(and Distraction Interposition Arthroplasty)
- Interposition arthroplasty of the elbow is a JOINT-PRESERVING, BONE-PRESERVING alternative to total elbow arthroplasty (TEA), indicated mainly for the YOUNG, HIGH-DEMAND patient with end-stage elbow arthritis (most often POST-TRAUMATIC, sometimes inflammatory) - because TEA in a young, active patient has a high failure rate and imposes a strict lifelong lifting restriction (often around 2-5 kg), which such patients cannot accept.
- The TECHNIQUE resurfaces the arthritic, debrided and contoured articular surface of the distal humerus with an INTERPOSED SOFT-TISSUE GRAFT - classically autologous FASCIA LATA, or an ACHILLES TENDON or DERMAL ALLOGRAFT - which acts as a biological resurfacing layer between the humerus and the ulna/radius, relieving pain while preserving bone and motion.
- DISTRACTION INTERPOSITION ARTHROPLASTY adds a HINGED DISTRACTION EXTERNAL FIXATOR (applied for around 3-4 weeks): the distractor separates the articular surfaces to UNLOAD and PROTECT the interposed graft and maintain the joint space, while its hinge (aligned to the elbow's flexion-extension axis) allows EARLY, protected MOTION - particularly valuable where there is instability or to protect the graft.
- The single most important determinant of success is ELBOW STABILITY: instability of the elbow, both before and after surgery, is strongly associated with UNSATISFACTORY results, so the collateral ligaments and the bony columns must be competent or be reconstructed/repaired, and the distraction fixator helps protect a potentially unstable elbow during healing; modern practice may allow immediate protected motion in a hinged brace WITHOUT external distraction when ligamentous stability is good.
- OUTCOMES are MODEST but useful: reported satisfactory pain relief in roughly two-thirds of patients (e.g. about 69% satisfactory pain relief and 62% excellent/good Mayo scores in the classic series), with similar results for post-traumatic and inflammatory arthritis - but it is LESS RELIABLE than prosthetic replacement, and complications (including ulnar nerve problems and graft/fixator-related issues) are not uncommon, especially in post-traumatic cases.
- A key advantage is that interposition arthroplasty does NOT 'burn bridges': because it preserves bone, a FAILED interposition can be CONVERTED to a TOTAL ELBOW ARTHROPLASTY later (with good results in reported cases), so it is a reasonable joint-preserving first step for the young arthritic elbow, reserving the motion-and-load-limited but more reliable TEA for older/lower-demand patients or as the eventual salvage.
- “Elbow interposition arthroplasty = joint/bone-preserving alternative to TEA for the YOUNG, HIGH-DEMAND arthritic (usually post-traumatic) elbow (TEA has a strict lifelong lifting limit + high failure in the young).
- “Resurface the debrided distal humerus with an interposed SOFT-TISSUE graft (fascia lata, Achilles/dermal allograft); a HINGED DISTRACTION external fixator (~3-4 weeks) unloads/protects the graft and allows early motion.
- “STABILITY is critical (instability predicts failure - reconstruct ligaments/columns). Outcomes modest (~60-70% satisfactory), less reliable than TEA; a failed interposition CONVERTS to TEA.
For the young, high-demand patient with end-stage (usually post-traumatic) elbow arthritis where TEA is undesirable (lifelong lifting limit, high failure in the young).
Interpose a soft-tissue graft over the debrided distal humerus; a hinged distraction fixator unloads/protects it and allows early motion. Stability is critical; convertible to TEA.
Indication, Technique & the Stability Principle
Interposition arthroplasty is a joint- and bone-preserving alternative to total elbow arthroplasty for the young, high-demand patient with end-stage (usually post-traumatic) elbow arthritis, in whom TEA's high failure rate and strict lifelong lifting limit are unacceptable. The arthritic distal humerus is debrided and contoured and resurfaced with an interposed soft-tissue graft - fascia lata, or Achilles/dermal allograft - which biologically resurfaces the joint while preserving bone and motion. A hinged distraction external fixator (classically 3-4 weeks) may be added to unload and protect the graft and maintain the joint space while allowing early motion, especially where there is instability. The decisive factor is elbow STABILITY: instability before or after surgery predicts failure, so the ligaments and columns must be competent or reconstructed. Outcomes are modest (~60-70% satisfactory) and less reliable than TEA, but a failed interposition can be converted to TEA.
| Feature | Interposition (+/- distraction) | Total elbow arthroplasty (TEA) |
|---|---|---|
| Ideal patient | Young, high-demand, end-stage (post-traumatic) arthritis | Older, lower-demand (or RA); inflammatory arthritis |
| Bone / future options | Preserves bone; convertible to TEA | Sacrifices bone; revision is harder |
| Load restriction | No strict lifelong lifting limit | Strict lifelong limit (~2-5 kg) |
| Reliability of pain relief | Modest (~60-70% satisfactory) | More reliable/predictable |
| Key requirement / risk | STABILITY essential; instability -> failure | Polyethylene bushing wear, loosening, periprosthetic fracture |
Outcomes, Complications & Conversion
- Outcomes: roughly two-thirds satisfactory pain relief (e.g. ~69% satisfactory, ~62% excellent/good Mayo scores in the classic distraction-interposition series), similar for post-traumatic and inflammatory arthritis - less reliable than TEA.
