Living autograft for segmental defects greater than 6 cm, hostile beds and biological intercalary reconstruction
- The fibula is a living bone flap: it unites like a fracture (6-12 weeks) rather than by creeping substitution, tolerates infected and irradiated beds, and hypertrophies under load.
- Nutrient artery enters the middle third of the fibula posterior to the interosseous membrane β the middle third MUST be included in the harvested segment.
- Periosteal supply from the peroneal artery is segmental β closing-wedge osteotomies (double-barrel, contouring) are safe if periosteum and pedicle are preserved.
- Preserve the distal 6 cm of fibula for ankle mortise stability; in skeletally immature patients add a distal tibiofibular synostosis (LangenskiΓΆld) to prevent progressive ankle valgus.
- Rule out peronea arteria magna (dominant peroneal artery with hypoplastic tibial vessels, roughly 0.2-5 percent) β harvesting the pedicle here devascularises the foot.
- Capanna technique: fibula telescoped inside a massive allograft combines immediate mechanical strength with biological healing and revascularisation potential.
- βSkin paddle survives on septocutaneous perforators in the posterior crural septum β it is the monitoring window for the buried bone flap.
- βFix the fibula so the pedicle lies free of plate, bone and tourniquet of soft tissue β pedicle compression is the leading technical cause of flap loss.
- βClaw hallux from flexor hallucis longus scarring/contracture is the classic donor-site complication asked in exams.
A dominant peroneal artery supplying the foot with absent/hypoplastic anterior and posterior tibial arteries. Harvest here causes foot ischaemia. Screen with pulses and Doppler; image (CT/MR angiography or catheter angiography) if pulses are abnormal, previous trauma or vascular disease.
Winds around the fibular neck. Proximal harvest and pedicle exposure endanger it β identify and protect early. Leave the proximal fibula (head and neck) unless the physis/epiphysis is deliberately transferred on the anterior tibial vessels for growing reconstructions.
Enters posterior to the interosseous membrane in the middle third. Segments excluding the middle third rely on periosteal supply alone β plan the osteotomy levels so the nutrient foramen sits within the graft.
Retain at least 6 cm of distal fibula above the lateral malleolus. In children, even with 6 cm retained, proximal migration of the remnant causes valgus β perform a distal tibiofibular synostosis or screw fixation at harvest.
Rationale: Why a Vascularised Graft
A non-vascularised cortical graft is dead scaffold: it incorporates by creeping substitution, transiently weakens at 6 to 18 months, and fails unpredictably in defects greater than 6 cm, infected beds and irradiated tissue. The vascularised fibula is living bone.
- Union biology β heals to host bone like a two-level fracture; osteocytes survive, no creeping substitution phase of weakness.
- Hostile beds β carries its own blood supply into irradiated, scarred or previously infected fields; delivers antibiotics and immune cells.
- Adaptation β hypertrophies under cyclical load over 1 to 2 years, eventually approaching host-bone diameter in the tibia and forearm.
- Growth β proximal fibular epiphyseal transfer (on the anterior tibial artery) can reconstruct a growing physis (e.g. proximal humerus in children).
- Geometry β straight tubular cortical bone up to about 26 cm; ideal cross-section for radius, ulna, humerus; double-barrelled for tibia/femur.
