outcome: 80-85% good results
Type II (With Lisfranc injury):
- Nutcracker fracture with Lisfranc injury
- Treatment: ORIF both injuries
- Outcome: 75-85% good results
Type III (Severe impaction):
- Severe impaction with significant bone loss
- Treatment: ORIF with structural graft
- Outcome: 70-80% good results
Pattern guides treatment approach.
Clinical Assessment
History
Symptoms:
- Lateral foot pain: Pain on lateral side of foot
- Swelling: Localised to lateral midfoot
- Difficulty weight bearing: Pain with weight bearing
- Mechanism: Forced plantarflexion and abduction
Risk factors:
- High-energy trauma
- Lisfranc injury mechanism
- Midfoot instability
Physical Examination
Inspection:
- Swelling on lateral midfoot
- Ecchymosis (may be delayed)
- Deformity (lateral column shortening if displaced)
Palpation:
- Tenderness over cuboid
- Lisfranc joint tenderness (if associated)
- Lateral column instability
Range of Motion:
- Midfoot ROM limited and painful
- Inversion/eversion painful
- Plantarflexion/dorsiflexion painful
Special tests:
- Lisfranc stress test: Check for midfoot instability
- Lateral column stress: Pain with stress
- Midfoot alignment: Check for collapse
Clinical Examination Key Point
Always check for Lisfranc injury - Nutcracker fractures are often associated with Lisfranc injuries (30-40%). Perform Lisfranc stress test and check for midfoot instability. CT is often needed to assess both injuries.
Investigations
Standard X-ray Protocol
AP view:
- May show cuboid compression
- Check for Lisfranc injury
Lateral view:
- May show fracture
- Assess lateral column alignment
Oblique view:
- May show compression better
- Lisfranc joint view
Key point: CT is often needed for diagnosis and planning.
Management Algorithm

Management Pathway
Nutcracker Fracture Management
CT is usually required for diagnosis - nutcracker fractures show impaction and bone loss. Assess impaction severity, associated Lisfranc injury, and lateral column shortening. Check for midfoot instability.
If isolated nutcracker fracture, ORIF with bone graft required. Restore lateral column length. Autograft from calcaneus or iliac crest. Allograft acceptable. Success rate 80-85%.
If associated with Lisfranc injury, address both injuries. Cuboid ORIF with bone graft as part of Lisfranc fixation. Restore lateral column length and midfoot stability. Success rate 75-85%.
If severe impaction with significant bone loss, structural bone graft required. Autograft from iliac crest preferred. Restore lateral column length and prevent collapse. Success rate 70-80%.
Surgical Technique
ORIF with Bone Graft Technique
Indications:
- Nutcracker fractures with impaction
- Lateral column shortening
- Bone loss requiring restoration
Approach:
- Lateral approach to cuboid
- Expose cuboid
- Protect peroneal tendons
Technique:
- Exposure: Lateral approach to cuboid, expose fracture, protect peroneal tendons
- Debridement: Remove impacted bone fragments, assess bone loss
- Bone graft: Fill impaction defect with bone graft - autograft from calcaneus or iliac crest (preferred for structural support), allograft acceptable, structural graft if severe impaction
- Reduction: Restore lateral column length, reduce fracture anatomically
- Fixation: Screws (2.7-3.5mm) or mini-fragment plate (2.0-2.7mm)
- Verification: Confirm reduction and hardware position fluoroscopically, verify lateral column length restored (compare to contralateral)
Advantages:
- Restores lateral column length
- Prevents midfoot collapse
- Allows early motion
ORIF with bone graft restores lateral column length.
Complications
| Complication | Incidence | Risk Factors | Prevention/Management |
|---|---|---|---|
| Lateral column shortening | 15-20% | Inadequate bone graft, severe impaction | Structural graft, restore length |
| Midfoot collapse | 15-20% | Lateral column shortening | Restore length, adequate fixation |
| Missed Lisfranc | 30-40% | Focus on cuboid only | Always check for Lisfranc |
| Nonunion | 5-10% | Inadequate fixation, bone loss | Rigid fixation, bone graft |
Lateral Column Shortening
15-20% incidence (if untreated):
- Cause: Inadequate bone graft, severe impaction, bone loss
- Prevention: Structural bone graft, restore length, adequate fixation
- Management: Revision ORIF with structural graft if symptomatic
Midfoot Collapse
15-20% incidence (if untreated):
- Cause: Lateral column shortening, inadequate fixation
- Prevention: Restore length, adequate fixation
- Management: Revision ORIF or midfoot fusion if severe
Postoperative Care
Immediate Postoperative
- Immobilisation: Short leg cast or boot
- Weight bearing: Non-weight bearing (6-8 weeks)
- ROM: Ankle ROM after cast removal
- PT: Midfoot ROM and strengthening
Rehabilitation Protocol
Weeks 0-6:
- Short leg cast, non-weight bearing
- Elevation to reduce swelling
- Ankle ROM exercises (if stable)
Weeks 6-8:
- CT to confirm healing
- Cast removal if healing
- Transition to walking boot
- Progressive weight bearing
Weeks 8-12:
- Full weight bearing
- Progressive activity
- Return to sport (3-4 months)
Outcomes and Prognosis
Overall Outcomes
ORIF with bone graft (isolated):
- Success rate: 80-85% (union, pain relief)
- Functional outcomes: 75-80% return to pre-injury level
- Lateral column: 80-85% maintain length
ORIF with bone graft (part of Lisfranc):
- Success rate: 75-85% (union, pain relief)
- Functional outcomes: 70-75% return to pre-injury level
- Lateral column: 75-80% maintain length
ORIF with structural graft (severe impaction):
- Success rate: 70-80% (union, pain relief)
- Functional outcomes: 65-70% return to pre-injury level
- Lateral column: 70-75% maintain length