- Stability is everything: competent or reconstructed collateral ligaments and bony columns; the distraction fixator protects an unstable elbow during healing; with good stability, immediate protected motion in a hinged brace without external distraction is feasible.
- Complications: ulnar nerve problems (consider decompression/transposition), instability, graft/fixator issues, pin-site problems, and the chance of persistent pain - more frequent in post-traumatic cases.
- Conversion: a failed interposition arthroplasty can be converted to a total elbow arthroplasty later, so it does not preclude future prosthetic replacement - a reasonable first step in the young arthritic elbow."
The decisive lesson of elbow interposition arthroplasty is that STABILITY determines success: instability of the elbow, present before surgery or resulting from the debridement, is strongly associated with unsatisfactory results, so the procedure must restore or rely on competent collateral ligaments and bony columns, and a hinged distraction external fixator is used to protect and unload the graft - and to protect an unstable elbow - during healing. It is offered to the young, high-demand patient specifically because total elbow arthroplasty is ill-suited to them (a strict lifelong lifting limit and a high failure rate), and its key advantages are bone preservation and the ability to be converted to a TEA later if it fails. But it must be presented honestly: the results are modest and less reliable than prosthetic replacement, complications such as ulnar neuropathy are not uncommon, and an unstable elbow is a relative contraindication unless the instability can be corrected.
Evidence & Key Studies
Distraction interposition arthroplasty for the mobile, painful arthritic elbow (fascia lata)
- In 13 patients with mobile, painful arthritic elbows treated by distraction interposition arthroplasty using fascia lata (with an elbow distractor for 3-4 weeks), 69% had satisfactory pain relief and 62% an excellent/good Mayo Elbow Performance score at a mean 63 months.
- Instability of the elbow, both before and after surgery, was associated with unsatisfactory results; success was similar for inflammatory and post-traumatic arthritis (about 67%).
- Four of 13 required revision to total elbow arthroplasty (mean 30 months) with good results; it is a useful but less reliable option for young, high-demand patients.
Elbow interpositional arthroplasty using an Achilles tendon allograft (modern technique)
- Interpositional arthroplasty remains a viable option for post-traumatic elbow arthritis in young, high-demand patients, in whom total elbow arthroplasty is generally reserved for older patients.
- A young patient treated with an Achilles tendon allograft interposition - allowed immediate protected range of motion in a hinged brace WITHOUT distraction external fixation because of good ligamentous stability - had significantly improved pain, motion and outcome scores.
- With good ligamentous stability, immediate protected motion can lead to excellent outcomes.
According to PubMed, the distraction-interposition technique with fascia lata and a 3-4 week distractor, the modest outcomes (about 69% satisfactory pain relief, 62% excellent/good Mayo scores), the critical role of stability (instability predicting poor results), the similar results for post-traumatic and inflammatory arthritis, and conversion to TEA come from the cited Cheng & Morrey series; the modern use of an Achilles tendon allograft with immediate protected motion in a hinged brace without external distraction when ligamentous stability is good, and the indication in young high-demand post-traumatic arthritis, from the cited Glazier case report. The bone-preserving rationale versus TEA (lifelong lifting limit, high young failure) is standard, well-established teaching. (See also our Total Elbow Arthroplasty and Post-Traumatic Elbow Stiffness topics.)
Clinical Decision Scenarios
Practise clinical reasoning and management decisions out loud
“A 40-year-old manual worker has end-stage post-traumatic elbow arthritis. Why might you choose interposition arthroplasty over a total elbow replacement?”
“What is the role of the distraction external fixator, and what determines outcome?”
Mnemonics & Memory Aids
INTERPOSE
Hook:INTERPOSE: Interpose graft, Not a TEA candidate (young), Total elbow avoided, Early motion (distractor), Respect stability, Post-traumatic, Outcomes modest, Salvage to TEA.
Why & who
- Joint/bone-preserving alternative to TEA
- Young, high-demand patient with end-stage (usually post-traumatic) elbow arthritis
- TEA avoided: strict lifelong lifting limit + high failure in the young
Technique
- Debride/contour distal humerus; interpose soft-tissue graft (fascia lata, Achilles/dermal allograft)
- Hinged distraction external fixator (~3-4 weeks) unloads/protects graft, allows early motion
- Modern: good stability -> immediate protected motion in a hinged brace without distractor
Key principle
- Stability is critical - instability (pre/post-op) predicts failure
- Restore/rely on competent collateral ligaments and columns
- Manage the ulnar nerve
Outcomes
- Modest (~69% satisfactory pain relief, ~62% excellent/good Mayo) - less reliable than TEA
- Similar for post-traumatic and inflammatory arthritis; more complications in post-traumatic
- Failed interposition converts to TEA (bone preserved)