- Best For
- Defects less than 5-6 cm, healthy bed
- Strengths
- Simple, no microsurgery
- Weaknesses
- Creeping substitution, fracture, non-union in long/hostile defects
- Best For
- 5-10 cm, especially trauma/infection after staged debridement
- Strengths
- No microsurgery, familiar technique
- Weaknesses
- Two stages, graft volume demand, less reliable beyond about 10 cm and in irradiated beds
- Best For
- Tibial defects with intact soft tissue envelope
- Strengths
- Regenerates native bone, addresses deformity
- Weaknesses
- Long frame time (roughly 1 month per cm), docking problems, pin sites
- Best For
- Defects greater than 6 cm, infected/irradiated beds, congenital pseudarthrosis, oncologic intercalary defects
- Strengths
- Living bone, hypertrophy, works in hostile beds
- Weaknesses
- Microsurgical expertise, donor morbidity, initial mechanical weakness, stress fracture
- Best For
- Large-diameter intercalary defects (femur, tibia) after tumour resection
- Strengths
- Immediate strength plus biology; allograft protects fibula during hypertrophy
- Weaknesses
- Complex, long operation, allograft complications still possible
- Best For
- Elderly, poor prognosis, need for rapid weight-bearing
- Strengths
- Immediate function
- Weaknesses
- Aseptic loosening, infection, not durable in the young
Indications and Decision Thresholds
- Segmental long-bone defects greater than 6 cm (trauma, infection, tumour) where non-vascularised graft and induced membrane are less reliable
- Infected or irradiated beds at any defect length where conventional grafting has failed or is expected to fail
- Congenital pseudarthrosis of the tibia (NF1-associated) after failed conventional surgery β FVFG and Ilizarov are the two workhorse salvage options
- Oncologic intercalary reconstruction β alone (forearm, humerus, fibula-for-radius) or as the Capanna hybrid inside a massive allograft (femur, tibia)
- Forearm and humeral reconstruction β fibular diameter closely matches radius/ulna; can arthrodese or reconstruct the distal radius after giant cell tumour resection (proximal fibula recreates the radiocarpal surface)
- Osteonecrosis of the femoral head in the young, pre-collapse or early post-collapse (Ficat II-III) β Urbaniak technique: core decompression plus vascularised fibula strut with anastomosis to ascending branch of lateral femoral circumflex vessels
- Peronea arteria magna in the donor limb (absolute)
- No suitable recipient vessels (previous radical dissection, radiation vasculitis) β reassess with angiography; consider arteriovenous loop
- Severe peripheral vascular disease; heavy smoking is a relative contraindication (flap thrombosis, non-union)
- Elderly/low-demand patients better served by endoprosthesis or acute shortening
- Femoral-head FVFG: collapse greater than 2 mm with acetabular involvement β outcomes poor, arthroplasty preferred; the whole technique is debated given modern arthroplasty results and its own donor morbidity
Below 5 to 6 cm: autograft or induced membrane. 6 to 12 cm: FVFG or bone transport depending on soft tissues, subspecialty availability and patient tolerance of frames. Greater than 12 cm, or large-diameter weight-bearing bone: Capanna hybrid, double-barrel FVFG, or transport-plus-flap combinations. Hostile bed (radiation, chronic infection) shifts the choice towards vascularised bone at any length.
Applied Vascular and Surgical Anatomy
- Peroneal (fibular) artery β arises from the tibioperoneal trunk roughly 2.5 cm below popliteus, descends between tibialis posterior and FHL along the posteromedial fibula. Calibre 1.5 to 2.5 mm; paired venae comitantes (often larger than the artery); usable pedicle length 4 to 8 cm, extendable by dissecting to the tibioperoneal trunk and by harvesting a longer proximal fibular segment then discarding bone to lengthen the effective pedicle.
- Nutrient artery β single branch entering the posterior/medial cortex of the middle third, posterior to the interosseous membrane. Supplies the inner two-thirds of the cortex (endosteal system).
- Periosteal/musculoperiosteal branches β segmental arcades from the peroneal artery along the length of the bone; supply the outer cortex. Because this supply is segmental, careful subperiosteal-sparing osteotomies (for double-barrelling or contouring) preserve viability of each segment provided the periosteal sleeve and pedicle remain intact.
- Septocutaneous perforators β 2 to 4 perforators in the posterior crural (lateral intermuscular) septum, concentrated at the junction of middle and distal thirds, supply the skin paddle used for monitoring and soft-tissue reconstruction (osteocutaneous flap).
- Proximal epiphysis β supplied by branches of the anterior tibial artery; epiphyseal transfer for growing reconstruction requires a different pedicle from the standard diaphyseal harvest.
SIX-SIXFibula Harvest Safety
Hook:Two sixes: six centimetres retained distally, six centimetres of defect as the indication threshold.