Long-Term Prognosis
Lateral column shortening progression:
- With proper treatment: 15-20% develop shortening
- Without treatment: 30-40% develop shortening
- Risk factors: Severe impaction, inadequate graft, delayed treatment
Evidence Base
"Restore lateral column length" ]} clinicalImplication="Recognize compression mechanism requires restoration of length" />
Lisfranc Association
- 30-40% associated with Lisfranc injuries
- Nutcracker fracture suggests midfoot instability
- Always check for Lisfranc if nutcracker present
- Both injuries require ORIF
Bone Graft
- Compression causes impaction and bone loss
- Structural bone graft required
- Autograft from calcaneus or iliac crest preferred
- Prevents lateral column shortening
Lateral Column
- Cuboid is keystone of lateral column
- Compression causes shortening
- Bone graft restores length (80-85% good results)
- Prevents midfoot collapse
Treatment Outcomes
- ORIF isolated: 80-85% good results
- ORIF Lisfranc: 75-85% good results
- ORIF severe impaction: 70-80% good results
- Lateral column shortening: 15-20% with treatment
Bridge Plating for Cuboid Fractures
- Mini-fragment plate bridging calcaneocuboid and cuboid-metatarsal joints
- Provides stable fixation in comminuted fractures
- Plate removal after union at 4-6 months
- Motion returns after plate removal in most patients
Exam Viva Scenarios
Practice these scenarios to excel in your viva examination
Scenario 1: Isolated Nutcracker Fracture
"A 28-year-old patient presents with lateral foot pain after forced plantarflexion and abduction injury. CT shows nutcracker fracture of cuboid with impaction and bone loss. No associated Lisfranc injury."
Scenario 2: Nutcracker with Lisfranc Injury
"A 32-year-old patient has a nutcracker fracture as part of a Lisfranc injury. The examiner asks you to explain how you manage both injuries and why bone graft is essential."
MCQ Practice Points
Nutcracker Mechanism
Q: What is the nutcracker mechanism for cuboid fractures? A: Compression between calcaneus and 4th/5th metatarsals - During forced plantarflexion and abduction. Causes impaction and bone loss. Often associated with Lisfranc injuries (30-40%).
Lisfranc Association
Q: Why are nutcracker fractures often associated with Lisfranc injuries? A: Nutcracker fracture suggests midfoot instability - 30-40% of nutcracker fractures are associated with Lisfranc injuries. Always check for Lisfranc injury if nutcracker fracture present. Both injuries require ORIF.
Bone Graft
Q: Why is bone graft essential for nutcracker fractures? A: Compression mechanism causes impaction and bone loss - Structural bone graft required to restore lateral column length. Autograft from calcaneus or iliac crest (preferred). Prevents lateral column shortening and midfoot collapse.
Lateral Column
Q: Why is lateral column length important in nutcracker fractures? A: Cuboid is keystone of lateral column - Loss of length causes lateral column shortening and midfoot collapse. ORIF with bone graft required to restore length. Success rate 80-85% if length restored.
ORIF Indications
Q: When is ORIF with bone graft required for nutcracker fractures? A: Impaction with bone loss or associated Lisfranc injury - Restores lateral column length and prevents midfoot collapse. Structural bone graft essential. Success rate 80-85% for isolated, 75-85% with Lisfranc.
Australian Context
Clinical Practice
- Nutcracker fractures rare but important
- Often associated with Lisfranc injuries
- ORIF with bone graft standard
- Structural graft for severe impaction
Healthcare System
- Public hospitals handle most cases
- Private insurance covers procedures
- High-energy trauma common
Orthopaedic Exam Relevance
Nutcracker fractures are a common viva topic. Know that nutcracker mechanism (compression between calcaneus and metatarsals), often associated with Lisfranc injuries (30-40%), ORIF with bone graft required (restores lateral column length), structural graft for severe impaction, and bone graft is essential to prevent shortening. Be prepared to discuss the nutcracker mechanism and why bone graft is essential.
NUTCRACKER FRACTURES
High-Yield Exam Summary
Key Concepts
- •Nutcracker mechanism = compression between calcaneus and 4th/5th metatarsals
- •Often associated with Lisfranc injuries (30-40%)
- •Bone graft essential for impaction
- •Restore lateral column length
Classification
- •Type I: Isolated cuboid compression - ORIF with bone graft (80-85% good results)
- •Type II: With Lisfranc injury - ORIF both injuries (75-85% good results)
- •Type III: Severe impaction - ORIF with structural graft (70-80% good results)
- •Key Factor: Impaction severity dictates graft requirement
Treatment
- •Isolated: ORIF with bone graft (autograft from calcaneus or iliac crest, 80-85% good results)
- •With Lisfranc: ORIF both injuries with bone graft (75-85% good results)
- •Severe impaction: ORIF with structural graft (70-80% good results)
- •Bone graft essential to restore lateral column length
Surgical Technique
- •Lateral approach: Protect peroneal tendons
- •Debride impacted bone, assess bone loss
- •Bone graft: Fill impaction defect (autograft preferred, structural if severe)
- •Fixation: Screws (2.7-3.5mm) or mini-fragment plate (2.0-2.7mm)
- •Restore lateral column length
- •Verify reduction fluoroscopically
Complications
- •Lateral column shortening: 15-20% if untreated (prevent with bone graft, restore length)
- •Midfoot collapse: 15-20% if untreated (prevent with adequate fixation)
- •Missed Lisfranc: 30-40% (prevent by always checking for Lisfranc)
- •Nonunion: 5-10% (prevent with rigid fixation, bone graft)