Preoperative Planning
- History and examination β donor leg trauma/surgery, claudication, smoking; palpate dorsalis pedis and posterior tibial pulses; handheld Doppler all three vessels.
- Imaging the donor leg β selective CTA/MRA as above; mandatory in congenital limb anomalies and abnormal pulses.
- Imaging the recipient site β full-length radiographs, CT for defect geometry, MRI for tumour margins; measure defect and add 2 to 3 cm for intramedullary docking or step-cuts.
- Recipient vessels β plan artery (end-to-side to a major axial vessel or end-to-end to a branch) and two venous options; in irradiated necks/limbs consider preoperative angiography of the recipient bed.
- Team and logistics β two-team approach (resection/recipient preparation simultaneous with harvest) shortens ischaemia time; microscope, microinstruments, couplers, implantable Doppler available.
- Consent β flap failure (roughly 5 percent in experienced hands), re-exploration, stress fracture, donor morbidity (great-toe clawing, ankle discomfort, weakness, sensory change), prolonged protected weight-bearing.
Operative Technique
Position β supine with a bump or lateral decubitus; hip and knee flexed, thigh tourniquet (exsanguinate by elevation, not Esmarch, to preserve venous filling for perforator identification).
Landmarks and incision β line from fibular head to lateral malleolus along the posterior border of the fibula; centre the skin paddle over Doppler-marked perforators at the middle-distal third junction.
Sequence (Gilbert-type lateral approach):
- Incise anterior to the marked paddle; raise the anterior skin flap and identify septocutaneous perforators in the posterior crural septum; include a septal cuff with the paddle.
- Elevate peroneus longus and brevis off the fibula anteriorly, leaving a 1 to 2 mm muscle cuff on bone to protect periosteal vessels; protect the superficial peroneal nerve; proximally identify and protect the common peroneal nerve at the neck.
- Release the anterior compartment muscles (EDL, EHL) from the fibula; identify and protect the anterior tibial vessels and deep peroneal nerve on the interosseous membrane.
- Mark osteotomy levels β preserve 6 cm distally and stay below the neck proximally; confirm the middle third (nutrient foramen) lies within the graft. Perform osteotomies with an oscillating saw under retractor protection.
- Divide the interosseous membrane; rotate the fibula externally to expose the deep posterior compartment.
- Ligate and divide the distal peroneal vessels below the graft; dissect the pedicle proximally between tibialis posterior and FHL, taking a cuff of FHL/tibialis posterior with the bone, up to the tibioperoneal trunk for maximal length and calibre.
- Deflate the tourniquet; confirm perfusion of bone (bleeding osteotomy ends, punctate periosteal bleeding) and paddle; achieve haemostasis; divide the pedicle only when the recipient site is ready.
Closure β loose fascial closure (do not close the crural fascia tightly β compartment syndrome risk), drain, direct skin closure if paddle less than about 4 cm wide, otherwise split-skin graft; below-knee backslab in ankle neutral.
Paediatric addition β distal tibiofibular synostosis or transfixion screw to prevent proximal migration and ankle valgus.
The commonest avoidable technical failure is pedicle compromise at inset: a screw through the vessel groove, plate edge against the pedicle, kinking within a Capanna allograft window, or tension after limb lengthening. Always visualise the pedicle lying free after final fixation and in the final limb position, and recheck flow before closing.
SPONDeeHarvest Order
Hook:Skin, muscles, bone cuts, membrane, then pedicle β superficial to deep, distal to proximal.
Graft Biology: Hypertrophy and Stress Fracture
The fibula-host junctions heal like fractures: callus and union typically by 3 to 6 months in favourable beds. Protect fully β the fibula alone carries a fraction of femoral or tibial load.
Graduated loading drives periosteal apposition. This is the window of stress fracture β reported in roughly 10 to 25 percent of lower-limb reconstructions, highest where a single-barrel fibula reconstructs the femur or tibia without allograft or nail protection.
Cortical thickening and diameter increase toward host dimensions (quantifiable by the de Boer and Wood hypertrophy index). Greater and faster in children and in weight-bearing bones.
Stress fracture management β most unite with immobilisation/protected loading because the bone is vascularised; persistent instability warrants supplementary fixation and bone graft. Prevention: double-barrel or Capanna constructs for large-diameter bones, spanning fixation retained until hypertrophy, graduated loading.
Complications
- Approximate Rate
- Roughly 5 percent (less in high-volume units)
- Prevention
- Recipient vessels outside zone of injury, tension-free anastomosis, paddle/Doppler monitoring
- Management
- Emergency re-exploration; thrombectomy, revision anastomosis; failed flap: debride and revise strategy
- Approximate Rate
- 10-25 percent (lower limb)
- Prevention
- Double-barrel/Capanna, protected loading until hypertrophy, retained spanning fixation
- Management
- Immobilise β most unite; fix and graft if persistent
- Approximate Rate
- 10-20 percent of junctions (higher with chemotherapy/radiation)
- Prevention
- Bleeding host bone, compression, stable fixation, intramedullary docking
- Management
- Revision fixation plus autograft; usually salvageable
- Approximate Rate
- Common (often subclinical); symptomatic in a minority
- Prevention
- Minimal FHL cuff, early toe mobilisation
- Management
- Stretching; FHL release or lengthening at the ankle if fixed
- Approximate Rate
- Significant if distal fibula inadequate or no synostosis
- Prevention
- Retain 6 cm; paediatric distal tibiofibular synostosis
- Management
- Synostosis/screw, supramalleolar osteotomy for established valgus
- Approximate Rate
- Weakness of eversion/great-toe flexion common early; compartment syndrome rare
- Prevention
- Loose fascial closure, drain, haemostasis
- Management
- Fasciotomy if compartment syndrome; physiotherapy for weakness β most recover to near-normal gait
Guidelines, Registries & Global Practice
- Global epidemiology of use β FVFG is practised worldwide wherever microsurgical expertise exists; the dominant indications differ by region: oncologic intercalary reconstruction and congenital pseudarthrosis in high-income centres; post-traumatic and post-infective defects dominate in many lower-resource settings, where bone transport is often preferred because it needs no microsurgical infrastructure.
- Society guidance β no society issues an FVFG-specific guideline. Relevant framework documents: BOA/BAPRAS BOAST on open fractures (early combined orthoplastic decision-making for segmental bone loss, reconstruction within a definitive soft-tissue plan); AO principles for segmental defect management (defect classification, staged strategies including Masquelet, transport and vascularised graft); musculoskeletal tumour society consensus favours biological reconstruction (allograft, FVFG, Capanna) for intercalary defects in the young where expertise allows.
- Registries β no implant-style registry captures FVFG; evidence rests on institutional series and systematic reviews, which consistently report union above 80 to 90 percent after all secondary procedures, with reoperation common (junctional grafting, stress-fracture management).
- Resource-setting variation β where microsurgery is unavailable: bone transport, Masquelet, ipsilateral pedicled fibula transfer for tibial defects (Huntington procedure β no microsurgery needed), or non-vascularised fibula strut for smaller defects. Selective rather than routine angiography is now the majority international practice for donor-limb assessment.
Controversies & Areas of Uncertainty
- Routine versus selective donor angiography β routine imaging detects rare variants but adds cost and (for catheter studies) risk; most units now image selectively on clinical/Doppler criteria, with a lower threshold in congenital deformity.
- FVFG for femoral head osteonecrosis β Urbaniak's results are difficult to reproduce; the operation is long, donor morbidity real, and modern arthroplasty in the young performs well. Many centres have abandoned it; others reserve it for pre-collapse disease in patients under 40.
- FVFG versus Ilizarov transport for tibial defects β comparable union in experienced hands; transport avoids microsurgery and donor morbidity but demands months in frame; choice is driven by defect length, soft tissues, patient tolerance and local expertise.
- Capanna versus fibula alone versus allograft alone β the hybrid adds operative complexity; whether it is required for defects under about 10 cm in the upper limb (where fibula alone performs well) is debated.
- Osteocutaneous paddle versus buried flap with implantable Doppler β paddle gives the most reliable monitoring but adds donor scarring and occasionally skin-graft morbidity.